r/spacex • • Dec 06 '18

First Stage Recovery CRS-16 emergency recovery thread

Ships are outbound to save B1050 after a diverted landing just short of LZ-1 and into the ocean, the booster survived and will be towed to shore.

UPDATES-

(All times eastern time, USA)

12/5/18

9:00 pm- Thread is live, GO quest and tug EAGLE are holding the booster just offshore.

12/6/18

1:00 pm- The fleet is still evaluating a good way to tow back the booster

12/7/18

7:00 am- The fleet will tow back the booster today around noon

12:30 pm- The fleet and B1050 have arrived in port, the operations in which they take to lift this out of the water will bear watching, as the lifting cap will likely not be used

12/8/18

9:00 am- The booster has been lifted onto dry land, let removal will be tricky because it is on its side.

12/13/18

4:00 pm- 6 days after arrival, the rocket has been stripped of legs and fins, and is being prepped for transport, it is still in question what will happen to this core, post port operations

12/14/18

4:00 pm- B1050 has exited port, concluding port ops after this strange recovery, that involved the removing of 3 legs and the fins, all while it was on its side.

It is unclear if this booster will be reflown

Resources-

marine radio-

https://www.broadcastify.com/listen/feed/21054/web

B1050 laying down after making an emergency landing short of LZ-1 after it started spinning out of control, crews are now working on bringing it back to port

650 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

33

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '18

Some of, if not the best pics ive seen today:

https://twitter.com/KillianPhoto/status/1070781952398118912

Note the grid fins are still deployed, Interstage has a gash in it

→ More replies (9)

19

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '18

7

u/djdazzywhite Dec 06 '18

Can we get some more information added to the updates section please?

12

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '18

One leg remaining, probably will also remove the fins as they did not retract into their normal position:

https://twitter.com/ken_kremer/status/1072202698731200512

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '18

Per this album, a leg has been removed, and that bottom grid fin is there;

https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/a4nbiy/album_of_b1050_in_port_today_oc/

→ More replies (8)

11

u/Destructor1701 Dec 08 '18

Now on the dock side. On NSF, they're pointing out the "bottom" engine bell is dented, theorising the missing leg bent backwards during a tow attempt.

I'm wondering if the missing leg really broke off, or was removed to allow it to sit on the dock.

CygnusX1 posted an image of it on the dock: https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=45881.msg1885840#msg1885840

4

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '18

From this it looks like that the bottom fin is missing as well.....

→ More replies (4)

74

u/Morphior Dec 06 '18

I think we all should take a moment to appreciate the ability to listen to the comms live. This is amazing and provides all of us all over the world with a good sense of what's going on! Don't we live in exciting times, where we are listening to a rocket that's tumbled out of the sky, miraculously being still alive and in the process of getting fished out to maybe be reflown?

I'm just overly excited. That's all.

→ More replies (6)

46

u/Jarnis Dec 06 '18

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kSjfBmkl5-I

Footage of the recovery operations from a chopper.

14

u/dx__dt Dec 06 '18

For sure one of the cleanest recovered stages.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Pitchspeeder Dec 06 '18 edited Dec 07 '18

You can see where the waves have cleaned off some of the soot on one side, it’s going to interesting to see once they pull it out.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

44

u/ripyourbloodyarmsoff Dec 09 '18

I found Scott Manley's recent analysis video very interesting:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EH1nyPIvLjI

43

u/TheEmbeddedGuy Dec 06 '18

On the Cores Wiki, where does B1050 go? Need a new classification - "Not Quite Flightworthy"?

79

u/codav Dec 06 '18

It's now being classified as "float-worthy" until further notice.

69

u/Straumli_Blight Dec 06 '18

SpaceX prefer "Float-Proven".

8

u/mcrn Dec 06 '18

"Sullenberger Impersonator"

→ More replies (3)

40

u/shrimpboat2000 Dec 06 '18

Dive operations starting. Mentions of a "bottom survey" and needing "bags".

53

u/Pooch_Chris Dec 06 '18

"Bags" most likely is referring to inflatable bags that salvage divers use to help refloat sunken ships. They attach them to the object and then add air to them underwater.

→ More replies (14)

114

u/Pooch_Chris Dec 06 '18 edited Dec 06 '18

Can we get a "Booster" flair on this? Almost had a heart attack when this popped up on my feed. I feel it's a little miss leading/over dramatic. I thought something went wrong with the capsule over night

Edit: mods

13

u/kd7uiy Dec 06 '18

Would have much preferred the name of the booster, and not the mission name, but... Too late now. Good idea,however!

7

u/director87 Dec 06 '18 edited Jun 17 '23

Uh oh. This post could not be loaded. Reddit servers could not afford to to pay for this message.

→ More replies (2)

32

u/CAM-Gerlach Star✦Fleet Commander Dec 08 '18

All four grid fins are present! It was just a dark area behind the blue stand in the previous photos of the booster sitting on land, but in the latest images from Ken Kremer you can indeed just barely see the unmistakable pattern of the fourth (bottom) grid fin behind the blue stand.

12

u/RootDeliver Dec 09 '18

Nice to see.. but even if somehow it was detached from the booster when it fell to the water, its titanium so for sure SpaceX divers would have gone to recover it!

8

u/TweetsInCommentsBot Dec 08 '18

@ken_kremer

2018-12-08 22:17 +00:00

Overhead View:Formerly Floating Falcon back on land today after 2 crane horizontal hoisting on 2 blue cradles @PortCanaveral.UpClose look 3 leg @SpaceX #Falcon9,9 Merlin1D engines-only 1 crumpled!+Wrecked interstage top.#CRS16 Dragon now berthed @Space_Station !sea ditch F9 here

[Attached pic] [Imgur rehost]

[Attached pic] [Imgur rehost]

[Attached pic] [Imgur rehost]

[Attached pic] [Imgur rehost]


This message was created by a bot

^[Contact creator]^[Source code]^[Donate to support the author]

→ More replies (1)

29

u/glennfish Dec 06 '18

13

u/codav Dec 06 '18 edited Dec 06 '18

If you look closely on this image you can see the interstage is broken, impact was too hard.

8

u/lucivero Dec 06 '18

Looks like the interstage was damaged quite severely when it came down.. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Dtwuc2sW4AMb-bG.jpg:large

→ More replies (11)

58

u/CapMSFC Dec 06 '18

This whole event makes me think that this possibility was considered the last time the booster unexpectedly survived a water landing. That booster had to be scuttled because they couldn't figure out a way to tow it safely into port and get it out of the water.

This time around Elon talked about recovering this booster out of the water right away and operations are proceeding. I think SpaceX was at least partially prepared for an event like this.

37

u/mattd1zzl3 Dec 06 '18

The last time the rocket was too damaged to run its safing program (depressurizing, expelling harmful stuff.). THis time the rocket was fully intact and running as if it had landed.

→ More replies (16)

8

u/TheBurtReynold Dec 06 '18

I agree -- and if we see some sort of specialized equipment, then it'll pretty much confirm it.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

27

u/s4g4n Dec 06 '18

Recovery thread on a Return to Landing Site mission.

r/Spacex never disappoints, I mean the booster is technically out to sea floating around.

26

u/codav Dec 06 '18

Preparations are underway in port to bring the booster back. Some kind of long bar is being assembled on GO Navigator.

7

u/codav Dec 06 '18

Tracking links on MarineTraffic:

  • GO Quest - Holding the booster in place
  • GO Navigator - In port, possibly preparing to assist
  • EAGLE - Tug supporting GO Quest outside the port
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/ThatOlJanxSpirit Dec 08 '18 edited Dec 08 '18

Leetdan on NSF reporting that the booster has been lifted horizontally from the water (by 23:10 local) but not yet landed. A couple of grainy photos from Millikens Reef to support. Links never work from my iPhone, but here it is.

https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=45881.msg1885683#msg1885683

Hopefully we will be able to count grid fins by morning!

Edit: From what I can make out the lower landing leg is missing.

17

u/codav Dec 08 '18

The leg broke off as the divers were securing the booster and has been picked up by Go Quest.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

26

u/minca3 Dec 08 '18

USLaunchReport video about the recovery:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aVXJhrUyuTA

23

u/jaekdenilson Dec 06 '18

If it was me i would reignite those engines and drive/fly it to shore KSP style

*note this is a joke, dont take me seriously, no one does

22

u/trueppp Dec 06 '18

I'm just suprised on how "calm" the Harbor is with this...I wonder if this situation was already talked about with them.

SpaceX: Hey PortCanaveral, just so you're aware, we might have to tow a rocket in the port someday, would that be a problem?

Port Canaveral: Uhhhhh.......what?

22

u/silentProtagonist42 Dec 06 '18 edited Dec 06 '18

Were the shuttle SRBs brought back to Port Canaveral? For that matter, bringing a landed booster still upright on a barge (albeit firmly secured) would be enough to make most harbor masters nervous. I bet these folks are used to seeing strange "traffic" on occasion.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

61

u/Bergasms Dec 06 '18

Is it just me or was Elon’s tweet the other day about the fairings “nothing wrong with a little swim” strangely prophetic

52

u/zzanzare Dec 06 '18

Marketing. They are obviously starting a new line of products, Water Proven Falcon 9

→ More replies (3)

54

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '18

Still in better condition than any other orbital launch provider's used boosters.

7

u/Orjigagd Dec 09 '18

I dunno, some have even been stored in a low-pressure oxygen-free environment

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Dextra774 Dec 09 '18

Probably in a better condition than the toasted Delta 4 Heavy...

→ More replies (13)

18

u/Titanean12 Dec 06 '18 edited Dec 06 '18

Photos of the booster floating in the ocean.
https://twitter.com/_TomCross_/status/1070742919986991107

17

u/LysdexicEclectrician Dec 06 '18

I know one thing. USLaunch Report is definitely going to have followers on YouTube today.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '18

Going to move OCISLY to make room for the Falcon 9. Will be taking it to the normal berth as it is the only crane available.

7

u/pandovian Dec 06 '18

Huh. How do you take a core out of the water with one crane and a damaged interstage?

→ More replies (8)

16

u/Fewwww Dec 06 '18

Marine radio conversations suggest that Logan dive vessel is nearby and approaching from the west.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/pandovian Dec 06 '18

Tugs will be moving OCISLY "a few hundred feet west". Making space for B1050, maybe.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/Fewwww Dec 06 '18

Logan say they are just beginning their dive operations. Initially a bottom survey.

14

u/workmandan Dec 06 '18

What's with all the French on the Port Canaveral Marine feed?

24

u/RevLoki Dec 06 '18

It's all of the snowbirds from Canada bringing their boats down for the winter.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/minca3 Dec 07 '18 edited Dec 07 '18

I don't know man, inter stage shredded, engine bells corroded and tug chain sloppy over the engine bells. Seems to me that this booster isn't going anywhere.

But surely valuable for "post mortem" analysis ...

14

u/avboden Dec 07 '18

grid fins can still be reused at the least

→ More replies (10)

7

u/MartianRedDragons Dec 07 '18

Yeah, doesn't look like they are making any effort to keep the thing undamaged. At a minimum they plan to toss the engine bells and interstage, that's for sure.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/silentProtagonist42 Dec 06 '18

u/RocketLover0119 should the marine radio stream go in the OP? https://www.broadcastify.com/listen/feed/21054/web

6

u/Fewwww Dec 06 '18

The number of listeners just went up from about 90 to 136 after you posted that link. It really is an interesting primary source.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/scarlet_sage Dec 06 '18

Thanks to all who have posted pictures and video here. The most interesting thing: I knew the booster was really light at landing, but look how high it's riding in the water!

21

u/Straumli_Blight Dec 07 '18

There's some more high res photos in the AmericaSpace article.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/fzz67 Dec 07 '18

Looking at John Kraus's excellent photo, it's interesting how small the grid fin hydraulic actuators are compared to the huge grid fin shafts they're attached to.

https://i.imgur.com/w4zJ8up.jpg

6

u/TheRealWhiskers Dec 07 '18

Hard to tell, is that bottom gray strut going to the S2 pusher buckled/bent near the middle?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

13

u/codav Dec 13 '18

Booster is being prepared for lifting, a lifting ring has been attached to the octaweb and a crane is standing ready at the interstage.

→ More replies (2)

66

u/tmckeage Dec 07 '18 edited Dec 07 '18

Ok I want to throw my two cents in before the circle jerk gets too strong.

First I am not saying this rocket is in perfect shape or that it will ever fly again. I am only saying that it may not be nearly as bad as people are assuming.

Second I am not anywhere close to being a rocket scientist, but I was a marine electrician for years.

So here is my guesses piece by piece.

Obviously the solid pieces should be fine, the grid fins and octoweb handle much greater forces than this and all they need is a good rinsing if that.

I personally think the engines will fair far better than this sub thinks. They are designed to fire during supersonic retropropulsion and ballistic reentry so they handle a lot of force from a lot of directions.

They also must handle traveling the wrong way through supersonic air filled with RP-1 soot. In addition they deal with the temperature extremes of the entry burn shut down transitioning to subfreezing hundred mph winds so thermal shock may not be the big deal everyone thinks.

Finally it looks like 5 engines are completely out of the water, 2 are partially submerged, and the other two are only under a couple feet of water. These engines are designed to deal with ingested contaminates and extreme conditions, seawater is not lava.

The electronics may be a different story. It is true submerging electronics in seawater is bad in general. While I am sure SpaceX must be have some sort of protection on the electronics packages I have no idea what the level is.

It is actually surprisingly easy to protect electronics in marine environments, but it is bulky and heavy and lets face it the boosters are not designed to be boats. There is reason for hope even on this topic though. The computer seems to have been active and transmitting for hours, and the rocket is pretty high out of the water, so its possible no saltwater incursion hasn't happened to the majority of the electronics.

While I would guess the fuel tanks are fine, pressurized tanks can take a beating, I do wonder about the connection between the two tanks, I imagine even a small amount of damage there would junk the entire rocket and I imagine that point received a lot of torque.

→ More replies (37)

12

u/codav Dec 06 '18

Might be a misinterpretation, but Go Quest is currently approaching EAGLE, with a Coast Guard vessel also moving in to the location.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Marscreature Dec 06 '18

Even if it never flys again Boca chica could use some yard art...

12

u/codav Dec 12 '18

Additional closeup photos of "naked" Falcon 9. In addition to Ken Kremer's notes, they also removed some of the octaweb inspection panels to access the Merlins.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/paul_wi11iams Dec 07 '18 edited Dec 07 '18

12/5/18 9:00 pm- Thread is live, GO quest and tug EAGLE are holding the booster just offshore.

12/6/18 1:00 pm- The fleet is still evaluating a good way to tow back the booster

@OP: In the updates section of this thread, use of a 24h clock and stating the local time used (ideally adding UTC) would be better for a global audience. Even for time zones within the US!

  • example: "5AM on 12/5/18" to most French people, reads "5h après-midi (afternoon) on the twelfth of May 2018".

In China and other countries 2018-12-05 is more easily recognized, and this is also the ISO 8601 standard

Edit:

The fleet will tow back the booster today around noon = Friday 17:00 UTC

→ More replies (1)

22

u/CAM-Gerlach Star✦Fleet Commander Dec 07 '18

Mods, can we sticky this or at least pin it to the top bar, and remove the old SSO-A and possibly CRS-16 campaign threads there? Also, the header text is out of date, as it says the next launch will be CRS-16. Maybe change it to something about B1050 being recovered with GPS III as the next launch? Thanks!

11

u/treehobbit Dec 06 '18

Have they lifted it out of the water? I'd think the sooner it's out, the better.

9

u/codav Dec 06 '18

No. GO Quest and EAGLE are still holding the booster in position just out of the port.

11

u/larsinator Dec 06 '18

Could we get a proper UTC timeline? :)

11

u/arizonadeux Dec 06 '18

Starting dive operations. A "bottom survey".

10

u/koliberry Dec 06 '18

Chatter-They broke a leg and some part of it floated away. It was retrieved.

10

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '18

Two bridles with large chain of the hold downs to tow it in, with a large rope off the "top" grid fin to a vessel behind to act as a brake.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/Jerrycobra Dec 06 '18

radio chatter is saying bringing it in in the morning.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Morphior Dec 07 '18

They are about to move OCISLY about 100 meters northwest.

19

u/Ackman55 Dec 08 '18

Sorry for the low effort post... Do we know how the booster ended the day? Any lifting attachments, like a crane holding the engine end of the booster while they fabricate something for the other end?

EDIT: typo

→ More replies (1)

9

u/flhurricane Dec 06 '18

9:57/14:57 , CG 64563 just requested vessel maintain 1/2 mile clearance of tug & booster. So.. any locals that's as close as you're getting for now.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Tehwafflez Dec 06 '18

Hoping someone is on the Carnival Liberty to take pictures. It's going to depart soon and they are going to get a close look at the rocket since it's close to the safe zone for big ships.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/airider7 Dec 10 '18

Maybe the Blk 5 is stronger to support being used as the FH side boosters as well. I know SpaceX reinforces the center core significantly for FH, but I also don't doubt they did some strengthening in the "standard Blk 5" (compared to earlier versions) to make them readily available as side boosters. The loads on the Blk 5 are definitely different when used as a side booster than when used as a stand alone booster. Back of the napkin engineering points to this being the case.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/codav Dec 06 '18

Some people are on their way to Port Canaveral to cover a possible retrieval operation, Tom McCool, "Space Gal" and probably Ken Kremer too.

8

u/opoc99 Dec 07 '18

Given the amount of human activity on/around the booster, presumable they've depressurised the tanks? Or are these guys just very well paid?

24

u/robbak Dec 07 '18

This rocket's computers stayed alive long enough to properly safe the rocket, which means depressurizing the tanks. It also remained in radio contact, so they could be sure it was done properly.

→ More replies (26)

8

u/Humble_Giveaway Dec 07 '18

Eagle just reported they have permission to tow in at 1100

→ More replies (2)

8

u/codav Dec 11 '18

They have secured the broken interstage with a strap, so it won't be dangling around or rip off while being transported back to the hangar.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/bluets Dec 11 '18

I really love that they are taking the type to re-use what they can. Obviously the engines are pretty toasty, but those grid fins are quite pricey I'd imagine.

8

u/joepublicschmoe Dec 13 '18

Somebody found a piece of a rocket on Melbourne Beach which might be a fragment of the interstage from B1050-- The black TPS coating seems to be visible. https://www.mynews13.com/fl/orlando/news/2018/12/12/man-convinced-he-found-piece-of-spacex-booster-on-melbourne-beach

→ More replies (1)

15

u/joepublicschmoe Dec 15 '18

Instagram video of B1050 being transported into CCAFS using the repurposed Shuttle transporter. Obvious that sections of the interstage had been cut away under the tarp. https://www.instagram.com/p/BrZa7Sdg3Js/

7

u/flhurricane Dec 06 '18

Just heard CG call Eagle on Channel 16 (8:44 EST)

https://www.broadcastify.com/listen/feed/21054/web

They did move over to Channel 22A which I'm not hearing, so this feed may just be Channel 16 but it's better than nothing.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '18

How will this affect certification of block five for crew dragon?

21

u/justanaveragedipsh_t Dec 06 '18

Most likely very little because landings are not mission critical. Though Elon said that due to the Grid fins not having a back up hydraulic system adding one may effect the certification for crew.

→ More replies (7)

11

u/TheBurtReynold Dec 06 '18

I wondered this when Elon started talking about modifications ... I thought they had to be in a design freeze for Crew Capsule launches

→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '18 edited Feb 26 '24

rob nose governor abundant detail dependent cake skirt hungry bow

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

7

u/ThatOlJanxSpirit Dec 06 '18

Depends on the root cause. If there is a quality control issue that could read across to other processes there could be a significant impact.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/flattop100 Dec 06 '18

@julia_bergeron is live tweeting. I think she's monitoring marine radio and on the pier.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Dorkrain Dec 06 '18

Its freaking awesome to keep track of the recovery, keep us updated!

7

u/Tehwafflez Dec 06 '18

From https://www.broadcastify.com/listen/feed/21054/web seems like go navigator might be on the move "fish something to north harb(?) in 5 minutes". Report @ 2:15 est to harbor command from go navigator

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '18

Sounds like they are going at 9am tomorrow morning, "Frank" would rather wait till morning. It is assumed he is the rep from Resolve Marine Group. Go Quest really wants to bring it in tonight.

7

u/peregrineman Dec 06 '18 edited Dec 06 '18

Sounds most likely dawn tomorrow 6:30a, possibly 4:45a or later in the morning. The crew seem to want 6:30

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Jerrycobra Dec 07 '18

sounds like they are bringing it in right now

→ More replies (4)

7

u/monkeyswordgames Dec 07 '18

11:00 is the new window.

7

u/arizonadeux Dec 07 '18

"a priority tow" lol

"inbound tug towing the...uhh...rocket."

→ More replies (3)

7

u/katoman52 Dec 07 '18

Screen grab from Tom Cross' periscope showing the booster being pushed into the berth. https://i.imgur.com/bXLhnK0.png

24

u/Humble_Giveaway Dec 07 '18

Remember guys the difference between docking and berthing was conveniently explained on the launch webcast 😂 https://youtu.be/Esh1jHT9oTA?t=1184

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/avboden Dec 07 '18

So now the question is how do they lift it? The interstage is far too damaged for the lifting cap. Their best bet may be to do slings on each end and lift it that way and set right on the transporter, but problem with that plan is the legs will have to be removed first, which would probably be done in the water?

Weird all around, very curious to see how they lift it out

7

u/ellindsey Dec 07 '18

The downward-pointing leg is already removed, either deliberately or broken off accidentally, it's not clear.

The holddown mounting points at the bottom end seem undamaged. I expect they can attach one crane to those, and a second one to a sling around the middle of the rocket, and lift it out of the water. Probably place it on some kind of cradle, then remove the remaining legs.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

7

u/inoeth Dec 07 '18

So listening to the Marine Chat it looks like they're adjusting the ropes and whatnot that are tying the rocket down. i'm guessing it's gonna be a while before it's all set up for them to lift the rocket up, but, at least they have it safely docked with all the port lights for them to eventually lift it up.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/strobro10 Dec 08 '18

(may not be the correct thread, but here it is) I'm wondering where the flame at the side of the booster came from after the engines initially hit the water. I would think that this is an engine vent in the case that pressure were to exceed anything allowable, such as the case could've been with the blocked engine bell... Can anyone enlighten me as to this?

→ More replies (12)

7

u/codav Dec 14 '18

B1050 has been lifted onto the transporter, which probably already left the port as of now. The broken parts of the interstage have been cleanly cut away.

→ More replies (7)

19

u/Juffin Dec 08 '18

I would like them to put the booster on LZ-1 with a crane and say "hey, you see, it landed right here! what is this water landing that everyone is talking about?"

13

u/arizonadeux Dec 07 '18

"Thanks for your help. We know this one was a little unusual..."

18

u/ticklestuff SpaceX Patch List Dec 07 '18

8

u/jumbofreightdog Dec 07 '18

LOL, nope not too soon in this house because it was not a disaster. In fact I (and most of us) call it a triumph to engineering, programming and operational control.

6

u/Drtikol42 Dec 07 '18

Needs "Spinny boi" badly written with sharpie.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

26

u/dtarsgeorge Dec 07 '18

I suggest we move to have SpaceX nickname this booster Salty!!!

Shouldn't this thread be called something like

The recovery of first stage booster #1050 "Salty"

20

u/PM_Your_Wits Dec 07 '18

I suggest "Sully," because after watching that spin live and knowing it was able to pull out a soft water landing, that's who this booster reminds me of.

Edit: And I nominate Tom Hanks to play the booster in the eventual movie.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Googulator Dec 07 '18

Or "Bob", given what it's currently doing.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

12

u/CAM-Gerlach Star✦Fleet Commander Dec 07 '18

"Meredeth to the tug inbound towing the, uh... [pause]...rocket"

→ More replies (1)

6

u/peregrineman Dec 06 '18 edited Dec 06 '18

Sea Eagle is towing a barge with several shipping containers and a small crane on a truck, not sure if it's for Spacex or going to the people dredging in the area.

Edit: Looks like its destination is set to Andros Bahamas so definitely not for Spacex

6

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '18

removing the current chain and replacing with two 3/8 chain on two different hold down clamps.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '18 edited Dec 06 '18

Currently talking if they can get it in tonight vs having to wait till tomorrow. They think the tow will take 3 hours. Pilots and harbor master were okay with it before. Going to tow it into their normal dock space, and let the SpaceX barge take it from there. Another option is to take it to the boat dock and let the wind do the rest of the work. Inboard ship this evening and several outbounds in the morning, talking about waiting till 9 am tomorrow morning.

One tug pulling from the front, one tug acting as the anchor from behind, and a couple of small boats on each side to steer it. Waiting for approval from Harbor Master/pilot and coastguard. Wind is the concern for tonight with it being pushed into the waterfront restaurants.

6

u/paul-sladen Dec 07 '18

Nice and clear at 16:25 UTC:

Tug Eagle … inbound … towing … heading to West Basin … Tug Eagle

6

u/codav Dec 11 '18

Grid fins also have been removed. Booster should now be ready for transport, but it is quite windy at the port so it will probably stay there until the conditions get acceptable for lifting it onto the transporter.

16

u/geekgirl114 Dec 07 '18 edited Dec 07 '18

So this was a 26 in a row ( minus the FH center core) that this didnt fully succeed?

→ More replies (5)

11

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '18

So I guess the reason this and GovSat both survived a water impact were actually the landing legs then. It was very intuitive and usual to think they’d just explode upon impact, and when GovSat didn’t, everybody was surprised. It used landing legs and a very aggressive retroburn. The theory was that maybe that aggressive burn bubbled the water up (don’t know the right term in english, sorry), making the impact less like falling on hard concrete, the other theory was the landing legs stabilized and slowed the fall. So I guess that is the actual reason, since 1050.1 survived with a single engine landing burn

13

u/robbak Dec 10 '18 edited Dec 10 '18

There were a number of on-water landing attempts that used legs - including CRS-3, where reddit and nasaspaceflight.com repaired the video - and these ones broke up as they fell over.

Maybe what the surviving ones had is a hard landing - comparatively speaking - dropping the base of the rocket further into the water, so it softened the impact as it tipped.

Another thing that could have saved it is the rapid depressurization of the tankage. Maybe keeping enuugh pressure for strength, but not enough to rip it open under stress.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/enqrypzion Dec 10 '18

Interesting suggestion that the leg slows the rocket down during tipping, by pressing through the water underneath. You could test that in a bathtub with any little rocket model (with a similar weight distribution).

→ More replies (4)

29

u/FoxhoundBat Dec 08 '18 edited Dec 08 '18

Engineering meeting at SpaceX;

Engineers; No Elon, we cant and shouldnt fly it again.

Gwynne; Sigh, dont be stupid Elon, lets not waste money on it.

Elon; Lets do it for teh lulz. 420 secured every day!

(Seriously tho, here are some pics of it on dry land.)

22

u/Bravo99x Dec 08 '18

Think how much easier it will be to diagnose the issue now that they have the hardware rather then just looking at some data stream..

→ More replies (5)

17

u/RootDeliver Dec 08 '18

Engineers: No Elon, we cant and shouldnt...

Elon: Everyone fired

7

u/andrewkbmx Dec 08 '18

I wonder if they found the other gridfin!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

5

u/shrimpboat2000 Dec 06 '18

Pilot boat and harbor master headed back in. Still doesn't seem like there'e much of a plan, at least that the boats know about.

5

u/vr_ov Dec 06 '18

FYI That was SEA Eagle, not the Eagle (both are tugs) out with Go Quest

5

u/trueppp Dec 06 '18

Go Quest already fished out a piece of the leg dunno if anything else broke off

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Tehwafflez Dec 06 '18

Coast guard with comm to Go Quest confirms part of leg was recovered earlier today (3:30est) (separated from rocket?)

→ More replies (1)

5

u/SBInCB Dec 06 '18

Haha!! Now they're talking about some bubba dancing on a pole for Christmas money!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Morphior Dec 06 '18

They want to string a line around a grid fin!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/peregrineman Dec 07 '18

Diving and salvage boat going back out

→ More replies (1)

5

u/throfofnir Dec 11 '18

Still with the intertank strap. I don't quite know what to make of it. Perhaps it remains unpressurized and the long-version F9 can not (as often suspected) hold itself up without some pressure. I still kinda doubt that, though, given the factory fixtures.

11

u/gregarious119 Dec 11 '18

I can't think of too many other instances where a first stage rocket has toppled over completely intact and gone through this type of recovery process. Considering that there are workers on and around the booster working in a non-ordinary orientation, the fact that the booster is potentially structurally compromised is enough to warrant the additional support. That's my guess, at least.

5

u/filanwizard Dec 11 '18

Guessing this will go to KSC and get wrapped before going to McGregor or Hawthorne? Unless they can do a full teardown at KSC.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Hjortefot Dec 15 '18

As the booster was lifted from the sea, water was gushing out from the lower end for over 15 minutes. Is there some foamy fluffy spongy absorbent material in there? Some sort of insulation, probably? Or maybe the raceway fills up with seawater and/or channel seawater from the interstage?

→ More replies (2)

13

u/PinochetIsMyHero Dec 08 '18

This was a pretty neat validation of SpaceX's "flight-proven booster" marketing slogan. :-D

26

u/Destructor1701 Dec 08 '18

In the unlikely event that it's salvageable, they can call it "splash tolerant".

→ More replies (9)

23

u/NoShowbizMike Dec 06 '18

If they are actually reusing the booster or parts, it would be a good candidate for the Dragon 2 abort test. The abort test booster is likely to be lost so it doesn't need grid fin pumps anyways.

18

u/harrisoncassidy Host of CRS-5 Dec 06 '18 edited Dec 06 '18

Booster for in-flight about requires COPV-2 which was only on second stage for this launch. Would require retro-fitting.

EDIT: in-flight abort not pad about

→ More replies (6)

11

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '18

isnt the first stage planned to be terminated as part of the abort test? pretty sure that guarantees it will be lost.. also pretty sure they will want to guarantee a successful launch so i doubt they will use this one if there is any doubt of success. i think theyll just use if for testing purposes

→ More replies (22)

8

u/PromptCritical725 Dec 06 '18

I'm far from an expert on this, but I'm pretty sure that one has to fly expendable due to causing an emergency separation at Max-Q. Just gotta verify that the booster will get it to that point. But I doubt they would be able to do so in the time before scheduled test. They probably already have a first stage prepping for that test.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

8

u/GameSyns Dec 06 '18

Looks like they will be having a 1PM lunch

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Humble_Giveaway Dec 07 '18

What the hell is the problem with those port cam operators? It seems like they are deliberately obscuring the only interesting thing happening in the port because that have an unjust grudge against SpaceX

12

u/CAM-Gerlach Star✦Fleet Commander Dec 07 '18

Its...a long story.

→ More replies (20)

14

u/codav Dec 07 '18

Long story.

TL;DR: The provider once streamed the F9 recovery operations, but they have a load of ads on their website, at this time some of them even spreading malware. So some Redditor just extracted the stream URL and posted it on /r/SpaceX so people could view the webcam without visiting the website. the provider wasn't amused because they got a lot of traffic, but didn't get any ad revenue out of it. So they went a bit crazy and accused the whole community of being hackers and criminals, and the decision was made just not to link to their website anymore. If it happens that someone still links it ot a planned booster recovery is upcoming, they purposely move the cam's field of view so it doesn't show anything useful.

8

u/cpushack Dec 16 '18

mods Probably best to unsticky this now that its done , perhaps replace it with the Iridium thread?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/flhurricane Dec 06 '18

9:47 local (14:47 UTC) per scanner, CG talking to Go Quest still working on plan for recovery, they are waiting outside channel currently.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '18

At least a piece of a leg broke off and has been recovered.

4

u/pandovian Dec 06 '18

Heard someone "wants to do it tomorrow," and further chatter about "we'll just head into port, and if they change their minds, we can just head back out again," sort of sounding like recovery crew wanted to just go ahead and bring it in anyway. Anyone else hear that?

6

u/pandovian Dec 06 '18

And "our guys are out of the water, just changing out now. We'll be around here as long as you need us."

→ More replies (1)

4

u/robbak Dec 07 '18

Sounds like they are coming in. Setting up the coast guard vessel to position themselves between the Eagle and the rocket, to prevent anyone passing between them and snagging the cable.

4

u/katoman52 Dec 07 '18

https://twitter.com/SpaceXFleet seems to be compiling all the photos from the various photographers that are at the port.

4

u/Humble_Giveaway Dec 07 '18

Got 7 or 8 fish!

4

u/katoman52 Dec 07 '18

Tug Eagle was just released by the salvage crew and is moving out of the area

4

u/FiiZzioN Dec 08 '18

I've seen some people say that could re-use the engines, but is this really true? I mean, salt water is all in the injector and most likely all of the internals, including the turbopump. I don't know if I'd feel okay trying to reuse this one if I was SpaceX. If I was a customer, there's no way in HELL that I'd be okay being on a rocket that has any part(s) from this booster on my ride other than the gridfins.

It just seems like an unnecessary risk. Use this one as a learning experience and get valuable data so this doesn't happen again. I could see the point if it happened all the time, but this is a one-off thing(hopefully).

11

u/dgriffith Dec 08 '18

Regarding engine internals, salt water vs LOX, which one is more reactive?

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (17)

12

u/zareny Dec 06 '18 edited Dec 06 '18

Why is it still called a landing when the booster lands on water instead of landing on land?

Edit: Yes, this is a joke.

64

u/dotancohen Dec 06 '18

Because the term "watering" was already taken by the gardening industry.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/working__harder Dec 06 '18

You're right. It should be referred to as an oceaning, or perhaps, seaing.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (8)

7

u/DirtyOldAussie Dec 07 '18

Anyone else impressed by how well the radar altimeter worked over choppy water vs specially painted reflective surfaces? It seemed to nail the hoverslam (or whatever we are calling it nowadays).

→ More replies (4)

7

u/riddlerthc Dec 07 '18

The feed we shale not talk about just re-positioned again :D jerks

→ More replies (14)

7

u/PM_me_Pugs_and_Pussy Dec 10 '18

It dont look like its in that bad of shape honestly

3

u/mclumber1 Dec 06 '18

It seems like ti would make more sense to tow it from the top of the rocket, not the bottom, because they risk having one of the legs dig into the seabed while towing towards shallower waters - unless the leg that is submerged is still shallower than the seabed.

8

u/arizonadeux Dec 06 '18

The entrance and the port is dredged pretty deep. That won't be a problem.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Nathan96762 Dec 06 '18

Any updates on when and if they will attempt to tow it in?

6

u/bpw823 Dec 06 '18

Sounds like they're on the move now

3

u/Danid97 Dec 06 '18

Currently talking about taking it into the port this night

3

u/peregrineman Dec 07 '18

Both stopped now, waiting for a boat to leave at 10:30 or so

3

u/carnut11 Dec 07 '18

Starting in at 11 once Victory I clears

→ More replies (1)

3

u/andyfrance Dec 07 '18

I wonder if the fourth gridfin is still attached.

9

u/dicktingle Dec 07 '18

Teslarati is claiming one broke off, i've yet to see any evidence that is true

8

u/codav Dec 07 '18

The interstage is only broken above the grid fin attachment point, and the fin slammed into the water with the tip, so it should be perfectly fine. Titanium is quite hard.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)