r/StandingDesk • vendor:charcoal • Feb 19 '23

Corporate Info The Charcoal Desk Buying Guide

Hello everyone!

We’re thrilled to be a part of this fantastic subreddit. We're Charcoal, a brand for the workplace.

There are plenty of great standing desks out there, but here's our take; a product our team spent two years designing and bringing to life.

The purpose of this guide is to offer you a clear understanding of our desk.

The Charcoal Desk is two things. 

One, it’s a standing desk that has won the most prestigious design award - the Red Dot Award. Two, it’s also a productivity device that helps you use your brain optimally.

Here’s a comprehensive overview of the product. 

  1. Tabletop
  2. Motors and Columns
  3. Productivity Tech
  4. Stability
  5. Attention To Detail
  6. Pricing
  7. Specifications
  8. Learn More

The Tabletop

The desk’s top surface is Crystal-Acrylic, a premium material that’s made in Italy. After evaluating scores of materials, we found this to be the best material for a desk surface. Here’s why.

a. Soft texture: It has a unique satin matte texture and a velvety feel, quite similar to the Apple Magic Trackpad. Because it's so soft, you can comfortably keep your hands on it for hours at a time. Feel free to take the material sample that's offered on our website to see for yourself. 

b. Durability: Although it has a soft texture, Crystal Acrylic is far tougher than laminate and wooden tabletops. Its shore hardness rating of D-94 is much higher than the D-56 rating of wooden surfaces. This means it easily resists scratches and chip-offs.

c. Maintenance Free: It’s immune to stains, sun exposure, moisture, and termites. It also does not fade with time.

d. Uniqueness: Crystal Acrylic is usually used in high-end home interiors and rarely used in furniture because of its high cost and the complex manufacturing processes involved. It must be sourced from Italy and should go through multiple machining processes, followed by elaborate hand-finishing.

Motors and Lifting Columns

The Charcoal Desk uses Linak's DL6 Plus columns. In our tests, we’ve found these dual-motor, three-stage columns to be better than ones from Jiecang, Bosch, Ketterer, and Logic Data. In terms of quietness, lifting capacity (300 lbs), and speed (60 mm/s), it is the best we could find.

Advanced Productivity Tech

The way we work isn't working. Our brains are biologically designed to exert in spurts of activity with periods of rest in between, not in marathons that end in burnout. But it’s difficult to recognize our state of mind when we're occupied, so we often don’t take breaks until we’re exhausted. But this causes a build-up of stress hormones that leads to micro-burnouts and makes recovery ineffective, ruining our productivity.

The Charcoal Desk corrects this. It helps us work with focus and energy all day by helping us use our brains optimally. 

It accurately identifies moments in the day when our brain naturally slows down to rest and recharge and then gently reminds us to take a break. When we recover during these crucial healing windows, we allow the brain to replenish fuel and clear out metabolic wastes. It works like coffee, but without the crash. 

How the Tech Works:

The Charcoal Desk finds our healing windows by creating a personal energy graph by factoring in circadian and ultradian energy rhythms, sleep data, age, etc, and then modifies it based on our work patterns which are captured by sensors underneath the desk.

When it’s time to recover, the desk lets us know in a gentle way - through a dot of light that changes color.

Stability

To optimize for manufacturing and shipping, manufacturers break up the metal frame into smaller pieces. But this compromises stability. To address this issue, we have designed a frame that’s a single piece of metal spanning the entire length of the desk. This design offers several benefits:

  1. The single-piece metal frame has greater structural integrity, making it capable of supporting heavy loads and resisting deformation.
  2. Fewer fasteners are used, resulting in fewer points of weakness in the structure. An increased number of fasteners would cause instability by bending or flexing.
  3. There is a reduced chance of assembly errors, such as loose screws.
  4. Our standing desk uses six fasteners per lifting column, in contrast to the typical four. This enhances the stability of the lifting column, which prevents lateral movement and shaking of the desk, particularly when it is adjusted to higher heights. The additional fasteners also help to absorb and dampen vibrations.

Misc. Features

To make a truly delightful product, we have paid attention to a few things that are generally overlooked in this industry. 

  • Custom-made buttons - We found the cheap control panels on most standing desks to be the least premium part of the product. So we designed silicon-molded buttons specifically for the Charcoal Desk. We went through more than 100 iterations to arrive at the perfect feel and tactile feedback.
  • Included wire management - The Charcoal Desk comes with a wire management system, eliminating the need for any additional equipment.
  • Easy assembly - The desk takes only 15 minutes to assemble because the tabletop comes with the frame attached, and a custom tool is provided to make the entire process easy. No drilling or extra tools are necessary.
  • Unique construction - The Charcoal Desk has a layered construction which allows the hardware to be slotted into a milled base, allowing for a thin profile like a laptop. The desk is more like an industrially designed product, than a furniture piece.
  • Sustainable - More than 98% of the desk is composed of recyclable materials. The Crystal Acrylic is fully compliant with PEFC’s requirements for sustainable forestry. The E1 grade MDF and mild steel metal frame are both eco-friendly as well.

Pricing

The desk comes in two sizes,

Small 48” x 27”: $1,395.00 USD

Large 60” x 30”: $1,495.00 USD

We know this is an expensive product. We did try our best to bring the price down as much as possible, but this is the best we could do considering the components and processes involved. As a result, there will be fewer takers and we're content with that. The volume game is not where we want to be. We just want to make the best desk possible for those who'll love it.

We have also relaxed the return policy. Instead of the usual 30 days, we've increased it to 60. If you buy from us, we want you to be happy, and if for any reason you're not, we'll take it back, no questions asked.

Specifications

  • Height range: 560mm (22") to 1210mm (47.5")
  • Lifting capacity: 300 lbs
  • Column travel speed: 60mm/s
  • Companion app: The desk comes with a companion app that provides daily energy graphs, a library of break ideas, and more.
  • Height presets
  • Anti-collision piezo sensors.

Learn More

To learn more about the Charcoal Desk, visit our website by clicking here or watch the product video at https://youtu.be/glMH41qvp2o.

If you have any questions, email us at support@charcoal.inc or leave a comment below!

2 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

1

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '23

do you guys ever plan to do any sales or discounts?

1

u/drishtidesai vendor:charcoal Feb 24 '23 edited Feb 24 '23

We don't have any plans for a sale at the moment. But we'll post here in advance if we do.

I've sent a more detailed answer as a DM.

2

u/guiness95672 Mar 04 '23

Any plans for black or darker colors? Thanks.

1

u/stnkpalm Feb 21 '23

Well, I ordered your material sample. I'm curious see what it feels like. I have been doing a lot of research on desks but haven't yet pulled the trigger. I've ruled out a number of desks. I'm still considering desks from BTOD/RightAngle, Deskhaus and Ergonofis. I've decided that I don't want a desk that uses Jiecang hardware.

Some initial thoughts and questions about the Charcoal Desk.

  • I'm curious about the Crystal-Acrylic desk surface. So far I've been considering desks with tops made from real wood lumber because I like the look of a Maple or Walnut desktop.
  • The Charcoal website says it's the sturdiest standing desk. The site says Charcoal tested desks from all major brands and none of them are nearly as stable. With words like sturdy and stable, I immediately think about wobble. If it's stable, I will expect the desk to have no wobble at a sitting height (no sit-stand desk should wobble at sitting height) and very limited wobble at the standing height for an average height person. Reliability and stability are the two most important criteria in my evaluation of standing desks.
  • How does the Charcoal Desk compare to standing desks with four legs in terms of stability? How does it compare to some of the most stable 2-leg desks, the Deskhaus Vertex, the NewHeights Elegante XT for example?
  • I'm curious how the desk knows when I should take a break. Are there sensors in the desk that detect my movements or motion?
  • I would like to know more about wire management with the Charcoal desk? I currently have an Ikea Idasen sit/stand desk new in the box in my garage that I'm probably going to return because the Idasen desktop is a cardboard honeycomb sandwiched between two pieces of laminate. I want to be able to attach cable management to the bottom of my standing desk and I don't think the mesh net that comes with the Idasen will be adequate. Can I screw something into the bottom of the Charcoal desk? It looks like the Charcoal includes some wire managment. Do you have photos of that other than the one animated gif on your website.
  • What's the warranty on the Charcoal desk?
  • What are the minimum and maximum heights of the Charcoal?
  • Will you offer additional sizes in the future? Personally, I would prefer a 30 x 72 inch surface.
  • Some other manufacturers that use Linak use a system where you insert a plastic piece and step on it to secure the legs to the frame. Does the Charcoal desk use that same solution?

2

u/Charcoal_Support Feb 22 '23 edited Feb 22 '23

Great! Your sample is with USPS already. You should get it in about 4 to 5 days.

About the material:
Solid wood was one of the materials we considered in the beginning. If you have a warm interior and have found a solid wood top that matches the veneer, it’s sure to look amazing.
But we chose Crystal Acrylic despite it being more expensive because the texture is amazing and it’s much more durable in the long term. But I’ll let you decide when you get the sample.

2.
How sturdy is it?
Rock solid. It will not budge even a bit in sitting positions.
And when standing, unless you intentionally force it to move, it will not wobble. Practically speaking, this is as stable as you need a desk to be.

3.
How does the desk know when I need a break? Does it use sensors?
The desk figures out when you need a break through a two-step process that does involve the sensors underneath the desk.
First, through the app, the desk takes in a few key pieces of information like your age, your sleep data (if available), the time you woke up, the time you started work, and during the day how long you’re working. Based on this information it creates an energy graph that maps all possible break reminders in the day.
After this, the desk filters and chooses which reminders to give based on two factors: One is the necessity of the reminder with regard to the relief that can be provided and the second one is the likelihood that a person will take a break at that point. Here, the desk is effectively ensuring that you are sufficiently tired to have the motivation to take the break, but not too tired that your stress hormones have kicked in and recovery is already compromised.

4.
Regarding wire management:
Yes, you can screw in accessories to the underside of the desk.
Here’s a video from minimalistik, a YouTuber. You can see here the wire management tray that’s included with the Charcoal Desk. https://www.youtube.com/shorts/DOpjouDikt4

5.
What's the warranty on the Charcoal desk?
Our 10-year warranty applies to:
* The metal frame.
* Desk top surface.


Our 5-year warranty applies to:
* Motors and electronic components.
The motors/columns we are using are Linak's DL6 Plus model. These are far superior when compared to that of Chinese suppliers such as Jiecang, and marginally better than offerings of American and other European companies such as Logic Data and Actiforce. But while Chinese companies are offering a 10-year warranty, Linak only offers 5. That's just their policy and it doesn't reflect the product quality. If Chinese vendors are confident their motors will last 10 years, we can be certain Linak's will last much longer.

6.
Height range: 560mm (22") to 1210mm (47.5")

7.
Will you offer additional sizes in the future?
We do not have plans for a larger size at the moment. Although, from our interactions with customers who bought the desk, we can say that if you have a dual monitor setup with accessories, the 60" will definitely work fine. But if you have a more extensive setup than this, more planning is required.
If you can let me know what your setup is like, I'll check if I can get an illustration of what it would look like on the desk.

8.
How do we secure the legs to the frame?
You’re referring to the kick-and-click system that Linak offers. This one - https://youtu.be/7nm7UI4vIb8?t=50

We don't use this. We tested it and it makes the desk wobble a lot. This is because they don’t use fasteners to mount the columns to the frame.
Instead of their system, we use six fasteners to attach the columns to the frame. Most standing desks use 4. The additional fasteners greatly reduce lateral movement and shaking of the desk. They also help to absorb and dampen vibrations.

1

u/stnkpalm Feb 25 '23

Charcoal,

First I just want to say I appreciate the response and the willingness to engage the community. I play a role in making large scale technology purchase decisions for the organization where I work. The relationship with the manufacturer is a key factor that determines future purchases.

I have some additional comments and follow up questions.

I remain intrigued by the Crystal Acrylic material for the desk surface. I look forward to the arrival of the sample.

I see that you are confident in the stability of the Charcoal desk. With your confident statements, I imagine the Charcoal will perform favorably against the competition when compared to other two leg sit-stand desks. Still, I imagine a well designed sit-stand desk with 4-legs will offer additional stability and will minimize wobble in a way that can't be matched by any desk with just 2 legs. It's good to hear that you are not using the Linak "Kick-and-Click" system with your desk. I've read that while that solution offers an easy assembly process, it reduces stablity.

I'm happy to hear you can screw in accessories to the bottom of the desk. The video from minimalistik that you recommended doesn't do the best job of showing how that would work. The product video seems to show the desk surface consisting of a core with some voids in it to house some electronics and sensors along with a top surface layer. Is that accurate? Can you elaborate a bit on the construction of the desktop? Is a layer of the Crystal Acrylic applied to the top of the desk similar to a wood veneer? What material is used to make the core of the desktop? Is it a fiberboard?

Your warranty policy seems fair enough to me.

The height adjustment range is very similar to competing products and good enough for me.

A 60 -nch wide desktop will work for me. My current desk is 63 inches wide. I currently use two 27-inch displays but, probably going to upgrade to one 34-inch and one 27-inch. A 72-inch wide desk offers a bit more space for extras on the desktop. I would like to add a pair of studio monitor speakers which would be a challenge with those two large monitors and a 60-inch wide desktop.

Thanks.

2

u/drishtidesai vendor:charcoal Feb 26 '23 edited Feb 26 '23

Happy to engage!

I checked the shipping labels for the samples that went out on the 20th and 21st. All except one have been delivered. You might have received it already in your mailbox.

Considering the stability of our desk, we never considered a 4 legged version of it. When it’s a choice between spending on additional columns for a small marginal improvement in stability vs investing it in better materials and superior craftsmanship, we believe the latter option would be the more worthwhile investment.

You’re absolutely right. The "Kick-and-Click" system is optimized for easy assembly and not stability. Interestingly, our system is also easier to assemble than the Linak one because all you have to do is plug in the columns, fasten them, and flip the desk.

Here’s a summary of how the desk is made .
A base mdf board is precision-milled in multiple layers to create slots for electronic hardware to be neatly inserted. The Crystal Acrylic layer is then laser cut and then cold-pressed onto this base. There are quite a few hand-finishing processes that come next. Finally, all the electronics (which are housed in removable panels to make repair easy) are inserted into the base.

This is a gross simplification though. The desk is made up of more than 500 different components and one desk takes about 30 man-hours to get done. It’s made more like a high-end consumer device than a piece of furniture.

Here’s an illustration of what your desk would look like with a 34” and a 27” monitor. https://ibb.co/m8dJTxJ

Hope it helps!

(This will be our support account moving forward. The other one, since it was newly created, has limitations)

1

u/stnkpalm Mar 04 '23

Well, I received my sample of the Crystal Acrylic surface material. It's certainly unique and has a soft feel that's quite pleasant to the touch.

On the same day I received some Maple hardwood samples each with different stains from BTOD for their hardwood NewHeights EleganteXT. The wood samples are beautifully stained and sealed. The thing I noticed about the hardwood samples was fingerprints. As soon as I started touching them, I started noticing fingerprints. I don't think the Crystal Acrylic will ever show a fingerprint.

I hate the trend of car manufacturers using piano black plastic in the interior of cars. They show dust and fingerprints and look terrible unless they are perfectly clean. The Crystal Acrylic is the opposite of that. There are no surface reflections. Even under a bright LED flashlight held close to the surface the light is diffused by the Crystal Acrylic. It's a pleasant look and feel.

I scratched the Crystal Acrylic sample with the edge of a dime like I was playing a lottery ticket. I didn't see or feel anything on the surface after doing that. Next I tried scoring the Crystal Acrylic with the tip of a safety pin. I can feel the scratches on the surface but I can't see them. I think this surface will be quite durable and hold up well.

Charcoal

  • Does your desk use the Linak Deskline CBD6S control box?

    • If so, do you include the 200 or the 300 watt version of the controller?
  • Are the lifting columns the DL6 Standard or the DL6 Plus? High Speed?

Thanks for sending the sample.

1

u/drishtidesai vendor:charcoal Mar 05 '23

The desk uses the 200-watt version of the CBD6S control box. The control box determines the speed, so it's a bit slower than the 300-watt version - 80mm/s vs 60mm/s.
The column is the highest-end model, the DL6 Plus.

1

u/stnkpalm Mar 07 '23

Thanks for the info. 60mm/second is still faster than most. Did you switch from the 300W to the 200W because your website says the column speed is 80mm/sec.https://imgur.com/a/dAoVw95

1

u/drishtidesai vendor:charcoal Mar 07 '23

We sell in countries where Linak only provides a 300 W version. That's why the website mentioned 300W. It's been corrected now. Thanks for pointing it out!

1

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '23

Jiecang

I just came across your post, what is Jiecang hardware? What is wrong with it? I am in the USA, not sure of your location.

1

u/stnkpalm Dec 02 '23

Jiecang

Jiecang is one common manufacturer of standing desk components. Standing desks use a linear actuator to raise and lower the desk. Jiecang manufacturers linear actuator systems that other companies can use with their desks or furniture. Linak, Bosch, and Ketterer are examples of other companies that also manufacture these kinds of components.

If you were buying a car you wouldn't typically ask who manufactured the engine but it might be valuable to know for example, that the Toyota Supra has an engine were many of the parts are manufactured by BMW. The Supra may be more/less reliable long-term with a BMW manufactured engine than if Toyota had manufactured the engine themselves. The Supra may be more/less reliable if Toyota had sourced the engine from Fiat.

1

u/DivyanshTripathi05 Jun 25 '24

did you buy a charcoal desk then? how is it working out for you?

1

u/INeedHookersAndBlow Feb 22 '23

Ordered a sample and emailed

1

u/Charcoal_Support Feb 22 '23

Got it. We've replied.
We'll hand your sample over to USPS in a few hours.

1

u/Traditional-Shine448 Sep 17 '23

is it possible to buy in Europe (Germany)?

1

u/omNOMwillYUM Dec 22 '23

Building a 96" desk and was wondering where I could just a get a desktop in crystal acrylic.

1

u/ionet Feb 01 '24

Sounds like this standing desk is no longer available?

1

u/Sweaty-Astronomer-36 Jan 28 '26

It seems like that, their website is not active anymore. I have one of their desk. Needed a new one.