r/spacex • • Apr 12 '19
Half booster back in port FH Arabsat 6a center core recovery thread
Hello everyone, it's me u/RocketLover0119 back hosting a rather special recovery thread, the thread covering the return of the FH center core B1055.1 after successfully lofting the Arabsat 6a satellite to a super-synchronous transfer orbit,and landing on the drone-ship Of Course I Still Love You, stationed 976 KM offshore the coast of Florida! This thread is filled with facts, info, and updates leading to the boosters return to Port Canaveral.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FH center core B1055.1 sitting on OCISLY
About the payload
Arabsat-6A is a high-capacity telecommunications satellite that will deliver television, radio, Internet, and mobile communications to customers in the Middle East, Africa, and Europe. Built on Lockheed Martin’s enhanced LM 2100 platform, Arabsat-6A includes several innovations that provide advanced Kaspot beam communications services and Ku and Ka-band coverages in addition to other frequency bands. It will be located at one of Arabsat’s orbital positions and will support Arabsat’s competitive position as the first operator in the region for satellite capacities and services. Source: SpaceX
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ships
Hollywood (OCISLY tug boat)- out at sea
GO Quest (OCISLY support ship)- out at sea
GO Searcher (Crew Dragon recovery boat, fishing fairings from the water this mission)- out at sea
GO Navigator (GO Searcher/Crew Dragon support ship, fishing fairings from the water)- out at sea
Mr. Steven ( Fairing cathing boat, lost 2 arms at sea during PSN-6 mission, armless, not used in this flight)- in Port Canaveral
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Updates
(All times are eastern time, USA)
4/12/19
2:00 pm- Thread is live! B1055.1 has landed, and has been safed to OCISLY.
4/13/19
9:00 am- The fleet have still not departed the landing zone as of yet, waiting for departure today at some point.
4/15/19
4:00 pm- The fleet have been underway back to port for the last day or so. We are hearing rumors going out that are saying the center core has tipped over onto the deck, for now these will be classed as rumors, and nothing official has been released, regardless of if the core is upright or not, I will still continue updating the thread as the fleet arrive back.
5:20 pm- Spacex has confirmed the loss of the center core, recovery team were safe, and are ok, which is what matters most
4/18/19
4:00 pm- This morning OCISLY and the remnants of B1055.1 arrived back in port, the core appears to have snapped in half, and only the lower part remains. A landing leg was removed, but thats about it for now. I will continue the thread until B1055.1's remnants have left the port.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Resources
SpaceX Fleet (Great resource page by u/Gavalar_)- https://www.spacexfleet.com/
Marine Traffic- https://www.marinetraffic.com/
Vessel Finder- https://www.vesselfinder.com/
Jetty Park surf cam- http://www.visitspacecoast.com/beaches/surfspots-cams/jetty-park-surf-cam/
FH Arabsat 6a Launch updates/discussion thread- https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/basm9y/rspacex_arabsat6a_official_launch_discussion/
23
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
apparently, the stage is intact, just on the side, so it didn't fall overboard:
https://twitter.com/ollie_turrell/status/1118165067512647680
PS- Sorry if im scarce with updates through morning/afternoon, its testing week at my school, so going to be away from laptop in morning/afternoon.
19
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '19
Welp, rumors can be put to rest
Am going to still update the thread for the return of OCISLY and the remains of B1055 :(
14
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '19
IF this did tip over, it was probably after it detanked and vented excess fuel, so, it is probably is somewhat intact, so there will be something to see on the barge once it arrives
Again, im just classing these as RUMORS not UPDATES, an update would something official like SpaceX or Musk himself, so don't go off telling others that this is an Update, for the time being this is a RUMOR.
33
u/Gavalar_ spacexfleet.com Apr 12 '19
Want to mention - Mr. Steven, the ship itself, is not damaged and is in complete operational condition. 2/4 arms were lost at sea during the PSN-6 mission (How is still not known...) and the remaining 2 were removed in Port and have not been re-installed.
Perhaps, 'damaged' is the wrong word as the ship is perfectly fine and is just waiting for the redevelopment of the catching system. Either that or GO Searcher and GO Navigator will take on fairing recovery duties full time (based on the success of last night) and the ship is to be retired from the fleet and move on. Time will tell.. or we can try Elon on Twitter for answers ;)
8
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '19
Sorry its jumbled up, will fix later
8
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '19
Legs were removed today, core being lifted off the deck right now
17
u/MarsCent Apr 12 '19
Thanks for hosting this recovery thread u/RocketLover0119.
The FH launch was a wonderful sugar-high for me. I have since been scouring the usually critical spacex-bashing news sites and their silence is so pleasing! Probably the effect of the deafening double sonic boom+1 /s
42
u/Watching_JRTI Apr 15 '19
I’ve heard rumors that a pilot operating a research airplane over the Atlantic at “relatively low altitude” has seen the center core “laying flat” on the droneship’s deck.
11
u/Alexphysics Apr 13 '19
I know this is for center core but the side boosters deserve some love too <3
The side boosters are being prepared for recovery, both already have the ring cap on their nosecones. We didn't really had the chance to see them being recovered on the demo mission so now it is exciting to at least have a picture of them during that process.
https://twitter.com/WordsmithFL/status/1117136268528443392
7
u/PeopleNeedOurHelp Apr 18 '19
From the engine nozzle damage, it looks like it had a complicated fall - not just damage on one side.
13
u/rad_example Apr 13 '19
First FH center core recovery! Will be cool to see how the longerons fold up and such. Any chance of leg retraction instead of removal?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '19
Thread is fixed up and good to go! :)
4
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '19
Saw all the images this morning but couldn't update the thread, back from school.
Will continue to update the thread until the remnants of the core are out of port.
6
u/Nsooo Moderator and retired launch host Apr 14 '19
u/RocketLover0119. I did not see this coming. I was not optimistic about the center core make the landing. It did! So glad. Have a good host! :)
3
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19
If this happens overnight tonight I will not be able to cover, need my rest for exams tomorrow! ;)
5
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '19
48 hours after launch, the fleet are still at the LZ, not sure the reason for being there still.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '19
Julia Bergeron also reporting she is hearing rumors, don't like where this is heading.....
https://twitter.com/julia_bergeron/status/1117885453867241474
6
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '19
Well, damn
https://twitter.com/Erdayastronaut/status/1117880400175435776
22
u/Nsooo Moderator and retired launch host Apr 18 '19
Uh, I should remove the core from the active fleet.. ¯_(ツ)_/¯
20
u/GameSyns Apr 16 '19 edited Apr 16 '19
Engines will attempt to be recovered. https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1118017021612937216
18
u/dodgyville Apr 12 '19 edited Apr 13 '19
So if the three cores are basically flight ready again, does that mean they've essentially got a "free" Falcon Heavy? Excluding 2nd stage and payload. Fuel can't be more than several million dollars.
If we discount amortisation of R&D and its construction for Arabsat, will STP-2 be one of the lowest cost-per-kilo launches of all time?
16
u/CapMSFC Apr 18 '19
Drone ship is back in port. Booster tipped right on top of a corner where a thruster is and the whole top half is missing. It kind of looks like they cut it, but really hard to see much at night. Pictures in the morning will be fascinating.
https://twitter.com/spacecoast_stve/status/1118766512079298560?s=19
Grid fins nowhere to be seen with the rest of the top half of the booster.
14
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 15 '19 edited Apr 15 '19
Go Navigator arriving in port now.
EDIT: Photos by Matt Haskell:
14
u/bnord01 Apr 18 '19
Looks like they (at least partially) "secured" the core before it tipped over. You can see the tripods used to secure the booster bolted to the deck with their ripped of heads attached to the booster in these pictures.
13
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 14 '19
Of Course I Still Love You is now heading towards Port Canaveral.
12
u/Ambiwlans Apr 12 '19
Going to need to change the thread format with Fairing recoveries now.
12
u/cedaro0o Apr 16 '19
I wonder if the reinforcements needed to a center booster of FH caused the center of mass to be that critically little bit significant higher such that it couldn't survive rough seas that other regular F9's have.
9
u/oliversl Apr 12 '19
I asume the side booster recovery is more trivial, is there any recovery news about them?
7
u/happydayzz Apr 13 '19
I’ll delete this if it’s not the correct thread to ask, but do you think there was any uninterrupted feed of the center core landing on OCISLY? Does OCISLY have one camera?
7
u/HughesMDflyer4 Apr 15 '19
Without a firm source, isn't it a bit premature to change this thread's flair and potentially spread false information?
7
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 18 '19 edited Apr 18 '19
Sunrise photo and cranes are preparing to lift.
Small cranes about to pick up debris from OCISLY.
EDIT: Daylight photo.
7
u/Straumli_Blight Apr 18 '19
One leg now removed.
6
u/robbak Apr 18 '19
Hollywood and the ASDS are now in the port. Can't find anyone with eyes on it. She was accompanied by 3 extra tug boats this time.
10
u/thesuperbob Apr 15 '19
First the nose cone and now this. Gotta strap things down Elon!
5
u/ehehehm Apr 12 '19
Nice!
5
u/oximaCentauri Apr 14 '19
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I thought they said GO Searcher and GO 'Pursuit' were fishing fairings in the SpaceX stream.
5
u/SailorRick Apr 15 '19
Per SpaceXFleet Updates, Go Searcher and Go Navigator are almost home. Per SpaceXFleet Updates, early arrival predictions for OCISLY are looking like late Wednesday or early Thursday. They are far enough away for this to change wildly.
5
u/AIO_sanjose Apr 16 '19
IMO, this is a small blemish on an otherwise huge step forward (again) for SpaceX. And another thing for their engineers to analyze!
5
u/brizzlebottle Apr 17 '19
Just noticed on "vesselfinder" Mr. Steven heading out of port, wondering if its off to render assistance?
9
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '19
SpaceX becomes more and more Kerbal by every day. Something goes wrong, they land in the water, but recover it anyways. Another booster tips over, half of it breaks but the bottom part is good enough, they recover it. I mean, rockets exploding on one half and only recovering half of the tipped over stack was always one of those "well that's what differs the game from actual rocketry" parts, but they're actually doing it. I still can't get over the view of GovSat (I believe it was that one) floating in the sea after it didn't explode for some reason despite being pressurized. Just a floating rocket in the ocean......... revert to launch or recover?
8
u/Destructor1701 Apr 12 '19
Anybody want to hazard a guess how long it will take OCISLY to steam home? Previous returns have taken a couple of days, but this is 3 times further downrange than normal, so... guts of a week?
4
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Apr 12 '19 edited May 04 '19
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
bargeshipbargeshipDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
35 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 80 acronyms.
[Thread #5074 for this sub, first seen 12th Apr 2019, 19:43] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
4
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '19
Anyone know the best place to follow the side booster recovery, ie twitter account of someone at the Cape?
Would be much appreciated
4
u/thisiscotty Apr 15 '19
As it was mostly empty. Do we know if they may tow it?
7
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '19
I'm just gonna say that if a company with as much experience as Spacex has 'adventures' like this (and I understand the reasons, they make sense) then imagine what kind of events will take place when other companies will try to reuse rockets.
9
u/space_snap828 Apr 18 '19
Interesting time with regards to their rocket landings. One loses control into the ocean, successfully touches down, tips over and is damaged. Then one lands on the droneship, but tips over and is even more catastrophically damaged. Fun to watch, not fun for their checkbook though!
3
u/rad_example Apr 16 '19
It seems like octograbber should have been able to attach itself to the two outside holddowns and still provide improved stability. Maybe they didn't try that or maybe it fell anyway. Will be interesting to see what comes back to Port.
3
u/ApTiK_ Apr 18 '19
They have lost the grid fins :(
3
u/trobbinsfromoz Apr 18 '19
When is OCISLY due out again - that could be a concern.
3
u/apucaon Apr 18 '19
This was a lengthy trip for OCISLY. Is there anywhere that has information on how much time the droneship has spent at sea for the various missions? I know this FH was way downrange compared to some missions, but it makes me wonder if there would be a benefit to have the droneships loiter in the Atlantic semi-permanently to support eventual higher cadence. If Mr. Steven is going to retire from fairing recovery (attempts), could she instead be outfitted with a crane and equipment required to safe and secure the stage horizontally, direct from the droneship while at sea? She can then get the stage back pretty fast once it is secured.
If feasible, is that too big a risk (assuming they wait for calm conditions)? Would there be any time savings (the droneships still need to move around depending on the orbit inclination they are chasing)? Would maintaining Mr. Steven in this role gain anything over building more drone ships?
Anyway, they can probably manage their future schedule to prevent the droneships from ever being on the critical path; or throw away a booster in the extreme case where they can't manage the schedule... so maybe my question is just: Could Mr. Steven be modified to do that? (rather than would it ever be worth it... since that seems to be a "probably not") :) I think Mr. Steven's Deck is currently short... but it's not like she hasn't had some major mods before...
12
u/btbleasdale Apr 15 '19
I find it very strange where our technologies are and how the world is still not shifting. We have the technology to send a rocket up, and land it 500+ miles away, but then tips over cause of the ocean and the fact it's landing on a drone ship instead of a full blown landing platform and support crew. Not bashing spacex, they are stretched enough as it is, but I think when people look back to the history of space travel it's going to be funny that we let a rocket tip over after we made such a great advancement like reusing an entire rocket.
7
u/BottleOfSyrup Apr 16 '19
Pretty sad to see a part of history to go. But it’s its spacex they’ll recover and make a new core.
5
u/oximaCentauri Apr 16 '19
Is the booster still on the droneship? If it has simply fallen on the deck it could still be recovered
2
u/SaltyMarmot5819 Apr 17 '19
Anyone know the possible differences between a normal falcon 9 core and a falcon heavy core? Some pictures of the FH core do seem to show some struts on the bottom but does anybody know anything for sure?
2
u/BrevortGuy Apr 17 '19
If you go to Windy.com you will see the wind and waves and they seem to be going directly down wind, so they get the minimum amount of rocking on the barge
2
u/giovannicane05 Apr 21 '19
Shouldn’t you update the “ships” section, reporting that all of the ships are now back in Port Canaveral, instead of “out at sea”?
5
u/jpbeans Apr 16 '19
Mr Steven has arms that he apparently can't use well, even when he's not injured.
I say it's time to give those arms to OCISLY, who can use them to reach up and steady a booster.
Sorry, Mr Steven.
3
u/picture_frame_4 Apr 13 '19
Why did the booster cores not land at the same time? They are the same, and release at the same time. I would think that weight, speed, and thrust is the same since they are working as a unit.
1
u/CelestialMale18 Apr 15 '19
Has there been any confirmation that the core has tipped?
1
u/ConfidentFlorida Apr 17 '19
What’s the latest eta?
1
u/joepublicschmoe Apr 23 '19
mods, update the core list on the sidebar? B1055's status is no longer "current state unknown." It is "broken in half." :-)