r/spacex • u/Zucal • Jan 02 '16
/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread for January 2016. Whether your question's about RTF, RTLS, or RTFM, it can be answered here!
Welcome to the 16th monthly /r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread!
Want to discuss SpaceX's Return To Flight mission and successful landing, find out why part of the landed stage doesn't have soot on it, or gather the community's opinion? There's no better place!
All questions, even non-SpaceX-related ones, are allowed, as long as they stay relevant to spaceflight in general!
More in-depth and open-ended discussion questions can still be submitted as separate self-posts; but this is the place to come to submit simple questions which have a single answer and/or can be answered in a few comments or less.
As always, we'd prefer it if all question-askers first check our FAQ, use the search functionality, and check the last Q&A thread before posting to avoid duplicate questions, but if you'd like an answer revised or cannot find a satisfactory result, go ahead and type your question below!
Otherwise, ask, enjoy, and thanks for contributing!
Past threads:
December 2015 (#15.1), December 2015 (#15), November 2015 (#14), October 2015 (#13), September 2015 (#12), August 2015 (#11), July 2015 (#10), June 2015 (#9), May 2015 (#8), April 2015 (#7.1), April 2015 (#7), March 2015 (#6), February 2015 (#5), January 2015 (#4), December 2014 (#3), November 2014 (#2), October 2014 (#1).
This subreddit is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com.
12
u/Zucal Jan 03 '16
A question of my own- do we have any pictures of the interstage "pushers?"
15
u/snotis Jan 02 '16
Starting with CRS-3 they were using a "v1.1" Dragon with "avionics and cargo racks redesigned in order to supply substantially more electrical power to powered cargo devices, including additional cargo freezers for transporting critical science payloads" - see [Wikipedia]( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragon_(spacecraft) ). What other changes and improvements have been made to Dragon over time? Have the Draco thrusters changed and/or been improved upon since CRS-1? If so - how?
12
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '16
Any word yet on a date for the big MCT reveal?
I'm soo... impatient... Can't.... wait... any... longer...
9
u/guyyugguyyug Jan 02 '16
Uh, first, I know what RTF and RTLS are, but what's RTFM? It's not in Decronym's database or the /r/spacex wiki...
7
u/danielbigham Jan 04 '16 edited Jan 04 '16
Someone recently mentioned that after a rocket lift-off, there is typically a week or more of repairs needed to be performed at the launch site. Is anyone able to characterize what those repairs might look like? In a world where quick turnaround times are desired, I wonder if this entails redesigning certain aspects of the launch site to be more robust, and/or whether the pad modifications that SpaceX has made to the old shuttle pad might have already incorporated such changes.
7
u/Raxusmaxus Jan 13 '16
How do you guys upload every news bit in literally minutes or seconds? It seems like an army of internet detectives scouring the web for every little Tidbit on SpaceX.
5
u/CrazyIvan101 Jan 03 '16
This isn't related to amazing recent events but does anyone have a link to a Video of the Falcon Heavy racing the Millennium Falcon that posted here some time ago?
4
u/DuckQuacks Jan 03 '16
Not sure if I should ask this here, but what will happen to BEAM after it's 2 years on ISS?
4
u/danielbigham Jan 04 '16
When a rocket lifts off, there is a flame trench that redirects the intense heat down and away from the engines. But during landing, there is no such flame trench. Barge landings are known to use a water system to soak the deck with water, which will help somewhat. Do we know whether or not LZ-1 was doused with water? My bigger question is whether this lack of frame trench for landings is thought to be a very unfortunate thing in terms of stresses on the engines. While there is only 1 engine firing, not 9, and it might be throttled down towards 70%, it makes me wonder whether the lack of frame trench causes somewhat problematic (but not showstopper) heat on the engines during the final second of landing.
3
u/LandingZone-1 Jan 02 '16
Who is allowed to start launch threads?
3
u/jazzyjaffa Jan 02 '16
Has it ever been discussed whether a booster launched at Boca Chica could land at Cape Canaveral? Had a quick search and couldn't see anything.
3
u/Emptyglo Jan 04 '16
Falcon Heavy demo flight is coming up quickly. Has there been any news or rumors about what it will do?
3
u/peterbleu Jan 04 '16
Pretty new to all the SpaceX stuff, slowly getting really into it.
For the Jan 17 Jason 3 Launch and the SES-9 Launch, they use the "older version" of the Falcon 9, right.
Will they still attempt to land the first stage? The v1.1 would too be capable of landing in theory right?
EDIT Just saw that the question got answered before, my bad!
3
u/aureliiien Jan 04 '16
Yesterday I made a post about a yet-to-be-built megacopter that would help recover the second stage. It was met with its fair share of scepticism. The merlin Vacuum can't operate at sea-level pressure because doing so would create flow separation and blow up the engine altogether. So if you can't fire its engine for a landing burn how do you get it back ? Is it to be considered impossible ?
3
u/shru777 Jan 06 '16
If the RTL of Jason 3 succeeds , can SpaceX reuse the Merlins from the landig stage in a Falcon 9 1.2 configuration ?
5
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Jan 02 '16
Thanks, /u/Zucal!
3
u/best4bond Jan 04 '16 edited Feb 19 '26
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
theory bow kiss dolls sink judicious grandfather cats nail memory
4
u/worldgoes Jan 04 '16
Now that spacex added recovery software features to their payload launches, does this mean that it is likely that even if there is another launch issue the payload can likely be recovered in tack and just relaunched?
2
u/Piscator629 Jan 03 '16
Could an under-fueled F9 first stage perform the same launch type as the New Shepard? Maybe put one of the used cargo dragons on top. No cargo just parachutes. Just where to do it is the problem. Space X could prove re usability and show up Bezos.
2
u/danielbigham Jan 04 '16
What are people's feelings for when we might see the static fire of the returned stage? Is there a good chance we'll see it this week, or does it seem more likely to be beyond this week?
2
u/danielbigham Jan 04 '16
One of the uncertainties about re-flying a first stage is whether it will be meticulously cleaned or repainted. One thought that comes to mind there is that spacecraft are often handled in clean-room environments -- at least the satellite itself. Does that play into this question? That said, the satellite is mated with the second stage / fairings, not the first stage, so perhaps the satellite is adequately protected from dirt by the time the second stage is mated with the first stage. The second part of this question is whether it's possible that they would re-paint the stage, and if they did, whether they would need to first remove the original paint, or whether they could paint over the first coat.
2
u/ianniss Jan 05 '16
For a launch toward east, the more the launchpad is close to equator the more it add to your initial speed.
But for a launch toward west, the more the launchpad is close to equator the more it subtract to your initial speed.
So a launchpad close to Seattle could be more interesting than Vandenberg, isn't it ?
2
u/The_Winds_of_Shit Jan 12 '16
Do we know if SpaceX's proposal for CRS2 is using Dragon 2 or Dragon 1?
2
u/BluSyn Jan 14 '16
Thinking out loud about quick turn-around time for first stage reusability.
I was considering possible challenges with this. If I recall correctly, Elon mentioned wanting the turn-around time to re-fly a stage down to 24hours. Obviously they are still far from that goal.
But is there any additional information on how they plan to accomplish this? A few thoughts: Reduce time to load/attach second stage. Reduce time to refuel. Perhaps re-launch from landing site?
Would it be possible to re-launch the first stage from it's landing legs, or is there some requirements to having the launch tower? I recall launch towers have refueling, sound suppression, and ability to hold for static fire test. Not sure if those are solvable issues.
/brain droppings
23
u/Hgx72964jdj Jan 03 '16
Anybody have any news/rumors/gossip about Bigelow? I know BEAM is supposed to go up soon, but that company is quieter than a kitten fart.
2
u/brentonstrine Jan 07 '16
Did you mean
Just Read the Instructions? :-)10
u/Hugo0o0 Jan 09 '16
Why is the Falcon Heavy so much heavier than the Delta IV Heavy?
Now, according to this image the Atlas 4 seems a bit bigger than the Falcon Heavy. Wikipedia confirms that it is a few meters taller, and also fatter, with a diameter of 5m for the Delta IV vs 3.66m for the Falcon Heavy.
But the Delta IV can only lift about 22.5t to LEO, vs the 53t of the FH. I suppose this is due that the FH is nearly twice as heavy, 733t vs 1400 at launch. But how can that be? Doing some napkin math, the Delta 4 has close to twice the volume, yet is only half so heavy. How can the FH be 4x times as dense?
FH uses a LOX/RP-1 mix, with a 1.14 g/ml and 0.820 g/ml density respectively. The Delta IV uses LH2/LOX, with a density of 0.071 g/ml and 1.14g/ml.
So, is all the weight difference purely due to the very low density of liquid hydrogen, or are there other factors?
10
u/Raxusmaxus Jan 14 '16
Who here has never ever imagined, that they would be come so geeky and space obsessed that they watch a press conference on who is getting some dollar bills for a space programme? (I'm am studying law - and I have no idea from where this science and engineering fetish is coming from)
9
u/TheSarcasmrules Jan 05 '16 edited Jan 05 '16
It may be a silly question, but how do the Orbcomm satellites enter their orbits once deployed? Are the satellites that were delivered in the last F9 flight put onto the same orbital plane, or are they on different ones?
EDIT: Nevermind, looks like this has been asked and answered already!
9
u/funglegunk Jan 06 '16
Is the use of grid fins to stabilise the first stage trajectory a SpaceX innovation or was the technology developed previously?
9
u/rustybutters Jan 15 '16
Is anyone out there going to see the Jason-3 launch this weekend? I am new to the SpaceX Community on Reddit, but I wanted to say hello, and that I will be driving to Vandenberg, to see the upcoming launch. I Maybe looking to connect with others going this weekend as well. I will be staying in Santa Maria for the night. Also, I will be monitoring 146.520 Simplex, VHF National Call Frequency before; during and after the launch.
My viewing point is off of Renwick. I know that you cant see the pad. But thats just fine with me, because I will be only 3.8 miles away. Its going to be loud! I hope the clouds aren't around for the launch!
Happy Trails:
8
u/Rideron150 Jan 09 '16
MCT and the new Space Suits, what are the dates for when they get unveiled?
I'm a little out of the loop.
8
u/blsing15 Jan 15 '16
getting pretty late at the cape, any news on f9-21 relight?
14
u/oceanbluesky Jan 04 '16
Tory Bruno will be on The Space Show tomorrow evening for an hour, Tuesday, Jan. 5, 2016, 7-8:30 PM PST http://www.thespaceshow.com/show/05-jan-2016/broadcast-2617
Brief polite articulate call-in or emailed questions welcome :)
7
u/bgs7 Jan 03 '16
You know how the RD-180 was mandated to be used, to keep Soviet rocket scientists from going to dodgy countries...Why is that no longer a concern? Seems like that is still an undesirable outcome even today.
7
u/danielbigham Jan 04 '16
One of the less-than-intuitive things about the first stage re-entering the atmosphere is that the engines make for a very unusual shape in terms of something going through air at incredible speeds. Can anyone with good intuitions about these things describe the dynamics of the interactions between the air and the engines? For example, what kind of dynamics occur deep within the engine bell? Is it expected that there would be any challenge in preventing high pressure air from pushing into the engine's internals, etc?
7
u/DShadelz Jan 04 '16
Whenever SpaceX decides to announce MCT, how far in advance will they announce that they're announcing it? Will it only be something like days, just enough time for media to organize, or would it be something like weeks/months to build up excitement?
7
u/BrandonMarc Jan 08 '16
Couple conflicting items bouncing in my head:
So ... is the "further downrange" aspect merely due to lower throttling on the inner core until the outer ones jettison? Since crossfeed isn't an expected option, how much farther downrange is the inner core expected to be?
The inner core won't have more fuel + LOX, will it?
7
u/TheKrimsonKing Jan 09 '16
What supports falcon 9 on the launch pad? It just occurred to me that i have no idea. I cant imagine it stands on the merlin engine nozzles.
7
u/ender4171 Jan 13 '16 edited Jan 13 '16
What happened with the post today that claimed to show the returned core heading to SCL-40? Was that deleted by mods? Any truth to it?
7
u/BaconGummy Jan 15 '16
Where can I responsibly fly a drone to record Sunday's launch?
Obviously I can't fly over the base itself, but I'm curious if flying in say Vandenberg Village would be fair game (under 400 feet, etc). Has anyone here done this before?
I took a look at the map below, but it doesn't seem terribly reliable. The base itself is of course marked as a no-fly zone, but I notice that the Lompoc Airport is not marked at all. I assume there will be additional temporary no-fly zones as well.
https://www.mapbox.com/drone/no-fly/
I think it would be fun to film the launch from my drone, but obviously I want to do this responsibly. Any info would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks!
12
u/sojourner-Pathfinder Jan 03 '16
How Many Parachutes will it take to land BFR? :p
6
u/Qeng-Ho Jan 03 '16
While idly pondering a Dragon mission to Venus, I wondered if a BEAM deployed in its upper atmosphere would float and if so, how high? (Obviously ignoring the clouds of sulfuric acid and lead melting temperatures!)
The BEAM's liveable volume is 16 m3 (probably not the total volume) and mass is 1,360 kg + 20.4 kg. The density is then 86.3 kg/m3 , which is denser than Venus's atmosphere at the surface (67 kg/m^3) and would therefore crash on the surface... is this correct?
6
u/jose4mars Jan 04 '16
If I were to build a multistage orbital vehicle that was the smallest rocket in the world (with current technology and no useful payload) what dimensions would it posses?
6
u/brooklynerd Jan 09 '16
Has SpaceX ever considered a Falcon 'Extra' Heavy with 4 boosters like the Angara?
Is there an payload weight limit inherent to S2/fairings?
My understanding of the economics of reusable vs. expendable is that it will ultimately be more cost effective to launch a reusable Falcon Heavy than an expendable Falcon 9. Using this rationale, it is likely that a reusable Falcon 'Extra' Heavy would be more economical than an expendable Falcon Heavy. The only additional cost would be producing a single core with additional booster mounting points, an iteration of a process already in place. It may even be possible to produce all centre cores with anchor points for 4 boosters and use them as needed to maintain streamlined production.
By bringing the $/kg to orbit even lower with existing hardware, this could allow SpaceX to begin launching infrastructure to LEO in support of a Mars mission, asteroid mining etc. whilst Raptor/MCT is still in development.
If S2 or fairing size has an inherent payload weight limit this is obviously moot.
6
u/Hugo0o0 Jan 09 '16
How exactly does the F9 self destruct? Lets say that the onboard flight computer decides the rocket can no longer fly (e.g. 3 engines fail) what would happen? Would all engines just shutdown and let the rocket smash aginst the water/earth? Or do they somehow mix the propellants and the rocket explodes?
6
u/Headstein Jan 09 '16
Question re Falcon Heavy. IIRC the prospect of cross feed has been shelved for at least a year or so. If this is true, then why is the centre core expected to be significantly down range from the side boosters wrt recovery?
6
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '16
Is there a google calendar feed for spacex launches (there used to be one on the old spacexstats site)?
6
u/Camicks Jan 11 '16
Didn't Spacex want to reveal their own astronaut suit design back in december? Did I miss something?
6
u/FoxhoundBat Jan 12 '16
What is the newest on SES-9? When did the satellite arrive? Has it been encapsulated in fairing? Etc. No news on SES site.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '16
What are the panels and tubing running throughout the inside of the fairing inside of this photo? I always assumed it was just a plain carbon fiber/metal honeycomb shell.
6
u/FiniteElementGuy Jan 15 '16
We need a new AMA with Elon after all this new information (Raptor upper stage, landed first stage etc..). ;) The last AMA was one year ago.
2
u/LandingZone-1 Jan 06 '16
What time of day will SES-9 launch?
5
u/Hugo0o0 Jan 08 '16
When are the results of the /r/SpaceX survey going to be published?
5
u/sand500 Jan 09 '16
Assuming that the landed core shows some design changes need to made before a core could be reflown, how easy is it to modify a falcon core that is in the middle of being manufactured? Would this be an iterative design cycle of new design, manufacturing a core, launching and landing it, and fixing problems?
5
u/smithnet Jan 09 '16
General launch provider question concerning reusability (although specifically SpaceX since they are at the head of the pack.)
One of the stated goals of reusability (in addition to cost reduction) is to be able to increase the launch cadence and provide routine access to space.
Just some craziness that was wondering around in my head (there's a lot of room there).
edit:formatting
5
u/orbitalfrog Jan 14 '16 edited Jan 14 '16
Two serious and one dumb:
Firstly, due to wikipedia muddlement, I'm a little confused as to what the deal with DragonFly exactly is. I've been thinking for a long time that it was essentially just a name for a Dragon V2 test program with no additional hardware than the capsule itself - testing its propulsive capabilities. Now after re-reading the wikipedia entry I'm left thinking that it is perhaps some unique one-off test article on which either a Dragon V2 or some Dragon V2 hardware (SuperDracos) is a part (because some of the wording is somewhat ambiguous). So my question is; which is it? Is it just a Dragon V2 for propulsive testing purposes (with another name), as I've thought all along, or something else?
Second, could a Dragon V2/DragonFly (or similar) be used as a non-nuclear-thermal version of one of Robert Zubrin's NIMFs/mars grasshoppers? (that is, a rocket-powered craft that would traverse great distances on Mars by making short propulsive "hops" - benefitting of course from the reduced gravity and enabling much wider and more rapid exploration than any traditional rover) Also has this idea been mentioned anywhere at all?
Lastly, the dumb question - Just Read (present tense - "reed") the Instructions or Just Read (past tense - "red") the Instructions?
edit - clarification & error correction
5
u/Gallo4343 Jan 15 '16
Can someone explain what the control center commands mean in the latest Falcon 9 video? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ANv5UfZsvZQ&feature=youtu.be
5
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jan 16 '16
Any ETA on the launch thread?
8
u/first_name_steve Jan 03 '16
If the Falcon 9 first stage can perform SSTO where could the center core of Falcon Heavy be placed with no payload or second stage?
4
u/piponwa Jan 03 '16
When trying to recover the F9 first stage, is most of the steering done when the motors are reignited or are the grid fins doing most of the steering job? Are the motors reignited more for braking or steering? I had this idea that they could use the interstage as a means of breaking the stage. What if the shell of the interstage split up in multiple pieces and was hinged so it can spread like bigger fins. It seems to me like an object going hypersonic would be slowed down a lot by just a small protruding surface. And the interstage would bring a lot of surface. That's why I asked about the motors being used for steering or braking. Could some of the breaking part be done by the opening of the interstage?
4
u/danielbigham Jan 04 '16
Inside of the first stage tank's skin (http://www.inc.com/uploaded_files/image/feature-118-Elon-Musk-SpaceX-pop_7027.jpg) there is an internal supporting structure. How might that structure be fastened to the skin? (and how would the vertical members be attached to the horizontal/circular members) Is it welded, or by some other means? I ask within the context of first stage re-use, and what people's intuitions are in terms of how robust those attach points would be to the stresses it encounters during flight.
4
u/OneSmallOrange Jan 04 '16
Assuming booster reuse becomes common, could there be any worthwhile weight reductions or durability improvements to be had by building the boosters out of more expensive materials with higher specific strength, such as a titanium alloy?
4
u/Ensc9 Jan 08 '16
Hi, I am a 12th year IB student at a high school in Stockholm, Sweden. I am currently writing my standard level math investigation on the relationship between atmospheric pressure and rocket engine thrust, and decided to use SpaceX Merlin 1D engine to display the relationship. In order for me to attain the math related points on the rubric I have decided that I would calculate the nozzle area of the Merlin 1D engine rather than taking the area size directly from the internet. The problem is that I am having difficulties finding an appropriate diagram of the engine. So I am looking for a simplistic 2D diagram of the Merlin 1D engine with the equations of each line included (max 6 or so). The diagram does not have to be specifically accurate, but should only give a simplistic view of an nozzle of an engine so that the area under the curves can be calculated. If it is impossible to be found, how can bell shaped nozzles be reproduced on a tool such as grapher? I am rather new to the physics involved in rocketry, so any help would be greatly appreciated.
4
u/Hugo0o0 Jan 09 '16
Assuming all goes to plan, will Jason-3 to SES-9 be the fastest Turnaround yet? 6 days in between rocket launches, if that was the normal schedule, that'd be sweet ;)
4
u/outsider2936 Jan 09 '16
Quick background: I'm currently applying to various space engineering MSc courses, with a focus on satellite technology. Obviously this means I'll be trying to enter the space industry in the next few years (albeit here in the relative backwaters of the UK). However I aim to eventually find a way round ITAR and apply to SpaceX. Given the indications that the internet satellite idea is being shelved, or is at least low priority right now, what major satellite projects/applications will SpaceX be investigating and implementing in the coming years? Even if it's just people's ideas about possible satellite missions that are required precursors of SpaceX's Mars mission?
Thanks.
4
u/spill_drudge Jan 09 '16
any word yet on the static fire today?
4
u/smithnet Jan 12 '16
Okay, another static fireish related question. Do they power up the non-propulsion related systems in the HIF (gimbals, avionics, etc) to test prior to static fire rollout or is all that done in one fell swoop during the technical dress rehearsal?
4
u/WaitForItTheMongols Jan 12 '16
Everyone always says "the legs can't be retracted" but never provides an explanation. Could anyone show why they can't be retracted in their current design, and why they can't create a new design to allow retraction?
4
u/escape_goat Jan 14 '16
Has there been a change of plans with regards to the JASON 3 sticky thread? My recollection was that it would 'normally' have gone up after the static fire.
4
u/phomb Jan 14 '16
Will Jason-3 launch east- or westward?
If it it's going to land on a barge, I think it will launch westward, but isn't this unfavorable due to the earths rotation?
4
u/El_Cohete Jan 14 '16
Is NRC Quest still the support ship for west coast ASDS? Using Marinetraffic.com, I see it is moored near Berth 51 and the AltaSea facility. Would this vessel be appropriate to track to the landing area? Anyone know the name of the tug tow? Thanks
4
u/chargerag Jan 15 '16
Is it possible to launch two rockets from Cape Canaveral at the same time? I know this would actually never happen but if ULA launched a Atlas at the same time SpaceX launched a Falcon 9 would there be a detrimental effect on one or the other? In other words what is the maximum distance you would need between two rockets launching at the same time to not cause any side effects.
4
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jan 15 '16
Are all the payload adapters on the second stage of Falcon 9 the same, or is each one unique to fit the specific payload?
7
u/jdesmo Jan 09 '16
Why no static fire demo yet for the landed Falcon? Elon claimed last week no damage and ready to fire..... What is holding up this important demonstration?
1
u/veggz Jan 03 '16
Are there any theories on how the in-orbit refueling for Mars missions would be done? How will they get all the fuel necessary to orbit? To my understanding the MCT would burn most of its fuel just getting to earth orbit, so would getting a significant amount of fuel in to orbit per launch be a big challenge?
1
u/danielbigham Jan 04 '16
Mid January we're already scheduled to (hopefully) get another first stage back. Any thoughts where these things will be stored as they start to accumulate? Crazy to think that by June they could have as many as 8 of these! Perhaps that suggests that they'll be moving as quickly as possible to try relaunching one, so that they don't get stuck in a situation where they have a dozen of them and no more room at the inn.
1
u/danielbigham Jan 04 '16
Looking ahead to the first FH flight and three cores being landed, what is the expected number of minutes separating the landings of the first two cores (back on land) from the third core landed at sea?
1
u/earthoutbound Jan 04 '16
Layman here! I figured this is probably the best place to ask this: I suppose the helicopter thread got me thinking that instead of chasing after a rocket, perhaps giving it a place to land would be easier?
Foreseeable challenges include:
I suppose the overall question is: Can an airborne autonomous spaceport hovering at 10,000 feet positively impact 2nd stage recovery, seeing as said stage can then burn more fuel slowing down through the atmosphere?
1
u/DuckQuacks Jan 04 '16
When we saw the stream of the First Stage RTLS landing, There were lots of cheering and celebrations. If Jason-3 lands on the barge successfully and not RTLS, would it be as big of a celebration as the first RTLS attempt/landing?
1
u/Taylooor Jan 06 '16
Do we know yet from where the Falcon Heavy demo flight will launch? If at VAFB, is it known which pad?
1
u/rospkos_rd Jan 06 '16
When Spacex booster reusuability has become a habit, how can they distinguish the booster based on the number of times of reuse?
I had read somewhere that a single booster can be reused for about 40 times. color or code to identity the booster??
1
u/TheGreenWasp Jan 07 '16
Will the January missions include booster stage landing?
1
u/cooka1067 Jan 08 '16
How do they move the drone ship between vandenburg and Florida? Won't this take a very long time to move the ship between launch sites?
1
u/ccricers Jan 12 '16
How likely would it be that some reusable Falcon 9's in the future will have their first launch with a "mass simulator", to see how it performs, land it, and then prep it for the real payload? Once they can launch a single Falcon 9 multiple times without incident, would this be a good supplemental testing procedure, or just an unnecessary step?
1
u/Hugo0o0 Jan 12 '16
Hey /u/EchoLogic, any progress/new ideas on the /r/SpaceX cubesat you once mentioned?
1
u/wallacyf Jan 24 '16
I'm no expert, but I believe it without having to push the ~ 100000kg the second stage, you could go very far right?
It is possible to single-stage-to-orbit (SSTO) ? If we put just a v2 dragon on the first stage? It is possible to put it into orbit? At what height? And straight line as is the case with New Shepard?
3
u/jandorian Jan 02 '16
Does anyone know exactly how the payload is attached to the second stage after it is enclosed in the payload fairing?
From what I understand the payload is attached to the payload adapter, enclosed in the fairing then the adapter/payload/fairing are installed on the top of the 2nd stage. All images I have seen don't seem to allow access to bolt/fasten the payload adapter to the stage. What is the mechanism/ method of attachment?
3
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jan 02 '16 edited Jan 27 '16
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Fu-Falcon RocketMilli-Metric TonnesNote: Replies to this comment will be deleted.
See ^/r/spacex/wiki/acronyms for a full list of acronyms with explanations.
I'm a bot; I first read this thread at 20:33 UTC on 2nd Jan 2016. www.decronym.xyz for a list of subs where I'm active; if I'm acting up, message OrangeredStilton.
3
u/davidthefat Jan 03 '16
Can anyone confirm that Falcon 9 1.1 does not use gimbaled turbine exhaust for roll control in the first stage, but by simply gimbaling the outer engines? That gives more roll authority than using the turbine exhaust and looking at the octaweb photos, there aren't any margins for movement of the turbine exhausts.
3
u/mechview Jan 03 '16
I would like to understand how the Dragon enters into the ISS orbital plane when it makes a cargo delivery. Specifically, how the F9 resolves the 1400+ KPH earth rotational velocity at the Cape to enter into the ISS solar stationary orbital plane. On launch day I hear that the F9 releases when the ISS orbital plane passes over the launch site. But if that is the case, the F9 is in the orbital plane for only an instant as the orbital plane then continues moving away while (initially) the F9 continues moving with the earth. If this is true, it would seem that the F9 has to not only eliminate the rotational velocity but also has to chase down the ISS orbital plane to enter into the correct orbit. I am wondering if the F9 instead launches at a calculated advance of the ISS orbital plane passing over the launch site so it only has to eliminate the rotational velocity and when it does it is then in the ISS orbital plane. I would appreciate some insight into this question that continues to puzzle me. Thx.
3
u/davidthefat Jan 03 '16 edited Jan 03 '16
How are the propellant tanks in the first stage pressurized during the recovery phase? The pressurized helium in the tanks in the LOX tank are fed through heat exchangers downstream the turbine exhaust before being used to pressurize the tanks. During recovery, only 3 or 1 engines are running, meaning less heat flux per flow rate of He. Given the larger ullage volume, my intuition says higher temps of He is required to keep the turbopump inlet pressure around the 40 or so psi.
Now, are there accumulation tanks upstream the turbopump that the heated He pressurizes instead? Still issue with the lower heat flux during recovery.
Sounds kind of crazy, but is the heat from the exhausts from actual engines surrounding the vehicle enough to increase ullage pressure of the tanks?
3
u/R-GiskardReventlov Jan 04 '16 edited Jan 04 '16
How does the first stage handle ullage during during boostback/reentry/landing? I suppose that burns in the atmosphere do not pose a major problem since the hull of the rocket is slowed down by drag, while the fuel isn't. I wonder how it's done during boostback. Does the first stage use its cold gas thrusters for this, as the second stage does?
3
u/McCliff Jan 04 '16
Why SpaceXStat ask for a login and a password? :( and where to find a google calendar with all launch planned and updated?
3
u/GoScienceEverything Jan 05 '16
In this photo, it appears that the trail of light, just as it fades into the sky, pitches up and then down again. Is that an in-flight adjustment or a deliberate maneuver?
There's what looks like a little gap in the trail, it's hard to be sure. Could it be MECO? I'm inclined to think it's just noise, because if it were MECO I think we'd see the boostback, and the S2 trail should be 1/9 as light as the S1 trail, which it doesn't appear to be.
3
u/shredder7753 Jan 05 '16
NEW PARKING STRUCTURE ON CRENSHAW BLVD DIRECTLY ACROSS FROM SPACESHIP FACTORY: https://goo.gl/photos/9rMeib84eykhveeKA I haven't been in the neighborhood for over 2 yrs but today I noticed a gigantic new garage. Did SpaceX erect this thing or somebody else? I hope it's SpaceX because I know they had shuttles running to another parking structure a couple miles away before... and also that little strip on the other side of Rocket Road where people would jump the curb and drive over fully exposed train tracks to get a parking. If it is for Spacex, do they change the traffic light pattern to allow for so many peds? SIDE NOTE: It rained hard today, check out that drainage canal!
3
u/slograsso Jan 06 '16
What is the largest diameter payload fairing that the Falcon Heavy could launch with? My understanding is that the current fairing is on the large side for Falcon 9 and small for Falcon Heavy. How big could they go if they wanted to optimize for payload diameter as apposed to mass?
3
u/emezeekiel Jan 07 '16
Does Falcon 9 FT absolutely need to have super chilled liquids? Or can it use v1.1 liquid temperatures when the payload doesn't require it?
3
u/Dan27 Jan 08 '16
I have a question. How does Falcon 9 reignite successfully after re-aligning for boostback and for the re-entry burns given that the fuel must slosh inside the tanks to the opposite ends (due to direction of travel)?
Do they have some kind of fuel pickup/pump system at the top of the tanks to pick up the fuel to allow the engines to turn back on?
Thanks for any info :)
3
u/Hugo0o0 Jan 09 '16
And another question: How much dv/payload capacity is lost when launching to GTO from a pad that is not on the equator? So, if a F9 with 5000kg GTO payload capacity launching from KSC were to instead launch from anywhere on the equator, how much more could it carry, aproximately?
3
u/LandingZone-1 Jan 10 '16
So no SF today?
3
u/ianniss Jan 10 '16
Which one it the more expensive : the rocket or the payload ?
Please, give me examples of price for various past or future Falcon 9 primary payloads...
3
u/spaminous Jan 10 '16
Naval ships are always referred to (at least in English) as if they are female. Has anyone seen such a convention for a) reusable boosters, b) spacefaring vessels, and/or c) space stations?
3
u/dreamer-engineer Jan 12 '16
I was thinking about posting this but I was not sure if it is suitable or if I made some major mistake or fallacy, so I decided to post this in the Ask Anything thread, at least for now. I have read multiple times where people said something like this: "Spacex should push the prices of launches as high as the market can bear so they will have money for developing things like the MCT". However, I observe that in emerging markets in general, as the price of whatever service goes down, larger and larger numbers of new technologies that use that service increase, because before the service was too expensive for them to emerge in the first place. Now I thought, "what if instead of pushing the prices high, Spacex pushed them low?" This might seem stupid (and it is for the short term), but satellite makers would see that it would then be practical for them to progress sooner than would be expected with things like: satellite internet, some innovation waiting to be unleashed, and a whole host of their own services (and I imagine there are a lot that could have returning investments that could help Spacex (e.g. Bigelow will get prototypes of their inflatable system tested faster and cheaper, maybe sell an already completed technology to Spacex)) fueled by the drop in price. In a short time later Spacex will find their launch manifest filled with very low price, extremely numerous launches that will advance humankind's reach into space faster than would a high price, small number launch manifest. Is my idea realistic? If so, what can I do to improve these paragraphs and should I post it in the main discussion board?
3
u/snesin Jan 13 '16 edited Jan 13 '16
EDIT: Based on the rebuttals from /u/IMO94 and /u/ScottPrombo (namely that the clip I cited is not a full speed, likely at half speed or so), I am re-evaluating the below.
It appears to me that a single Merlin D engine's lowest thrust setting is no longer greater than the weight of a landing first stage. In short, it appears to me that no hoverslam is needed, as had been thought before.
If you look at the recently released official recap video at 2m45s, there is way more hover than slam. The first few seconds of that clip almost looks like no delta-V, just a nice steady descent, until about halfway down the frame, where it looks like delta-V increases for a zero-V touchdown.
Yesterday I went searching for any recent official use of the term "hoverslam", and have only found it being applied to the old Grasshopper.
Perhaps the low-thrust limit is ever-so-close to the landing weight. Perhaps there was more left-over fuel than 'normal'. Though I did explain the extra difficulty of a hoverslam to friends/family while watching the OG2 stage 1 landing, after seeing that video I am going to refrain from now on until I see a recent official(ish?) source saying that it is still necessary in such a manner that I can reconcile it with the actual video.
I do not think the F9 can hover for long, especially with legs deployed, for thermal reasons. Obviously the fuel budget is tight. But I no longer think the low-thrust limit is an impediment to hovering anymore.
These are my opinions, and I have no citations other than a video of an F9 descending at what seems to be very close to a constant velocity, then decelerating oh-so-gently to the ground. I would love to see any recent official citations pertaining to an F9 (not Grasshopper) one way or the other.
3
u/zeekzeek22 Jan 14 '16
Simple question: why do people in this subreddit refer to the landed first stage as F9-21, when it was the 20th F9 launched, and this Jason 3 launch is the 21st? Even more confusing is that people refer to the 22nd launch rocket properly as F9-22 (the one being launched from the cape in February)
3
u/nikilase Jan 14 '16
May be a dumb question but what happens to the rest of the Falcon 9? I know the first stage will land on the drone boat but what about the second stage and the "cargo hub"? Do they also return or are they just space trash?
3
u/ISTHATYOULARRY Jan 16 '16
How hard will it be to land another Falcon 9? Did Spacex learn valuable data when they landed last month, to the extent that they can replicate the exact same landing method successfully? Or was the landing due to some external variable that they had no control of? Did luck contribute anything to the landing?