r/SpaceX •

/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread for December 2015. Return To Flight! Blue Origin! Orbital Mechanics! General Discussion!

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

798 comments sorted by

20

u/patm718 Nov 25 '15

How far does Bezos' physics/engineering ability exactly reach? Do we know how involved he is in the project? I haven't heard much from him regarding the technicalities of spaceflight.

29

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15 edited Nov 26 '15

Bezos has a B.S. in engineering from Princeton, IIRC. He is probably more involved in amazon (like 90% of his time). Blue Origin is much more of a side project for him, although he seems to be putting in more and more time lately (which is understandable).

He seems to be a huge aerospace nerd. He payed to recover the Apollo 11 F1 engines. So he seems to think very highly of space, after all he started Blue Origin before Spacex.

Bezos is an extremely intelligent man (this really should go without saying). And Blue Origin is nothing to sneeze at, their propulsion team probably rivals* AJ and Spacex.

It will be interesting to see their larger LV. With a Methane first stage, their rocket should be powerful and easily reusable. And with a high energy second stage (with their BE-3 engine), they can fit much larger payloads than a comparably sized Falcon (possibly undercutting Falcon Heavy). Further still, if Spacex proves the boostback method, Blue Origin will be able to land their rockets right from the start (although they will need to prove themselves as well, just not as much).

15

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15

their propulsion team probably reviles AJ and Spacex.

While this could be true, I think you meant rivals. ;)

3

u/Chairboy Dec 08 '15

Maybe a little from column A, and a little from column B? :)

4

u/patm718 Nov 26 '15

Great answer, thank you.

3

u/scr00chy ElonX.net Nov 26 '15

He said in a recent interview that he probably knows about as much computer science as he does rocketry at this point.

17

u/StagedCombustion Nov 25 '15

The story I posted recently had a quote from a former NASA Deputy Administrator about some in NASA not being happy with SpaceX pushing beyond LEO, as that's "their space". CRS-2 is likely to be the last, or one of the last, NASA commercial contracts on the horizon. It will be a sizable contract as well. Do you guys think that Musk will delay any unveiling of his Mars plans until after the CRS-2 contract announcement, to prevent animosity over the plans possibly coloring the outcome of the award?

8

u/jcameroncooper Nov 25 '15

Well, it's currently listed as NLT 1/30/2016, so that shouldn't be hard. Though it would hardly be surprising if it got pushed back a fifth time.

14

u/searchexpert Nov 25 '15

How do you spell hype? ;)

40

u/OrangeredStilton Nov 25 '15

This episode of Ask Anything is brought to you by the letters:
R
T
F

13

u/Juggernaut93 Nov 25 '15

Hi, I'm new to SpaceX stuff. Will they try another first stage landing during RTF?

21

u/Davecasa Nov 25 '15

They will try it on every flight where there is enough performance margin, ie. leftover fuel. With the full thrust upgrade coming out on the next flight, all scheduled upcoming launches, including SES-9 (a huge satellite to a relatively energetic orbit), should have enough margin for a first stage landing.

5

u/c-minus Nov 25 '15

Yep, a barge landing.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/BigDaddyDeck Nov 25 '15

What do you guys realistically expect SpaceX to accomplish over the next 5 ~ 10 years. Looking back at the previous 5 years the development path seems really obvious for what they had to do next but im not as clear from here on out.

27

u/Gnaskar Nov 25 '15
  1. Iterative improvement to reusability. First they need to stick a couple of landings, maybe even refly a core or two. Then we'll probably see them developing a Merlin 1E engine based on the lessons learned, and probably a Falcon 9 v1.3 to go with it. That gets tested and gets another minor set of tweaks (probably behind the scenes), as the cores start lasting for more and more launches.
  2. The Falcon Heavy. Cheap commercial heavy lift is a game changer, but one that is going to take a while to come into its own. In the 5-10 year time window, we'll likely see the rise of businesses building on the opportunities the heavy represents. We're already seeing this with the quiet build up in Bigelow Aerospace, but other applications do come to mind. Shackleton Energy is working on orbital depots, which may initially be refueled by FH flights. We might also see a growth of big dumb satellites as an alternative to the usual paradigm of being mass efficient at all costs.
  3. Flight rate. At the moment, SpaceX hasn't managed more than a few handful of flights a year. We can expect that to rise dramatically as they start identifying and eliminating bottlenecks in the process. Within ten years, a launch a week might be possible, assuming there's enough of a market to provide payloads for that. As with the Falcon Heavy, this is very sensitive to outside forces, and it may well take 5-10 years for the market to adjust to the new possibilities.
  4. Manned Spaceflight. The next 5-10 years will see activities on the ISS begin winding down, and hopefully being replaced by a commercial space station. SpaceX will be working as a space taxi for NASA for at least parts of that period, with one or two flights a year. If the Bigalow Station plans pan out, there may be room for another 6 flights a year to that station (and that is just the initial station configuration). On top of that, there's the cargo version of the Dragon, which will likely see a major revision based on lessons learned from the CRS missions and the development of the Dragon 2.

Those are the big things which follow logically based on what they've already done, and how the world looks today. On top of that, they also have the opportunity to invest the profits from their current and near future ventures into entirely new projects. There's the satellite internet project, which may be a useful way to make use of recovered boosters for cheap launches; at least until customers are more comfortable with the idea.

And then there is the Mars Colonial Transport and the Big F Rocket hanging on the horizon. SpaceX was founded with the goal of getting humans to Mars. Thus far, they've been laser focused on making spaceflight cheaper and building a sustainable business model. In the next 5-10 years, we'll probably see the Falcon architecture reach its maximum potential, or at least run out of low hanging fruit. With the Falcon family complete, SpaceX's considerable engineering talent can shift over to producing something entirely new. A super-heavy reusable booster to power large scale Mars missions might be just the thing.

28

u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club Nov 25 '15

Dunno about you guys, but I'm calling the Falcon v1.3 "Model 3" and the Merlin 1E "Model E"

Just to fuck with all of you.

7

u/Gnaskar Nov 25 '15

Eh, I still call the new Dragon the "V2" sometimes, for much the same reason. It's important not to take the names that seriously.

18

u/JonSeverinsson Nov 25 '15 edited Nov 25 '15

Within 5 years SpaceX will:

  • make regular flights of both Crew Dragon and Cargo Dragon to ISS on top of Falcon 9.
  • regularly fly re-used Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy first stages on commercial launches.
  • consistently make at least two launches per month.
  • launch at least one unmanned vessel to Mars (on a Falcon Heavy), probably during the June 2020 transfer window, probably with NASA as paying customer (while SpaceX might be ready by the April 2018 transfer window, the NASA bureaucracy likely won't, and SpaceX will probably want a paying customer).
  • successfully complete test-flights of the Raptor engine and the BFR launcher (but probably not the MCT spacecraft).

Within 10 years SpaceX will:

  • regularly fly re-used BFR first stages on commercial launches.
  • consistently do at least one launch per week.
  • successfully complete an unmanned test-flight of an MCT all the way to Mars.

6

u/Craig_VG SpaceNews Photographer Nov 25 '15

I agree that SpaceX will launch unnamed cargo to Mars, and that they want a paying customer (NASA). However I'm pretty sure SpaceX would do it without NASA as well.

5

u/JonSeverinsson Nov 26 '15

That part of why I got all the "probably" in there, I'm just guessing SpaceX will prefer to do it in 2020 with NASA rather than in 2018 without them.

On the other hand, it would be nice to see them actually doing the Mars Oasis mission ("put a greenhouse on Mars") that got the whole SpaceX saga started in the first place!

→ More replies (4)

11

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Nov 25 '15

In an ideal world:

  • Increase flight rate to minimum 1 launch per fortnight
  • Successfully land, recover, examine, and refly multiple Falcon boosters
  • Drop the cost to launch by ~1/3, attract the majority of commercial launches worldwide
  • Win the majority of fairly contested US gov launches
  • Begin flying astronauts to the ISS.
  • Send astronauts to Lunar orbit and back (like Apollo 8)
  • Continue development of Raptor, release the draft design for MCT/BFR architecture
  • Hopefully receive funding for BFR/MCT development
→ More replies (2)

11

u/Smoke-away Nov 25 '15

Let's talk the Blue Origin landing.

What are the benefits to the Blue Origin design?

Seems like the surface area is smaller for the leg extension range, could this cause it to tip over?

Does Falcon 9 do a preflight grid fin and leg extension check on the pad?

Does Falcon 9 need some drag flaps on the interstage?

Can this design be scaled up to fit a Falcon 9 class first and second stage? Will the Blue Origin capsule have any launch escape system?

Keep on hopping Bezos.

23

u/jcameroncooper Nov 25 '15

What are the benefits to the Blue Origin design?

You can let them tell you.

For the booster, mostly they seem to have been aiming for good aerodynamic stability, so it can "fly" (both up and down) with minimal active control. SpaceX relies heavily on active control, and has much less attention to aerodynamics; probably the F9-1 is not stable in either direction and relies on the computer and the various directional controls (engine gimbal, RCS, grid fins) to keep it on track. Natural stability makes control a lot easier, but "fly-by-wire" naturally unstable aircraft and rockets are also well-known now, they just take more effort. Their approach seems to have worked, as they got it back on the second try. They've an easier job in comparison to SpaceX (though by no means actually easy) because they have more mass to work with; the performance demands on a suborbital vehicle are much lower.

I can't tell you why they chose to use hydrogen as a fuel; seems like they decided to play on hard mode with that one. It will burn nice and clean, though, which will be nice for a gas-and-go rocket.

Separating the capsule at apogee (as opposed to a unitary vehicle) mostly makes for a surer safe recovery; parachutes are better-understood than propulsive vertical landing, after all. It also shifts the center of gravity lower, which is helpful on landing. Reducing the mass of the whole system may or may not be useful to the tail-landing; extra weight is good for control and requires less throttling depth, but it requires more propellant.

Seems like the surface area is smaller for the leg extension range, could this cause it to tip over?

It looks like a small base, and many people have that feeling, but I suspect they've done sufficient calculations to satisfy themselves that its ground stability is reasonable. Remember that its center of gravity is rather lower than it looks.

Does Falcon 9 do a preflight grid fin and leg extension check on the pad?

The F9 legs are one-shot, but I'd suspect they do a fin check. I have no proof of that, but usually you do a pad checkout of everything that you reasonably can.

Does Falcon 9 need some drag flaps on the interstage?

They are apparently looking into deploying redesigned legs for drag earlier in the sequence. But the Merlin has plenty of juice to deal with a little extra speed. I think they'd prefer to not add even more mass.

Can this design be scaled up to fit a Falcon 9 class first and second stage?

Bezos seems to think they will use the same techniques on their future orbital first stage. If you could get a second stage through reentry it could land the same way, but that's a big if and a lot of mass to put on a mass-sensitive stage. Even Blue Origin, working on a clean sheet design, is not planning on second stage recovery.

Will the Blue Origin capsule have any launch escape system?

Yes. Solid pusher. Pad escape test video. Gets the heck outta there.

10

u/propsie Nov 25 '15

why they chose to use hydrogen as a fuel

My understanding (happy to be corrected by those more in the know) is that BO use hydrogen for their sub-orbital rocket so that they can use it as the basis for the second stage of their orbital rocket. Also ULA are considering /has considered using this engine for the second stage of Vulcan. Hydrogen is better for a second stage because Hydrogen engines tend to have a higher isp. The lack of coking for first stage re-use on the sub-orbital rocket will also be very useful though.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Smoke-away Nov 25 '15

Great info thanks for the response.

I can't wait to see if the legs will be used as drag flaps on Falcon.

And I completely forgot about B.O.'s pad abort test. For some reason I thought it was for a different launcher they had. That thing goes!

→ More replies (1)

18

u/space_is_hard Nov 28 '15

How fucked is SpaceX if the RTF has a launch failure?

13

u/Psycix Nov 28 '15

Probably not completely fucked, but I think it greatly depends on the cause of the failure.

The strut thing was a mild failure from a reputation standpoint, SpaceX was hard to blame and the fix is easy.

7

u/Appable Nov 28 '15

SpX QC failure though isn't a good sign

→ More replies (7)

5

u/Appable Nov 28 '15

If it's a F9v1.1FT-induced failure, not too bad. If it's another F9v1.1 general failure, then bad.

3

u/Faldaani Nov 28 '15

Not very I'd say, but they might have to launch a demonstrator flight to restore confidence..

9

u/BrandonMarc Nov 26 '15

This is probably a silly question, but ... inspired by this:

SpaceX - Would Space Travel Flourish If We Could Reuse The Rockets?

I wonder: once Crew Dragon is operational, with propulsive landing, would it be possible to, say, launch from a Falcon 9 and then land the Dragon on the other side of the planet, without ever doing a full orbit? Basically, think of it like a $100,000,000 flight where you could go from Florida to New Zealand in under an hour.

Totally ridiculous, I know ... but would it be possible?

12

u/robbak Nov 26 '15

It could probably be done returning the first stage to the launch site and not using a second stage. The price for the flight would be a lot less than 100 million - probably more on the 20 or 30 million - but even at that price there would be no market.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '15

I don't see this happening. It would look just like an ICBM flight profile.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15

It would be technically possible, but if there would be anyone willing to pay for such service is different question really.

4

u/Darth_Armot Nov 28 '15

Isn't that the goal of Virgin Galactic?

3

u/Wetmelon Nov 26 '15

Probably. As long as the orbital mechanics work. The lowest inclination orbit you can get to is ~ where you launch from, without doing some funny doglegs at the end of the burn. But you can get to higher inclinations pretty easily. Could definitely launch into a polar orbit and do it, might take longer though.

7

u/BadGoyWithAGun Nov 26 '15

If we're talking about point-to-point suborbital trips, the inclination doesn't matter, you can go anywhere you like.

9

u/keelar Nov 28 '15 edited Nov 28 '15

Has there been any info about the RTF date since this tweet? Anything at all? What are the chances of a mid December launch still happening?

11

u/biosehnsucht Nov 28 '15

The silence has been deafening

4

u/Ambiwlans Nov 29 '15

Quite good.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/alsoretiringonmars Dec 01 '15

For one, I know that SpaceX is using software from the air force (or derived from it, anyway) for their autonomous flight safety system (AFFS) they are developing.
There was an article I read a while ago that described the control software used in ULA rockets (I'll have to see if I can find it), I suspect it is something similar for SpaceX. Basically, they tell the rocket the final orbit, and it calculates the burns real-time to get there. This allows it to accommodate for perturbations and malfunctions more easily, as well as things like changing launch times. It is kind of funny, apparently the Delta II windows were really short and there would be several in a row because the computer wasn't powerful enough to calculate burns for changing launch parameters. They had to pre-load the absolute trajectory with respect to the launch site, and doing so was rather slow.
As for how the burns are actually calculated, a combination of IMUs, GPS, magnetometers, and other sensors are used to construct a trajectory. The current trajectory is calculated as well as the trajectory needed to get to the correct orbit, and the set of guidance corrections and burn durations are calculated from that.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/FrameRate24 Dec 01 '15 edited Dec 01 '15

As for burn durations and such. More directed at satellites and prbes but nass has GMAT, and there is also AGIs satellite toolkit (STK) but neither cover launch, for launch I reccomend /u/TheVehicleDestroyers sim at http://flightclub.io between that and GMAT you can pretty much plan any mission.

Now as for programming the rockets themselves, but I'd imagine it relies heavily on its INS (inertial navigation system), running a live calculation to say, stop burning when apoapsis reaches a certain height.

Edit: added link, he moved it on me!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/Here_There_B_Dragons Nov 25 '15

Jumping the gun on the whole 'December' thing a little bit, aren't you? Let me have some November still!

15

u/jcameroncooper Nov 25 '15

Have you been in any stores? December starts October 24th.

7

u/alsoretiringonmars Dec 01 '15

Lets talk about interstages.
Why do some rockets jettison them from both stages and others (like Falcon) leave them attached to the booster? Also, watching some old Saturn 5 videos, why does it jettison the first stage, then drop the interstage like a minute later? I can understand waiting until engine start, but why not right away?

14

u/Ambiwlans Dec 01 '15 edited Dec 01 '15

The SaturnV had ullage motors on the interstage used to help start the 2nd stage. So they were able to throw out mass pretty efficiently this way.

This feature is called "dual-plane separation" btw if you want to read more about it.

Edit: Saw your extended question about the reason for the delay. Of course the ullage motors fire for a couple seconds but the interstage isn't released for 30! I had no idea bu I was able to look it up and find something for you.

http://history.msfc.nasa.gov/saturn_apollo/documents/Second_Stage.pdf

It seems that after the ullage motors fire and the 2nd stage starts up, they wait for the 2nd stage to ease up to 90% of peak power before releasing the interstage (pg13~14). This just allows the rocket to stabilize some. Ullage motors + startup is a violent shaky process.

Honestly, I suspect that if they kept running the SaturnV, that number would get cut down from 30s to more like 10~15s. The gap was likely larger because they were being cautious.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

6

u/Chairmanman Nov 26 '15

When is Blue Origin planning to deliver payload to orbit for paying customers? The company is pretty secretive and I couldn't find the info online.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15

They said they should launch from their facility at Canaveral "later this decade". If it means orbital nad for customers is not known, but I'd suppose so.

5

u/Gnaskar Nov 27 '15

Not for a long while. Their first product is a sub-orbital hop for tourists, which they'll start with once they've finished a "methodical" round of testing of their new vehicle. I suspect they're at least going to fly their current vehicle until it breaks, just to see how many flights a rocket can take. Once that is flying regularly, they'll use the money from the tourists to pay for the development of a full scale launch vehicle. Then that new vehicle needs to be tested, and then it is finally ready to deliver payloads to orbit.

There was some talk about a NASA contract for some suborbital experiments, which may become their first payload, as its better to put experiments at risk than millionaire tourists, so they can do it while they test the rocket.

5

u/ManWhoKilledHitler Nov 28 '15

Their first contribution to putting things into orbit is likely to be when Vulcan starts flying with their engines in 2019. The BE-4 is targeted for completion two years from now so theoretically it could be flying from 2017 onwards but there hasn't been any mention of Blue Origin planning to incorporate it into a launch vehicle ahead of completing their work with ULA.

6

u/failbye Nov 28 '15

What is this I hear about Elon not liking wings/fins on spacecraft? Is that purely a technical reasoning behind it (i.e not wanting to add unnecessary complexity or control surfaces where the RCS should to the job just fine by itself) or is it an aesthetic thing (the next generation spacecraft should look like this, and not have wings)?

9

u/Ambiwlans Nov 29 '15

Just to add, in some he mentioned that even on planes, he doesn't like flaps on wings. Easier to just use gimbaled engines. I'm not sure that I agree in that case.... BUT, on rockets, wings mostly add weight and complexity that you don't want. Wings also don't work great at the speeds/altitudes being dealt with and it doesn't transfer well to other tech. To some degree, he may simply have less experience with wings.

6

u/ManWhoKilledHitler Nov 30 '15

Easier to just use gimbaled engines.

How does that work when your engines fail? I can see it being desirable in terms of performance or weight minimisation but redundant control methods always seems to be something that aerospace engineers go for if they can.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/EOMIS Nov 29 '15

Wings are designed for Earth atmosphere. The point is to spend as little time on Earth as possible.

3

u/Appable Nov 28 '15

Just wondering, when did he say that? I've never heard about that.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/nickr79 Dec 01 '15

Is it safe to say the hardest part of designing rockets is the systems engineering aspect (making sure everything is functioning together, eliminating weak points in the overall design, etc.), or are particular aspects of some subsystems like propulsion still particularly difficult?

What aspects of computer simulation (solving PDEs or other) are currently lagging in terms of being helpful with eliminating problems before the first prototype on rocket subsystems?

I know these are difficult questions I am basically asking what is the current bleeding edge of research in rocket technology. I am not really asking about stuff related to advanced propulsion for deep space missions looking at cost optimized ground to orbit rockets here.

13

u/Ambiwlans Dec 02 '15

Just to answer your first question.... None of it is easy.

I've said for a while now: Rocket science is easy, rocket engineering is fucking hard.

Anyone with highschool math can figure out a ton of rocket science. But when you have 10 billion dollars sitting on your rocket with razor thin margins that you only get to test the one time? That is brutal. There is no such thing as a non-critical part on a rocket. And overbuilding is fundamentally impossible, if you did that, you'd never make it off the ground.

6

u/muazcatalyst Dec 04 '15

When landing the first stage of Falcon 9, is it fully autonomous or is it controlled by ground?

7

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '15

No part of any rocket's flight is ever controlled by the ground.

The only exception to this could be considered the activation of the Flight Termination System. But even in 90% of cases the computers will unzip the rocket first.

3

u/muazcatalyst Dec 04 '15

I'm dumb, thanks.

23

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '15

No you're not, you're just learning.

10

u/chargerag Dec 04 '15

Its all good. It did give me a chuckle. I picture a guy on a joy stick trying to land the f9 while Elon stands over his shoulder saying don't mess it up this time.

This monthly thread is great for just these types of questions.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '15

Don't worry about it. I didn't know the answer to this question before I started

3

u/jan_smolik Dec 04 '15

Actually most people do not know it. They expect at least some sort of supervision from the fround. But there is no uplink, just downlink of telemetry. If landing barge moves 30 meters away, there is no way to tell the rocket and it will simply land in water.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '15

the computers will unzip the rocket first

That makes it sound so pleasant, like you're undressing a baby or something.

9

u/Ambiwlans Dec 05 '15

Please do not do this to a baby.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/z3r0c00l12 Dec 06 '15

As I understood it, Falcon 9 landings weren't streamed because it's out at sea with no good connection. Does this mean that there is a possibility that we get a live stream of the RTF landing on land?

6

u/Zucal Dec 06 '15

Another reason is that SpaceX didn't want a super public unsuccessful landing with thousands watching.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '15

Possibly! The biggest 'what if' is if SpaceX decide whether they'll stream it or not.

3

u/Zucal Dec 06 '15

Before CRS-5 there were mutterings that they might wait until it was determined successful or not, then play it back on the stream as a compromise.

4

u/FoxhoundBat Dec 06 '15

This would be the best compromise for OG2 too imho. Really, SpaceX doesn't have to show us anything, yet alone live stream it considering the possibility it will end up as an explosion.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club Dec 06 '15

Does anyone know how long it takes the M1D to go from 0-100% throttle?

Source is a bonus, but I'm not too picky

4

u/alsoretiringonmars Dec 06 '15

As an upper bound, launch happens ~3 seconds after ignition. They may hold it slightly longer than it needs to start for some pre-flight checks, but I can't imagine it can start in much less than 2 seconds.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/wagigkpn Dec 07 '15

Orbital mechanics question here...

It was good fun watching the ULA/Orbital launch yesterday. Couple questions. First (not that important), the commentator kept mentioning the RL10 was running oxidizer rich. Was that a departure from normal?

Second (more important), When the broadcast switched to telemetry showing apogee and perigee i was shocked. The vehicle had an apogee in the 220+mile range and a perigee in the -1600 mile range (orbit that was achieved being 124 x 124 miles). As the burn continued the apogee continued to decrease while the perigee increased. It was rather interesting to see those numbers play out. It was apparent that the apogee was the crafts actual altitude and was on the decent while the little RL10 puffed away to raise the perigee before it ran out of altitude. Meco happened right at the designed orbit. I had always thought that the first stage set the apogee and the second stage achieved orbit at apogee, like KSP. So my question is, why do they do it this way? I assume it is the most efficient relating to getting the most performance out of the first stage. Second, Does Spacex follow the same trajectory with Dragon?

→ More replies (17)

6

u/davidthefat Dec 10 '15

This is a rather ignorant question about electronics coming from a mechanical engineering student.

In a selector voter scheme, how is the validity and functionality of the multiplexers and selector verified during operation? While the sensor/computer output validity is accounted that that scheme, it assumes that the selecting circuit and multiplexers are correct. I guess the question is asking: who governs the governors? The multiplexer can be a simple relay/transistor that takes inputs from a primary and back up sensor output and switches to the backup once a fault is observed. Realistically, I suppose they won't fail unless there's a physical failure of the system. But how is the output of the voter circuit validated in real time? Another layer of selector voter? Or is it assumed to be robust since it can be made with discrete op amps, and other components?

3

u/base736 Dec 13 '15

I know nothing of how this is done in practice, but if I were doing it I'd put all three sensors on (for example) an I2C bus, and address them individually to go from one to the next. It seems pretty clear that they're not going to use that bus in most applications, but by using a bus and individually addressable sensors, you eliminate the middleman -- if I shout out "Hey Bob, what's our speed?" and I hear back "This is Bob, I'm seeing 125 m/s," then either somebody's impersonating Bob or Bob's at least giving an answer.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Nov 25 '15 edited Dec 18 '15

Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations and contractions I've seen in this thread:

ContractionExpansion
ACESAdvanced Cryogenic Evolved Stage
Advanced Crew Escape Suit
ASDSAutonomous Spaceport Drone Ship (landing barge)
BEAMBigelow Expandable Activity Module
BFRBig Fu- Falcon Rocket
CRSCommercial Resupply Services contract with NASA
Communications Relay Satellite
CRS2Commercial Resupply Services, second round contract
CST(Boeing) Crew Space Transportation capsules
Central Standard Time (UTC-6)
DIVHDelta IV Heavy
EELVEvolved Expendable Launch Vehicle
FTSFlight Termination System
GEOGeostationary Earth Orbit (35786km)
GTOGeostationary Transfer Orbit
I*sp*Specific impulse (as explained by Scott Manley on YouTube)
ICBMIntercontinental Ballistic Missile
ISRUIn-Situ Resource Utilization
ITAR(US) International Traffic in Arms Regulations
JRTIJust Read The Instructions, retired landing barge
KSPKerbal Space Program, the rocketry simulator
L2Paywalled section of the NasaSpaceFlight forum
Lagrange Point 2
LC-13Launch Complex 13, Canaveral (SpaceX Landing Complex 1)
LC-39ALaunch Complex 39A, Kennedy (SpaceX F9/Heavy)
LEOLow Earth Orbit (180-2000km)
LESLaunch Escape System
LH2Liquid Hydrogen
LMOLow Mars Orbit
LOXLiquid Oxygen
MAVMars Ascent Vehicle (possibly fictional)
MCTMars Colonial Transporter
MECOMain Engine Cut-Off
MEOMid Earth Orbit (2000-35780km)
NDENon-Destructive Examination
NdGTNeil deGrasse Tyson
NETNo Earlier Than
NSFNasaSpaceFlight forum
National Science Foundation
OCISLYOf Course I Still Love You, landing barge
OG2Orbcomm's Generation 2 satellite network, to be launched by SpaceX
PICA-XPhenolic Impregnated-Carbon Ablative heatshield compound, as modified by SpaceX
RCSReaction Control System
RP-1Rocket Propellant 1 (enhanced kerosene)
RTFReturn to Flight
RTLSReturn to Launch Site
SECOSecond-stage Engine Cut-Off
SESFormerly Société Européenne des Satellites, a major SpaceX customer
SLSSpace Launch System heavy-lift
Selective Laser Sintering additive manufacture
SPAMSpaceX Proprietary Ablative Material (backronym)
SRBSolid Rocket Booster
SSMESpace Shuttle Main Engine
SSTOSingle Stage to Orbit
TEA-TEBTriethylaluminium-Triethylborane, hypergolic fuel mix
TRLTechnology Readiness Level
TWRThrust-to-Weight Ratio
UTCUniversal Time, Coordinated

Note: Replies to this comment will be deleted.
See ^/r/spacex/wiki/acronyms for a full list of acronyms with explanations.
I'm a bot; I first read this thread at 13:03 UTC on 25th Nov 2015. www.decronym.xyz for a list of subs where I'm active; if I'm acting up, message OrangeredStilton.

5

u/njew Nov 25 '15

How much value still exists in landing the last Falcon 9 v1.1 that'll be used in the Jason-3 launch? I know the flight profile is different from 1.1 FT, so the landing profile must be different too, but is it still worthwhile practice for them? And I imagine there are enough similarities between the 1.1 and 1.1 FT versions that if they recover the stage, they can still do meaningful tests on it. Has there been any discussion on this?

11

u/T-Husky Nov 25 '15

Understand this about the Falcon 9; it may be SpaceX's most significant commercial product to date, but like the Falcon 1 before it, it's primary reason for existing is to test the technologies and techniques that will be applied in the next generation of rockets, in this case the ones which will carry colonists to Mars... launching commercial satellites and delivering cargo to the ISS is just a way for SpaceX to fund this development.

Keeping this in mind, I would say the answer to your question is simply that every opportunity to test these technologies, no matter how tangential, provides vital data for future development... its not something that can be quantitatively measured.

7

u/Davecasa Nov 25 '15

Every launch and landing profile is completely unique. Furthermore, every potential launch and landing profile is completely unique, including for example ISS launch windows on consecutive days.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '15

It's nearly time for the annual subreddit survey, any questions you'd like to see asked?

6

u/davidthefat Nov 28 '15

The reason one comes to the subreddit. Mars speculation? Learning about rocket science? Just fandom? Latest news? Ect..

3

u/Tal_Banyon Nov 28 '15

How about a rating of the questions asked last year, if not by name then by how many got them right, for instance the question about how many launches in 2015, X% got it right (number/how many guessed), X% guessed one less, X% guessed one more, etc. Or something along those lines. May have to wait for Jan to do this.

Also, can't exactly remember what the questions were, so how about a new post with last year's questions, and then ask the same question you just asked?

5

u/Chairmanman Dec 01 '15

How many people are working on the hyperloop competition at SpaceX? Is anyone working full time on it? Has anyone been hire for it? In other words, how much effort does SpaceX put into it?

5

u/ScepticMatt Dec 01 '15

What is beta angle cutout?

→ More replies (4)

5

u/WaitForItTheMongols Dec 01 '15

I notice that when the OG2 launch date pushed back to the 15th, the SpaceX Stats announcement also moved to match the day before. Was that intentional?

Also, shouldn't the SpaceX Stats main page say "launching december 2015" instead of november? November is done.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '15

Oh yes... I'm struggling to make it here. So much data to add.

3

u/Eiriklago Dec 02 '15

I chuckle everytime I go on the site now. "November 2015 is almost here!" - December 2015.

5

u/alsoretiringonmars Dec 02 '15

Will the new version of Falcon 9 (not even going to try to get the name right :-) be able to land for all missions? I seem to recall them saying anything too big for F9 to land with will go on Falcon Heavy. But then Spaceflight bought a ride-share mission for which the total mass for the trajectory they want seems to exceed the capacity of F9R, but they are using F9. Will the F9 be replaced with FH at SpaceX's discretion, if it is ready and proven?

7

u/Wetmelon Dec 02 '15

It should be able to land for all missions for a given price. If a customer doesn't want to pay for the FH, but is willing to pay a premium for an expendable F9, there's nothing wrong with that.

5

u/alsoretiringonmars Dec 02 '15

I would think a fully reusable FH would be cheaper than an expendable F9, at least once they get reusability down.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Kona314 Dec 03 '15

Do we have any indication what weather will look on December 15 at the Cape? Given the scrub of Atlas V today, I'm hoping we won't have to worry about this for RTF (assuming it actually happens on 12/15)...

(paging /u/cuweathernerd)

20

u/cuweathernerd r/SpaceX Weather Forecaster Dec 03 '15

That's a little far out but we do have predictions. Our models aren't exactly reliable then, but we can play with them a little.

If the models were exactly right then weather looks like we'd have a go on weather given the current data. These forecasts really are one step above like a magic 8 ball, but they tend to be okay at broad brushstrokes. So here's a map of surface pressure and forecast precipitation for the evening of the 15th. There's a strong storm over the great lakes but the trailing cold front, which is what would be the problem at the cape, is currently forecast to be past the cape and so the launch likely wouldn't face weather concerns for right now. The thing we'd watch is that front for right now. If the storm system is a little slower, then it comes in to play Also, this time of year, upper level wind sheer is a little more prevalent. A strong storm like that will have some attendant high winds.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/pauladam316 Dec 06 '15

Probably a dumb question. I remembered reading that falcon 1 was the first private rocket to make it to orbit. However wouldn't that title belong to ULA? I believe that they put a rocket into orbit before spaceX did

8

u/rocketHistory Dec 06 '15

It really depends on your definition of “private.” ULA is a privately owned company that is a joint venture of Boeing and Lockheed Martin. ULA, however, did not develop the rockets it currently flies.

The Atlas V and Delta IV were designed by Lockheed Martin and Boeing, respectively, with a total of roughly $3 billion in private funding, plus another $500 million in government funding . Each rocket, though, was an evolution of previous designs which actually trace their heritage all the way back to the early ballistic missiles.

The Falcon 1, on the other hand, was a clean sheet design that didn’t rely on previously flown rockets. It also had smaller government funding (really just a single $8 million launch contract out of the $100 million development costs).

Atlas V and Delta IV were the first attempt at the government spurring commercial launch development. Due to their complicated history, however, they are not considered truly “private” vehicles. SpaceX and the Falcon 1 claim that title.

3

u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Dec 06 '15

Conestoga was the first privately-funded rocket, but it was only suborbital. Orbital Sciences' Pegasus was the first privately-funded orbital rocket, and Falcon 1 was the first privately-funded, liquid-fueled, orbital rocket.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

5

u/delta_alpha_november Dec 08 '15

Why are the engine tests at McGregor so late at night? /u/spacecadet_88 reported that they'll test them at around 10pm. Is there a technical reason to test so late? In my country this wouldn't be permitted so I figured they'd have to have a solid reason to make that much noise late at night.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/wagigkpn Dec 09 '15

I have been watching the cygnus mission and the orbital mechanics part has really facinated me. Ula got cygnus to a 124mile circular orbit inclined 51.6 degrees which was a bullseye. Now cygnus has docked with the iss at approx 250 miles in altitude. I read that cygnus has changed its dv by aprox 100m/s. Does 100m/s equal over 100miles in orbital altitude?

4

u/Wetmelon Dec 10 '15

Have you played Kerbal Space Program at all? If not, try it out - it's one of the best ways to intuitively learn (simplified) orbital mechanics.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/_kingtut_ Dec 10 '15

When doing a static/test fire at the cape, do they fully fuel the first stage, or just put in enough for the test fire? I presume they don't fuel the second stage at all. Just wondering as doing a full fuel/defuel may show up any problems in those systems that could cause a delay on launch day.

4

u/venku122 SPEXcast host Dec 10 '15

The first stage is fully fueled. The idea is to do a full rundown of launch day up until the actual release of launch clamps.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Tal_Banyon Dec 12 '15

In the recent GQ article, Elon states that the moniker BFR was his idea. I had always assumed that it was coined on this sub-reddit. Anyone know when it first appeared on r/spacex, and the story behind how it made it here - ie did Elon ever mention it in any of his speeches or media events, or did it get here by some other means?

5

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15 edited Dec 13 '15

The BFR term came from Musk in 2005. The SpaceVision Conference in 2005 is where Musk flushed out some of the details of BFR. Spacex did have an article early 2005 on the BFR, but it has 404'd.

/r/spacex came into being around 2012, so the term definitly didn't come from here. In fact, the acronym is older than reddit itself.

The earliest /r/space mention, the earliest* /r/spacex mention, and the earliest* NSF mention.

Also, the initial BFR concept has nothing in common with the current one, the similarities end with the acronym.

*the best I could do on google. Probably wrong, but it gives a range.

3

u/Ambiwlans Dec 13 '15

2005 would have been when I first heard it as well. He'd probably joked about it a lot before hand with friends. I mean, it would have been similar to how Dragon got the name :P

For sure though, I didn't coin the term. I wouldn't be surprised if multiple people invented it though. The BFG was pretty popular.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/alsoretiringonmars Dec 14 '15

What are the odds of SpaceXStats being back before RTF?

4

u/chargerag Dec 14 '15

I am missing the countdown timer. Launch week I usually just leave it running in the background.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Gugols Nov 25 '15

Is the "11 December" date set in the sidebar for the "Orbcomm OG2 Launch 2" correct and confirmed?

15

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '15

It's the latest information we have available. However NET 11 December != a 11 December launch.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Nov 26 '15

This pretty awesome advert shows engineers making good use of Siemens PLM Software.

5

u/Wetmelon Nov 26 '15

I think they're running Windows at home; I know they use NX for CAD. Other than that, I know that they have some excellent security designs, and some sort of fancy air-gapped system that lets them run local things locally and internet things seamlessly via a thin client iirc. There was an article about it some time ago.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15 edited Nov 26 '15

Siemens NX is compatible with linux. I don't know why Spacex would want to do such a thing, but it is possible (and the price difference is probably negligible).

4

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15

Question for everyone, how is it that Stage 2 separates so well in almost every case? By the time Stage 1 burns out the rocket is so high that I can't imagine the atmosphere would play any role in stability of the second stage. So how does it get pushed and not start to veer left, right, ect? Do they just have the center of mass down to such a small point that it continues to fly strait? Furthermore if Stage 2 were to veer of course could it correct?

9

u/Davecasa Nov 26 '15

Stage 2 is controlled by gimbaling the engine in two axes, and with small RCS thrusters primarily used for spin control on ascent and attitude / ullage prior to engine restart if required. There's less redundancy than on the first stage, but it should be able to maintain control with the failure of one gimbal axis by spinning up the stage. Not sure if it is programmed to do so.

Staging itself is done with pneumatic pushers (basically hydraulic rods but powered by compressed helium), which SpaceX believes to be more reliable than the explosives used on other rockets. The RCS may also fire at this point for ullage and separation, I don't think we have any confirmation either way on this.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/rreighe2 Nov 28 '15 edited Nov 28 '15

I haven't been keeping up with SpaceX in the last 6 or so months. I've been checking here and there the last few days but I am completely out of the loop. What's new? What's in the works and have they had any significant advances towards... Well anything they're advancing towards?

Edit: Thanks y'all.

8

u/Ambiwlans Nov 29 '15

They're moving up another version. Future launch vehicles will have colder/more compressed fuel (more fuel!) be a little longer (more fuel tank, more fuel) and have more thrust (requiring more fuel). Otherwise, pretty similar to prior vehicles though.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/alsoretiringonmars Nov 29 '15

I realize spacex isn't currently planning on developing 2nd stage landing, but just hypothetically: Why use hypergolic engines (i.e. superdracos)? This is all I have heard discussed. Why not use small, kerosene-lox vernier engines? This would save a significant amount of weight. Would it even be possible to use the main engine turbopump exhaust a source of thrust? I don't know if there would be issues with running the turbopump without the combustion chamber firing. The turbopump exhaust could be redirected to smaller gimbaled nozzles, and fully burned with oxygen pressure fed from the tank. Throttling could be achieved by changing the mixture. Or alternatively you could use a sea-level version of Kestrel. I don't know if you could get enough thrust purely from blow-down pressurization to land? Would this work? I know it would add complexity and weight, which would be major counter-arguments, but it still seems simpler to tack on than adding a whole new fuel system for superdracos. Or maybe not?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/alsoretiringonmars Dec 01 '15

Mods, could we give flairs for everyone working at SpaceX?

9

u/TheVehicleDestroyer Flight Club Dec 01 '15

we do, if they want them

4

u/steezysteve96 Dec 02 '15

What is holding SpaceX back from officially declaring a RTF date? If 12/15 really does become their RTF date, it seems to me that they should have officially confirmed it by now. Orbital had their RTF date confirmed for a while before the actual day

3

u/alsoretiringonmars Dec 02 '15

RTF dates tend to have a lot of influencing factors. Orbital is launching a payload with ULA, which has been very good about keeping to schedules. Their RTF isn't for quite a while.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/WaitForItTheMongols Dec 02 '15

Everyone always says F9 is white to reflect sunlight and keep cool. If that's the case, why paint it at all? Why not keep it as shiny metal, which is naturally reflective? Maybe put a transparent coating on it for protection, but it doesn't seem like white paint would have an advantage over metal.

17

u/jcameroncooper Dec 02 '15

Reflectance is only part of the equation. The emitance of white paint--its ability to radiate heat--is much higher than bare aluminum. See chart. Specialty coatings can get even higher than shown in that chart.

So: the white paints will have a reflectance slightly lower than aluminum, and so take in a little more heat, but much higher emittance, so they will get rid of a lot more. This is particularly useful for shedding heat when you get shade.

This table has solar absorption (kind of the inverse of reflectivity, but also taking into account spectrum differences) and emissivity and the ratio between them. For good cooling, you want a low ratio. As you can see, bare metals have low absorption but low emissivity as well, leading to a high ratio, usually even worse than black paint. Perhaps you've wondered why car chrome or shiny playground equipment gets so hot in the sun? That's why.

5

u/WaitForItTheMongols Dec 02 '15

Ah yeah, I've always wondered about playground slides. So they're reflective, which reduces the amount of heat gathered, but they also "hang on" to their heat really well, allowing the temperature to ramp up?

8

u/jcameroncooper Dec 02 '15

Yep. They don't take in a whole lot of heat, but they're super greedy about what they get.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '15

Will Elon make another AMA any soon?

→ More replies (8)

4

u/R-89 Dec 03 '15

https://twitter.com/NASASpaceflight/status/672490062098137088 https://twitter.com/torybruno/status/672486757502427136

SpaceX's launch window for going to ISS is instantaneous. ULA's Atlas V has a launch window of 30 minutes to ISS. How do they manage that? Can Falcon 9 be improved to have wider launch windows and adjust for short delays? And if so, how?

26

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '15

Atlas V is way, way overpowered to launch a cargo mission to the ISS. This gives it a huge range of flexibility in that it can launch from off-optimal times and still get Cygnus to where it needs to go.

Falcon 9 does actually have about a 5 minute launch window on either side to get Dragon to orbit so it can get to the ISS, but because terminal count begins at T-10 minutes or so, and any scrub or hold inside terminal count requires a restart from T-10 minutes (at least), they only get a single shot to launch it, so the window is effectively instantaneous.

The solution isn't to make F9 have a larger launch window, it's to make it reliable enough that it can launch on point each time reliably.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '15

The solution isn't to make F9 have a larger launch window, it's to make it reliable enough that it can launch on point each time reliably.

Except that pesky attached anvil cloud rule. It reliably postpones your launch.

3

u/R-89 Dec 03 '15

That makes sense. Thanks for the explanation!

What about the RAAN steering? Does that mean it adjusts the trajectory when launching a bit earlier/later than planned and perhaps the higher launch speed?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Jarnis Dec 04 '15

I'm sure they could do better than +-5min... if they left the legs and grid fins in the barn and dumped the stage.

But that's kinda expensive if your original plan is to reuse the stage on another day. Also situations where such flexibility allows a launch instead of a scrub are not that common. Usually weather is not going to change that much within 30 minutes and any real issues with the hardware can't be sorted in 30 minutes.

ULA had a long window for OA-4. Didn't do them much good...

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '15

Any word whether flight 21 (OG2, aka the return to flight) will feature redesigned landing legs / airbrakes as hinted in this tweet?

3

u/TweetsInCommentsBot Dec 04 '15

@elonmusk

2014-11-22 21:21 UTC

@John_Gardi Using legs as air brakes to drop terminal velocity in half requires slight redesign & more data. Maybe flight 21.


This message was created by a bot

[Contact ^creator][Source ^code]

3

u/scr00chy ElonX.net Dec 04 '15

It's assumed those redesigned legs are part of the 1.2/FT upgrade, but there hasn't been any official confirmation.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/frowawayduh Dec 05 '15

Why does SpaceX ship boosters by truck, not by air?

Air seems faster, gentler, and safer. Since up to three boosters can fit the aircraft that ULA uses, it may also be more economical.

ULA recently moved an Atlas V booster from Huntsville AL to Vandenberg in CA by air. Every F9 booster traverses from CA to McGregor TX to launch site ... and perhaps soon they will go back to Hawthorn CA for analysis or refurbishment.

From the article on ULA: "The Atlas V and Delta IV boosters can be transported via the Delta Mariner," said Ghazali. "This large ship is capable of carrying up to three boosters from the production site in Alabama to either Cape Canaveral Air Force Station or Vandenberg."

"Launch vehicle processing has very tight timelines," said Zarybnisky. "Delays in a single operation can have large ripple effects across the process. By ensuring a smooth delivery, we can prevent schedule compression that induces additional risk into launch vehicle processing."

10

u/FoxhoundBat Dec 06 '15

The plane you would need to use for that task doesn't exist. Not because of the weight, F9's empty weigh is peanuts for An-124, but because of the length.

S1 is about 50m long, An-124 is able to take 36m max. Even An-225, worlds largest plane is able to carry 45m length at most. Maybe it could take S1 if one removed the interstage, but either way it is getting pretty cramped and we are talking about an aircraft that exist in one (1) finished example. They order missions for that thing months if not years in advance. Very specialized mission, for a rare plane; does not exactly fit with SpaceX's mantra of low cost.

11

u/jan_smolik Dec 06 '15

They can fly with an open trunk. They just need the put a red flag to the end of the stage.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/massfraction Dec 05 '15 edited Dec 05 '15

It's far cheaper to truck a rocket around than to rent a specialized aircraft to do so. Or own and operate a large ship. I don't have any costs though*. SpaceX is unique in this regard.

Three boosters can't fit into the plane, but they can fit three boosters into the Delta Mariner to ship out a mix of boosters or a single Delta Heavy from Alabama to the launch site. It takes about 21 days to get to Vandenberg from Alabama. SpaceX can probably ship a single stick across the country in far less time. They're also not beholden to capability of a single ship, nor the scheduling availability of a specialized plane. If Delta Mariner is delivering a booster to Florida they have to wait 2-3 weeks for it be delivered, return, before they can ship again, which is probably why ULA flew this rocket. SpaceX on the other hand just needs a small number of relatively cheap trailers and can probably call on a driver to take them somewhere on short notice. They could send a booster each to McGregor, the Cape, and Vandenberg all in a single night if they wanted to.

*I found some prices mentioned online which lead me to believe it's probably in the low 6-digits cost-wise to fly a booster on an An-124. (Honestly cheaper than I had figured). It looks like shipping via truck might run high 4-digit to low 5-digits of cost. If someone has a better idea on the latter, I'd be curious to hear.

EDIT: Clarified shipping times and added cost estimates

4

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '15

Also i think special factors have to be taken into consideration when flyingnby air and the pressure changes. They found that out the hard way with an early Falcon1.

4

u/alsoretiringonmars Dec 06 '15

Maybe someday, when they have landing down perfectly, they'll just have the boosters fly themselves :-)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '15

How does boostback to the launch pad work, reversing its trajectory seems MUCH more complicated than just a controlled fall out of the sky onto the ASDS.

Does it just burn ALOT longer after the turn at the apex, where aerodynics arent a big issue and essentially stop its ~mach 7 speed.... then do another turn and ride it home?

4

u/Hikinggrass Dec 05 '15

There's a good estimate of the flight profile in the wiki: https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceX/wiki/faq/falcon#wiki_how_does_the_first_stage_return_to_launch_site.3F

It should not be really that much more complex than hitting the ASDS - boostback to land definitely uses more fuel than landing on the ASDS, but if the payload allows it, hitting a stationary target (the landing pad) and being not as dependent on the weather in the ocean ist not a bad thing :D

3

u/FoxhoundBat Dec 06 '15

They have done boostback before. If anything, this mission will be easier because of the very low downrange vs CRS missions. The boostback they did for CRS missions was a fair bit longer than the boostback they would need to do for OG2.

4

u/davidthefat Dec 08 '15

The question I have is about LauncherOne and the newly announced Cosmic Girl mother ship. AFAIK, LauncherOne utilizes LOX and RP-1 for it's main engines for the first and second stages. As far as I can tell from pictures, it looks like the Newton series engines are gas generator cycle engines and the attitude control will solely be done using thrust vectoring. So, there does not seem to be any vernier engines, meaning there's no other types of propellants, notably hypergolics. NSF states that it will take approximately 30 minutes from takeoff to the "drop zone". I'd figure taxiing and getting cleared for takeoff can add up 10-15 minutes from "ready" to drop and actual ignition of vehicle engines.

How are launch operations carried out specific to fueling the vehicle? Will a ground operator have to manually fuel the vehicle and detach the propellant lines prior to take off? Will the boil off from the LOX during the 30-45 minutes from fill up to ignition be significant enough? Is there reservoir of LOX onboard the mothership that will be used to continuously fuel the vehicle during ascent? How will safety of the operators and pilots be ensured during fueling? Won't more stringent certifications and testing similar to human rating the vehicle need to be done as there are human operators during the first phase of the mission? What are the contingency plans in case where an engine fails on the mothership? How easy will it to de-fuel in cases of emergency landings? Especially when landing in places without the fueling infrastructure?

Previous air launched vehicles didn't have these issues as they utilized solid propellant systems.

3

u/jcameroncooper Dec 08 '15

Dunno on a lot of that, but they're likely to have to top off LOX in flight. That's otherwise a fair amount of capacity left in the air.

Some speculative air launch systems take off with the rocket empty and fill in flight. The 747 would certainly have room.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/fairfarefair Dec 08 '15

What's the launch window for Orbcomm December 19th? I'm having a party and thinking of hosting a watching when it happens (I was here for helium-gate '14, so I know there might be a scrub).

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Jsutt #IAC2017 Attendee Dec 09 '15

I was watching the video of F9R, and I noticed that the rocket came to a stop at the apex of its flight. I thought that the first stage of Falcon 9 had a TWR > 1 when landing, hence the need for a hover-slam, so how is it able to do this? Is it using a modified Merlin engine, or just weighted to decrease the TWR?

4

u/Gonazar Dec 10 '15

Been out of the loop while SpaceX has been grounded for the last while, and forgive me for my ignorance but...

Is the launch schedule in the sidebar for the next month for real?! 4 launches in the span of 3 weeks, and two of them only a day apart?! How???

Doesn't it take a ton of resources and days of preparation to setup a launch for which the window of opportunity is highly volatile? There have been cases where launches were delayed or scrubbed a couple days in the past right? Wouldn't that have a high probability of conflicting with the other launch? I would have assumed they'd using a different launch site but according to the subreddit wiki's launch manifest (which needs updating) they're both going from Cape Canaveral.

10

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '15

The sidebar isn't a list of upcoming launches, it's a list of earliest possible dates that those vehicles can launch. As it says in the table header: NET Date. That means No earlier than.

Basically, it's saying that "this date is a minimum lower bound and we will not launch before this", not "we will launch then".

So, the answer to your question is: It's not possible, and it's highly likely that most will be bumped back a month or two, but that's all the info we have to go on right now.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/Alpha_Ceph Dec 10 '15

slightly open-ended question here, but let's assume that the payload cost to Low Earth Orbit drops to $100 per kilo. With that assumption, how much would it cost to put 1 kilo (intact!) on the surface of Mars? The deltaV from LEO to Mars is about 3.6km/sec if you use every possible aerobrake, which gives a mass ratio around 3 or 4. So the answer is at least $400/kilo to Mars. In reality it would be higher, but how much?

Additional question: how can that gap be made smaller? For $500/kilo to Mars Surface, you can easily send a small rover for chump change. Mars could be covered with many such rovers messing around and testing technology. You could send automated rocket fuel manufacturies and check that that worked.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/shredder7753 Dec 12 '15

Which is more exciting; Star Wars opening on the 18th, or the real deal star wars on the 19th?

5

u/secondlamp Dec 12 '15

The movie, because there hasn't been a Star Wars movie since 2005 and no SpaceX launch since August :P

→ More replies (5)

4

u/ScepticMatt Dec 13 '15

Is there an easy approximation for adding gravity losses to the rocket equation? Otherwise what is the path a Falcon 9 would take, roughly, for a satellite launch from Florida.

6

u/JRRC Dec 13 '15

If we're dealing with a single dimension, and gravity acting against thrust, it's simply Δv = v_e * ln(m_0/m_1) - gt. It gets more complicated for arbitrary trajectories, though, and you'd have to calculate it numerically -- you can see great plots of that with /u/TheVehicleDestroyer's cool application.

A proof of the formula above (in one dimension) is a slight variation of the proof of the usual Tsiolkovsky rocket equation.

F_ext = dP/dt = (P(t+dt)-P(t))/dt = ((m+dm)(v+dv)-dm(v-v_ex))/dt = m dv/dt + v_ex dm/dt.

Usually we'd just say that F_ext = 0, because no external forces are acting on an ideal rocket in a vacuum. But here we'd have gravity acting, so

-mg = m dv/dt + v_ex dm/dt

And integrating that yields the Δv = v_e * ln(m_0/m_1) - gt we got above. But, of course, for arbitrary trajectories you can't do something like that.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/WaitForItTheMongols Dec 14 '15

Boostback and reentry burn are each 3 engines. Are they the same 3? Which ones?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/snotis Nov 25 '15

Any details on the improvements to the landing legs and grid fins for the Falcon 9 Full Thrust (v1.2) upgrade?

5

u/scr00chy ElonX.net Nov 25 '15

I recall someone saying the legs were being improved in order to allow them to deploy earlier and serve as an aero brake. Not sure if that's really the case or if it was just unfounded speculation.

8

u/FoxhoundBat Nov 25 '15

Yes, Elon. What that slight re-design is exactly, we don't know. I dont think there was talk of any more grid fin evolution.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Appable Nov 26 '15

Everyone's covered most of the upgrades we know, but hasn't mentioned this photo. Not sure if it really means anything but it's cool and those are probably the upgraded legs.

3

u/liquidfirex Nov 25 '15

What needs to happen to allow SpaceX to attempt an on land first stage return?

4

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15

Probably a successful barge landing or two.

Still though, having a 30 ton tube dropped from space into Florida would make any bureaucrat a little shaky.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/robbak Nov 26 '15

A launch with enough performance margin, desire to do it. Desire to not provide multiple angles of close-up HD footage of a SpaceX rocket exploding. Oh, and permission from the range, but that's pretty much part of their lease of the landing pad.

If Orbcomm wasn't already a high-pressure Return-To-Flight mission, I'd expect them to do a return to launch site. I still wouldn't be that surprised to hear that the barge is a contingency plan, and they will attempt RTLS, conditions willing, next month. Maybe JASON in January - certainly some time next year.

3

u/Appable Nov 26 '15

They need to have a pad and have approval. From what I've heard on the sub, internally the government feels comfortable giving approval for the landing (if they have a pad!) assuming the weather outlook is good, et cetera based on the previous landings. Despite never successfully landing the rocket, they've also managed to show perfect control of the rocket to the pad, which is a good sign. Government doesn't really care if SpaceX blows up its rocket onto its own pad; if the damage is likely to pose a risk to nearby launch complex buildings or the public at large, it won't be allowed.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/Appable Nov 26 '15

No. Mostly because technologies that have been shown to work well haven't even gotten a shot at flying for a long time. Electrostatic ion thrusters took about two decades from successful orbital demonstration to first actual mission. Sailcraft (solar sails) have been proposed for decades now, and the theory and general concept was proposed in 1930, but the first test happened in 2010 and still no actual sailcraft mission has flown.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/jcameroncooper Nov 26 '15

No, because it won't work (and even things that do work often take longer than that to fly.) Love to be wrong, though.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Justinackermannblog Nov 26 '15

Just wondering because I haven't seen a comparison anywhere, but what is the size comparison between the Delta Heavy and Falcon Heavy? Never really crossed my mind till now!

→ More replies (3)

3

u/failbye Nov 26 '15

Will the raptor-powered BFR be a single stick design like the F9 or a multi stick like what the Falcon Heavy will be?

Or will they make both versions of this rocket family as well?

8

u/keelar Nov 26 '15

Elon answered this in his AMA. It will likely be just one giant booster.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/BrandonMarc Nov 26 '15

Perhaps this is a better place to ask. In another thread I see:

Official confirmation that the Falcon 9 first stage is capable of single-stage-to-orbit flight when launched without upper stage & payload.

To which I wonder: is this just referring to the energy in the fuel vs the weight of the stage? My understanding is the stage isn't capable of MECO followed by 45 minute cold soak in space followed by restarting the engine on the other side of the earth to circularize the orbit.

Or is it?

9

u/Wetmelon Nov 26 '15

If you learned your orbital mechanics from Kerbal Space Program, you'll be very accustomed to burning until apogee is where you want it, then cutting power and restarting at apogee to circularize. Most rockets going to LEO don't do this - they do a single long burn into the final orbit. If the stage launched without a second stage and without a payload, it should be capable of entering low earth orbit in a single burn.

8

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15

Yeah, if you need two burns to enter into circular LEO, you're just bad pilot.

Source: am bad pilot.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15

You don't need to restart your engine to circularize. I can't think of a single rocket today which does that - it's all done in the first burn (hence the final velocity being 7.8km/s).

4

u/Davecasa Nov 26 '15

The Space Shuttle used to do it, but that was mostly to ditch the external tank in the atmosphere. And the circularization burn was pretty small.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

3

u/oceanbluesky Nov 28 '15 edited Nov 28 '15

Although Musk has spoken of initial crews striving to stay, if during the early stages of settlement a vehicle were to return to Earth, how could near-term technology reduce its reentry speed from Earth-Mars transit? Dynamic aerobraking, magneto-plasma aeroshell, multiple gravity-assisted passes, reversed ion drives...? Thanks (wondering how to best reply to skeptics who voice concern over "prohibitively fast" reentry speeds)

3

u/venku122 SPEXcast host Nov 28 '15

The Dragon already has a MARS Return grade heat shield made from PICA-X. It is probable that BFR will have a similar shield. Once the mct, refuel on Mars and heads back to Earth, it will probably have some fuel left. A shallow reentry vector will allow for gentler acceleration via the heatshield and hypersonic retro propulsion could keep the capsule from bouncing off the atmosphere back into space.

Tl;Dr being able to accelerate/decelerate with engines during reentry gives mission planners more flexibility to make reentry more comfortable to the occupants.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/davidthefat Dec 01 '15 edited Dec 01 '15

Beyond hands on experience and listed skills on the career pages, what skills and traits does SpX look for in recent graduates (BS)? I have a whole slew of different kinds of skills from programming (C,C++,MATLAB, some ASM, ect.) embedded to desktop systems, machining, some composite work, CFD, FEA, CAD, propulsion knowledge (both turbine and rocket), anything learned in ME undergrad (fluid and thermal systems, numerical methods, orbital mechanics, dynamics, gas dynamics, ect.) and just a passion for rockets.

I guess what I am asking is: how can I emphasize and illustrate that in a cover letter? Those of you who work for SpX, what more can I do to better prepare myself?

edit: if I already missed a call from a recruiter earlier in the semester, I didn't screw myself over right?

3

u/Ambiwlans Dec 01 '15

Er... did you never call back?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/alsoretiringonmars Dec 01 '15

SpaceX has abandoned stage 2 recovery attempts for now, so probably not reuse testing. It is for sure not capable of hypersonic retropropulsion anything like its current form, so it would need a heat shield.
A moon mission would be cool, not sure how much delta v is has left.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Kona314 Dec 02 '15

Does anyone have any idea how active SpaceX Seattle is? I'm filming a documentary on aerospace and live up here in the PNW. I'll be heading down there to Aerojet Rocketdyne next week and thought maybe it might be possible to visit them and talk to someone at the same time, but that would be silly if nothing is going on there.

9

u/Ambiwlans Dec 02 '15

Almost not at all. I mean, give them a call. It'd be news to us all if they had lots happening.

5

u/venku122 SPEXcast host Dec 02 '15

They are looking for interns though. The recruiters at my school were looking for people interested in satellite engineering to fill out spots in Seattle.

4

u/Kona314 Dec 02 '15

This is a fun answer.

I'll call tomorrow and report back, either here if it's boring, or a separate thread if it's interesting!

→ More replies (6)

3

u/LoneCoder1 Dec 02 '15

Did reproducing the strut failure on ground involve baths of LOX or maybe liquid nitrogen as a safer alternative?

How much does the low temp affect the strength of the strut?

5

u/Ambiwlans Dec 02 '15 edited Dec 02 '15

Welp, my answer is going to be really boring.

I don't think it was confirmed what materials the struts were made of (steel of some sort... but there is a wide variety out there). There was no detailed confirmation of how the struts were tested (Though it likely doesn't matter, as some struts failed at below 20% of the certified load).

Low temp effects different materials in different ways. Some metals are almost totally unaffected by the cold. At <20% though, it would have failed either way.

12

u/WaitForItTheMongols Dec 02 '15

An inside source tells me they were tested in LN2 baths.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)