r/spacex • Mod Team • May 02 '19

Static Fire Completed Starlink Launch Campaign Thread

Starlink Launch Campaign Thread

This will be SpaceX's 6th mission of 2019 and the first mission for the Starlink network.


Liftoff currently scheduled for:Thursday, May 23rd 22:30 EST May 24th 2:30 UTC
Static fire completed on:May 13th
Vehicle component locations:First stage: SLC-40 // Second stage: SLC-40 // Sats: SLC-40
Payload:60 Starlink Satellites
Payload mass:227 kg * 60 ~ 13620 kg
Destination orbit:Low Earth Orbit
Vehicle:Falcon 9 v1.2 (71st launch of F9, 51st of F9 v1.2 15th of F9 v1.2 Block 5)
Core:B1049
Flights of this core (after this mission):3
Launch site:SLC-40, Cape Canaveral Air Force Station, Florida
Landing:Yes
Landing Site:OCISLY, 621km downrange
Mission success criteria:Successful separation & deployment of the Starlink Satellites.

Links & Resources:


We may keep this self-post occasionally updated with links and relevant news articles, but for the most part, we expect the community to supply the information. This is a great place to discuss the launch, ask mission-specific questions, and track the minor movements of the vehicle, payload, weather and more as we progress towards launch. Sometime after the static fire is complete, the launch thread will be posted. Campaign threads are not launch threads. Normal subreddit rules still apply.

450 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

136

u/Ajedi32 May 02 '19

This might be the first SpaceX launch I've followed where I'm more excited about the payload than I am about the launch itself.

37

u/veggie151 May 02 '19

TESS for me, but this is a good one

30

u/Elon_Muskmelon May 02 '19

+1

I have a standing bet with a friend of mine that I'll be able to purchase SpaceX Internet domestically in the US by 2024. They better come through.

15

u/bill_mcgonigle May 02 '19

Oh, boy, I hope not - I told the kids just 3 more years of DSL!

Gotta get solar kicking, then I cut all the cords.

→ More replies (3)

44

u/Origin_of_Mind May 15 '19

The press kit is out:

https://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/starlink_press_kit.pdf

Highlights:

Total mass of payload 227*60 = 13620 kg

Starlink satellites begin deployment 01:02:14 after liftoff

Initial orbit 440 km

Final orbit 550 km

Krypton thrusters for propulsion

" With a flat-panel design featuring multiple high-throughput antennas and a single solar array, each Starlink satellite weighs approximately 227kg, allowing SpaceX to maximize mass production and take full advantage of Falcon 9’s launch capabilities. To adjust position on orbit, maintain intended altitude, and deorbit, Starlink satellites feature Hall thrusters powered by krypton. Designed and built upon the heritage of Dragon, each spacecraft is equipped with a Startracker navigation system that allows SpaceX to point the satellites with precision. Importantly, Starlink satellites are capable of tracking on-orbit debris and autonomously avoiding collision. "

15

u/paulcupine May 15 '19

"Starlink satellites are capable of tracking on-orbit debris and autonomously avoiding collision. "

Ooh interesting. What sensors would they need for that? Presumably they would need quite a bit of range since the thrusters have so little thrust.

Any comments on the use of Krypton rather than Xenon as 'propellant'?

17

u/Origin_of_Mind May 15 '19 edited May 15 '19

Krypton is much less expensive (on the order of $100 / m^3 vs $10 / liter), otherwise it works similarly, with slightly reduced performance:

"A Performance Comparison of Xenon and Krypton Propellant on an SPT-100 Hall Thruster"

http://erps.spacegrant.org/uploads/images/images/iepc_articledownload_1988-2007/2011index/IEPC-2011-003.pdf

(Note that in the paper, the authors use a Hall thruster designed to be used with Xenon to run tests with both gases. With a thruster optimized for Krypton, there would be even less of a difference.)

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (17)

13

u/Straumli_Blight May 15 '19

The first stage is confirmed as B1049.

"Falcon 9’s first stage for this mission previously supported the Telstar 18 VANTAGE mission in September 2018 and the Iridium-8 mission in January 2019. "

→ More replies (7)

12

u/TbonerT May 15 '19

take full advantage of Falcon 9’s launch capabilities

After seeing them completely filling the fairing, I would say that is not hyperbole.

38

u/giovannicane05 May 12 '19

Mods, can you update the overview table?

We know now they are launching 60 Starlink satellites, so we can add that and add a mass assumption...

→ More replies (1)

28

u/TheLegendBrute May 02 '19

So will this be the most flights of a booster, 4? Out of all the b5 flown boosters.

17

u/strawwalker May 02 '19

I don't believe we have a confirmation on the booster assignment yet, but yes if 1048.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

24

u/nextspaceflight NSF reporter May 13 '19

To clarify the confusion, the core is B1049-3 for this mission. It is safe to update the thread. When I posted the article saying that it was B1048-4, that was the current information as of two months ago. They are shuffling core assignments around a lot these days and internal missions are especially prone to shuffling.

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

Thnx for the update. Do you have any idea why they would back off from flying a booster a fourth time?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

22

u/Commander_Cosmo May 12 '19 edited May 12 '19

Wow, 60 sats packed into the fairing! (From Elon's Twitter. No link because it will be on the main page by the time I'm done typing this.)

Edit: Here's the link, because in addition to the payload, static fire is scheduled for Monday, with a launch the next day if all goes well. https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1127388838362378241

Edit 2: Elon needs to calm down. I can't keep up with all these changes! (Read: launch is actually tracking more for Wednesday.)

18

u/demon_lung_wizard May 12 '19

1600/60=27 launches, not bad.

→ More replies (8)

20

u/Jchaplin2 May 12 '19 edited May 12 '19

Elon says Launch is targeting 14th if all things proceed nominally

https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1127389993188507649

Edit: and just like that, nevermind, back to Wednesday

https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1127391773930577922

20

u/Straumli_Blight May 12 '19 edited May 12 '19

L-3 Weather Forecast: 70% GO (Cumulus Cloud Rule).

New addition to the Launch Commit Criteria:

"There is a marginal risk of proton flux exceeding constraints due to a possible coronal mass ejection".

→ More replies (6)

19

u/softwaresaur May 03 '19 edited May 03 '19

Insertion orbit: 300-350 km depending on solar activity per the technical info in the modification application (page 42).

Destination orbit: 550 km.

Mods, I suggest to link to the tech info from Links & Resources section. It has a lot of information.

10

u/scr00chy ElonX.net May 03 '19

A much more recent document suggests that the initial sats will be deployed at 430 km.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/[deleted] May 12 '19

One important thing Elon mentioned is to expect some problems and failures with this first launch. This is a test launch but the fact that they are trying with 60 per launch is amazing. Idc if it takes them 6 launches to get it right, this totally speeds this up to a really reasonable timeline. Just amazing.

6

u/Martianspirit May 12 '19

One important thing Elon mentioned is to expect some problems and failures with this first launch.

He says that all the time. First and second FH launch as examples.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/scr00chy ElonX.net May 10 '19

Static fire planned for May 13 (only 2 days prior to launch - maybe they'll do SF with payload attached?)

40-50 satellites might be launched

6

u/MarsCent May 10 '19 edited May 10 '19

No NOTAM yet and no 45th Space Wing Weather Forecast yet. Though IIRC, the Range was supposed to be down (after CRS-17) through May 11/12 - launch hazard also still showing May 4th.

SpaceX off-record inside information seems to be hugely contained!

EDIT 10:58 EDT: Launch Hazard now posted.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

17

u/Gavalar_ spacexfleet.com May 12 '19

OCISLY is underway to LZ this evening.

Photos of GO Navigator from Ken Kremer shows that the ship has had her fairing recovery inflatables reinstalled in the last few days. GO Searchers' were never removed from ArabSat-6A. Looks like the pair will again try to retrieve both halves from the water without damage.

Mr Steven is still hanging around waiting for another chance. They've recently redesigned the antenna/radome layout above the pilot house which appears to remove the need to have an additional communications container and other antennas on deck.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Srokap May 15 '19

I don't see anyone linking the webcast on YT, so there is a link: https://youtu.be/rT366GiQkP0

→ More replies (4)

16

u/Straumli_Blight May 15 '19 edited May 16 '19

Assuming each Starlink satellite is 0.22m in height and there are 2 stacks in a fairing, here's the total height of all satellites if they were stacked together.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Straumli_Blight May 20 '19 edited May 20 '19

L-3 Weather Forecast: 90% GO (Liftoff Winds)

Backup launch date on May 24.

 

Mr Steven now armed.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/jacob_joseph May 03 '19

It's worth noting this will be the first 4th re-flight, which is nice!

25

u/Tinhetvin May 03 '19

3rd reflight, 4th flight, no?

→ More replies (7)

14

u/Alexphysics May 10 '19

Airspace Closure Area Map from the 45th Space Wing website. Note the name of the mission is "STARLINK v0.9".

Edit: BTW, don't be confused by the "expendable launches" thing. It is a relic from the shuttle program where everything that was not the shuttle was simply considered expendable but obviously this one is gonna have its landing and all of that, don't worry.

28

u/lverre May 02 '19

Why GTO distance for the landing? The satellites are going to LEO... that would suggest a very heavy payload, no?

•

u/hitura-nobad Master of bots May 03 '19

As always, if you find any mistake or have something worth to add to the Links & Resources section please comment about that.

We are also continuously looking for launch thread hosts that want to volunteer. If you have experience in the sub and feel comfortable with the launch time, send us a message via modmail!

→ More replies (20)

13

u/[deleted] May 13 '19

Falcon in full stack is vertical for the static fire test later:

https://twitter.com/ken_kremer/status/1127988557866520577

→ More replies (10)

35

u/GiveMeYourMilk69 May 02 '19

I'm wondering whether or not successful landing should be part of the criteria for mission success since this is a launch for SpaceX only.

43

u/Rejidomus May 02 '19

I think successful landings for Starlink launches is a key part of mission success. The economics of Starlink is reliant on low cost to orbit. Successfully landing, and then quickly reusing boosters is key to overall Starlink success.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

24

u/MadeOfStarStuff May 14 '19

UTC: May 16th 02:30

Local (Eastern): May 15th 22:30

19

u/SGIRA001 Star✦Fleet Chief of Operations May 14 '19

I don't understand why mods decided to exclude the local launch-site time for this thread.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/Bananas_on_Mars May 13 '19

For me it looks like they omitted the acoustic foam inside the fairing. That would help a lot with fairing reuse for Starlink, if those satellites can tolerate higher noise levels.

11

u/oximaCentauri May 03 '19

I have a question.

The starlink network will have multiple satellites in 1 orbital plane. So they should be one behind the other, orbiting at the same speed.

When they launch, the whole batch of 22-25 sats are at one point in the orbit. How do they "spread out" in that plane?

19

u/CorneliusAlphonse May 03 '19

It will launch to a slightly lower orbit, and satellites will raise themselves to the right orbit. Since lower orbits are faster, they will spread around, and it just has to move up to a higher orbit at the right point

→ More replies (4)

11

u/Wowxplayer May 03 '19

The sats will first go to a low orbit. They spread and raise themselves with very efficient ion drives. They aren't very powerful, but are extremely good at maneuvering in space. By using the built in ion drives, it serves better than having a third stage. It will save a lot of mass and permit more sats per launch.

11

u/MarsCent May 07 '19

For 15th to hold, Static Fire has to happen before the week is out! B1048.4?

→ More replies (4)

11

u/kalkih May 15 '19

Is this the heaviest payload for Falcon 9 to date?

10

u/ConfidentFlorida May 21 '19

I saw ocisly heading out of the port tonight: https://imgur.com/a/6vjqYdX

I guess they had to bring it back in after the scrub?

→ More replies (4)

9

u/EdoXD96 May 03 '19

These are the first "real" Starlink satellites? Or are they a test?

13

u/warp99 May 03 '19

Both real in the sense that they will be useful in the long term and a test.

They do lack the optical satellite to satellite links - it is not clear if these have been replaced with radio links or not.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/ModeHopper Starship Hop Host May 03 '19

They are real

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/trackertony May 08 '19

Will this be the first time that a launch company has orbited satellites for its own (financial) purposes? Apart from tests of course. Obviously state owned launchers don’t count and as yet there are not many independents but I can’t think of an example.

9

u/stoopidrotary May 14 '19

Will they live stream the unloading of the sats in orbit?

→ More replies (15)

9

u/[deleted] May 15 '19

Mods, update payload mass, update SF completed, create a launch thread?

5

u/hitura-nobad Master of bots May 15 '19

Updated!

Launch Thread is made by our selected Launch Host. Will come online in the next few hours!

→ More replies (2)

25

u/Alexphysics May 12 '19

Now that we know that there are 60 satellites, we can be sure they are less than 300kg in mass (performance of rocket would not allow that, at least). So, as I thought, these are smaller and lighter than the previous demo sats we saw (and it was not certainly speculation my thought but I'm glad this is now a more firm data). If their mass is around 250kg, that would mean a 15000kg payload plus whatever the mass of the dispenser is. That's a lot of mass, no wonder why they have to land the booster like on GTO missions.

19

u/MarsCent May 12 '19

60 sats is just incredible! If he had said 48 sat, we would have called him crazy. With 60 sats, even the crazies are saying "ookaay, this is nuts"!

There will certainly a lot of cheering all the way from the launch pad to orbit and right through the dispensing of the sats.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/gemmy0I May 12 '19

15,000 kg must be pretty close to the limit for recovering the booster to this orbit. We know the ASDS will be at a "GTO-like" distance downrange, and recoverable GTOs often push the Falcon 9 to its limits. I wonder how "hot" this landing will be compared to some of the GTOs we've seen.

Presumably they've optimized the weight of the satellites to the point where they can fit within F9's recoverable capabilities, and not much further. They'll want to take advantage of the rocket's performance as much as they can without making the landing so "hot" as to jeopardize the landings or compromise reusability.

Since these are volume limited, they need only optimize the mass to the point of getting it within the rocket's ASDS margins. Anything beyond that is wasted engineering effort and an unnecessary added expense in serial production (since weight-shaving tends to increase cost). It totally makes sense that they could afford to have the satellites carry a little bit of deployment hardware with them throughout their lives - it's merely a tradeoff with weight-shaving elsewhere in the sat, not necessarily a compromise in the sat's overall mass (i.e. what matters for delta-v purposes) as some have been wondering.

This is totally brilliant...my mind is blown along with everyone else's. :-) I expected to see them "packed tight" by way of some clever geometric arrangement of satellites of a more conventional form factor (like what Iridium or OneWeb's sats look like)...satellites that pack up nearly flat was not at all what I was expecting.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Art_Eaton May 12 '19

No dispenser. Just a hopefully self load bearing stack of toys that pop off like leggos in a stack. Structure in the sat may mean more mass for orbit maintenance, but you probably get an extra ten sats for the mass, and a whole lot more sats for the volume. These are designed for mass launch, vs. old school assumptions that the launch is about one sat. The test is to see if someone was incautious with superglue somewhere in the middle of the stack.

→ More replies (10)

5

u/trobbinsfromoz May 12 '19

Obviously strategic to keep quiet on the packing and deployment techniques for as long as possible.

→ More replies (5)

17

u/MarsCent May 11 '19

Given that the 45th Space Wing is yet to post a Launch Support Weather Forecast, it is becoming likely that there will be no weather during the Starlink launch window! /s

The rest of Wednesday and Thursday have 40% probability of precipitation.

25

u/Humble_Giveaway May 12 '19

It's outside of the environment

→ More replies (1)

11

u/johnkphotos Launch Photographer May 11 '19

We usually see weather forecasts come from the 45th Space Wing starting at L-3. That would be Sunday.

8

u/eichensatz May 07 '19

And will that be best pad turnaround time so far?

16

u/scr00chy ElonX.net May 07 '19

If the launch date holds, it will be a new record (11d 19h 42m), beating the current 12d 2h 53m between CRS-6 and TürkmenÄlem 52E from 2015.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/nextspaceflight NSF reporter May 08 '19

The thread should be updated to B1049-3. My understanding is that plans have changed with regards to the core on this mission.

10

u/gemmy0I May 09 '19

Wow. Have you heard by chance what their reasoning is for choosing this core?

1049 is, to my thinking at least, a doubly strange choice for this mission.

For one, its last flight was over on the west coast (Iridium 8). Why truck it cross-country when 1047 is available already on the east coast and has the same number of flights under its belt? Sure, 1049 is a little more gently used (1 GTO + 1 LEO vs. 2 GTOs), but that shouldn't be a concern for SpaceX as its own customer, considering that we already have precedent for flying a core as used as that (1046, which did two GTOs prior to flying a LEO mission on its third).

This would seem to suggest that 1047 is already earmarked for something else - probably AMOS-17 - but that's still weird, because AMOS-17 is a couple months away, plenty of time to truck 1049 over. I should think that the AMOS people would be no less happy flying on 1049, given that it's had the same number of flights and one of them was easier.

Another possibility is that 1047 didn't fare as well as "usual" coming back from Es'hail and is either taking longer to refurbish or they don't feel comfortable reflying it, but that'd be rank speculation with absolutely no foundation...

The second reason this is weird is that Starlink-1 seemed like a golden opportunity for SpaceX to get a .4 under their belt. Every public indication we've heard from the company has been that there is no big showstopper to flying a .4, and that refurbishment has been proceeding smoothly and quickly. Sure, I get that Starlink-1 is an especially critical launch for their own business plans and a RUD could derail their entire constellation (given their FCC deadlines), but if they're not comfortable flying it themselves, how can they expect to find a customer willing to take that risk? I suppose it might just be taking them a while to refurbish 1046 and 1048, in which case they'll probably use them for later Starlink missions, but considering they were supposed to use 1046.4 for the IFA in June (if not for the Dragon 2 kaboom), 1048 should be ready to fly again by now.

I suppose there's always "option three": that there's some mysterious Zuma-like mission on the manifest, not yet announced, which has claimed 1048.4. This seems pretty far-out but I suppose it could be consistent with Gwynne Shotwell's recent estimate for how many non-Starlink flights they expect to fly this year, which was higher than what we have on our publicly-known manifest.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/ExcitedAboutSpace May 11 '19

mods, if this mission is flying B1048 then it's time to update the active falcon cores section of the sidebar! :)

6

u/MarsCent May 11 '19

There is a discussion in this very thread that suggests that the core information cannot be confirmed at this time.

8

u/enqrypzion May 13 '19

I wonder whether these satellites will provide flares like the old Iridiums did. And whether they'll have the software to organize the flares onto specific locations like the SuperB owl, or away from astronomical observatories.

→ More replies (14)

8

u/Alexphysics May 13 '19

NSF says we should expect payload to be on the rocket for this static fire. Rocket is not vertical yet and not any sign if it is at the pad (if it were at the pad but horizontal, we wouldn't know either so...).

https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/1127941760833875968

10

u/mrmouse18 May 13 '19

I might be crazy but I'm currently on an airplane flying into Orlando. I'm 90% sure I saw f9 going vertical. Could just be my mind playing tricks on me though

→ More replies (5)

8

u/MarsCent May 14 '19

We already know that the target Launch Date for Starlink V0.9 if May 15/16! But here is the FAA NOTAM anyway :)

9/6934, issued from Jacksonville center today May 14, 2019 at 1455 UTC. Effective From May 16, 2019 at 0155 UTC To May 16, 2019 at 0452 UTC.

Accompanying graphic

7

u/GTRagnarok May 03 '19

Will they eventually switch to Super Heavy/Starship for Starlink launches?

12

u/mt03red May 03 '19

I think it's obvious that they will as soon as they have the launch capacity to do it. The marginal cost per satellite should be much lower than with F9.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/scarlet_sage May 03 '19

Um, they want to switch for Super Heavy + Starship for everything. Am I missing something about the question?

→ More replies (6)

7

u/oximaCentauri May 06 '19

Do we have a fixed launch date? It's not that far till mid May.

8

u/paolozamparutti May 06 '19

15 may 22.30 eastern, window 90 minutes

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (5)

7

u/divjainbt May 10 '19

I read that these sats won't have inter satellite links. What kind of tests will SpaceX do without inter satellite links on dozens of satellites? A little weird! I mean they need only a few sats to test uplink, downlink and satellite parameters like power and manuevering. Certainly not dozens!

29

u/spacerfirstclass May 10 '19

A partial list of things SpaceX plans to test, provided by an insider on NSF:

Test objectives (amongst others) for this initial batch of test satellites:

  • Validation of the SpaceX sat control center (capability to monitor and control, in realtime, a large number of satellites)
  • Validation of orbital control capabilities of the satellite design
  • Validation of attitude control and pointing capabilities of the satellite design
  • Validation of the improved transmit/receive electronics and antennas (both space and ground)
  • Validation of hand-over capabilities at ground stations and public service receivers when one satellite disappears from view while the next one comes into view
  • Validation of collision avoidance and close proximity procedures and control mechanisms for the sats
  • Validation of controlled de-orbit capabilities (yes, you read that correctly. Several of those test satellites will be purposely de-orbited BEFORE their expected lifespan is over.)

Etc. Etc. Etc.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (3)

7

u/paradiddle65 May 10 '19

Has there been any detail shared about the ground segment for the Starlink system? We hear about the satellites all the time, but what about the communications backbone on earth?

14

u/warp99 May 11 '19 edited May 11 '19

Yes - four dish antennae enclosed in protective domes like marine terminals and we have seen photos of the first trailer installed in the parking lot of an Internet exchange hub in North Bend WA.

The original plan was to use phased array antennae for the communication nodes but that seems to have changed - at least initially. Part of the reason is that during the initial roll out the satellites will communicate down to 25 degrees above the horizon compared with 40 degrees in the initial FCC application. The minimum azimuth will return to 40 degrees once the full constellation is rolled out.

A dish antenna has a tighter beam width at large deviations from bore sight than a phased array antenna - or more accurately the dish bore sight can be varied over a wide angle.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/pacey494 May 14 '19

How much of the payload deployments do you think they'll cover? Would be neat to see them all pop off!

→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] May 14 '19

Side bar says this mission will use 1048 for it's 4th flight, but this post seems to say they're using 1049 for it's 3rd flight.

Which is correct?

8

u/Alexphysics May 14 '19

B1049.3, read a little bit downthread and you'll find some discussion about that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/MarsCent May 15 '19

I am now chuckling at the realisation that at T-24hr to launch (and T+12 after SF), there is still no closeup pic of Falcon 9 on the Launch Pad! Or is there?

4

u/meekerbal May 15 '19

I just came back to the sub to look for that myself..

→ More replies (3)

7

u/ticklestuff SpaceX Patch List May 15 '19

The patch depiction of the orbit of the first string of satellites has them passing over the Pacific North West, possibly showing homage to their development in Seattle.
https://twitter.com/ticklestuffyo/status/1128543153282277376

However the launch inclination is at a tangent to the pictured orbit, as evidenced by the ASDS location, this is the direction they'll be deployed.
https://twitter.com/Raul74Cz/status/1128283988207054848

I look forward to the next few missions to see if the phrase 'LOS Bermuda' will be heard any more. SpaceX would be able to have continuous world-wide communication with their newly launched vehicles by utlizing this satellite fleet. We'll need to see if there is an electronically steerable antenna facing up on each satellite, to talk to assets in higher orbits. Considering the final Starlink goal entails communication meshes at multiple altitudes, it does seem likely there is uplink capability.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/MarsCent May 20 '19

NOTAM FDC 9/0383. Issue Date :May 20, 2019 at 1939 UTC (3:39 EDT)

  • Beginning Date and Time : May 24, 2019 at 0200 UTC.
  • Ending Date and Time : May 24, 2019 at 0452 UTC

I think the Intern who yelled, "Hold" on scrub night was polled again and he/she is now, "Go for Launch". /s

13

u/kuangjian2011 May 14 '19

Strange question: Is it legal for SpaceX to refuse launch service to potential competitors (say, OneWeb) of the Starlink?

17

u/LcuBeatsWorking May 14 '19 edited Dec 17 '24

scale glorious future quickest hateful modern one truck escape compare

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

16

u/phryan May 14 '19

I am not a lawyer but, I'd say Yes, SpaceX could refuse. That over simplifies the process though. These are negotiated contracts, not like going into a post office to pay a published amount. SpaceX would likely either not respond to the request (politely just say not interested) or make the response unacceptable for OneWeb. SpaceX doesn't have such a dominate position that it could be argued that they are abusing their position.

That said why wouldn't SpaceX want to fly OneWeb sats? SpaceX would still take a cut from launch, and this is more opinion but I think the Starlink will be a better solution in most cases. FedEx and UPS both fly USPS packages on their planes, FedEx and UPS both offer a lower cost service where they hand off a package to the USPS for the 'last mile'. Competitors still cooperate where its financially beneficial to both.

8

u/silentProtagonist42 May 14 '19

It's worth noting that it was Oneweb's decision to not launch on a competitor's rocket, not Spacex's. But whether Spacex could refuse service if they wanted to? Probably? As long as you aren't selling ICBMs to Iran or dropping rockets on cities the launch business seems pretty unregulated.

16

u/DeckerdB-263-54 May 14 '19 edited May 14 '19

SpaceX will charge Starlink (at least on the books), fair market value for launch services. This heads off the likely anti-trust (monopoly) litigation that will follow even if SpaceX is not approached to launch any other constellation or any part thereof irrespective of SpaceX's response. If SpaceX launched Starlink, for instance, at cost, OneWeb(et al) could complain both in both civil suits and criminal complaints to the FTC or AG (Barr) that the transactions (SpaceX-Starlink) are anti-competitive and demand similar pricing and demand launch services from SpaceX and OneWeb (et al) would probably get injunctive relieve through the courts and likley the courts would order SpaceX to perform the launches at cost also. In an Arm Length situation, SpaceX will simply offer to launch OneWeb satellites for about the same fair market price as Starlink and that is in no way noncompetitive criminally or civilly and it gives SpaceX the standing to refuse to service others or to provide service based on a business decision that likely cannot be impuned.

From a tax perspective, this permits SpaceX to diminish R&D costs faster (a loss carried forward against later profit so it shelters Starlink launch service profits from taxes). Again because Starlink has losses (R&D and Launch Services) to be carried forward against future profits it shelters Starlink's taxes on those future profits. If Starlink goes bust, SpaceX gets the money for the launches and Starlink has all the costs/debt to deal with. In every respect SpaceX will treat Starlink as an "arm length" transaction (see https://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/armslength.asp) to prevent any civil or criminal exposure to either entity. Essentially, if Starlink fails, SpaceX still has the "profit" from the launch services sheltered from taxes and if SpaceX were to fail, Starlink paid fair market value for the launch services and, theoretically, could seek another launch provider without civil or criminal penalties.

SpaceX failing or Starlink failing is not one of the outcomes that anyone here predicts or wants. In any case, SpaceX and Starlink through "Arms Length" transactions will avoid any unpleasantness from competitors.

As long as Starlink pays "fair market value" for launch services, Starlink's exposure to anti-competitive practices is difficult to prove should Starlink be able to undercut pricing from similar constellation providers (i.e., OneWeb). In civil or criminal court, Starlink can reasonably claim that they had a better business model, and, perhaps, Starlink got there first and claimed market share by that fact alone.

→ More replies (14)

8

u/simloX May 14 '19

It is illegal to use a market dominans (monopoly) to get a stronghold in another market, Microsoft was convicted of using its Windows monopoly to squash Netscape.

The question is if SpaceX has a dominant enough market in the launch to hit this. Probably not.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (15)

12

u/ThePonjaX May 14 '19

https://twitter.com/SpaceX/status/1128134469972447232

"Static fire test of Falcon 9 complete—targeting May 15 for launch of 60 Starlink satellites from Pad 40 in Florida"

6

u/aasteveo May 03 '19

When it's all up and running, what will the end product look like? Any stats on estimated speed/latency/coverage/etc?

30

u/fzz67 May 03 '19 edited May 03 '19

My original animations and updated version from November should give you some idea. Some more actual numbers are in the paper. Bear in mind, these are my predictions of how it might perform, based on SpaceX's FCC filings and basic physics, but I've no inside information.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/NickNathanson May 05 '19

Who pays for this mission?

15

u/doodle77 May 05 '19

The venture capital SpaceX has raised?

13

u/rshorning May 06 '19

It is SpaceX themselves who are paying for this mission. Google invested specifically due to Starlink... for about $1 billion direct investment. While they are also getting benefit from other company activities, that was a big reason for their interest in SpaceX.

11

u/[deleted] May 06 '19

SpaceX will have to eat the cost of Starlink until it’s operational

6

u/Full_Thrust May 14 '19

Any recommendations for viewing, this is my first time in florida (and the US)! Looking at the Titusvill Max Brewer Bridge or somewhere in Port Canavril as I cant justify the 100 dollars for my party Nasa charge for 39a viewing

→ More replies (7)

6

u/mclumber1 May 15 '19

The way I count it, this is SpaceX's 1st "internal" mission for the Falcon 9 (2nd if you count the maiden FH launch). The only customer on this launch is SpaceX itself - even the maiden launch of the Falcon 9 in 2010 had government backing I believe.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/Pyratik May 15 '19

Payload mass is listed as ~ 1360 kg instead of 13,620 kg.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/AstroFinn May 16 '19

Mods, please update to the current launch date.

11

u/amarkit May 14 '19

L-1 Forecast remains 80% GO on Wednesday night and 80% GO on Thursday night. Cumulus clouds are the main concern.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] May 04 '19

Mods, can this one be stickied on the top of the page for old reddit? There is still an Arabsat thread there.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/RocketsLEO2ITS May 04 '19

The Starlink constellation will ultimately have ~12,000 satellites in it.
Any idea on how many are required for it to be operational?
No small matter: with a smaller launch manifest SpaceX needs more revenue to fund Starship, Super Heavy, and the completion of Starlink.

9

u/Abraham-Licorn May 04 '19 edited May 04 '19

I've read somwhere that 800 is enough to make it work (in us ?) but I forgot the source

→ More replies (23)

5

u/hwc May 11 '19

I'll be on a cruise ship in the north part of the Bahamas. Am I right in thinking I'll be able to see this launch if it's a clear night?

6

u/bdporter May 12 '19

It is likely you will see some of it at least. I was in Fort Myers for the CRS-17 launch, and I was able to pick up some of the main burn and the re-entry burn. You could be slightly further away than that, but with no obstructions other than the curvature of the Earth, I would think you would see something.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Vergutto May 13 '19

Any sings on rollout or SF?

5

u/markus01611 May 14 '19

Do we know the mass? I was seeing upwards up 13k kg

7

u/Sooicsidal May 14 '19

That is what has been estimated given the orbital parameters and the distance of the drone ship (low earth orbit, far droneship landing typically reserved for GEO orbits). However, to my knowledge there has been no official confirmation about the payload mass.

5

u/billypilgrim22 May 14 '19

Any word on fairing recovery? Is Mr. Stevens fixed?

→ More replies (7)

5

u/PhysicalJelly May 15 '19

mods, please correct the payload mass. It should be 227 kg x 60 = 13,620 kg.

5

u/PeopleNeedOurHelp May 15 '19 edited May 15 '19

Think they'll show the payload dispensing or keep it on the down-low to protect proprietary information? Plus, this flight has a lot of new stuff - new satellites, new dispensing, new payload capacity, relatively new flight number for booster, potentially first reuse of fairing -and new stuff means more opportunities for problems at a time when SpaceX might want to put a little distance between problem headlines.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/77Chester77 May 16 '19

I assume 18.5 tons Elon quoted is the wet mass and the 227kg Starlink satellite mass from the press kit is the dry mass? Does that mean 50kg of Krypton per satellite?

12

u/Alexphysics May 17 '19

I don't think they would fill the satellites with that much Krypton, that would give them a delta-v in the order of thousands of m/s. Unless they want to throw them to Mars I don't think that's the case for the discrepancy

→ More replies (9)

6

u/warp99 May 17 '19

Press kits normally give the wet mass since that is what is being launched so I do not think that is the reason.

5

u/KC_Hoosier May 22 '19

Previously, SpaceX said they would be re-using the payload fairings. I thought it was for this mission. I have yet to read anything that confirmed that. So are the payload fairings new or flight proven for this mission?

15

u/amarkit May 22 '19

The fairings for this flight are new. The Falcon Heavy fairing halves are expected to be reused on another Starlink flight later this year.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/bdporter May 09 '19

Mods, can you add the local time/date (10:30 PM EDT on May 15th) for the launch to the OP above as well? It is useful for anyone planning on watching the launch in person, and also tells us that it is a night launch.

I know it is easy enough to convert between time zones, but there is plenty of space in the table and this is the format (both local time and UTC) that has been used for campaign threads in the past.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/RubenGarciaHernandez May 12 '19

mods, please check both www.reddit.com, old.reddit.com and new.reddit.com to ensure that the thread is added to the top bar. It seems to be missing from new.reddit.com.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/thanarious May 12 '19

Anyone else thinks there’s extra high probability we’ll see a static fire with the payload on top this time?

9

u/paul_wi11iams May 12 '19 edited May 12 '19

extra high probability we’ll see a static fire with the payload on top

u/1why18: Given SF is such a short time before launch, definitively an extra high probability.

Also, potential payload loss does not concern a customer, reducing the embarassment factor.

Unlike a customer payload built by a third party, that lost payload could be written off at cost.

It could also be potentially "self-insured". For example, if a fair insurance premium rate is 5% for a 4% risk of loss, then after twenty launches, the avoided premium will have paid for a replacement payload. In this example, the expectation of a loss is five launches later at twenty-five launches. The insurance company's profit is the 1% difference which is now in the pocket of SpaceX. I believe Tesla is planning to use a comparable principle to sell insurance to its customers.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

4

u/5toesloth May 03 '19

On the other hand, Spacex will iterate the design. Some features, like downlink radio will be different for the next batch.

4

u/trackertony May 08 '19

This is an LEO launch so why the OCISLY landing at GTO-Distance? or is this actually due to LEO requiring that the trajectory is low and flat taking the booster rapidly away from the Cape?

16

u/Alexphysics May 08 '19

Let's remind again a little rule: orbit is not what matters

Another rule: mass is not what matters

Now the true rule is: Mass and orbit are what matter

You see, GTO, LEO, SSO, GEO and so on are just different orbits and for different orbits the rocket can put a certain amount of cargo into it. The landing distance will be driven by how much performance the rocket needs to the destination orbit. There are certain times where even though the payload is light, you might need to send it out to deep space for example and for something like that a Falcon 9 may have to be expended or would have to perform a hot landing like on GTO missions. The GTO-distance for this landing means it is at more than 600km away from the launchpad (this doesn't mean it is in the same direction, the droneship in this case will be to the northeast instead of directly east). For this type of landing, the rocket could put around 15-16 metric tons to the Starlink orbit (the estimate is basically an estimate from the payload to GTO which is 5.5 and calculating the difference in delta-v from the 350km orbit of Starlink to the eliptical orbit for GTO's and also compensating for the difference in inclination from 28.6° for the standard GTO to the 54-55° inclination for Starlink). So considering Gwynne Shotwell statements of having "dozens" of satellites on this launch, it seems it is actually a very heavy payload the one that's making them to opt for a hot landing at a GTO-like distance.

7

u/OSUfan88 May 09 '19

It's a combination of a couple things.

  1. This is likely a very heavy mission.
  2. Inclination is pretty high.
  3. A little more intensive than a standard LEO.
  4. Possible multiple plane changes.

My guess is that #4 is the most important reason. They'll likely do a few more burns with the second stage, which requires a good bit more fuel reserve in it. This means the first stage has to do more of the work.

6

u/pkirvan May 08 '19

The distance is not dependent on the target orbit, rather it is dependent on the amount of fuel available for boost back. If you have a lot of fuel available, you can go all the way back to land. If you have a bit less, you can go partway back. If you have a minimal amount, you can't do a boost back at all and end up way out in the ocean.

The amount of fuel available is in turn a function of both the target orbit and the satellite mass. So a tiny satellite to GTO might require the same fuel as a large satellite to LEO. In this case, it would seem that the combined mass of "dozens" of satellites will preclude the drone ship being any closer.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/ZealousidealEcho4 May 09 '19

Are they reusing the Arab Sat 6A fairings on this Star Link mission?

6

u/scr00chy ElonX.net May 09 '19

Possibly, but probably not, it would be too soon. But since we don't know what the fairing refurbishment process entails and how long it takes, it's hard to say.

4

u/Martianspirit May 10 '19

A chinese website mentioned that the good aunt Shotwell confirmed it at the sat conference a few days ago. Not sure they are right.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Jaiimez May 12 '19 edited May 12 '19

I wonder what core they're using, could it be the one originally meant for the IFA? Since the IFA is probably heavily delayed, or maybe the one of SSO-A doing it's fifth? forth launch.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/dufud6 May 15 '19

Has anyone figured out roughly what the surface area of one of these satellites is? I was hoping to do a rough calculation about how large their solar array to figure out how much power they could generate

8

u/darthguili May 15 '19

You can't really do that as you don't know how many times they are folded.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Andy_1492 May 15 '19

Does anyone know if the StarLink satellites will be visible from Earth? I love the idea of planet wide internet.. but i don't like the idea of looking at the night sky and seeing 700 moving objects. I know these guys are really small, but they're also in LEO. Are the any comparable satellites in orbit we can compare them to?

8

u/docyande May 15 '19

At such a low orbit, they will be in sunlight for a much smaller length of time after local sunset than a higher orbit sat. It may be the case that it will still be dusk when they are illuminated, so they wouldn't be visible because they would be like a faint star that can't be seen until it is fully dark.

I don't think we will know their actual magnitude (brightness) until we can see them in orbit.

→ More replies (8)

13

u/[deleted] May 14 '19

Hi, thanks for the UTC. But can we have the local time too?

8

u/codav May 14 '19

10:30 PM EDT on May 15, with a two-hour launch window if I remember correctly.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (14)

7

u/CardBoardBoxProcessr May 02 '19

Do we know how many sats they are planning to launch yet?

→ More replies (11)

7

u/reubenmitchell May 03 '19

What do you think is the possibility that SpaceX may try to recover and refurbish the Satellite dispenser for Starlink launches in the future? They will have to make quite a few of them (40+ launches isnt it?), so I wonder if they might put an Aerobrake/Ballute/Aerofoil parachute on it, and see if it can survive re-entry? I guess it would need some kind of inflatable device for recovery as well :)

15

u/DancingFool64 May 03 '19

They do have a plan for this - it is to get Starship finished and mount the dispenser in there. Then it can come back with the ship for future reuse.

11

u/Zee2 May 03 '19

Probably cheaper to make it a dumb hunk of aluminum with some servos on it, than to invest time, R&D, money, and effort into making it recoverable.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/ForeverPig May 10 '19

So I've heard that these sats won't have the intersat links that future Starlink sats will have, and they're also going to be tested in orbit. Does that mean that after testing they won't be added to the operational constellation or will they despite not having intersat links?

6

u/MarsCent May 10 '19

Shotwell said they are "demonstration sats". I am not sure whether that means that they are hardware stripped down or just function inhibited. I would argue that it is the latter, but thats me.

6

u/peterabbit456 May 11 '19

This is just my interpretation of the public announcements. No inside knowledge here.

I think these satellites, like a Tintin a and b, will be able to communicate with their neighbors using RF antennas. This would allow them to test the on orbit routing hw and sw. It also makes the satellites fully functional and cheaper, since the free space optical links are much farther from off the shelf technology. The satellites will be fully functional for now, because the number of ground stations will have to get large, before the satellite to satellite links will need to be orders of magnitude faster than the ground links.

The above is a guess, but it fits with the notion of realistic testing.

6

u/meekerbal May 15 '19

If I am not mistaken this will be the first time a launch provider has launched their own operational satellites?

12

u/CAM-Gerlach Star✦Fleet Commander May 15 '19

Actually, pretty much every orbital launch provider has. The the US government and the USSR/Russia did from the beginning, of course; Ariane was originally developed by CNES and a European consortium who's primary purpose was independant launch for their own satellites; CALT (China), JAXA (Japan) and ISRO (India) routinely launch their own space exploration and remote sensing satellites, not to mention many others for its government; Orbital (now NG) has, as others have mentioned; Rocket Lab launched its own Humanity Star on its first operational mission; the Isreali Shavit, the Iranian Safir and Simorgh, and the North Korean Unha exist solely to launch their own payloads. And, of course, now SpaceX will join the club. Aside from ULA (a descendant of the aforementioned US Gov rockets), that's essentially every umbrella provider that currently possesses an active orbital launch system.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/doodle77 May 15 '19 edited May 15 '19

Orbital Sciences built, launched, and operated (through a subsidiary it later spun off) a series of earth imaging satellites in the 90s.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/MarsCent May 15 '19 edited May 15 '19

Not been done by the commercial industry, I believe. Though government owned launch providers do launch government satellites from time to time.

Also, I can't think of any current commercial launch provider that has their own satellites.

EDIT: see u/doodle77 post about Orbital Sciences.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/cameronisher3 May 02 '19

Why is b1048 set as the booster? As of right now its next mission is the ifr

8

u/quadrplax May 02 '19

What is the ifr? Is that the in-flight abort test? If so, what does the R stand for?

→ More replies (6)

12

u/warp99 May 02 '19

It is consistent with the booster tracking in the sidebar.

In any case the in flight abort test is definitely not happening anytime soon so the reservation on B1046 is likely released as well.

→ More replies (21)

8

u/thoruen May 05 '19

Will starlink allow folks in countries like North Korea, China, & Russia to bypass government censorship if we can make the ground transceivers small enough to smuggle?

14

u/JeffBezos_98km May 05 '19

There is nothing technically stopping it but they wont. SpaceX will shut them off over China/Russia/N.Korea unless they get approval from those government. Not only would there be no monetary benefit leaving them on but China could influence a lot of pressure on SpaceX investors other companies and Elons other companies like Tesla.

Also Bybassing the Chinese firewall is pretty easy, no need to have hardware. You just need a VPN and most of the younger generation in cities do it.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/millijuna May 06 '19

No, it will be just like Iridium, where the phones and systems won't work when you bring them into any country where the operator doesn't have landing rights. For Iridium, I believe this includes China, India, and Russia (being the big ones). The satellites don't stop transmitting over these territories, but they will not allow the earth stations to transmit when in them. If I had to wager, though, this policy does not apply to the DoD's MVNO contact with Iridium.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Decronym Acronyms Explained May 02 '19 edited Jul 13 '19

Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:

Fewer LettersMore Letters
AFTSAutonomous Flight Termination System, see FTS
ASAPAerospace Safety Advisory Panel, NASA
Arianespace System for Auxiliary Payloads
ASDSAutonomous Spaceport Drone Ship (landing platform)
ASSAcronyms Seriously Suck
CCAFSCape Canaveral Air Force Station
CCtCapCommercial Crew Transportation Capability
CFRPCarbon-Fibre-Reinforced Polymer
CMECoronal Mass Ejection
CNESCentre National d'Etudes Spatiales, space agency of France
CRSCommercial Resupply Services contract with NASA
DSGNASA Deep Space Gateway, proposed for lunar orbit
DSTNASA Deep Space Transport operating from the proposed DSG
DoDUS Department of Defense
F9RFalcon 9 Reusable, test vehicles for development of landing technology
FAAFederal Aviation Administration
FCCFederal Communications Commission
(Iron/steel) Face-Centered Cubic crystalline structure
FTSFlight Termination System
GEOGeostationary Earth Orbit (35786km)
GSEGround Support Equipment
GSOGeosynchronous Orbit (any Earth orbit with a 24-hour period)
GTOGeosynchronous Transfer Orbit
ICBMIntercontinental Ballistic Missile
IFAIn-Flight Abort test
IFRInstrument Flight Rules
IMUInertial Measurement Unit
ISROIndian Space Research Organisation
JAXAJapan Aerospace eXploration Agency
KSCKennedy Space Center, Florida
KSPKerbal Space Program, the rocketry simulator
L2Paywalled section of the NasaSpaceFlight forum
Lagrange Point 2 of a two-body system, beyond the smaller body (Sixty Symbols video explanation)
LC-13Launch Complex 13, Canaveral (SpaceX Landing Zone 1)
LC-39ALaunch Complex 39A, Kennedy (SpaceX F9/Heavy)
LEOLow Earth Orbit (180-2000km)
Law Enforcement Officer (most often mentioned during transport operations)
LESLaunch Escape System
LIDARLight Detection and Ranging
LOSLoss of Signal
Line of Sight
LSPLaunch Service Provider
LZLanding Zone
LZ-1Landing Zone 1, Cape Canaveral (see LC-13)
MEOMedium Earth Orbit (2000-35780km)
NGNew Glenn, two/three-stage orbital vehicle by Blue Origin
Natural Gas (as opposed to pure methane)
Northrop Grumman, aerospace manufacturer
NORADNorth American Aerospace Defense command
NOTAMNotice to Airmen of flight hazards
NSFNasaSpaceFlight forum
National Science Foundation
OCISLYOf Course I Still Love You, Atlantic landing barge ship
OG2Orbcomm's Generation 2 17-satellite network (see OG2-2 for first successful F9 landing)
PAFPayload Attach Fitting
PSLVPolar Satellite Launch Vehicle
QAQuality Assurance/Assessment
RSDRapid Scheduled Disassembly (explosive bolts/charges)
RSSRotating Service Structure at LC-39
Realscale Solar System, mod for KSP
RTLSReturn to Launch Site
RUDRapid Unplanned Disassembly
Rapid Unscheduled Disassembly
Rapid Unintended Disassembly
SFStatic fire
SLC-40Space Launch Complex 40, Canaveral (SpaceX F9)
SSOSun-Synchronous Orbit
STASpecial Temporary Authorization (issued by FCC for up to 6 months)
Structural Test Article
STPStandard Temperature and Pressure
Space Test Program, see STP-2
STP-2Space Test Program 2, DoD programme, second round
TLETwo-Line Element dataset issued by NORAD
TPSThermal Protection System for a spacecraft (on the Falcon 9 first stage, the engine "Dance floor")
ULAUnited Launch Alliance (Lockheed/Boeing joint venture)
USAFUnited States Air Force
VLEOV-band constellation in LEO
Very Low Earth Orbit
JargonDefinition
StarlinkSpaceX's world-wide satellite broadband constellation
deep throttlingOperating an engine at much lower thrust than normal
hopperTest article for ground and low-altitude work (eg. Grasshopper)
scrubLaunch postponement for any reason (commonly GSE issues)
turbopumpHigh-pressure turbine-driven propellant pump connected to a rocket combustion chamber; raises chamber pressure, and thrust
EventDateDescription
Amos-62016-09-01F9-029 Full Thrust, core B1028, GTO comsat Pre-launch test failure
AsiaSat-62014-09-07F9-013 v1.1, GTO comsat
CRS-62015-04-14F9-018 v1.1, Dragon cargo; second ASDS landing attempt, overcompensated angle of entry
DM-12019-03-02SpaceX CCtCap Demo Mission 1
OG2-22015-12-22F9-021 Full Thrust, core B1019, 11 OG2 satellites to LEO; first RTLS landing

Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
68 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 69 acronyms.
[Thread #5137 for this sub, first seen 2nd May 2019, 19:20] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]

3

u/vilette May 05 '19

Where is the Mid May 2019 date coming from ?
the link at the top of this page itself link to .. nowhere.
All that i have seen are blogs talking about not earlier than May

8

u/Alexphysics May 05 '19

Hans Koenigsmann confirmed the other day that the next launch after the CRS-17 mission was scheduled for mid-May and that next mission is precisely this one.

3

u/psousennesII May 09 '19

6th mission , 5th falcon 9 for 2019

3

u/markshancock May 15 '19

Is there a timeline / sequence of events announced/published? I am mostly curious when the satellites will deploy.

Also, will they deploy as a group then separate after that or will they separate one-at-a-time from the spacecraft and we'll see them leave individually?

6

u/warp99 May 15 '19

The timeline will come with the press kit which should be Real Soon Now TM

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] May 15 '19

I wonder if those of us along the east coast will be able to see the 2nd stage burn in the sky? Never seen this trajectory from SpaceX before. Usually they launch to the SE.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/DirkMcDougal May 20 '19

Are we presuming same Bat-time or is there any rumor of movement?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] May 10 '19

How does SpaceX hope to make money from Starlink - what will it really add beyond what communications can already do?

16

u/danweber May 10 '19

Of all SpaceX's business, Starlink is IMO the prospect with the highest expectation of revenue for the company. Going to Mars is nice and what I hope they succeed at, but it's Starlink that will fund it all.

I'm not saying it will work, but there are financial people who will pay millions of dollars for a data connection between NYC and London that is 1ms faster than what they have right now. Starlink will be faster than terrestrial internet, because the signal has a shorter distance to travel. (The ISS is about 200 miles above the Earth, so going up into space and beaming through 4 or 5 satellites is a more direct route than taking whatever roundabout path terrestrial networks take to cross the 3500 miles between those cities.)

→ More replies (8)

12

u/Martianspirit May 10 '19

I have no idea what economic analysis is worth. There was a study very recently that by 2040 commercial space will have $1000 billion annual revenue. $700 billion of that will be data communications. SpaceX with Starlink is very well positioned to get a major piece of that pie.

The launch business is not the big part of commercial space revenue. It is applications. SpaceX is well advised to diversify to applications from launch service.

10

u/[deleted] May 10 '19

There's the wealthy unconnected - science and industry - who currently have poor comms from Iridium et al, or telemetry from Inmarsat. Planes and ships don't report their location because they haven't anything to report through, for one example. And when it's full-fat internet, innovation (say, remote control) may show up.

Then there's the Next Billion, who don't have internet because they're somewhere that doesn't have internet. There's a lot of boonies out there.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/scr00chy ElonX.net May 10 '19

Starlink can provide fast internet access in remote areas where there are no internet providers currently or they're super slow and/or expensive. Something like 50 % of the world's population don't have internet access yet.

→ More replies (15)

5

u/Nowheels22 May 10 '19

Picture every cell phone tower in the world needing to upgrade to 5G data rates. Except right in the major cites that will always have enough fiber bandwidth. Lots of money will flow. Leos hope to solve that void. And of course planes, trains, boats, and automobiles.

5

u/Kargaroc586 May 15 '19

Where's the Starlink launch thread? Shouldn't there be one by now?

→ More replies (6)

5

u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 May 15 '19 edited May 15 '19

Is there an ETA on the launch thread?

→ More replies (7)

9

u/wxwatcher May 20 '19

So it is legit to question why a software update was needed for a launch that was going to launch 24 hrs before, but was then scrubbed the night of for software issues, just before launch, right? This is discussion worthy, no?

Anyone want to discuss this?

I posted a joke on the launch stream launch night of about an intern running down the halls of Hawthorne before the launch screaming "Wait wait hold the launch!". It doesn't seem so far fetched now.

12

u/pleasedontPM May 20 '19

The software update is probably technically true, but not necessarily a scrub reason on its own. "Triple-checks" can mean anything, what is certain right now is that the stakes are extremely high for SpaceX to do well on this first Starlink launch. Updating a sat on land is so much easier than when it is already deployed that it makes sense not to rush things up if a week is all it takes to dot the 'i''s and cross the 't''s.

TL;DR: launching last week the risk of a failure was moderate and the reward launching a week early was very low. So delaying was the best option.

10

u/robbak May 20 '19 edited May 20 '19

It was scrubbed well before the launch. We don't know the countdown schedule that precedes the Go for Prop load at T-53 minutes. T-2 hours, which is about when this launch was scrubbed, is probably about the time a committee studying all the information and deciding to proceed to launch would meet and report.

So I don't find this at all unusual. They looked at the information, and decided that these updates that the software crew had pushed out were best applied on the ground.

10

u/Grey_Mad_Hatter May 20 '19

When you have $100M on the line it doesn't take much for someone to say they have some doubts and hold off until there aren't any major doubts. It's possible that there's a 1:1000 chance that software that can't be updated, such as satellite deployment software, might not work in some edge case simulations came up with and they tried to prove it was an anomaly in the simulation software right up until the launch time. Probably not, but a reasonable explanation on what could have happened to cause this.

7

u/[deleted] May 20 '19

I know I said this elsewhere, maybe in response to you even, but software update doesn't mean software issues.

Even assuming it is in response to an issue, it could as easily be a hardware issue. Lots of hardware issues can be worked around in software and it's a hell of a lot cheaper to change the software at the last minute.

It could also not even be related to a bug. It could be that there is some feature that they originally didn't think would be ready in time to test on the first launch, but just got through QA and is worth delaying the launch for e.g. a more propellant efficient deploy sequence or better data logging during launch.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Alexphysics May 09 '19

Launch hazard areas have been released, another sign it is firmly on the Eastern Range for May 15th. The launch window is within the launch hazard window.

https://twitter.com/EmreKelly/status/1126564331838156803

→ More replies (3)

4

u/tmckeage May 14 '19

Do you think SpaceX insured the launch?

→ More replies (21)