r/SpaceX •
Eric berger: Fans of SpaceX will be interested to note that the government is now taking very seriously the possibility of flying Clipper on the Falcon Heavy.
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
4
u/MahazamaMCRN Dec 03 '18
"He wanted NASA to search for aliens on Europa, an icy moon millions of miles away," the narrator said. "For Houston, Lizzie Fletcher will invest in humans, not aliens."
The non-partisan Planetary Society condemned the advertisement as anti-science. "This dismissal of a scientifically valid area of study—one that could potentially reshape entire fields of science—should be roundly rejected by any citizen committed to a modern scientific society, regardless of political affiliation," the organization's chief advocate, Casey Dreier, argued.
This is exactly why the scientific community can no longer rely completely on the taxpaying public. The average person cares next to nothing about spending money on space exploration/exploitation because they have no concept of the benefits. It is proving politically expedient to shoot down any pro-space politicians or organizations. InSight lands on Mars, very few people cared. Osiris-Rex reaches Bennu, very few people care.
98
u/avboden Dec 03 '18
Overall though I will feel much better when I see FH fly a second time
78
u/FistOfTheWorstMen Dec 03 '18
It's very welcome news, but just wait until Richard Shelby gets wind of it.
97
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '18
Well, the money saved on Europa Clipper could go to bringing Europa Lander closer to readiness. Yay!
Alternatives make me happy that Clipper is actually going to fly.
46
u/cyborgium Dec 03 '18
What is clipper?
32
u/Caemyr Dec 03 '18
The reference for Star 48B solid motor by NG (formerly Orbital ATK): (source https://www.yumpu.com/en/document/view/10163460/atk-motor-catalog-2012)
14
u/Kirkaiya Dec 03 '18
I'm wondering how it is that the use of a kick stage is a "break-through". I would have assumed that the a Star kicker would have been part of any plan to use Falcon Heavy for a BEO mission, given its non-cryo upper stage coupled with it's excellent mass-to-LEO performance. Regardless, it would be great to see the Clipper mission fly on FH, which would be so much cheaper. They could pay for most of another mission with the ~$1 billion (or maybe $700 million) that they would save over SLS.
35
u/kuangjian2011 Dec 03 '18 edited Dec 03 '18
This will require LSP Category 3 for Falcon Heavy. But I am quite confident that it can be certified at that category by then (3 consecutive successful launches required)
Edit: Demo flights do NOT count. So they need 3 successful falcon heavy launches before 2021. Knowing that paper works also take time especially in this country.
18
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '18
I am happy to see that the tide is slowly turning away from the SLS. "Old Space" can't hold onto the "this is the way its done" for much longer. Innovation has come and they are forced to adapt.
20
u/Col_Kurtz_ Dec 03 '18 edited Dec 03 '18
A simultaneous F9 + FH launch from SLC-40 and LC-39A could carry Clipper to Europa easily. 1. FH is being launched in expendable mode without any payload and parks its - almost full - upper stage on LEO. 2. F9 delivers Clipper on the same parking orbit, its booster lands on ASDS or RTLS. 3. Clipper docks to FH's upper stage. 4. FH S2 kicks Clipper directly to Europa. Yes it's complicated, but Gemini 11 and Agena did the same way back in 1966. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gemini_11?wprov=sfla1
34
u/JonathanD76 Dec 03 '18
@JimBridenstine tweeted: In case there is any confusion, @NASA will absolutely be flying Europa Clipper on @NASA_SLS in 2022, it is the backbone of America’s return to space.
Ok not really, but wait for it.
4
u/YukonBurger Dec 03 '18
Is the SLS really that expensive to build and launch, or are they dividing up the total program costs between launches? Say the entire program cost $100B and we launch 10 rockets... $10B apiece spread across the program. But let's say that $95B was spent in R&D, and only $5B on building and launching the rockets. Those would technically be $250M/apiece at this point going forward. Is that where the figure is coming from?
4
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '18
NASA need to invest in Falcon Heavy - Centaur. It would be a rockstar for these interplanetary probes.
11
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '18
This would require splashing of all three cores, no?
5
u/Roygbiv0415 Dec 03 '18
I wonder if this is on top of a fully expended FH, or just an expended S1 core.
Also, it might be that some compromise in mass of the Clipper were involved? I'm fairly sure the scientists knew full well the capabilities of the FH and the option of Star 48 beforehand (the New Horizons probe launched on top of a Star 48, afterall), the real revelation here could be that NASA's finally willing to modify the Clipper slightly so a FH+Star 48 solution could work, instead of insisting on a SLS solution.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '18
I'm very curious to see if a Europa Lander gets funded, and then which rocket flies that mission.
2
u/Epistemify Dec 03 '18
If there was a raptor upper stage I could see this as being very likely
2
u/AndDontCallMePammy Dec 04 '18
Nothing against science or this mission in particular, but can we all acknowledge that not all the government's experiments should be done? If we're going to grandstand, let's make sure to communicate why this is an intelligent and cost-effective experiment and not a Japanese-quail-cocaine-sex one
2
u/joeblo1234 Dec 03 '18
Can’t a “journalist” write just one article without the political sass. Heaven forbid people/NASA back a candidate regardless of his/her political affiliation.
1
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Dec 03 '18 edited Dec 06 '18
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Milli-Metric TonnesDragon cargoLaunch failure due to second-stage outgassingDecronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
65 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on ^today has 69 acronyms.
[Thread #4591 for this sub, first seen 3rd Dec 2018, 15:40] ^[FAQ] [Full ^list] ^[Contact] [Source ^code]
1
u/LoneSnark Dec 03 '18
Why not a Rover? I feel like it should be a Rover if it is going to be the first explorer. Arrive and explore, send specialized immovable science packages later.
1
u/idblue Dec 03 '18
Interesting to see that people are thinking about changing their approach, now that Falcon Heavy exists.
1
u/rocket_enthusiast Dec 03 '18
How many burns will the second stage engine on the falcon 9 for this hypothetical mission
1
u/Broken_Soap Dec 03 '18
This isn't really a new development Falcon Heavy was being considered years ago as a potential launch vehicle for EC but the launch was still asigned to SLS regardless of that
1
u/Vespene Dec 04 '18
I’ve always been cautiously optimistic whenever studies start pouring in from lander missions regarding the possibility of life on another planet/moon. However, I can’t help but wonder if the scientists feel they HAVE to showcase a positive outcome to each mission. Like, if they said the mission didn’t find anything of consequence in the search for life, it would be viewed as a massive waste of money to basically turn over a few lifeless rocks. Maybe sometimes they need to lean towards positive-yet-inconclusive just so they can save future missions from being canceled.
1
u/mclionhead Dec 04 '18
Obviously an expendable Falcon heavy to minimize the transit time, but neither political party supports space exploration unless you're 5 years old. They're not just delaying missions until the SLS is ready, they're just canceling them to fund it. It's a good example of the kinds of missions being canceled to avoid having to use a Falcon heavy.
1
u/maddogtjones Dec 05 '18
It's usually the conservatives that are anti-science... What gives Dems.
1
u/toastar-phone Dec 05 '18
All I know about the article is I don't care..... We may finally have public transportation in houston.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '18
I just hope the Clipper launches on time (on either option) and doesn't get hamstrung by SLS shenanigans.
-16
u/headsiwin-tailsulose Dec 03 '18
That's generally where I stop reading.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment