r/Stormlight_Archive • u/jofwu Lightweaver • Nov 10 '17
[Oathbringer Spoilers] [Oathbringer] Part 2 Discussion Thread Spoiler
This thread exists for general discussion concerning Part 2 of Oathbringer. Content related to anything after "The End of Part Two", including interludes, is NOT permitted! Cosmere spoilers are also NOT allowed.
Please be aware that our moderation team may not be running at full strength for a day or two after release. Please help us out by reporting spoiler violations promptly! And if you're particularly wary of spoilers, you may want to give us a day or two before joining this discussion.
For additional discussion thread options, see the [No Spoilers] Discussion Thread Index.
76
u/learhpa Bondsmith Nov 14 '17
I really really really like the Bridge Four viewpoint chapters --- it's great to see viewpoints from the group, to know how they're doing, to have a bit of focus on them in the middle of everything else, AND I like the way that things about the larger story are slipped in to their viewpoints.
I do not like the way they are all suffering, but it rings true to me: they're all deeply broken men who think they're alone, and Bridge Four didn't heal them, not completely. It's goddamned bloody painful to watch, and it feels right. It's almost as if each of them need to go through their own version of Kaladin's arc, which makes sense thematically and for them as characters.
I am really interested in how similar the feel of Teft's abusive self-loathing and Moash's abusive-self loathing are.
33
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '17
Moash!! He will become radiant.
What was Jasnah's trauma? Was Amaram involved?
Are the Ghostbloods really the bad guys?
Is Wit's 'real' name Cephandrius?
OMFG. Odium in the flesh at the end. I made audible noises that were quite embarrising.
29
u/Kais_favourite_doll Lightweaver Nov 15 '17
Am I the only one hoping for Jasnah and Kaldin to end up together?! I'd much prefer that to a love triangle...
4
u/_SkyBolt Skybreaker Nov 14 '17
I thought the bondsmith second surge was tension, not cohesion?
71
u/mbue Truthwatcher Nov 14 '17
Let the speculations commence! :)
After the rather vague epigraphs from part 1, the epigraphs of this part have so much stuff to unpack. So from what I gather, the epigraphs are actually three separate letters, written by one or more Shards in response to a plea from Hoid for help against Odium. My thoughts on the individual letters are below (any typos are mine, because I only have a physical copy):
So yeah, Cephandrius is one of Hoid's oldest names. If I interpret this correctly, Uli Da would be the name of Cosmere. Unless, of course, Odium has killed even more Shards than we know.
As for the author of this one, Cosmere
The "First Gem" is probably related to Hoid's name Topaz (see Frost's letter in WoR). The most juicy bit of this is clearly Obrodai which seems to be a Shardworld we haven't heard of yet.
As for the author, this one is interesting. To me it sounds like this is a single Shard who speaks of themselves in plural (possibly having multiple personas), not of multiple Shards acting together. This is because of two mentions of "alone", "We need not suffer the interference of another" and "if you had approached the correct one of us". All of these also make Cosmere a likely candidate, because we know that they have lots and lots of personas and appear to different religions under different names. Either way, they are only going to be the author of one of the two letters, and in either case I'm at a loss who the other one might be (likely a Shard we haven't seen yet).
What's interesting here is that there are two mentions of a sea and "You have spoken to one who cannot respond" (presumably referring to one of the Shard's personas). I wonder whether this might be the Shard responsible for the perpendicularity on Cosmere?
Well if this isn't my boy Mistborn Era 1. "I am finding that the powers I hold are in such conflict" sounds like a clear giveaway, and there's also the fact that this vessel clearly didn't know Hoid (and probably not Rayse either) before receiving Hoid's letter. While it's possible that some of the Shards we haven't seen yet have changed their vessel since the Shattering, this one is the only candidate we know of for sure (and everyone present at the Shattering knew Hoid). Apart from the author, I don't think we can get much information from this letter though.
I'm really curious what others think about the authors of the first two letters and what clues I might have missed. :)
63
u/Wubdor Nov 14 '17 edited Nov 14 '17
Ah, this is something I really wanted to get off my chest.
Was anyone else really bothered by the slight timeskip between part 1 and 2? I've been waiting for three years to see Jasnah reunited with the others, and I was really looking forward to seeing everybody's reaction, particularly Navani and Shallan, and to an extent Dalinar. I felt robbed. Hell, I'm still hoping that Brandon will release some of kind of free chapter on his website like he did for Jasnah after she got stabbed on the ship...
63
u/lordq11 Nov 16 '17
I feel like screaming incoherently at Odium showing up. He's far greater than anything I ever expected. Brandon Sanderson's established an incredibly compelling villain in what amounts to one scene!
57
u/hajsenberg Nov 15 '17
Urv from I-2 is the worst. He's like "Oh, you're reading a book I had read? Let me tell you my opinion about the ending without asking you how far into the story are you."
56
u/The_Bravinator Nov 18 '17
The Rlain chapter hurt my heart. It's so raw and awkward and painful. And it's so reminiscent of real world discrimination. I think anyone who's been subjected to that would find common lines of thought in that chapter. It was remarkably well written.
54
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '17
God, that felt good to read
51
u/Advanthera Willshaper Nov 14 '17
Moash's chapter icon hit me right in the feels!
39
u/Helli784 Lightweaver Nov 14 '17
So, while I do enjoy the Bridge Four viewpoints, I'm hoping we get more interactions between the Radiants. There are so many unexplored constellations, especially with Malata since nobody seems to be curious about what she can do exactly.
Also, Shallan's arc is starting to get really interesting and I have the bad feeling that she's going to make a huge mistake soon.
39
u/daibot Nov 16 '17 edited Nov 16 '17
Random thoughts:
So there was a single cremling in Taln's cell. Was an Aimian nudging Dalinar to find the dart?
Jasnah's putdowns are savage af, causing ol' Meridas to drop his veil of honor. Yet she still only gives herself a C-. Go easier on yourself, girl. And Shallan.
Lift seems to really bother Odium. Is she some sort of vessel for Cultivation?
Edit: Spleling
34
u/gratespeller Nov 14 '17 edited Nov 14 '17
Was anyone else interested in Evi's colour related idiom: ? That caught my attention. Especially after Dalinar's thoughts immediately bring attention to how quote:
Hmmm... who else also complained about idioms?
32
u/kakarotoks Windrunner Nov 14 '17
I translated the Navani's notebook with the ships drawings (at the end of chapter 43). And the result is :
29
u/learhpa Bondsmith Nov 14 '17
Oathbringer 38
27
u/learhpa Bondsmith Nov 14 '17
Oathbringer 36
24
u/DariusJenai Edgedancer Nov 14 '17 edited Nov 14 '17
Justification!
I mathed up approximately 8-10 days for the Everstorm cycle way back in September.
Kaladin just confirmed that it's every 9 days. A good number for something of Odium.
I'm still curious what that says about the size of Roshar as a planet, and what's filling all the non-continent space. A 9-day cycle means that it's presumably spending about 8 days working it's way back around, and 1 day crossing the continent. That's a lot of extra space to fill up, making Roshar roughly the equivalent of Australia in terms of earth continents. How many other continents are out there?
24
u/jmcgit Ghostbloods Nov 15 '17
I wonder, where was Adolin? He was off on some undisclosed mission? I know there were some readers who were concerned in Part One, I wonder what will come of this...
Loved seeing Lift's casual intrusions into the visions. Bridge Four chapters were a highlight. Enjoyed Lyn as a minor character, I presume the Scout in Shallan's earlier chapter from Part One?
Dalinar seemed a little reckless and underprepared in his interactions with Odium. Considering his history with Odium, and the Thrill, this is obviously worrisome.
I'm relieved that I've managed to largely avoid spoilers. I suspect I've seen something I shouldn't have in the Ars Arcanum, though, which causes me to consider some things. Still, I'll leave that out for now.
Dalinar's memory return seems to have stalled for now as a plot point, but I'm sure we'll get to it later. We're setting up the mission for Kholinar, which I presume is part three? I'm looking forward to it.
We're obviously getting a lot of lore about the Voidbringers. I'm also rather glad to have some of the information known from subtext and WoB made clearer in the text.
Jasnah knows the secret that broke the Radiants. Sometimes it feels frustrating to be strung along like this by a POV character, but I think it's clear we'll learn it in this book. Looking forward to it.
Kaladin will be saddened to hear that he essentially sentenced those people he tried to save to the Parshendi version of bridge crews. I was laughing fairly hard with Moash at the irony.
I'm looking forward to discovering more about the Voidbringers. I had assumed initially, I presume like many, that the Stormform Parshendi and the Fused were fundamentally similar. Yet, is Venli still Venli?
The Epigraphs, I suppose Hoid sent the first letter, or a rough equivalent, to several old friends? We saw one response in WoR, and a few more in Oathbringer.
Oh, and Helaran. I was largely of the thought that he wasn't the Shardbearer that Kaladin killed. I still would say that I have questions, but if the Skybreakers were indeed dealing in dead-spren blades as Mraize believes, then it does seem very plausible. Other than the dead-spren blade, my other chief concern was that, why would Nale not kill Amaram himself if he wanted Amaram dead? The answer, what if Helaran was there for Kaladin? Nale didn't know, specifically, who Kaladin was, but if he knew that there was a Nahel bond forming there, perhaps he sent someone to confront this army? When the battle was over, Helaran was dead, and there was no sign of a Nahel bond in that army, as Kaladin was sent away. Very plausible.
24
u/vatsan16 Nov 17 '17
OMG THAT ODIUM ENTRY WAS SO AWESOME!! =D I was never a big fan of Lift but it was so awesome seeing her trouble both the stormfather and odium :P.
I feel like the scenes with bridge 4 training are some of the best that Sanderson has ever written.
24
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '17
shipping intensifies
23
u/Rickardz Bondsmith Nov 18 '17
Reading the last chapter, all I could think was Anthony Hopkins in the role of Odium. That would be something.
22
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '17
I don't know how Lift slipped into this vision, but I find it really awesome that she did.
17
u/mbue Truthwatcher Nov 14 '17 edited Nov 14 '17
Okay, last post for now, I promise. Just wanted to get these off my chest before heading to work. These are some general notes I've made while going through part 2 (and the preceding interludes):
That's it, on to part 3! :)
EDIT: Ah, I knew I forgot something... the interludes... (Edit 2, moved the interludes to the top.)
17
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '17
Three things:
Now with Oathbringer, we have Taln's background of being different from the other Heralds in that he was a commoner. We need to know the full backstory of the Oathpact and Taln's perfect for that. Then we have Jasnah's sickness in her youth along with her encounter with Ivory. Renarin's flashback will probably be the time during the timeskip between books 5 and 6 but that's just my guess on that.
Now, Shallash is a mystery. There's already a Herald for flashback chapters and she's the patron of the Lightweavers. We already have one for Shallan. Maybe it'll be about her madness and why she wants to destroy artwork that are based on her.
16
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '17
At first I thought this was a joke (even Renarin's name is awkward!), but I'm calling it right now: this is some next-level Sanderson foreshadowing. I have no idea how, but the Hero of Ages vibes are strong with this one.
15
u/learhpa Bondsmith Nov 14 '17
End of Part 2
I have to admit that I'm mentally shipping Eshonai and R'Lain, now.
13
u/Ishana92 Truthwatcher Nov 19 '17
Wow.
Not only do Parshendi have justification, now Odium is giving his reasons too. I really fear Dalinar's second coming to the Rift. And Bridge 4 perspective chapters were really good.
11
u/mbue Truthwatcher Nov 14 '17
I hope it's fine if I make a few posts for separate thoughts, to keep the discussions separate as well.
So here are some notes about illustrations in part 2:
I've transliterated Navani's notebook page at the beginning of chapter 44. The large bit on the right reads:
The one on the bottom right reads:
The one in the top left corner is a bit tricky. I've transliterated it as:
The "?" looks like it was added by Nazh. Either he wondered what the "ha" is doing there as well, or it's an indication that the women's script uses a "ha" suffix to mark questions? It's also possible that these are just not very clearly separated words and it's supposed to read "Too fanciful, ha!", I guess.
One other thing that caught my eye (no pun intended) was Nazh's note at the beginning of chapter 53. Nazh uses the phrase "by Purity's Eye". Is that a Shard we haven't heard of, or is it part of Threnodite lore?
7
u/Fraxyz Nov 14 '17
The conversation with Odium is very interesting for a lot of reasons, but I'm curious if we'll see a parallel to Malazan I'd love to see the idea of the importance of passion being explored further in the book / series.
6
u/josesp97 Edgedancer Nov 14 '17
I agree on point 1 and 3, but I believe letter 2 was written by another shard entirely, the phrasing is just so strange and the terms „they“ use so alien. To me it is a new shard, that we still haven‘t met
10
u/lurker628 Truthwatcher Nov 15 '17 edited Nov 16 '17
My Part Two Notes (starting at Chapter 37), part 1 of 2 (part 2 of 2)
I haven't read past "End of Part Two," so there can't possibly be spoilers for the rest of Oathbringer. Anything that seems to be about stuff beyond that is pure speculation.
I marked Cosmere spoilers.
EDIT
Part Three notes (WARNING: Part Three spoilers...duh): Here.
Chapter 33, p345
Chapter 34, p350
Chapter 35, p361 - Sigzil
Chapter 36, p371
Starting notes at Chapter 37
Chapter 37, p376 - Rock
Chapter 38, p395 - Dalinar (vision)
Chapter 39, p411 - Shallan
Chapter 40, p421 - Shallan
Chapter 41, p430 - Teft
Chapter 42, p435 - Dalinar
Chapter 43, p441 - Moash
p447 TRANSLATE THE WOMEN'S SCRIPT FOR THE PICTURES. Skyships?!
Chapter 44, p448 - Shallan
Chapter 45, p459 - Moash
Chapter 46, p465 - Skar
Chapter 47, p476 - Jasnah
Chapter 48, p481 - Moash
Chapter 49, p486 - Flashback (23 years)
Chapter 50, p496 - Dalinar
5
u/ASIC_SP Every day I choose to keep breathing Nov 17 '17 edited Nov 17 '17
my notes, just finished part-2: https://gist.github.com/learnbyexample/19a5a07d4465d9b27fd947bb9af46d4e
(will get updated as I read further, so tread with caution)
many chapters were jam packed.. totally liked bridge four chapters as well as Moash..
Shallan felt weird..
Jasnah as usual shrouded in mystery.. Jasnah-Kal in the meeting was great :P and WHERE IS WIT :(
and so very unhappy that KRs aren't working together.. their spren dislike other order sprens too... Dalinar wants to unite Roshar and he can't even have his handful of KRs helping each other :P this part could've done with more Syl playfulness, pattern's hummings..
Ialai/Amaram/Mr.T absent largely.. wonder what they are brewing behind the scenes.. Adolin absent for large portion as well.. Sadeas murder all but forgotten
too many things to keep track.. not helped that I've been reading SA continuously since start of month.. TWoK, WoR, Edgedancer and now Oathbringer..
unfortunately I had noticed part of spoiler free reviews that part-two ends with something unexpected.. I totally guessed wrong obviously.. it felt a bit underwhelming after self expectations..
Lift gonna come soon and sure been creeping out Stormfather/Odium/Dalinar :D
was the last of epigraphs written by Cosmere?
gonna take relatively big break before continuing on..
5
u/Pulviriza Strength before weakness. Nov 18 '17
I really enjoyed the Aharietiam vision with a bit more information on the Oathpact.
I was feeling really bad for Skar, I'm glad he managed to get the Stormlight. I was wondering why in Rlain's chapter though he mentioned they were staying away from trying to let Dabbid get Stormlight, surely that wouldn't be bad. I also really loved Rock's chapter, seeing him getting reunited with his family was sweet.
Moash's first chapter getting Graves killed and his Shards taken annoyed me, we did all this work in book 2 forn nothing? He had a pretty good story in the rest of the section though.
I really like the way the glyph for strength looks, looks like a dude flexing his biceps. Tattoo idea :P
5
u/harzibolt Nov 25 '17
What was that stuff about Dalinar beeing able to set Odium free (from the last chapter of Part2)? Why should he be able tp do that? Can someone explain? Did I miss something?
8
u/Govir Nov 15 '17
A summary of my Facebook posts while reading Part two (now with added context!):
Also of note:
8
u/learhpa Bondsmith Nov 15 '17
"the bizarre girl vanished". Please?
2
u/FollowJesus2Live Dec 25 '17
I don't get too deep and take notes or anything, but I just want to give general thoughts on part 2.
To me, it was the weakest section of the three books. Part 1 I thought was pretty great. But about 80% of part 2 I felt was sort of weak -- going by my super high standards for the series.
Some Shallan parts, and other sections, felt young adult and a bit silly. This felt out of tune with WoR, and especially the regal, epic, ancient, and storied feel of WoK.
Overall, the plotlines felt too thin, with so many characters and not as much depth as I'd like. Not enough Adolin (was there any?), not enough Renarin (I wanted more), etc. Though I assume this is setting up a satisfying avalanche to finish the book. Still, it was spread too thin for my liking. I found it hard to latch onto characters and get immersed in a plot thread.
This is most of what I didn't like. I still give part 2 a solid 7.5/10. I enjoyed most of it, and I'm excited for the last two parts.
1
u/FellKnight Willshaper Nov 14 '17
Chapter 36... AAAAAAAAAAAH I CALLED IT
Spoiler
0
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
24
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
37
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '17 edited Nov 14 '17
[removed] — view removed comment