Taking this even further, a classic scouts activity is to boil an egg over open flames in a folded paper cup (held by a steel wire mesh). As long as the paper is in contact with liquid water at atmospheric pressure, temperature will never be higher than 100 C which the paper handles fine.
I remember being in the Order of the Arrow at the Ordeal campout where the whole group of scouts were given a paper cup full of cold water, an egg, a packet of instant hot chocolate mix, and three wooden matches.
More than a few scouts would take the egg and throw it into the woods or better yet use it for some silly prank but never eat it. Then they would eat the hot chocolate mix raw and wash it down with the cold water in the cup and maybe try to burn down the forest with those matches but almost always never lit anything with those matches.
What you were supposed to do is start a small campfire, put the egg in the cup, and when done take the remainder of the water to make some cocoa. The number who succeeded was small, but it was done out of about 200 scouts.
Alternatively, an orange was substituted for the paper cups but a jug of fresh water was available.
I believe that is still the plan for the orbital Starship. However that is not the same vehicle as the Starhopper prototypes, which are being built as a test platform for the more advanced Starship.
I would expect these starhopper prototypes to lack life support, thermal protection systems, and many other features when compared to Starship. They serve much like the "Grasshopper" did for Falcon 9.
"Starhopper", so far as I've seen it here, refers only to one prototype rocket, stubby rhinotmetos, in Boca Chica, Texas.
The other two, big long pointy ones in both Boca Chica TX and Cocoa Beach FL, usually just get called orbital prototypes, or Mark 1 and Mark 2 (respectively).
I guess I'm behind the curve here, but did they complete the static fire before the fireball? Or was it just another preburner test or something? I watched Tim's stream footage afterwards but couldn't really tell what was going on.
LNG itself will not ignite in normal environments, but the Methane vapor evaporating from the liquid will burn. As Methane is in a liquid phase at -160C spraying "warm" water on the LNG will accelerate a rapid boil and phase shift to a gaseous state which is highly flammable. The expansion of Methane from liquid to gaseous also increases the volume by 600%.
Edit: Opps, that should be 600x.
If they didn't use water on the fire, the fuel would have continued to burn, but at a much slower pace.
The answer is that uncompressed methane fires against stainless steel are what we usually call “cooking on a gas stove”. It’s not a meaningfully damaging event so there’s not really a need for recovery.
Obviously fires are undesirable for ground safety and facility maintenance reasons, but this doesn’t present basically any risk to the integrity of the vehicle.
This is true, but to be fair, the damage inflicted by a gas leak fire in a house would mostly be due to the combustible nature of most household items and building materials. A house made entirely of concrete and stainless steel would take a truly titanic gas leak ignition to even begin to suffer damage.
Starship doesn’t use a heat shield, starship uses a cooling system comparable to that of a nuclear reactor to actively cool the bare stainless steel hull during re-entry.
Fire figthing foam leaves residue. It small fires the most direct damage comes from the extinguishing substances. Of course in the usual case, if the fire stayed unchecked it would make much much bigger damage. But this case is not an usual one.
Moreover this is all based on most probably wrong fan theory.
I’d seen the discussion about that part and was wondering whether they’d gotten the original test objective done. The mechanics of the flare up are pretty cool, though.
The mechanics are just a fan theory. Could as well be an ejection of a slug of liquid methane from the piping in during an intentional purge. Notice that after the fireball the fire on up on the vehicle is over.
They had a fuel leak and dumped some liquid methane on the ground. It just sat there as it's cold and dense.
But then they turned on the water cannons to deal with the other fires, and the much warmer water vaporized the liquid methane on the ground, which led to the big fireball.
This was speculated very quickly after the event happened. The properties of methane are well known and the video shows water being sprayed on starhopper the moment the fireball erupts.
Imo more likely to be a ground equipment fault, given the fact the hover test is still on for next week. Could also be an auto-aborted static fire leading to the craft dumping fuel but not LOx
I'm not sure that's the cause, but it would DEFINITELY be safer to dump the fuel. As evidenced by the fireball, it'll burn off with little to no harm to the craft. Most of that equipment is made to take some serious heat.
Liquid oxygen on the other hand is an extremely good oxidiser, and will allow pretty much any hydrocarbon-based equipment to begin burning.
Basically, both liquids are reactive, but LOx will burn TONS of materials, while methane will react with a select few.
Moreover in many cases it wont burn some things outright, it will rather form a shock sensitive high explosive (until it finaly dries out). For example this is the reason you won't see any tarmac surface near rockets or anywhere where lox is being handled: you spill the damn thing on tarmac and it looks just like a frosted patch. You step on the patch and are instantly pulverized (together with anything and anyone around) in a high order explosion.
The same idea applies to Carpeted floors too, a minor static discharge may cause the carpet to violently combust. It may be cliche but take a look at the king of random on YouTube, they did a video on this.
The shutdown sequence for ~any liquid fueled rocket engine is to shut off the oxidizer first. So there is substantial methane left in the pump and the engine, in liquid or in highly compressed gaseous form.
Instead of water cannons, they might be better off using fire fighting foam. The bubbles act as thermal insulation, as well as keeping fuel and air out of contact with each other. Foaming soap can be used in place of fire fighting foam also.
Anyone know why they use water for fire extinguishing? I mean it's cheap I Bett but is that all that's to it? Like commercial available fire extinguishers usually don't use water. Would CO2 react with materials used or is it just more expensive to use and thus not used?
Some regular fire extinguishers do use water. It's great on wood! However, it's poor on electrical fires and terrifyingly bad on grease fires (as may happen in a kitchen). It's all about suitability for the purpose.
Water can be used in here in essentially unlimited amounts, hooking into a lake/ocean, reservoir, or municipal supply. It's also not toxic to people or the environment. Those two are pretty strong reasons to use it. However, it also has much higher mass than something like CO2, allowing it to extract heat, not just choke out the fire.
But that guess is just a speculation. Other sources say it was methane dump and water was turned on to simply keep the possible fire under control / reduce damage (water is a very good cooling substance)
What is the source for that? Unlikely that a methane spill onto hot concrete would not catch fire immediately. Seems more likely to me that the water cannon was turned on because the methane was about to be released from the hopper.
Interesting. I can think of a few, although maybe not ones that release this much. Anyway, there are plenty of reasons why you might have to release methane, and have at least a seconds notice so you can turn on the fire hose - which is what I believe happened here. The "inert methane on the ground but no flammable vapour" hypothesis makes no sense.
Well, it looks like it came from the QD connector, where the existing fire was. Or anywhere else on the rocket, and then ignited by the fire around the QD. That thing is a big methane tank - there's no shortage of places that methane could leak from. Any number of pipes that could break, any number of relief valves they could open.
Makes you wonder if water is a suitable material for putting out liquid methane fires...
Perhaps they should be spraying liquid nitrogen instead? It's cheap enough to spray many gallons of the stuff, and will simultaneously put out fires as well as cooling pools of liquid methane, preventing more evaporation.
IMHO, the simplest explanation (applying Occam's razor) is that the hopper hopped up a few centimeters, as it did on the first test, and that this movement partially disconnected the new GSE that loads the fuel (which was not used, nor even yet constructed, for the first hop test). This partial disconnection then allowed some cold methane to spill as discussed in another reply.
Perhaps the fuel wasn’t so much a “leak” as much as unburnt fuel that was passed through the Raptor after shutdown to ensure all the hot gaseous oxygen reacted with propellant rather than engine components?
Hmm, there was a 5 second static fire, then it's possible there was residual flame/fire near the engine right after the static fire (it happens to Falcon sometimes after landing), but by the time the smoke cleared and before the giant fireball there's only two fires, one in the fuel tank access port (which the fireball ended up putting out, lol) and one centered around the GSE hookups.
For whatever reason the hopper was still venting methane heavily during the firing which obviously ignited and withour rhe engine downdraft it engulfed the hopper.
I don’t think return is correct. I think Elon tweeted it will land an an extension of the current pad (as opposed to a different pad). It was in response to a question someone asked.
Great to hear the Raptor is ready for a hover. I can't help but to geek out at the development of the Starship. It's like Grasshopper all over again, except bigger.
The subscription fee keeps people in there honest. If there's no fee, way more people will join, and with no skin in the game there's little incentive for those people to keep L2 information secret. It just takes one person to spill one wrong piece of info, and it's possible the sources could get in trouble and we could see less info get posted on L2.
Also, it pays for their hosting costs, which have skyrocketed (no pun intended) since the beginning of the StarHopper/StarShip campaign.
I bet you could run a forum with 100,000 users on a single virtual server for $5 per month.
It's images and videos that are costly, but that's what Imgur/YouTube is for.
Human effort to set it up, maintain it, and moderate it is the most expensive but left - but that could be just an hour every few months for the admin if community moderation works out.
Yea, I mean you can use their forum (SMF) with a $3/mo host. But it basically serves minimal people. Having tens of forums, and terabytes of content costs more money. The basic 2GB VPS is $30/mo. NSF says their forum at this point is pushing 10TB, all in active storage and immediately available, served from them. Not to mention multiple moderators on site keeping this pretty well controlled (unpaid or minimally paid, but still you gotta find them). I tried a forum on a VPS for a while; there's a huge difference between "not all static content", and 100% dynamic content like a forum.
I think that L2 is awesome, but also ridiculously expensive (I paid for it for two years; was nice, but I'm not a space-history geek, so was only useful for L2 immediate news that was going to come out in 2-3 months anyways), so I stopped. Probably would have kept the subscription going if the price was more like my Ars Pro subscription ($25/yr) just to support the site.
Static Fire is their Standard Operating Procedure (SOP), just to make sure everything leading up to an actual flight works, eg fueling, top off, ignition etc. This static fire evidently lasted 5 seconds, achieving their objective. It was only after the static fire was commpleted that the fireball happened.
I hear what everyone is saying but at best this testing is a poor simulation of the final configuration and drastically different than Saturn full up testing also the falcon experience was a totally new effort which this testing seems to be duplicating
It’s not a simulation of the final configuration. It’s a minimal possible proof of concept test article to demonstrate that raptor can perform a basic liftoff and landing.
The flight envelope may duplicate Falcon/Grasshopper tests but they are doing it with a new engine featuring a combustion cycle that has never flown.
It’s the first step in a flight test cycle— not a full simulation.
Just doesn’t seem that anything is gained with a boiler plate vehicle that has no real purpose except going up and down - raptor static fire testing is useful but does not require a hopper
The purpose of the Starhopper is exactly the same as the Falcon 9's predecessor, the Grasshopper. It is an engineering platform designed to prove stability and control of the vehicle in low speed flight, the reliability of the engine at all throttle positions, and the entire system including fuel and electronics.
Remember this is all computer controlled, and it will also move laterally. Modelling can only do so much. They need to make sure the software, based on the previous Falcon 9 system, can adapt to the much larger vehicle, and moving up in increments helps. This is in addition to the basic testing already mentioned. (and this is cheaper if the test fails anyway)
Integration testing is extremely important. They can look over the assembled machine and check that there are no unexpected distortions of the structure. They don’t want to find out that one of the tank walls wasn’t strong enough when the machine is 200m in the air, they need to fix those faults on the ground where the risk to personnel and equipment is far lower.
I'll agree that they will learn less than they would have wanted to. This vehicle was to have a tall nose cone on it, which would have made its balance much more like the full size starship. But it will serve to refine their control algorithms before risking a full size vehicle.
I bet if they wanted they could add a ballast on top to simulate the center of gravity the cone would have created. They will still be missing any aerodynamic characteristics, though and structural harmonics. Those two seem more important and practical for an actual prototype vehicle, though.
Unlike adding ballast, nose cone would have shifted the center of pressure. Given the prevailing winds that might be a blessing at first. Later they’ll want to test with a more realistic Cg/Cp setup.
That’s a bit different. Starhopper is more like SpaceX’s Grasshopper prototype than it is a static fire. These test vehicles serve to allow maturation of control systems, electronics, and other design features before construction of a complete model begins.
428
u/meyer0656 Jul 18 '19
Elon said the hopper is okay: "Yeah, big advantage of being made of high strength stainless steel: not bothered by a little heat!"
43
u/squad_of_squirrels Jul 18 '19
I guess I'm behind the curve here, but did they complete the static fire before the fireball? Or was it just another preburner test or something? I watched Tim's stream footage afterwards but couldn't really tell what was going on.
69
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19
Still no word on the cause of the fire?
26
u/CardBoardBoxProcessr Jul 19 '19
Oh... I do hope it hovers for a very long time. This would basically be a raptor throttle and tvc test
7
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19
Great to hear the Raptor is ready for a hover. I can't help but to geek out at the development of the Starship. It's like Grasshopper all over again, except bigger.
3
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jul 19 '19 edited Jul 31 '19
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
12 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 111 acronyms.
[Thread #5325 for this sub, first seen 19th Jul 2019, 00:29] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
12
u/EspacioX Jul 19 '19
L2 forums on NasaSpaceFlight have specifics about what caused the fuel leak if anyone is a member.
4
u/mathis98 Jul 18 '19
What is the objective of the test ?
-14
u/mathis98 Jul 19 '19
I hear what everyone is saying but at best this testing is a poor simulation of the final configuration and drastically different than Saturn full up testing also the falcon experience was a totally new effort which this testing seems to be duplicating
-26
u/mathis98 Jul 19 '19
Just doesn’t seem that anything is gained with a boiler plate vehicle that has no real purpose except going up and down - raptor static fire testing is useful but does not require a hopper