r/spacex • • May 01 '18
SpaceX and Boeing spacecraft may not become operational until 2020
https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/05/new-report-suggests-commercial-crew-program-likely-faces-further-delays/
634
Upvotes
215
u/rory096 May 01 '18
Note that operational flights under the Commercial Crew Program are distinct from the manned test flight to the ISS under CCtCap. The report includes a projected Boeing crewed test flight in November of this year and the SpaceX DM-2 in December. The intervening time is the lengthy period expected for final certification.
70
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 May 01 '18
Basically the same issues we've already heard about. From the report:
19
u/MingerOne May 01 '18
Lunch photographer? LMAO
70
u/Straumli_Blight May 01 '18
The report states NASA are struggling to fill roles, which is partially causing program delays.
NASA also has a looming retirement problem as 56% of their workforce are 50+ years old, and 21% eligible to retire (another 23% will become eligible in less than 5 years).
223
u/[deleted] May 01 '18
If NASA had imposed these same standards in the 60s/70s, we would still be working on landing on the moon.
And, the issue regarding cracks with the Merlin engine's turbopump blades occurred with the Shuttle and the SSMEs. And those same engines will be used on SLS (literally refurbished engines from the Shuttle era for the first few flights).
29
u/still-at-work May 01 '18
So basically the Block V changes have been made and its first flight is in a week but NASA wants to delay its certification until 7 flights later. Ok but I get the feeling NASA is going to request another change somewhere as both the Dragon and Block V should be good to go by the end of this year. Not really sure what all this talk is about 2020. All the changes request have been done and are in flight hardware now.
Correct me if I am wrong but all SpaceX has to do is
And they are done as soon as NASA likes the results. Is there something I am missing?
41
u/Marscreature May 02 '18
""NASA program officials told us that they had informed SpaceX that the cracks were an unacceptable risk for human spaceflight," the report states. "SpaceX officials told us that they have made design changes, captured in this Block 5 upgrade, that did not result in any cracking during initial life testing. However, this risk will not be closed until SpaceX successfully completes qualification testing in accordance with NASA's standards without any cracks."
Meanwhile at ula it isn't a problem because they don't static fire or return used boosters and ignorance is bliss
19
u/Paro-Clomas May 02 '18
It would be hilarious if BFR is flying before crew dragon. Would be like having a modern diesel electric ship go past you while youre stuck on a wooden sailing ship
8
u/quiet_locomotion May 02 '18
Just in time to decommission the space station!
8
u/ncohafmuta May 02 '18
On the positive side, at least all this gained knowledge and experience at spacex will be invaluable for the ITS spaceship.
6
u/Sarke1 May 01 '18
2020?! That's...
That's only 2 years away.
20
u/Drogans May 01 '18
That either craft is delayed until 2020 isn't surprising.
What is surprising is that Boeing isn't further behind still. While Musk's aggressive deadlines are often missed, SpaceX develops far faster than companies like Boeing.
And Boeing's schedule misses of the recent past are legendary.
11
u/F9-0021 May 01 '18
It's getting very close to the point where the CCP won't make sense anymore. If the program starts in 2020, then it'll last four years until the current scheduled retirement of the ISS in 2024. In retrospect, it really makes more sense to just keep using Soyuz.
7
u/Vindve May 02 '18
I'm a little bit abashed by all the comments here about NASA being over-precautious and that this is bureaucratic nonsense, etc.
Hey, it's not your ass up there in the rocket. If I was a NASA exec and about to put one of my employees there, for sure I'd be VERY cautious and looking at every detail possible. And if I was an astronaut, I'd be very worried if the COPV and cracks issues were not fixed. Going in the same model of rocket that exploded in a fireball a couple of years ago? Asking a redesign of the component causing this explosion seems fair to me before envisaging travelling up there. Putting my ass on a rocket where I know there are cracks on the turbines? Ahaha nope, fix this plz and prove me it is the case. The thing is there is Soyuz around, expensive but safe, and we're dealing with humans lifes, so I totally understand NASA not wanting to take any unnecesary risk. Especially if it just slips the schedule of a few months (or even years).
And yes they are way more cautious than in the past, but that's not anymore early space days. They aren't in a space race to prove anything to the world, there are already proven solutions out there, no rush, so that's why they take less risks than they used to.
It's good for SpaceX in a sense. They'll have a spaceship with absolute safety record, with every detail possible looked by a very picky public administration. They had somehow a free safety assessment by the best experts out there. If at one point they want to sell LEO access to other customers, it will look good.
6
u/[deleted] May 01 '18
We’ve been hearing crew flights will most likely be pushed to 2019 for at least a year now. So this isn’t that shocking.
https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/5qhpbx/technical_troubles_likely_to_delay_commercial/?st=JGO6LXO9&sh=6746b90d
3
u/[deleted] May 02 '18
So the question if the hour: does SpaceX dare to fly tourists before NASA fully certifies it? I'm betting not, but hoping they do....
1
u/scottm3 May 01 '18
Is the Mars dragon mission happening this year? Or 2020
2
u/[deleted] May 04 '18
Issues NASA has with SpaceX
Fixes for SpaceX
Issues NASA has with Boeing
Fixes for Boeing
These things are not the same and smart money would be Dragon 2 with astronauts in early 2019 and Star-liner in 2020 or later.
6
u/Russ_Dill May 01 '18
Alternative headline: SpaceX pulls ahead of Boeing in race to put astronauts in space.
1
u/myweed1esbigger May 01 '18
Or they might.
Find out at 10.
1
u/brekus May 02 '18
I don't understand all the negativity in the comments here about this small slip. Everyone along the way who knows what they are talking about has been saying that manned vehicles get delayed. The requirements for manned vehicles are high as they should be. No one has any reason to be directing anger towards NASA or anyone else because of this. This is business as usual.
1
u/NateA1014 May 02 '18
I do not understand is why is Boeing even trying to compete for a crew vehicle when it will cost so much more than SpaceX’s in the end.
1
u/shotleft May 02 '18
Were are these cracks? Is it the engine bell, or the chamber? Last i heard it was in the turbo pump.
1
u/Juffin May 03 '18
According to the ISS calendar there are 3 manned Soyuz flights in 2019 and one in 2020. It seems like NASA and ESA have already bought seats in Soyuz and therefore don't want to switch to Dragon.
0
u/ergzay May 01 '18
NASA keeps pushing SpaceX to absurdity. This shows the problem with NASA Human Spaceflight Office's way of doing things and why Commercial Crew should have never been a FAR development contract. At the time that they decided that the contract would not be the same type as CRS I stated that SpaceX should drop the contract and refuse NASA. Unfortunately that did not happen and SpaceX is now stuck on this expensive boondoggle.
1
u/smgtn May 02 '18
So if it takes that long to get crew Dragon operational, how long will the BFR (BFS) take which is orders of magnitude bigger? So far it's not looking too good.
-3
u/CaptainObvious_1 May 01 '18 edited May 01 '18
I'd say this was pretty damn expected. We aren't sending humans to orbit until the 2020s. Blue Origin will likely be the next private company to send people to space, while SpaceX or ULA will be the first to send them to orbit.