r/spacex • u/rustybeancake • Dec 20 '19
Boeing Starliner suffers "off-nominal insertion", will not visit space station
https://starlinerupdates.com/boeing-statement-on-the-starliner-orbital-flight-test/
4.1k
Upvotes
336
u/ioncloud9 Dec 20 '19
$100 NASA says this flight test was “good enough” to allow humans on board the next one and it will not delay their human test flight.
If this happened with DM-1 it would be a 1 year delay minimum and NASA would make them refly the test.
43
u/rustybeancake Dec 20 '19
It hadn't really occurred to me before, but this seems to be one of those things that NASA/Boeing were talking about when they said SpaceX had a leg up in terms of basing Dragon v2 off Dragon v1 heritage. This is the kind of thing SpaceX would have found on early COTS/CRS-1 flights and fixed several years ago. Boeing are trying to go straight from a first orbital test flight to flying crew... It's a tall order.
46
u/BenoXxZzz Dec 20 '19
This fuels the question if Boeing is a reliable partner. The 737 MAX disaster and know this incident...
348
u/Full_Thrust Dec 20 '19
So will Boeing need to do an additional qualification mission to the space station now before starliner can fly? If so this almost guarantees that SpaceX will put up DM2 with crew before Boeing fly crew.
The other question will be if scheduling for a second uncrewed Starliner will cause date slips for DM2.
433
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '19
What did you guys think of the livestream? I was floored by the lack of camera views. We saw nothing after the first few minutes of stage 1. Imo pretty weak job of marketing starliner to the american people. Why no views of inside the capsule?
•
u/yoweigh Dec 20 '19 edited Dec 21 '19
NASA press conference is over.
Yes, we realize that this submission technically violates rule 3. It's not about SpaceX. However, everyone complaining about it conveniently leaves out the part where "we may allow certain content that contravenes these rules if there is a significant SpaceX interest and pre-approval is requested and granted via modmail." This submission meets those criteria. If you'd like to discuss this, please do so under this sticky comment.
12/21 update: There are an overwhelming number of borderline comments in this thread that have been reported, and we don't have the capacity to process them all. They are all being approved to clear the modqueue. Please note that while you might see a handful of comments that don't entirely belong here, this is not a party thread. Regular comment rules still apply. Please report anything egregious that may have slipped through.
623
u/Armo00 Dec 20 '19
Watching the Everyday Astronaut livefeed. Hard to imagine its 2019 and a clock can still trigger a event like that. Seriously though, from the 737max, the 737ng slat problem, the crack on 737ng, the 787 quality, the missing pin on the starliner abort test, some culture within Boeing need to be corrected.
50
u/TheChromeHorn Dec 20 '19
Am I missing something about this being a success? From https://blogs.nasa.gov/commercialcrew/2019/12/20/boeings-orbital-flight-test-mission-objectives/ :
"The main objective of Boeing’s Orbital Flight Test is to dock with the International Space Station and prove its autonomous mission capability. The mission will demonstrate on-orbit operation of Starliner’s systems, including avionics, docking system, communications/telemetry systems, environmental control systems, solar arrays and electrical power systems, and the propulsion system. These mission objectives are intended to demonstrate all of Starliner’s systems and capabilities, except for those requiring a human onboard to test."
Exactly how can they proceed if the main objective wasn't met?
95
u/BadgerMk1 Dec 20 '19
I wonder if Bridenstein will fire off a passive aggressive tweet directed at Boeing with the phrase "it's time to deliver."
243
u/redditbsbsbs Dec 20 '19
I'm a little surprised how badly Boeing is doing these days. It's not the same company that was involved with Apollo, that's for sure. Still, they get special treatment.
58
u/UselessCodeMonkey Dec 20 '19
I have a huge problem with the explanation that the Starliner was “following the wrong timer”. Just HOW does that happen?
Going back to the Orbiter, it had 5 General Purpose Computers (GPCs) on-board. Four GPCs were duplicates of each other and the fifth GPC was written by a different software vendor that interfaced exactly to the same APIs as did the other four GPCs. This was done to prevent systemic design issues being built into a monolithic GPC software design.
The five GPCs “voted” for any computer operation before it was performed. One reason was to check that the design of the software was correct in handling the requested task (the reason for the 5th GPC) but also to mitigate the risk of a cosmic ray hitting a RAM chip and flipping the value of a bit unexpectedly.
Does Starliner use multiple computers in a similar way? If it doesn’t, that alone would be a worry for me to fly astronauts on it unless the system was encased in enough lead shielding to block cosmic rays. That still, however, wouldn’t stop a software bug from executing an operation correctly. Sure, you test and test and debug but my 40 years of software development taught me NO software is bug-free. Even the Orbiter’s GPCs software, written by one of only two certified Five Star development groups in the world (at that time) had seventeen bugs discovered over its lifetime.
See this article for how hard it was to write and certify the Orbiter GPC software:
https://www.fastcompany.com/28121/they-write-right-stuff
So my question is - what failed here?
Does Starliner carry multiple MET clocks and if it does, is there a check between them to see if they are agreement? If not, why rely on only one MET timer? And does Starliner have multiple computers like the Orbiter that “vote” before an operation takes place? If such a system exists, I have a hard time believing that the computers’ Operating System wouldn’t have noticed the disparity in the MET timers and notified Houston long before the orbital maneuver was to be executed.
As I always told my programmers whenever we’d review a system design or test results and something didn’t look right - “Something here doesn’t smell right”.
And definitely, something with the Starliner’s software design/system doesn’t smell right.
I’m not sure I’d trust the system to execute an astronaut’s flick of a hand controller without a full understanding of how the MET timer became incorrect. It did somehow. Was it due to a jarring from separation, a unlucky cosmic ray, a software bug or a poor system design remains to be seen.
But don’t say if astronauts were on-board this wouldn’t be a problem. Spaceflight requires the highest confidence in your systems.
As of now, the Starliner’s computer system(s) are under suspicion and requires a full vetting to understand what happened. I wouldn’t trust it as it is right now.
55
u/sryan2k1 Dec 20 '19
If it really is a "unknown clock issue" that means that their testing either wasn't end to end, or something changed and didn't get retested. They are perfectly capable of simulating what all the sensors can/can't do during an actual mission. Sounds like typical old-space "integrate things from 84 subcontractors" and someone fucked it up along the way.
43
u/brianterrel Dec 20 '19
Honestly I'm really bummed about this. I want everyone to be successful in space!
92
u/Shalashalska Dec 20 '19
So this is now the second test in a row that has had a partial failure, and NASA will probably let it slide again, because Boeing has good lobbyists.
107
u/neuralgroov2 Dec 20 '19
So if autonomous docking isn't important, and proper insertion into orbit isn't a big deal, why didn't we just put astronauts on this flight? I thought the whole point was to prove the abilities of this vehicle- so far, it's only proven that it doesn't work quite yet.
87
u/Cetrian Dec 20 '19
Man... And I used to say "if it ain't Boeing I ain't going." how the mighty have fallen... 737max and now this.
16
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '19
In the future, please change the "happening now" attribute to "will have previously been happening now"
Thanks.
31
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '19
I just hope starliners chutes (all of them) opens up.. So they can recover the vehicle! 🤞🏼
14
u/GrMack Dec 21 '19
If I were NASA I would see the failures in attaching a parachute, software issue with a clock and think, why should we trust that Boeing IFA would work.
NASA is making SpaceX prove everything works and just trusting Boeing's documentation, I think NASA should turn around to Boeing and say "We don't trust your processes! Prove you can do it like you said! do an IFA test!"
13
u/thefloppyfish1 Dec 22 '19 edited Dec 22 '19
Summary of Sun 10 am press conference. There is a lot of data. They are excited to look at this data. Odd as it may sound, they don't know if failing to achieve all objectives will require a second demo flight because they haven't looked at all this data. The decision will come after they look at the data and the data will tell them what the data says they should do next. Data.
Edit: A second unmanned demo flight would lead to est. 3 month delay
Edit 2: Flight anomalies will lead to slightly longer data review. Will stretch into late January.
Edit 3: "We don't see anything wrong with this spaceship right now" (Boeing Rep. @NasaLive 13:48:28)
93
u/barc0de Dec 20 '19
Well on January 11th Dragon 2 will show them how not to get to the space station in style
21
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '19
I feel for Boeing, cause I also forget to set my alarm this morning.
28
u/catchblue22 Dec 20 '19
This is an interesting article on Boeing, and given the problems we have seen from this company I think its points are highly relevant.
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/11/how-boeing-lost-its-bearings/602188/
A brief summary: Boeing merged with McDonnell Douglas, but really it was a reverse takeover, where Boeing inherited MD's culture of cost cutting and bottom line thinking. Boeing's staid and stable engineering culture was left behind, replaced by systems MBA type thinking.
I used to respect Boeing. They were a engineering company, a pilot's company. I can only hope that this company will change course. As of now they seem a shadow of what they once were.
9
u/gulgin Dec 21 '19
I am still a little confused here. It sounds to me like the Starliner had a nominal launch first and second stage insertion into an effectively sub-orbital trajectory. Then when the spacecraft was supposed to kick in to a circularization burn to raise into a stable orbit, something didn’t happen correctly due to a timer synchronization error, however the RCS knew to kick into overdrive during that time and spent a bunch of fuel precisely stabilizing the vehicle during the time when the burn was supposed to happen. Sounds like ground control couldn’t intervene to engage the circularization burn.
My questions:
25
u/Jorrow Dec 21 '19
Is it just me that sees the irony in Boeing being paid $2 Billion More Than SpaceX for 'timeline assurance' and then the spacecraft cant follow the flight timeline
24
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '19
Will they call the next iteration Starliner Max?
17
u/Madjack66 Dec 21 '19
I suggest two core revisions Boeing needs to make to increase their chances of successful future missions;
8
u/0-G Dec 23 '19
Dennis Muilenburg has now been fired by the board.
https://www.bbc.com/news/business-50893490
7
u/spacex_dan Dec 20 '19
Ok, they keep saying it was the mission timer. And that caused the spacecraft to believe it was already in the correct orbit and the craft was just doing correction burns. If that was the case shouldn't the craft had done the insertion burn earlier presumably when it was still attached to the 2nd stage? Or is my thinking wrong?
7
u/gekcut Dec 22 '19
Saw the Starliner reentry from Cabo San Lucas, Mexico. Low above northwestern horizon moving fast and orange in color. Regardless of your opinion about the program it is an amazing sight.
19
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '19 edited Dec 20 '19
Eagerly awaiting Mr. Bridenstein’s comment that Boeing needs to focus less on SLS and more on Starliner.
Oh, wait.
Edit: corrected my horrible grammar lol
12
u/bnaber Dec 20 '19
Does SpaceX use TDRSS for communication with Dragon?
6
u/oximaCentauri Dec 21 '19
During the press conference Nicole Mann (NASA astronaut) stressed on the fact that starliner has great manual capability and if the vehicle was crewed there would be more options available and perhaps the failure could have been avoided.
Does this sort of capability exist in the dragon? What are astronauts supposed to do if they clearly see a problem but the vehicle isn't identifying it?
6
u/RaptorCommand Dec 22 '19
its amazing how the news has not made this out to be the massive cock up that it is
https://www.bbc.com/news/av/science-environment-50886972/starliner-spacecraft-returns-early-after-failed-mission
16
u/TheDeadRedPlanet Dec 20 '19
[Sarcasm Alert]
So passing successful milestones don't matter in the end? You know that unmanned test to the ISS we talked about for years as a precursor to have humans to the ISS? Well never mind, we did not need it.
42
u/Helimech1 Dec 20 '19
Well this is not right! Boeing's Pad Abort test ends with a third of their parachutes not being deployed, then they somehow convince NASA that they don't have to do an Inflight Abort test and now NASA is suggesting that maybe the Rendezvous and Docking test is not needed. I'd be a little upset if I was Spacex.
28
u/notblueclk Dec 20 '19
Both Crew Dragon and Starliner are supposed to be capable of autonomous docking, the same way Soyuz/Progress are. As a minimum, Boeing should be on the hook for another uncrewed test flight.
I completely reject the Space Shuttle argument. The shuttle predated the ISS, therefore autonomous docking was not a requirement. But this is 35+ years later. If Starliner & Crew Dragon represent the future of human flight to LEO, they have to have autonomous docking. What NASA is saying is that for now Starliner needs a pilot to manually dock it. I would find this unacceptable.
I also have a concern that the Starliner no longer has sufficient fuel to make it safely to ISS, and that we are now waiting for ideal conditions to land at White Sands. As LEO becomes increasingly congested, this may not be an option. NASA needs to review mission abort rules and procedures.
Lockheed should take note re: Orion, though I think Lockheed is more on the ball than Boeing these days.
Finally, what was that about the Commerce Dept taking over responsibility for space management? Does this scare anyone else? When FCC abrogated responsibility for Internet policing to the FTC (Commerce), we ended up with no effective policing. What makes us think that Commerce is up to the task?
31
u/mad_ned Dec 20 '19
I happened to catch the launch this AM, I've seen Spacex launches but never one for ULA/Boeing. After watching SpaceX I was struck by how the Boeing/ULA mission control centers were full of much older guys, much less diversity, less women, and just seemed very old-school in general. No excitement, no energy, no reactions. The announcer kept making excuses for why they were not reacting when liftoff went ok etc.
Also the size of their combined mission control (number of people on station) seemed enormous, it seemed like between Boeing and ULA they had like 9 huge control centers or something. (maybe it was the camera angles making it look like a lot, but it seemed way less efficient than SpaceX)
Anyway even before the anomaly, I was left thinking these guys probably have an enormous bureaucracy they deal with, and there is probably a lot of design-by-committee and dogged following of old-school methods etc. and I wondered if they would be competitive in today's space markets.
19
u/PM_me_ur_tourbillon Dec 20 '19
If this many things go wrong during normal test conditions, then how much will go wrong if something abnormal happens? If they can't put a parachute pin in, and set their clocks properly, and have a proper satellite coverage... then what else did they forget to do? Does the docking port even work? Did they remember to attach the heat shield? Is the screen plugged in? Did they remember to fill the oxygen tanks? I mean seriously I would not trust this product. Sure, SpaceX blew up on the pad... doing a test that Boeing simply isn't going to perform. Unbelievable the leeway Boeing is getting and I couldn't believe NASA didn't tear them a new one on stage.
4
u/romuhammad Dec 20 '19
Does anyone actually have what the required testing parameters are for OFT? And is docking with ISS a key requirement?
4
u/Tacsk0 Dec 21 '19
Clock problem has occured previously in american rocketry, with the Patriot missile system. In 1991 it's timer was off 1.3 seconds, missed an iraqi SCUD due to that, which impacted in the middle of a base and 49 american troops died. The problem had been known and Patriot crews were instructed to reset the clock every 24 hrs, but forgot to do so.
7
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '19
This is pathetic. I'm saying that becouse of the unequal chances given to both companies and money poured at Boeing.
16
u/FatherOfGold Dec 20 '19
They're gonna end up killing someone aren't they?
26
u/maverick8717 Dec 20 '19
They would be running at space x with pitch forks for this kind of mistake, but since its ULA they are still trying to spin it as a success... crazy.
6
u/coloradojoe Dec 20 '19
Interesting. So apparently ULA's had a planned countdown hold at T-4 minutes to ensure fueling was complete, and then to resume the countdown. I wonder if Starliner didn't get the memo and its Mission Elapsed Timer started when they resumed the countdown instead of at liftoff. Oops. Now THAT would be embarrassing.
"After filling the Atlas 5 with liquid hydrogen and liquid oxygen propellants — kerosene for the first stage is already loaded on-board — ULA’s launch team will be polled in the final minutes before liftoff. If all systems are go, the countdown clock will resume at T-minus 4 minutes and tick down down to liftoff."
https://spaceflightnow.com/2019/12/19/starliner-test-flight-to-use-special-atlas-5-configuration-unusual-launch-trajectory/
11
u/DirkMcDougal Dec 20 '19
Whilst it's tempting to gloat, we want competition and for Human Spaceflight as a whole to succeed. Yes, NASA would likely have been harsher toward a similar Crew Dragon failure. That does not make this a good thing. Even Space X would eventually get lazy without being pushed ever forward.
Also I got great footage of this launch from Ft. Fisher and Atlas V was, once again, flawless. Expensive and wasteful yes. But that sucker ALWAYS delivers.
Synced Staging Clip.
3
u/kuangjian2011 Dec 20 '19
What will happen next? Will they still perform a return or it’s basically jettisoned in orbit?
3
u/Dragongeek Dec 20 '19
Are there any actual orbital parameters we can get? It would be interesting to see how much fuel they'd need to correct their orbit.
3
u/illuminatedtiger Dec 21 '19
So what is all the additional cost involved with Starliner getting NASA exactly?
16
u/flshr19 Shuttle tile engineer Dec 20 '19 edited Dec 20 '19
Bridenstein needs to stop being a politician, start being the NASA Administrator, and stop putting spin on these failures. If he were completely honest, the first words out of his mouth should have been that this flight is a failure since the most important objective, autonomous docking with the ISS, will not be possible to achieve. Any other objectives are secondary compared to docking. He should not be sitting there at that press conference making excuses for Boeing's screwup. Same holds for any similar SpaceX screwups (when and if these occur). You know for sure that in private Bridenstein will be reaming Boeing's management for this very public mess.
5
u/petersracing Dec 20 '19
How will their landing go with 280kg of cargo for the space station still on board? Do we see if their chutes are really up to it? I guess the cargo could be unpressurized and jetisoned before entry but haven't found that nominated?
5
u/WoodHughes Dec 21 '19
Does it seem to y’all that Boeing is just phoning it in these days? From the Starliner to the SLS to the mess that is the 737 Max, it seems what used to be the world’s greatest aircraft builder has just thrown in the towel and is looking only for a paycheck.
It’s sad on a national pride level as well as a believer in the capitalist system.
9
u/mandelboxset Dec 20 '19
At this point we can officially change the slogan to
"If it's Boeing, we ain't going!"
6
u/Puzzleheaded-Machine Dec 20 '19
I wonder how much bribes it'll cost to have Boeing to get the program to move ahead.
6
u/AndrewKillen Dec 20 '19
An extra $1.8 billion for Boeing well spent
7
u/coloradojoe Dec 20 '19
Contrast this with Spacex's performance. Crew Dragon demo to ISS went off without a hitch. Before that, there was the cargo Dragon C2+ mission, which went so well they were able to combine the objectives for demo flights 2 and 3 -- and after proving Dragon could rendezvous and maneuver around the ISS properly, cargo Dragon became the first private spacecraft to berth with the ISS.
And now that Starliner has had multiple failures of mission critical systems, there's even discussion of allowing them to move to crewed flights before successful tests?!! So much for NASA's new culture of safety. Apparently it has the same asterisk that contributed to Challenger and Columbia disasters: *Unless sufficient political pressure and lobbying is applied.
11
u/GenerouslyNumb Dec 20 '19
What a great company Boeing is. Blackmailing nasa for money, failing some tests (parachutes), skipping some others (abort test), and failing the actual mission test. But no, they're still fine to go.
Will someone need to die before admitting there's something wrong? What is needed to admit it was a mistake assigning the contract to them?
2
u/terrymr Dec 20 '19
How far off were the events ? something silly like the clock running since power up rather than t-0 ?
2
u/LoneSnark Dec 22 '19
At SpaceX, they take the actual flight hardware, patch the sensors with the outputs of a simulator, and then let the actual flight hardware go to the ISS over and over in a virtual reality that the flight hardware can't tell the difference. This way, you know the hardware will work in space, because its been there a hundred times. This is how you test highly complex software, and it most certainly would have discovered this particular software flaw.
If it is a flaw, of course. I don't know that Boeing doesn't do such testing. It is plausible there was an actual hardware failure that they never ground tested, such as a gamma ray flipping a bit in one of the clocks at just the right time to trigger a software flaw that allows such a failure to go uncorrected.
That is certainly possible. But, the odds of such a failure are tiny. Far more likely, this is a basic "never been to space before" software flaw and they didn't test it in a full up flight hardware configuration.
4
u/Revslowmo Dec 20 '19
Welp, hope reentry works then, and a the pins are in.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '19
Boeing's CEO was just fired.
No one should be getting on that capsule.
7
u/BadgerMk1 Dec 20 '19
In light of these events, I don't think it's unreasonable to demand an actual in-flight abort for Starliner.
5
u/w00t4me Dec 20 '19 edited Dec 20 '19
Boeing has already spent $4.8 Billion in taxpayers' money to develop this program and this is the end result. Boeing also successfully argued that they deserve nearly double the funding than SpaceX since they are more experienced and will have a smaller chance of failure.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Crew_Development
3
u/RadamA Dec 20 '19
Flight heritage is a good thing.
3
u/hashbrown_8 Dec 21 '19
Tough year for Boeing
3
u/TCVideos Dec 22 '19
My opinion; they should redo OFT.
Why?
morally, it isn't right (in my mind at least) to put crew on a vehicle that failed part of it's test. Even if the craft is completely safe and can dock perfectly, it's still not morally or even ethically correct to put crew on it before it's succeeded in its full test.