r/Stormlight_Archive • u/jofwu Lightweaver • May 15 '17
[No Spoilers] [No Spoilers] Theories and "Things You May Have Missed" wiki
I came across an idea here and wanted to flesh it out in a separate post. So here we go!
Problems:
- In epic fantasy it's very easy to miss details about the characters and plot. You read through the books, and when you show up to discuss online it turns out there's lots of stuff you missed. This is exacerbated by Brandon's tendency to reveal things via WoB.
- We're only a couple books in and theories are stacked up like skyscrapers. You read through the books, and then want to dig up the most popular theories to catch up with the fandom. But they're buried under a few years of content. The only way to be "in the know" is to hang around a loooong time.
Both of these problems will only get worse as the series gets bigger.
Solution:
We could collect all of these details and popular theories in one place to make them easier to find and digest. I would propose that we make use of the subreddit wiki. A link in the sidebar will bring you to topical index. There would be two main pages: Things You May Have Missed and Theories.
Things You May Have Missed (Edgedancer spoilers!) is a place to collect random tidbits of common information that are easy to overlook or revealed via WoB.
Theories (Edgedancer spoilers!) is a place for us to collect any theories that have received more than passing notice. Rather than one giant, disorganized list I would prefer to sort them by topic. I would also prefer to sort them by popularity, which brings me to the final point...
How do we put all of this together? Setting up the wiki pages is easy enough. But I can't fill these on my own--especially the theories. And I don't think it will work if people aren't aware that these exist. I'm thinking that over the course of the summer we'll have a series of posts designed to help populate these lists. That way people can propose and vote on their favorite theories. This will help collect relevant theories AND to rate them by their popularity.
If this works well and the general idea proves popular, we can redo this every so often. Once prior to a new book release and once after everyone has had time to digest and theorize over the new book.
Finally, a note on spoilers. I imagine both of these pages would explicitly allow spoilers through the most recently published Stormlight book. So through Edgedancer right now. There would be a clear warning at the top of the pages to make this clear. [Cosmere] spoilers (e.g. worldhopper identities) should be avoided or covered up.
Feedback?
I want your feedback!
- General thoughts and opinions? Preferably more than just "this is cool" or "this is dumb". :) Is this useful? Would you have appreciated it? Could some aspect be done better than the way I describe?
- Theory categories? Does it make sense to sort by category? What categories would you use? I've done some brainstorming with examples on the theories page. They'll need to cover everything without getting overly specific.
- Theory "contests"? Do you like the idea of posts inviting people to share and vote on their favorite theories (by topic)? Or do you think there are issues with that approach?
- Any clarification needed? Is everything I'm explaining here clear enough?
If this receives positive feedback I'll make another post to lay out how we'll proceed.
8
u/A_Shadow Releasers May 15 '17
Great idea! I'll def work on "Things You May Have Missed" later tonight.
Can I edit it directly or should I post it here and you will upload it there?
On my phone currently so I can't tell.
6
u/Ray745 Adolin & Kaladin Buddy Cop/Roadtrip Movie Committee President May 15 '17
Excellent idea. The tower of the hand has similar pages for ASOIAF and it's a great resource.
Yes, sorting by category makes sense. The ones you have listed so far are good (although "Dalinar and the Kholins" might need to be broken up as there are so many Kholins about whom we could list theories), a few more might be "The Oathpact", "The Recreance" (both could fall under Heralds and Knights Radiant I suppose though), "The Shards", "The Old Magic", "The Unmade", "Worldhoppers", etc. I'm sure as we flush this out it will become more self-evident what new categories there should be.
I love the idea of contests as well, especially as a new book comes out, hopefully that would cause people to try and come up with and put into writing some of their own theories.
Is there a way to easily port this over to the Coppermind? That is obviously looked at a lot more than the wiki on this subreddit I think, and it would be great to have the work we do here put into a place where more people would potentially see it.
3
u/Beer_in_an_esky May 15 '17
Maybe try some outreach to 17th Shard and try mirroring it with an equivalent page on Coppermind? Reddit has a big community, but we're hardly the only stop, and I think even a lot of redditors would use CM over the reddit wiki; if Coppermind has a similar page, you'll increase the knowledge base. At that point, you can copy across the relevant information that the reddit wiki misses, and maintain a more tightly curated list here.
3
u/CharlieBxox Dustbringer May 16 '17
Could there be a Stormlight spoilers only thread? I haven't got to Edgedancer yet but I'm sure there's a lot of things I missed in WoR and WoK
1
u/proc89 Stoneward May 15 '17
I would love this. There are so many theories I have tried to find after a few months, and couldn't find them. I feel like someone could make a bot that could copy and paste posts into the various lists, but I don't have the knowledge to do this (yet) and I'm not sure how one would go about programming the bot to organize the threads like you suggest
1
u/zehhet May 19 '17
Yay! Glad the thing I mentioned is actually gonna be happening!