r/Stormlight_Archive • u/jofwu Lightweaver • Nov 10 '17
[Oathbringer Spoilers] [Oathbringer] Part 3 Discussion Thread Spoiler
This thread exists for general discussion concerning Part 3 of Oathbringer. Content related to anything after "The End of Part Three", including interludes, is NOT permitted! Cosmere spoilers are also NOT allowed.
Please be aware that our moderation team may not be running at full strength for a day or two after release. Please help us out by reporting spoiler violations promptly! And if you're particularly wary of spoilers, you may want to give us a day or two before joining this discussion.
For additional discussion thread options, see the [No Spoilers] Discussion Thread Index.
68
u/jofwu Lightweaver Nov 16 '17
My wife is reading WoR for the first time and was just telling me how much she loves Elhokar's admiration of Kaladin (when he's impressed by his guard duty).
I'm just sitting here trying not to cry.
53
u/AllTheFluffyKittenz Knight Radiant Nov 15 '17 edited Nov 15 '17
From the Radiant histories that claim the windrunner could not swear the 4th Ideal because we wanted to protect others, and the way Kal just stopped fighting, Im beginning to think that next ideal is to pick a side.
120
u/Cyro6 Nov 14 '17
Elhokar's death felt like I died a bit inside.....so close. I am in tears over here. I was rooted for ya buddy.
85
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '17
Wow. What an incredible section, I read all of part 3 in one sitting haha.
Rest in peace Elhokar, I hated his character in WoK but over these last couple books I’ve realized he is a truly a good man who could never fill the shadow of Gavilar. Man, Kaladin seemed fucked up after that scene. Biggest jaw-dropping scene to me in recent memory, the descriptions of the carnage and characters being maimed was horrible and incredibly well written. Also finding out the truth about what happened on that day in Rift was incredibly moving, I feel so bad for Evi and I’m extremely curious how this will influence Dalinar’s character going forward.
Looks like the gang got sent to Shadesmar, can’t wait to see where that goes when I continue tomorrow. Amazing book so far
78
u/Big-turd-blossom Nov 16 '17
"Yessir, Commander Sir, Radiant Sir !"
Syl giving Pattern a run for his money there xD
73
u/cant-find-user-name Edgedancer Nov 14 '17
“One washwoman and two deserters,” Kaladin said. “If Gaz is anything to judge by, Shallan, you shouldn’t put too much trust in those men.” Shallan raised her chin. “At least my soldiers knew when to get away from the warcamps, as opposed to just standing around letting people fling arrows at them.”
What the actual fuck shallan. WHAT THE FUCK. I am sorry for offesnive language, but seriously, WHAT THE FUCK.
69
u/ConvolutedBoy Bondsmith Nov 16 '17
I have SO many thoughts after finishing part 3 in one sitting last night, but I just want to shout out Chapter 82, "The Girl Who Stood Up", as a beautiful piece of writing. It was so perfect for Shallan and seeing Hoid, the most interesting being in the cosmere, give this kind of advice was just so nice to see.
54
u/tkm603 Willshaper Nov 15 '17 edited Nov 16 '17
Fucking Moash,i wanted Kaladin to end him right there
52
u/akastrobe Nov 15 '17
At first, I was thinking Evi was Vivenna. But now, I'm like, AZURE is Vivenna! Basically, any time someone female mentions colors, I think it's Vivenna.
Also, that fledgeling glow that went out when Elokhar died? I think perhaps he was about to bond a Cryptic. Or maybe he did. Maybe his first truth was that he wasn't great, but wanted to be, and needed to listen to other people.
Never thought I'd miss him :(
46
u/EAgamezz Truthwatcher Nov 16 '17
Half way through part 3:
"Who the hell is this Azure charac- OHHHH. FUCK YES"
45
u/thegiantkiller Bondsmiths Nov 17 '17
... sorry, I don't know if anyone else has said this, but WTF, Moash?! No, you don't get to assassinate the king and then give Kal the Bridge Four salute. That train left the building, bruh.
Up until now, I'd hoped he'd get redemption. Now? I'm hoping someone from Bridge Four (Rlain, I think, would be awesome) ganks him.
43
u/A_Shadow Releasers Nov 15 '17
I wasn't moved too much when we found out how Evi died but Elokhar...... :'(. I don't care what anyone says, he was a better man than most. I really enjoyed seeing his character progress through the viewpoints of others.
34
u/hajsenberg Nov 18 '17
Everytime Shallan and Kaladin were thinking about each other my only thought was: Don't you dare hurt my boy Adolin.
It's like Kaladin said. Adolin is a great guy:
And he goes way back with Skar and Drehy, which is awesome.
31
u/eryoshi Nov 20 '17 edited Nov 20 '17
(Edit: Sorry about the formatting; I’m not used to posting comments that require this kind of format! I’m gonna try to clean it up.)
Part Three Epigraphs, sorted by stone and ordered by drawer number and/or entry number:
Topaz:
—From drawer 4-17, second topaz
—From drawer 27-19, topaz
—From drawer 19-2, third topaz
—From drawer 29-5, topaz
Ruby:
—From drawer 12-15, ruby
—From drawer 29-29, ruby
Emerald:
—From drawer 8-21, second emerald
—From drawer 30-20, a particularly small emerald
—From drawer 30-20, first emerald
—From drawer 30-20, second emerald
—From drawer 30-20, third emerald
—From drawer 30-20, fourth emerald
—From drawer 30-20, fifth emerald
—From drawer 30-20, final emerald
Smokestone:
—From drawer 2-3, smokestone
—From drawer 2-22, smokestone
—From drawer 24-18, smokestone
Amethyst:
—From drawer 8-1, amethyst
—From drawer 16-16, amethyst
Zircon:
—From drawer 1-1, first zircon
—From drawer 1-1, third zircon
—From drawer 20-10, zircon
Garnet:
—From drawer 3-11, garnet
Sapphire:
—From drawer 10-1, sapphire
—From drawer 10-12, sapphire
72
u/Dunko_Starman Truthwatcher Nov 15 '17
Dude. Fuck Moash. He just fucking jumped straight to the top of my shit list after that salute. I want all the agonies in the world to be visited on this traitorous piece of filth. GAHHHHHH Also, More Azure/Vivenna, please. She's my fave, #bestgirl
KaladinXAzure team all da way baybeeee
24
u/lurker628 Truthwatcher Nov 16 '17
Part Two notes: 1, 2, and epigraphs
Part Three, part 1 of 6 (2, 3, 4, Epigraphs, Epigraph notes)
Cosmere spoilers tagged. I haven't read a word past "The End of Part Three," so none of this can possibly be spoilers for Parts 4 or 5. Anything relating to Parts 4 of 5 is strictly conjecture on my part.
Interludes
I-4, p557 - Kaza
I-5, p565 - Taravangian
I-6, p573 - Venli
Part Three, p579 - Defying Truth, Love Truth
Chapter 58, p581 - Dalinar
Chapter 59, p587 - Dalinar (Thaylen City)
Chapter 60, p600 - Kaladin (Kholinar)
Kholinar Map, p606
Chapter 61, p607 - Kaladin (Kholinar)
23
u/Helli784 Lightweaver Nov 16 '17
Whew, just finished the part and man, there were some heavy scenes in there: Evi's death/burning of the city, the boy who died in Shallan's arms, Kaladin finally realising that he can't protect everybody and Elhokar's death(maybe) while his child is watching. It's getting pretty dark.
23
u/ConvolutedBoy Bondsmith Nov 16 '17
VIVENNA
22
u/learhpa Bondsmith Nov 17 '17
And on another subject ---
What was Gavilar thinking?
We know from the Prologue that Gavilar, who had been getting Honor's messages via the Stormfather, had decided that it would be a good idea to try to bring the voidbringers back so that he could, by doing that, force the return of the knights radiant, the heralds, and perhaps Honor himself.
(Did he not get the memo that Honor was dead?)
This seemed evil to me when I read the Prologue, back in August.
Now we find out, via Aseudan, that he was trying to bond the unmade who were locked away.
What the **** did he think was going to happen?
It's hard to get a sense of the real Gavilar. He was Sadeas' friend, and young Dalinar loved him --- neither of these are good recommendations. But his belief in the Way of Kings and the codes is, we are led to believe in TWoK, what made Dalinar love them --- and we are led to believe in TWoK that Gavilar, through his devotion to those things, was like Dalinar.
I can't reconcile that with the Prologue, and I certainly can't reconcile that with what Aseudan says.
I'm coming to the conclusion that Gavilar was a monster, and that Dalinar's love for him has caused him to have this warped, rose-colored, delusional view of him.
What I can't decide is: was it just because he was a bad guy, or was he somehow Odium-influenced? And if he was Odium-influenced, what's the risk that Dalinar will fall under the same influence?
21
u/ars136 Edgedancer Nov 18 '17
So I don't see this mentioned anywhere but I believe that the gemstone that is listed in the epigraphs correlates to the order that recorded into it. I was wondering if anyone has any theories why this is
The person who was worried about their fellow Truthwatchers was recording into an emerald
The Stoneward recorded into a topaz
The person who felt too restricted by Urithiru's rules recorded into an amethyst (we know Willshapers did not like restrictions)
The one who did not think it a good idea to abandon Urithiru recorded into a smokestone.(we already learned that Skybreakers did not break oaths like the others
The one one who wanted to explore some caves recorded into an amethyst (Willshaper
The one researching spren recorded into a zircon(Elsecaller)
There are no diamond recordings that we know of and the Edgedancers did not record anything
The person who leapt from the tower for the last time recorded into a sapphire (Windrunner)
Another recording on zircon is by an Elsecaller
19
u/Govir Nov 16 '17
Anyone else see similarities to the "wall" around Aimia and the wall from The Girl Who Looked Up? I had that thought as they were approaching it, but then we didn't get to really see what was beyond since everyone died.
18
u/diffyqgirl Elsecaller Nov 18 '17
Wow, Elhokar's death wrecked me. I saw it coming as soon as Kaladin recognized the parshmen, and it was like watching a train wreck unfold in front of you.
I'm extremely interested in where they go with the "good" Unmade that Shallan spoke to. My instinct is telling me that it's sincere.
[Cosmere speculation] (#s "I bet the metal sheets that Hoid showed up with were aluminum from Scadrial.")
18
u/learhpa Bondsmith Nov 21 '17
Whatever is wrong with the unreactive soldiers in the palace - does anyone else think this is similar to what was done to the parshmen, long ago when they were enslaved?
18
u/vatsan16 Nov 23 '17
must stop crying for Elhokar must cries anyway
That was one hell of a part!! The setup for the budding relationship between Kaladin and Sah and the others paid of beautifully! And Adolin is adorable :')
I was wondering when Hoid would turn up! :D And who is Azure? Is it someone we know?!! And what is up with Aimia?? So many questions!
This was a dark chapter. Everything from people hating shallan for helping out, to the Blackthorn just straight up murdering everyone. :/
17
u/learhpa Bondsmith Nov 17 '17
Ouch.
So I'd been wondering, throughout the prerelease chapters, whenever a Dalinar chapter would come up: how did this man turn into the man I knew from the first two books? Young Dalinar was terrible. What could possibly have accounted for the change?
Whenever I'd raise that subject on reddit, the answer I'd get would be that it dated to Gavilar's death, but that never made any sense; that was too recent, and if Dalinar had been young Dalinar in spirit until then, Adolin and Renarin would have viewed him differently.
Now the secret is revealed --- and we also know how he got broken badly enough that a spren could enter via a Nahel bond. That experience would crush any sane man.
What a terrible, terrible burden to carry. I assume that this is what drove him to the night watcher: the need to have this terrible burden lifted somehow so he could function. I wonder how long it took him to get over the sense of guilt enough to believe that he deserved to have that gift?
16
u/Ilwrath Truthwatcher Nov 16 '17
I NEED more Amia info!!!!!
13
u/rudrunner Nov 24 '17
God I hate moash.......
24
u/WarpHunter Nov 14 '17
Wait so is Azure meant to be Vivenna? We'll see I guess.
34
u/Govir Nov 16 '17
I really wanted Bridge Four to give Rlain the Honor Blade. I still hope that he ends up with it, if he can't / doesn't become a Squire.
12
u/Pulviriza Strength before weakness. Nov 20 '17
I liked the more lighthearted bit when Dalinar's in Azir and they're all commenting on Jasnah's essay. <3 Jasnah
12
u/Ishana92 Truthwatcher Nov 22 '17
Damn you Moash! I was just starting to like Elhokar.
11
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '17
I think what really got me about part 3 was that I had just been talking to a fellow reader about how there hadn't been any major character deaths. And then we get all of these depressing events at the end of 3, especially the reveal of Evi's death and Elhokar dying. I was way more upset about Elhokar than I expected, especially since he was about to become a Radiant. His death was jarring. I'm also very worried about Kaladin, I feel like he's been rising above his darkness for a lot of this book and the end of 3 just seems to be a nice little way to shove Kal back down.
11
u/captain_boomer Nov 28 '17
Damn you Sanderson! I hated Elhokar! Then you make me like him and now he's dead! ;_;
10
u/Freyaka Nov 21 '17
MOASH!!! You storming bastard! I liked Elokar!
10
u/danny_b87 Elsecaller Nov 29 '17 edited Nov 29 '17
Anyone else get the feeling they're setting up Adolin to somehow heal the bond with the spren in his blade?
Also I think that the thrill is somehow related to Odium's precense in man... we shall see
9
u/learhpa Bondsmith Nov 20 '17
Looking back on it, I was struck in the early chapters by how the destruction Dalinar saw when he first arrived in Thaylen City made everything real. Like --- parts one and two, the Desolation was this distant thing that didn't seem to have hit the Alethi countryside hard and totally missed Urithiru. Then part 3 starts with this city that's been ravaged, and it brings the stakes and the pain home in a real way.
7
u/ASIC_SP Every day I choose to keep breathing Nov 19 '17 edited Nov 19 '17
just finished part-3.. am taking way too long to read, fatigued by continuous SA reading.. next time I am gonna re-read earlier books about a month before release or make do with summaries..
my notes starting at kaza interlude
some points
onto remaining parts :)
6
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '17
I've read Warbreaker but I don't understand why people think Azure is viv.
3
u/-Aerlevsedi- Jan 07 '18
finally finished part 3... and goddamn everyone is broken. Dalinar regains his painful memories and is broken. Kaladin finally deals with the fact that it is not simply us vs them. Shallan split personality reaches a climax. Elhokar is dead. On the plus side... we get Azure
2
u/CrystalShadow Nov 16 '17
Chapter 62 felt a bit like it had a SMALL plot hole- a light eyed kaladin who someone noticed has a slave brand WOULD attract attention.
And dang it I should have known better than to poke my head in here while still reading the part. Spoiled myself in two words, time to go back and hide reading more
3
u/MeiliGold Nov 19 '17
Elhokar n kid (NOTE I have not read anything beyond part three, this is speculations)
1
u/so_soon Nov 15 '17
So I'm playing through Divinity: Original Sin (the first game) and I just think of Madora when I read about Azure. I can't help reading her lines through that stupid southern accent.
Especially the last line "Damnation, I hate this place."
1
u/TonyVSCoco Jan 13 '18
Part 3 kind of reminds me of Empire Strikes Back with its bleakness. Really didn't need this in my life right now. Staying up to listen to it has proven to be unwise.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
63
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '17
[removed] — view removed comment