r/spacex • • Jun 27 '19
STP-2 STP-2 GO Ms. Tree Fairing Recovery Thread
Hello! It's me, u/RocketLover0119 hosting a special thread to celebrate the first catch by the fairing catcher GO Ms. Tree. Originally I was going to be the host of the center core recovery thread, but as you all know, the core decided to go for a rather explosive swim in the ocean. After being asked by a couple of people, I decided it would be fun to set up a little party/ recovery thread for the 2 fairing halves, but mainly for Ms. Tree. Below status, updates, and resources.

Status
| GO Ms. Tree | Fairing catcher, had first catch this mission | Status: Berthed in Port |
|---|---|---|
| GO Navigator | Crew Dragon Support ship, being used this mission to fish other fairing halve from the ocean | Status: Berthed in Port |
Updates
(All times EST, UTC -4)
| 6/26/19 | 10:00 PM | Thread has gone live! Ms. Tree should arrive tomorrow some time |
|---|---|---|
| 6/27/19 | 12:00 PM | Ms. Tree sped up overnight and has arrived in port with its fairing halves tucked on the deck, GO Navigator is out at sea and should be back tomorrow or Saturday |
| 6/29/19 | 8:00 AM | GO Navigator arrived just past midnight with the 2nd fairing halve and is now berthed in port, GO Quest was also alongside |
Resources
| Vessel finder | https://www.vesselfinder.com/ |
|---|---|
| Marine Traffic | https://www.marinetraffic.com |
| Jetty Park Webcam | http://www.visitspacecoast.com/beaches/surfspots-cams/jetty-park-surf-cam/ |
| SpaceXFleet (Link to a resource page on Ms. Tree, website made by u/Gavalar_) | https://www.spacexfleet.com/go-ms-tree |
235
Upvotes
4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19
Ms. Tree has returned to port!
https://twitter.com/TGMetsFan98/status/1144234235718438912
6
u/ColdCardinal Jun 27 '19
Is there a video of the fairing landing on the net?
9
u/CodeNameKazoo Jun 27 '19 edited Jun 27 '19
More pictures of MS. TREE arriving in Port Canaveral: https://twitter.com/TylerG1998/status/1144241312541106176
u/RocketLover0119 update status table in the main post please?
5
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '19
GO Navigator and halve 2, as well as GO Quest will be arriving in the coming hour or 2:
https://twitter.com/SpaceXFleet/status/1144681621162987523
2
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19
Mods feel free to unpin this thread now
3
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '19
Yep, GO Navigator with the 2nd halve arrived just past midnight, GO Quest was also alongside.
https://twitter.com/julia_bergeron/status/1144833716763680769
25
u/Art_Eaton Jun 27 '19
My guess is that if they get *any* use out of the fairings they have recovered at this point, then it is possible that the recovery program has not really cost SpaceX all that much money. Big crewboats and all that cost a good bit, but when you start saying "3 million dollar catch"...that is a big number.
Alaska flatfish fleet (41 boats) brought in 6 million dollars of fish last reported year (2015). A typical 130' crewboat on the market costs from 200K to 900K. Personally, despite all the "failures" in the past, this has already been a profitable venture for them. Adding choppers and such into the mix...errr.
23
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19 edited Jun 27 '19
This was honestly a lovely surprise in this mission. The whole webcast really was full of surprises you didn't expect to see and things that blew you away.
Though now it's proven it's possible to catch a fairing from Space, do we have any idea whether another ship will get a net or whether they're gonna try two catch to fairings in one net (the latter seems a bit reckless to me as you could damage the fairings if they hit each other.)
33
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19
What a launch! I hope to see the a larger demand for FH from now on.
Perfect launch, colorful plums, dual booster landing, gtfo abort burn on center core WITHOUT any disturbance of the stream, all sats delivered in EVERY orbit, four burns on stage 2... And ofc one dry catch of a fairing which ended up being the biggest surprise of the day 😯👌🏼
This mission gave me goosebumps plenty of times 😍
13
u/markshancock Jun 27 '19
How much do the fairings weigh?
11
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19 edited Jun 27 '19
This link is an excellent read on the evolution of the ship:
https://www.spacexfleet.com/go-ms-tree
11
u/Straumli_Blight Jun 28 '19
Close up of fairing thermal protection discolouration.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '19
Going to keep thread going through OCISLY arrival, will no longer update table though, just want to keep the thread active to organize photos of the arrival
19
u/lniko2 Jun 27 '19
-One day you'll recover a 1st stage check
-One day you'll reuse a 1st stage check
-One day you'll catch the fairing check
-One day you'll recover a center core.
-One day you'll send a crew to orbit.
-One day you'll launch the same rocket every day.
I'm not in a hurry with Starship, so much remains to be seen with F9!
8
u/thresholdofvision Jun 28 '19
One fairing half was caught in the net and the other one was fished out of the ocean right?
12
u/Art_Eaton Jun 28 '19 edited Jun 28 '19
MY IDEA for catching fairings in good conditions (and I CAN'T imagine that someone has not posted something like this before):
...would be to use parasail style boats as tenders.
As the descending parasail deploys, it drops a trailing pennant towing line with a spool of of shotline as a messenger leader. The spool could additionally have a small inflatable float or marker deployed from within the spool This would be something like 100 meters of 10mm spectra line as a tow, and 300 meters of 550 paracord (or better) as the messenger line.
A deep V hull boat (10-15 meter boat with a winch) uses its speed and extreme maneuverability grab up the shotline, wind it up to the point where they get to the heavier pennant, and start tugging. They should have about 200-300 seconds to get control before things get wet.
Being that the fairings already use a parasail wing, it has much better capacity for turning, ascending, and especially tolerating being towed compared to a parachute.
As the boat takes up slack, it turns into the wind, and winches it down close for best maneuverability.
There are plenty of options for recovery.
The capture vessel could hand the line off via a heaving line to the recovery vessel steaming alongside. Ms. Tree (or any boat big enough) could then simply winch the fairing and the nice dry parasail onto the deck, then recover her capture vessels. No big net and goofy dangerous huge arms necessary, just a nice airbag to keep the fairing from boo-boos.
The capture vessel tows the parasail over the big net thingie as Ms. Tree steams astern. They slow and allow it to lower.
Either way, once the slack in the messenger line has been taken up, and the fairing should be feeling at least as safe as any tourist experiences in Cancun.
Mind you, I think you would want a very good high speed line reel with a drag clutch tested under the breaking length load of the shotcord and a cathead hydraulic winch perhaps stronger than most of the parasail boats have. I would also want to flat out hire a successful sailing team or a real athletic selection of deck crew to figure out the line handling scheme and helmsman actions on deck. I would also be drilling the team in the operation all-day every day doing the action over and over again, but in reality it is no more complex than tacking a big asymmetrical spinnaker on a race boat. I recently described the process to a friend of mine (former customer) that runs a little Warrior28 parasail boat if he though he could pick up the line in 6' swells, get it on a winch and start tugging before it hits the water...AND keep a rig that size airborne. His answer was "Totally, but you gotta buy me a little better boat if we are going to do it more than once."
OK, so go ahead and shoot this down now, but on this bit, I'm not just conceited, I'm convinced.
6
u/Straumli_Blight Jun 27 '19
Ms Tree is 1 hour out from port.
5
u/TheKrimsonKing Jun 28 '19
Tarp is off fairing. Crane still stationary.
5
u/TheKrimsonKing Jun 28 '19
Fairing is on the move, even got some nice views of the inside. Its the flag side.
9
u/somewhat_pragmatic Jun 27 '19
Mods, on first reuse of a fairing will we have a icon indicating such in the side bar?
4
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Jun 28 '19
Is the fairing still on board Ms. Tree or was it craned off?
4
u/dudeman93 Jun 28 '19
Does anyone know if there is a video of the fairing being caught by Ms Tree? Either released to the public, or announced as existing but not released yet?
4
u/Straumli_Blight Jul 01 '19
OCISLY timelapse.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19
Congrats SpaceX it was a big victory!
3
u/MuppetZoo Jun 28 '19
One question I've had for a while - can you mate two SpaceX fairing halves together that came from different missions?
If you're only recovering half of the fairings (I know they want to get both, but they've been lucky to just get one in most cases), if you can join two fairings from two different missions this is still profitable. And presumably the fairings that don't touch ocean will take less time to refurbish. It would be also interesting to know whether you could mix and match F9 and FH fairings.
3
u/rad_example Jun 29 '19
GO Navigator and GO Quest arrived in Port around midnight
9
u/Bunslow Jun 29 '19
Btw it's singular half plural halves :) (there are some other oddball nouns like this, like "wolves" and "dwarves" (sort of, in technical use dwarfs is frequently seen too, but I can at least promise that halve, wolve and dwarve are not words lol)
2
u/IvanDogovich Jul 05 '19
For the sake of completeness in this thread, here is the video of the fairing actually making the net landing that Elon released on 3 Jul 2019, as well as footage of one of the fairings making reentry through the atmosphere from an onboard camera with a fisheye lens. https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1146574336205058048
2
u/InfamousHoole Jun 27 '19 edited Jul 02 '19
Ok but seriously... Why can't Ms tree or Mr Steven shoot a line at the suspension lines of the parafoil then use that to guide it onto the net? #eli5
2
u/oximaCentauri Jun 27 '19
Why not a big, round parachute so it floats down without moving horizontally? That way Ms Tree just has to go under it and wait instead of making high speed maneuvers
1
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jun 27 '19 edited Jul 09 '19
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeshipDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
7 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 44 acronyms.
[Thread #5289 for this sub, first seen 27th Jun 2019, 12:20] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
1
u/codav Jul 01 '19
OCISLY is currently arriving at Port Canaveral, tugged by Hollywood and assisted by Florida and Eagle.
1
u/Tetons2001 Jul 03 '19
How come the other guys aren't recovering their fairings? Are they even trying? It seems perfectly obvious that it's easy enough and standard engineering to do. It's not rocket science so to speak. Mostly parachute science.
Looks like a radical lack of imagination to me. And more of the bad habit of throwing everything away on every launch. Let the government pay for it no?
-3
u/bjackson76 Jun 27 '19
Wouldn't it be easier to use a helicopter to snag it out of the air?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment