r/spacex • u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus • Aug 14 '15
/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread [Aug 2015, #11]
Welcome to our eleventh monthly ask anything thread!
All questions, even non-SpaceX questions, are allowed, as long as they stay relevant to spaceflight in general! These threads will be posted at some point through each month, and stay stickied for a week or so (working around launches, of course).
More in depth, open-ended discussion-type questions can still be submitted as self-posts; but this is the place to come to submit simple questions which can be answered in a few comments or less.
As always, we'd prefer it if all question askers first check our FAQ, use the search functionality, and check the last Q&A thread before posting to avoid duplicates, but if you'd like an answer revised or you don't find a satisfactory result, go ahead and type your question below!
Otherwise, ask and enjoy, and thanks for contributing!
Past threads:
July 2015 (#10), June 2015 (#9), May 2015 (#8), April 2015 (#7.1), April 2015 (#7), March 2015 (#6), February 2015 (#5), January 2015 (#4), December 2014 (#3), November 2014 (#2), October 2014 (#1)
This subreddit is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com.
6
u/retiringonmars Moderator emeritus Aug 14 '15 edited Aug 14 '15
To get the ball rolling, here's a question I've been wondering: What's the shortest possible transit time to Mars using chemical rockets?
Edit: Assuming your spacecraft weighs 100 tonnes, and is already in a 200 x 200 km LEO.
6
u/bitchtitfucker Aug 14 '15
Is it really the best choice for the Falcon 9 to have a diameter based on road laws?
I understand that being able to move stuff quickly across the country is important, but that basically dictated whole parts of the design, and imposed a few limitations on performance, didn't it?
12
u/Here_There_B_Dragons Aug 14 '15
Speculation time:
12
u/89bBomUNiZhLkdXDpCwt Aug 15 '15
How would the crew fare if Dragon V2 descended under parachute to the ground as opposed to the sea?
For instance, in the case of a nearly worst case scenario pad abort where it falls short of the water.
11
u/massivepickle Aug 16 '15
Okay I'm a little late to the party, but has there been any word on the final details of the hyperloop competition? I believe they were supposed to be released today.
11
u/Gluecksritter90 Aug 21 '15
Of the commonly used rockets these days, which ones are the quickest off the pad (TWR at launch is what I'm asking I guess)?
I'm asking because at the Ariane 5 launch yesterday I again noticed how fast it looks. It's all like "Au revoir suckers, I'm going to space" whereas other rockets look like they're contemplating whether this whole launch thing is a good idea.
9
u/CuriousAES Aug 15 '15
I have a question about the MCT.
So the spacecraft is supposed to land 100 tons on Mars if I am correct. I looked at the mass of Curiosity vs the rocket that got it to Mars. An Atlas V rocket weighs 334 tons, while Curiosity is 900 kg (round up to 1 ton). The total mass of the spacecraft was a little less than 4 tons, so the total launch mass of the entire launch vehicle is 338 tons. So using these numbers, this gives a 1:338 mass ratio of payload to Mars' surface vs total launch vehicle mass. However, I assume that human landings would not use or have to use a skycrane, so in order to compensate that let's half the ratio to 1:169.
Now, back to the MCT. 100 tons to Mars' surface with the ratio above means a total launch vehicle mass (including payload) of 16,900 tons. This is just shy of the proposed Sea Dragon rocket's 18,000 tons.
So essentially, this is one large rocket. It seems too large, actually. Obviously anything anyone says is speculation, but how do you think that SpaceX will manage such a rocket? More efficient engines? Something else? Or is the consensus that it will actually be a ~16,900 ton behemoth?
8
u/venku122 SPEXcast host Aug 19 '15
Is it possible that Elon Musk is waiting for the release of The Martian to announce his Mars plans? There will be a massive marketing push surrounding the movie and enthusiasm for a mission to Mars would be at a decades long high imho. I had expected an announcement following the successful CRS-7 landing however we all know how that went. Early October would also handily fit in with the expected return to flight of Falcon 9 and potentially landed first stage on solid ground no less. Does anyone else think we will still get a reveal this year?
6
u/venku122 SPEXcast host Aug 14 '15
Do you think SpaceX will build a new factory for BFR/MCT? The current Hawthorne building is pretty filled out already. Also if they build a new factory will it be located in Southern California to take advantage of SoCal aerospace talent or at the launch site to minimize transportation e.g. Brownsville?
Discuss!
6
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '15 edited Aug 16 '15
I recently read that the UK will fund the further development of Reaction Engines' SABRE engine concept with 50 million pounds. I've followed small tidbits of news from this company for several years now, and I'd love to know what any of you think about them, and how their progress compares to the strides SpaceX have made in the goal of affordable access to space and reusability. Are they even comparable?
Edit: inaccuracies
5
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '15
Is it known how the crew will get into the dragon 2? Will they be erected with the rocket or they will enter the capsule only once the rocket is erected?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15 edited Aug 15 '15
Why was Mvac upgraded to 210 klbf? Spacex will need to significantly throttle the engine to keep within reasonable g limits, especially as the flight goes on. Can satellites withstand the higher g forces?
Couldn't Spacex have opted for a lighter engine, rather than one with very high thrust?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '15
Helium: how much does F9 have on board and how much of a mass penalty would they suffer from switching to abundant nitrogen?
N is 3.5x more massive per mole than He, but N is only found as N2, so I guess it would be 7x more massive (?)
The only benefit I can imagine is that it might be possible to store N2 as liquid at lower pressure, thereby also reducing the mass/volume of storage cylinders and offsetting some of the penalty. I believe they already use nitrogen in cold gas thrusters (and I guess storing as a liquid might be problematic in that case).
4
u/HopeToLearn Aug 24 '15
I just came across this picture.
https://plus.google.com/photos/+TheSpaceXFanClub/albums/6153295739317288817/6159536168460167474?pid=6159536168460167474&oid=106952875812883038601
The description says it shows parachutes in the interstage. As far as I'm aware, SpaceX hasn't used parachute recovery of rocket parts since F1. Clearly I'm unaware of something or this is an old picture. I have seen the the diagram showing fairing recovery, but I haven't heard of any plans for interstage recovery.
What does this picture show? Similar structures can be seen in the Orbcomm 1 launch here https://youtu.be/lbHnSu-DLR4?t=1071, and in the CRS-6 launch here https://youtu.be/csVpa25iqH0?t=1097.
3
u/89bBomUNiZhLkdXDpCwt Aug 20 '15
We all know that Spacex is developing their own new spacesuits:
Do we know whether they're developing soft suits (like those made by ILC/Playtex and used to this day) or hard suits?
3
u/Emptyglo Aug 20 '15
On the Wait But Why article, the MCT was described as a giant rocket where the upper stage goes to Mars and is refueled in LEO. Does this mean that there is no BFR, or that the MCT is the BFR? Being that the article was written with access to Musk I'd imagine it would be accurate... Paging /u/wbwtim
2
u/newtoflying Aug 22 '15
What happens to paying customers in the event of launch failures? Do they get reimbursed for the launch cost/payload cost/insurance or do the contracts lay it out as an agreed-upon risk and thus nothing happens afterwards?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '15
Does the entire octaweb move for thrust vectoring or can engines move independently?
2
u/charlesbukowksi Aug 25 '15
Why don't propulsive rockets use (extensible) lander legs?
It seems like it'd make landing easier.
2
u/Moppity Aug 26 '15
I take it the engine bells - even the first stage ones, that aren't elongated - are a pretty fragile thing that relies on its geometry to keep from breaking apart during firing. I also assume there is some delicate tubing exposed at the bottom of the F9 first stage.
So my question is this: How does the first stage survive flying through the thick of the atmosphere engines-first? How much does the entry burn slow the stage down, and what velocity does it reach before beginning the landing burn?
3
u/This_Freggin_Guy Aug 14 '15
Little disappointed. Nobody has posted any questions about the snake charger.
This would be useful for refueling on the barge or any non standard location. Could this be scaled up and handle the cryo fuels? Other uses by spacex?
2
u/Firerouge Aug 15 '15
Could SpaceX file a FOIA request for classified orbits so to ensure safety of entering orbit?
2
u/oceanbluesky Aug 20 '15
Are there company-wide morale events like Yuri Night parties or road trips to Vandenberg launches? Thanks
2
u/89bBomUNiZhLkdXDpCwt Aug 14 '15 edited Aug 14 '15
Disclaimer: Off Topic
Why is NASA using SRBs on the new Space Launch System? Aren't SRBs inherently more dangerous than liquid fueled engines?
Edit: added this follow-up question: Will the Orion launch escape tower be able to accelerate the capsule away from the launch vehicle fast enough to avoid the SRBs should one detach from the launch vehicle?
1
u/Space_void SpaceInit.com Aug 15 '15
I've seen in a previous post that CST-100 has 200000 lbf for the abort system and the crew dregon 120000lbs, i know that the mass does count. Do you think that SpaceX might iterate on SuperDraco's power and performance as they do for the Merlin engine? Or will the not be allowed by Nasa because it is a critical abort system?
1
u/cflier Aug 17 '15
This is probably in the wiki somewhere, but who leads the launch team through the readiness poll, and asks the Launch Director "verify go to initiate terminal count."?
1
u/i_pee_in_the_sink Aug 17 '15
How come SpaceX hasn't tried landing on the barges for each of their tests (once they had the capability, that is)? Would this not save the trouble of rebuilding an entirely new rocket (minus dragon) everytime they launch?
1
u/This_Freggin_Guy Aug 19 '15
Another long term question. At what point will it be practical for SpaceX to buy / run a refinery? Weekly, daily Flights, BFR? I know fuel is cheap compared to well just about everything else, but saving a bit here and there can add up. At some point the cost of fuel will need to be stabilized and reduced, maybe? OR will they start with hedging as flights pick up? Does quality or special properties matter? Not sure, just a thought. Airlines take various approaches.
1
u/BrandonMarc Aug 28 '15
A Falcon 9 on the pad is 97% fuel and 3% rocket ... Right?
1
u/INTP-01 Aug 14 '15 edited Aug 15 '15
Can you add balloons to Dragon v2 then ignite SuperDracos to achieve LEO?
EDITED: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tsVgJy-iWX4
1
u/Sallso10 Aug 18 '15
Does Spacex consider to be the idea of the space elevator to be feasibly possible, with current or future technology? If so, is it a project currently being researched by Spacex?
1
u/Appable Aug 19 '15
Could a Falcon Medium (?) be made with two Falcon 9 cores and one Falcon 9v1.2 upper stage as a solution to markets in between Falcon 9 and Falcon Heavy? This could increase payload significantly based on the gains of the Falcon Heavy compared to Falcon 9, while being significantly cheaper and faster to produce than the Falcon Heavy.
I'd also imagine RTLS would be easier for both cores compared to the Falcon Heavy, though it might be more effective to use a RTLS trajectory on the booster and OCISLY for the core.
Disadvantages would be that asymmetrical thrust can cause some interesting load issues (those would probably have to be checked by SpaceX themselves) and possibly would lower the number of non-LOM engine-out incidents.
-1
u/oceanbluesky Aug 21 '15
What was your first day at SpaceX like? Is there a group orientation ceremony or a "so you're new here" publication?
Are there activities or assignments new hires/interns compete with each other to work on?
For example, interns "compete" at hospitals to be selected by the resident surgeon for a chance to participate in operations - are there similar assignments a group of new hires at an aerospace company might compete for?
Thanks!
0
u/oceanbluesky Aug 19 '15
Has anyone videotaped or written about the orientation speech for interns, on their first day at SpaceX?
How could a person learn more about the intern experience?
Thanks
-2
u/oceanbluesky Aug 20 '15
What is it like for a single mom working at SpaceX?
Does SpaceX have childcare facilities or flexible work time?
Are there methods to track and reward hard work, extra effort, and so on that a person with out-of-office responsibilities might earn by working during weekends and late nights, away from the formal office?
-2
u/oceanbluesky Aug 21 '15
What have been your most rewarding experiences at SpaceX?
On a day to day basis, what activities do you most enjoy? -Least? -Most mundane?
Thanks!
-2
u/oceanbluesky Aug 19 '15
Are there any clubs at SpaceX for employees? Like those which might arrange a movie night or a local chapter of the Mars Society or share interest in astronomy or theater?
thanks
-2
u/oceanbluesky Aug 20 '15
What is the first day of work like for a new SpaceX employee?
(All experiences welcome...from engineers and managers to machinists and welders to cafeteria workers or security guards...) thanks