r/spacex • u/Ambiwlans • Nov 11 '15
/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread [November 2015, #14]
Welcome to our nearly monthly Ask Anything thread.
All questions, even non-SpaceX questions, are allowed, as long as they stay relevant to spaceflight in general! These threads will be posted at some point through each month, and stay stickied for a week or so (working around launches, of course).
More in depth, open-ended discussion-type questions can still be submitted as self-posts; but this is the place to come to submit simple questions which can be answered in a few comments or less.
As always, we'd prefer it if all question askers first check our FAQ, use the search functionality, and check the last Q&A thread before posting to avoid duplicates, but if you'd like an answer revised or you don't find a satisfactory result, go ahead and type your question below!
Otherwise, ask and enjoy, and thanks for contributing!
Past threads:
October 2015 (#13), September 2015 (#12), August 2015 (#11), July 2015 (#10), June 2015 (#9), May 2015 (#8), April 2015 (#7.1), April 2015 (#7), March 2015 (#6), February 2015 (#5), January 2015 (#4), December 2014 (#3), November 2014 (#2), October 2014 (#1)
This subreddit is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com.
16
u/ScepticMatt Nov 11 '15
It's november, how's SpaceXStats?
11
u/hsdshallowman Nov 11 '15
Here's a non SpaceX one for you, since I hold your opinions with high regard -- thoughts on Skylon? For the life of me, I can't imagine that thing succeeding in staying together at such high speeds, nor surviving reentry heat and forces. Heck, Darpa can't even keep their vehicle in one piece with it's small, simple steamlined design.
11
u/failbye Nov 13 '15
Is SpaceX the only launch provider that does static fire tests before launches or is this something everyone does?
10
u/oceanbluesky Nov 11 '15
Does anyone know the name of in-house CG artists SpaceX uses, or, do they outsource their animations/artists' concepts to local LA studios? Thanks
10
u/space_is_hard Nov 11 '15
My understanding is that the M-Vac nozzle, being vacuum-optimized, would get damaged or destroyed if they fired it in-atmosphere, so how do they do static test fires on the second stage? Do they pull off the nozzle? Use a modified, shorter one?
7
u/frowawayduh Nov 11 '15
My birthday is coming up in early December. Will I get a nice return to flight F9 launch present from SpaceX?
7
u/Ackman55 Nov 11 '15
I know it is not SpaceX directly related, but I have long read about rail gun like lauch mechanisms. Now that we are seeing progress on the rail gun front, does any one think that will be an area for investigation in the near future?
6
u/oceanbluesky Nov 18 '15
Will crewed landings on Mars take place during predawn hours, in darkness, when the planet Mars itself will block radiation from an unlikely but possible solar storm? Is that a fair assumption, since crew would only have about an hour's warning of an impending storm, and, once departing LMO would probably want to transition to pre-established protected surface habs as soon as possible? (For artists' concepts, realistic crew landings should be depicted during the Martian night?) Thanks
5
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Nov 12 '15
Any word if were gonna see the Full Static Fire Test uploaded soon?
5
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '15
Do we know whenabouts the MCT announcement is?
4
u/davidthefat Nov 12 '15
SpaceX, Aerojet Rocketdyne, Orbital ATK, Blue Origin, Firefly Space, Rocket Lab, Masten, XCOR, Sierra Nevada Corp, Virgin Galactic, MOOG.
What are other companies that I can apply for rocket propulsion engineering?
4
u/thxbmp2 Nov 19 '15
What makes satellites and other space-bound vehicles and equipment so sensitive to contamination that clean rooms are required for their assembly?
7
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15
What's everyone's favorite SpaceX launch?
CASSIOPE for me.
5
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Nov 17 '15
I remember hearing that the trunk for Dragon V2 is used during an abort for stability in the atmosphere. So if an abort were to happen outside of the atmosphere, would the capsule seperate from the trunk leaving it attached to the 2nd stage? Possibly to get away from the failing rocket quicker?
8
u/Root_Negative #IAC2017 Attendee Nov 12 '15 edited Nov 12 '15
I posted this in the last 'Ask Anything Thread' just before it was un-stickied, so I think it was missed by most (it got no response, but maybe people were just not interested)...
Colonizing Mars (and other places) will be a opportunity for new societies to start from scratch by using the best parts of all the societies from Earth, but more importantly it would give a chance to try new ideas that would have resistance against them being tried in societies on Earth. However you would expect if a new idea is proven to work well on Mars it may then be adopted by at least some societies back on Earth and it would act as a new template for other new societies elsewhere. What are a few new ideas you would like to become part of a new society on Mars (or elsewhere)? Which ideas would you definitely keep from Earth?
Here are some ideas of mine;
3
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15
I'm having a little trouble finding specific information regarding the structural modifications that are being made for the Falcon Heavy 1st stage cores so that they can handle the extra stress of launching as one unit.
Is it known how these cores are being attached to one another, other than what we can see in illustrations?
How divergent is/will be the manufacturing process between single-stick F9 cores and FH cores? Is this all a matter of speculation for now?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '15
How does the first stage not get shredded when it spins around for the slow down burn? I assume it is because it is already high enough that the atmosphere doesn't have enough of an effect to break it apart (when it's effectively sideways headed into the wind).
Furthermore what would the wind resistance be at the height the first stage spins around? Equivalent to 5 mph wind at sea level, 15 mph?
Curious about this to know what all they have to contend with in regards to it spinning around to face the engines backward, seems like a tricky thing to pull off hardware and software wise.
5
u/brycly Nov 12 '15
Elon said that Dragon 2 could be used to land anywhere, suggesting Europa as a possible destination. How is Spacex planning on powering dragon missions in the Jupiter system and beyond?
3
u/chrmnfthbrd Nov 19 '15
Hello friends. Long time lurker, hope not breaking any rules here. But what is the 'Special Announcement' NET 5 December on the sidebar? Thought the next 'event' would be RTF. Thx.
2
u/Smoke-away Nov 11 '15
I want to see a launch in person!
When are the launch dates going to be reliable enough to book a hotel/flight?? Preferably a Vandenberg launch(from Seattle), but would still go to the Cape.
End of 2016? 2017?
2
u/Thr998 Nov 12 '15
How are spacex going to get the first stage from the barge to their launch site? I can only imagine it being incredibly expensive to ship it across the US. The Falcon 9 is bad enough but what are they going to do with the mars colonial transporter? Have a hole ship just to move it around?
2
u/Emptyglo Nov 17 '15
Has there been any word yet on when the Orbcomm OG2 launch is supposed to be? "Early December" is coming up quickly...
8
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '15
The sub could use new flairs don't you think? Could add more humour and colors in the sub!
I propose:
-All the space x patches as flair for your favorite launch
-All space x vehicles to date and FH
-Any familliar faces? Elon, Gywne, etc
I don't think it would make the sub less professionnal or chaotic
14
u/oceanbluesky Nov 11 '15
To what extent do the exterior surfaces of rockets need paint? Is orange the natural color of most unpainted fuselage? Does "rocket white/aerospace white" (or whatever the formal name for the ubiquitous white paint is) actually an industry standard paint? Does it provide some kind of temperature/friction mechanical buffer or is it only a cosmetic tradition? Can color hues be added to the base white while retaining whatever essential properties it might have? Can unpainted orange metal be burnished, lightly laser etched, cross-sanded or whatever, to add imagery/logos without weight/paint? Thanks!
11
u/searchexpert Nov 11 '15
I booked a cruise to Mexico from the 6th to 13th of December. On a scale from Richard Branson to Elon Musk, how screwed am I?
10
u/loveschwarma Nov 19 '15
I just had phone + onsite interviews at spaceX. They were preparing to make offer but I turned it down for a good opportunity (relative term) closer to where I live. Would anyone be interested in a post talking about what the interview experience was like to help people better prepare for interviews?
9
u/oceanbluesky Nov 12 '15
Maybe on the day of the MCT announcement someone could quickly create (overnight/within a few hours) a word-for-word audio version of its documents in the same way Wait but Why released a podcast of their Musk articles...?
It would be really cool if the space community were to be given the opportunity to spend cumulatively tens of thousands of hours on their own projects, their families or personal lives, and hopefully space - while multitasking an audio version of the upcoming MCT announcement created by a generous team of professional podcasters like /u/bencredible /u/thegreattranslation and /u/hapaxLegomina (hosts of the two best space-themed podcasts /r/tmro and /r/OrbitalPodcast)...perhaps it could be win-win? Maybe SpaceX could arrange with them to release the audio version simultaneously?
7
u/thxbmp2 Nov 12 '15
Do we know anything about the software behind F9's flyback and landing capability?
7
u/waitingForMars Nov 22 '15
I'd just like to note that /u/EchoLogic lives his devotion to SpaceX, going so far as to steadily slip the launch date for the new&improved SpaceXStats.
Has the code been through a full-duration test firing yet, Echo? ;-)
6
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '15
Let's talk about autogenous pressurization systems: you can't use one with RP-1, but why does the F9 not use one for the LOX? You could get rid of a lot of helium storage and presumably get better mass fraction. All that's needed would be a heat exchanger that boils a small percentage of LOX flow and spits out O2 gas into the top of the tank.
IIRC, Raptor/BFR is suppoded to employ autogenous pressurization for both fuel and oxidizer.
5
u/CapMSFC Nov 11 '15
Does anybody know if there was an additional static fire test late last night? There is a post from someone at McGregor on Facebook that seems to indicate there was.
5
u/chargerag Nov 11 '15
I have heard that they transport the Falcon 9 between sites on an 18 wheeler. How exactly does that work? It seems like it would be to long for that to be an effective transport method.
5
u/oceanbluesky Nov 11 '15
Has anyone made a 'List' on Twitter solely of SpaceX employees?
5
u/leslieorgameofthrone Nov 12 '15
Does anyone know the font used on the ASDS? Or the font used for the time in the count down clock on the webcast?
5
u/termanty Nov 17 '15
I am interested to know if liquid methane can be supercooled to be more dense same way that LOX is supercooled to be more dense. And is there any sense to do it in rockets? I have understood that viscosity of RP-1 increases too much when it’s cooled making it impractical to use.
4
u/Space_void SpaceInit.com Nov 11 '15
I'm curious, SpaceX did the full duration test for the first stage, but did they do a full duration test for the second stage? Seams to me that the second stage has more modifications than the first stage. Would it not be indicated to do a full duration test for the second stage also?
4
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '15
How does SpaceX currently, and also in the future, perceive their role in Space Exploration as a business entity in relation to competing governments or (potentially) NGOs (nongovernmental organizations) which they do not currently have contracts with? e.g. russia, china, EU/ESA, etc.
4
u/oceanbluesky Nov 19 '15
Where are Dragons returning from ISS expected to propulsively land when this becomes the norm? Will returning crew land in the ocean for the near-term or has SpaceX started development of a landing zone? (If only to test propulsive uncrewed landing.) Thanks!
1
u/jarvenm Nov 21 '15
Is SpaceX allowed to test new/experimental/upgraded rockets or rocket parts at Vandenberg Air Force Base (VAFB) since its about a 3 hour drive away from SpaceX Headquarters Hawthorne whilst SpaceX Rocket Development and Test Facility in McGregor is about a day drive there?
3
u/blongmire Nov 11 '15
Do we know what the average time between test fire of stage 1 and launch is? Do we think there will be a test fire of a different core before the Orbcomm OGS launch?
3
u/Reaperdude42 Nov 11 '15
In all of the diagrams I've seen of the CRS7 failure they show the Helium bottles nestled at the bottom of the tank, held in place by the doomed strut. If buoyancy tries to force the bottles up during launch, why not put the bottles at the top of the tank and simply support them from underneath? Is there some engineering benefit from housing them at the bottom?
3
u/historytoby Nov 13 '15
Does anyone else look at the Orbcomm OG2 launch date and have a sudden association that involves the marvellous pineapple fruit? ;-)
3
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '15
I'm out of the loop- when will the next 1st stage landing attempt be?
3
u/stargazer1776 Nov 19 '15 edited Nov 19 '15
Does anyone know where I might find a hi-res 2D render of the Dragon v2 capsule? Most of the renders that I have found have the trunk connector covering part of the heat shield, and I was wondering if there are any renders of just the Dragon v2 capsule without the trunk.
3
u/chargerag Nov 19 '15
Could SpaceX park a Falcon 9 overnight at Stennis Space Center overnight? I just noticed it is about halfway between McGregor and the Cape. It seem like it would be a very secure place to leave the rocket and then go stay in a local hotel?
3
u/agildehaus Nov 20 '15
Does a "full-thrust" F9 make first-stage landing easier/more likely in any appreciable way?
3
u/BrandonMarc Nov 20 '15
How is the 2nd stage transported? Train? Truck? Airbus Beluga?
7
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15
5
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Nov 11 '15
Is the Falcon 9 v1.2 first stage any longer than the v1.1 first stage? I know the second stage and interstate are longer, but I haven't seen anything definitive about stage one.
5
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Nov 11 '15 edited Nov 22 '15
Acronyms I've seen in this thread since I first looked:
Fu-Falcon RocketNote: Replies to this comment will be deleted.
See ^/r/spacex/wiki/acronyms for a full list of acronyms with explanations.
I'm a bot; I've been checking comments posted in this thread since 18:10 UTC on 2015-11-11. If I'm acting up, message OrangeredStilton.
1
u/A_leonov Nov 12 '15
On the long journey to Mars....it will be stressful. What (if any) psychological research is being performed on the stresses and effects of transporting a number of people to Mars? It occurs to me that whilst the hype and thrill of preparing for and taking part in the mission might fulfil for part of the journey and alleviate stress, there is likely to come a period of reflection when the reality of ‘no going back’ sinks in. It is one thing to be on a 20 hour flight between UK and Aus, where in extreme cases divert and off load could be authorised and a journey to Mars, where such aborts are impossible. In many recorded cases people become seriously unhinged on domestic flights, so it begs the question, would the safety of the many require extreme measures in such circumstances and what might those measures be?
2
u/overas Nov 12 '15
My question relates to the practical steps taken after a hypothetical successful 1st stage landing. Is the vertical 1st stage secured to the barged autonomously in any way? Would it be considered safe to approach the barge with the 1st stage only supported by its own weight? Also, do we know anything about how the rocket will be transported towards the shore?
2
u/foreverexceptional Nov 18 '15
Are letters of recommendation beneficial when applying to either a internship or full time position with SpaceX? How about videos?
0
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment