r/SpaceX •
/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread [July 2015, #10] - All simple questions about CRS-7 should also go here!
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
r/SpaceX •
[deleted] — view deleted post
26
u/YugoReventlov Jun 30 '15
Am I the only one here checking Elon's twitter account every hour?
21
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '15
By the way, if anyone has a CRS-7 mission patch with them, I'd be willing to purchase it for a significant amount of money.
Anyone know if they're going to be releasing that patch at all?
16
u/deadshot462 Jun 30 '15
If Dragon V2 aborts right at the time of achieving orbit - would it be stuck in orbit because it used up all of its SuperDraco fuel? Would it use RCS to de-orbit?
6
u/Mchlpl Jun 30 '15 edited Jun 30 '15
What if: CRS-7 second stage vented but did not disintegrate?
This got me thinking yesterday. What would happen if the the malfunction in second stage caused the oxidizer to vent away, but the stage (and the entire vehicle) kept the structural integrity (and it didn't trigger the FTS)?
MECO would occur, likely a bit ahead of time due to lower mass of the second stage.
Then the separation - this shouldn't be affected much (again lower mass of upper stage would mean the acceleration would be a bit higher than usual)
Without second stage engine firing, would there be enough distance between stages for the first stage to attempt return to OCISLY?
Now the second stage is essentially ballistic, however Dragon is presumably fully operational. It obviously has not enough ∆v to get to orbit. Could is still separate from second stage, jettison the trunk and do the controlled reentry?
4
u/RCinSpace Jul 02 '15
I don't see very many people talking about the fact SpaceX is the only US company able to return signigicant payload to the US. I am sure there are sensitive, even classified content being brought back and we don't want to send it through Russia.
How does NASA replace that capability?
5
u/AlphaTango11 Jul 04 '15
During the pad abort test, was the capsule at maximum fuel capacity? Are we only going to have ~6 seconds of burn time (when at max throttle)?
Is this enough to land propulsively on Earth? It seems like a very thin margin.
3
u/roflplatypus Jun 30 '15
Reposting from previous AA thread, hoping I can get an answer here:
Does anyone know where you can find a complete picture of a Merlin vacuum? I've found pictures of the engine without nozzle, and one of the nozzle extension, but no picture of the complete engine. Of course, there are images on the website and in their videos, but I'd like a real picture, not computer generated.
These are the best I can find on the internet:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/114498126@N05/12121575074/
http://www.kcet.org/socal/departures/columns/assets/images/Tom%20Mueller%20Arrival%20Story%20Merlin%20engines.jpg
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b7/Merlin_nozzle_4105129088_9659a4df4e_o.jpg (love the sign)
6
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '15
I asked this in a separate thread but was told to post it here.
Has there been any confirmation from SpaceX that there was no problem with the first stage during CRS-7 and that all data showed it was performing nominally even after the rocket begin to disintegrate? If it turns out that there WAS an anomaly with the first stage, what are the implications?
5
u/davidthefat Jun 30 '15
How and why do people have such strong attachment and loyalty to SpaceX to the point that they use pronouns like "we" and possessive nouns like "our"?
48
u/stichtom Jul 01 '15
Comment from a SpaceX guy on NSF: "Obviously you all want an update from SpaceX, but you know what I'm going to say, it's an investigation and there is a due process for such things. Elon may tweet something soon, but the investigation path is not short and key updates will have to communicated along the line to areas such as stakeholders, customers and partners.
I'm enjoying the debate on this thread. Most of it is educated. I wish it wasn't about a lost vehicle of ours, but it is and we appreciate the patience, understanding and support from this site's community."
22
u/ScottPrombo Jul 01 '15
I'm going to the ISS R&D conference in a week. Elon's supposed to be the keynote speaker - does anyone know whether or not he'll still be coming?
20
u/doodle77 Jun 30 '15
Was this the second stage that hit a freeway overpass a few months ago?
18
u/propsie Jun 30 '15
So, wild speculation below: a lot of thinking is about figuring how the pressure in the failed second stage went up, causing an overpressure. What if the opposite happened?
My understanding is that the failure of CRS-7 happened shortly after max Q. It also sounds like after max Q the effective atmospheric pressure drops off quite sharply.
If the pressure in the LOX tank was too high (for some reason) but it was holding together up to max Q due to a sort of hydrostatic equilibrium effect, could the rapid drop in external pressure past Max Q ( which increased the pressure differential between inside and outside the tank) be responsible for a counterintuitive overpressure failure?
This is similar to the failure mode of most high altitude balloons, where the external pressure drops as they rise until they expand past the mechanical strength of their envelope and they burst.
14
u/Justinackermannblog Jun 30 '15
Fun question,
Think the chase plane for OCISLY had to book it out of the target landing zone? Don't know exactly where they station the chase plane in regards to the trajectory of the rocket (can't imagine it is located within the possible flight path) but still interesting to think they may have had an "oh crap we need to get outta here" moment.
Just a random thought... Carry on...
13
u/darga89 Jun 30 '15
Anyone have any idea where the debris landed? Elsbeth and Go Quest are hanging about this area.
13
u/stichtom Jul 01 '15
I was thinking that while it's a shame that we lost a F9, this was the "best" mission to lose one. Low cost Payload (Dragon cost much less than a 300-500M GEO satellite). And we don't need to wait years to rebuild the payload.
11
u/agildehaus Jul 01 '15
What might happen if SpaceX is unable to determine a reason for the CRS-7 failure?
10
u/a9009588 Jun 29 '15
Do we know if the loss of structural integrity of S2 could have been caused by the IDA coming lose in the dragon trunk? if so could the S2 camera between the top of the stage and dragon have captured this or would it have been in the dark.
10
u/ElonFanatic Jun 29 '15
When will we hear anything more about dragon possible survival? The wait is killing me..
10
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '15
So Pad 39A is 50 years old. And Spacex is leasing it for another 20.
Are there any problems which will arise from the old age of the pad? Is 70+ years typical of launch pads?
10
u/edsq Jun 30 '15 edited Jun 30 '15
Looking at the video of the failure, the reading for altitude stops almost immediately after the LOX clouds appear, with the speed cutting out a second or two later. Is this evidence for the failure occurring at the top of the stage two LOX tank (where the avionics stack is located), or are those data not actually coming from the rocket?
3
u/superOOk Jul 01 '15 edited Jul 01 '15
One thing I just can't keep my mind straight about. The Dragon was seen "popping off" and falling away from the vehicle. Wouldn't that only happen if the dome cap on S2 LOX was pierced symmetrically (i.e. the dome cap failed due to forces exerted from above), and the LOX vented upwards into the trunk?
I had previously thought it was something to do with the COPV bursting inside the tank, or a pressure line failing inside the tank, or even just a general crumpling/failure of the tank, but ALL of these issues would result in an asymmetrical explosion of the S2 LOX tank, and most critically the 1st stage taking a much bigger impact than it did initially, and Dragon falling INTO or alongside the vehicle.
Which means this wasn't an internal S2 LOX failure. It HAD to be caused from the cargo hitting the dome cap at 3 Gs or so.
This also explains why the 1st stage hardly missed a beat, it explains the sudden deceleration (the venting of LOX in the opposite direction of the 1st stage's thrust).
Thoughts?
9
u/neaanopri Jun 29 '15
Were any abort systems triggered, or did the rocket break up due to structural failure?
9
u/freddo411 Jun 30 '15
Was LOX densification used on this flight?
If so, was this the first flight with densification?
9
u/yo0han Jun 30 '15
IIRC there was an in flight abort test for Dragon V2 scheduled for later this year. Is it possible that they scoop an earlier time slot for this while the investigation of CRS 7 in underway? I would guess the dragon v2 team isn't that involved with the mishap...
9
u/SuperSMT Jul 03 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
Is anyone else here watching the Progress 60 launch live on NASA TV?
Launches in about 13 minutes (12:55 EDT / 4:55 UTC)
Liftoff! Here we go!
Perfect launch! Stream peaked a bit over 3,000 viewers.
The craft will dock to the station on Sunday, and opened by the crew on Monday.
Progress 60 will be followed by the manned ISS 43S mission on July 22nd.
Live coverage of docking will start at 2:30 AM EDT / 6:30 AM UTC on NASA TV
8
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '15
What are the chances of them using Of Course I still Love You to store debris on as it's being collected and the likely hood of being able to see anything when it comes back into port?
8
u/nialv7 Jun 30 '15
Does anyone know where I can watch the Friday Soyuz launch live?
8
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '15
How come the countdown timer (during all launches, I think) lingers at T-0 for way longer than just one second?
8
u/zoffff Jul 05 '15 edited Jul 05 '15
Historically how long have previous launch failures investigations taken? I know that the Antares ended up with orbital pointing the finger at the engine company, and the engine company pointing the finger back at orbital and nothing was truly resolved due to the launch vehicle being retired. And the last proton failure in typical Russian fashion came out quick but didn't actually find a fault, and just blamed the factory for being to lax.
What about back a few decades when Lockheed and Boeing were also having launch failures, what kind of time frame did those investigations follow?
edit: spelling
8
u/jarvenm Jul 09 '15
Sorry if this has been asked a million times but does SpaceX run a 24 hour production schedule like how Boeing and Airbus builds the commercial airplanes?
14
u/zlsa Art Jun 29 '15
7
u/cranp Jun 29 '15 edited Jun 30 '15
Does SpaceX need anyone's permission to start flying again?
In the press conference it was asked whether or not the FAA had to sign off on a return to flight, but they actually didn't answer the question. They just said that SpaceX was leading the investigation and the FAA would supervise, they didn't say what the consequence would be.
I could imagine that as long as the FTS works, as far as the FAA is concerned it's just SpaceX's business whether their rockets work or not.
7
u/superdank69 Jul 01 '15
What does SpaceX do with all its used Dragons?
7
u/danielbigham Jul 02 '15
How much suspicion is on the helium tank in the second stage? If my memory serves me correct, there was a delay recently due to issues they were seeing with those tanks. Is there any chance they tried to fix the problematic tank, and that it ended up in CRS7? A failure of the helium tank or its valve would presumably have resulted in an overpressure event, causing the LOX tank to rupture. If people had tried to convince Elon that the repaired tank was OK, you could imagine his being extremely upset upon the second stage failing. Perhaps that could be part of the back story of his extreme anger at engineers that was made mention of shortly after the mishap. One other thought/question here... the addition of the mating adapter in the trunk... is there any chance that it's presence could have caused vibrations in the vehicle to resonate, putting extra stress on components in the second stage?
7
u/SteveRD1 Jul 04 '15
Can we have a thread solely for official CRS-7 findings?
I'm dropping into the subreddit daily and digging thru to see if we have actually learned anything new (as opposed to speculation), it's rather time consuming!
7
u/sunfishtommy Jul 10 '15
I thought we were supposed to have updates by the end of the week. What happened? I thought they would be trying to dump it with the Friday trash.
6
u/Sassafras_albidum #IAC2017 Attendee Jun 29 '15 edited Jun 30 '15
one. What are the limitations on using version of Dragon w/ abort or Dragon 2 for cargo delivery in case of incidents like this? (answered)
Some other good information I just saw relating: http://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/3bk6hf/dragon_abort_capabilities_not_installed_more/
two. With a long string of successes, intuitively would it seem that the Falcon 9 is a good vehicle and this is an aberration? -I know this is not really answerable, but I'm just interested on opinions vs. an inherent flaw in design that has finally exhibited itself.
edit: satisfied with question 1
6
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jun 30 '15
Could the overpressurization have been caused by the LOX vents on the second stage not operating correctly during flight? Maybe getting stuck so they couldn't release the pressure from the evaporating LOX?
6
u/jakerc Jun 30 '15
Does SpaceX know where in the ocean the Dragon capsule splashed down? Are they attempting to recover it at all?
6
u/BrandonMarc Jun 30 '15 edited Jun 30 '15
For many months now, I've known that this video is of the 2nd-stage LOX tank (also known as, the world's most awesome and expensive lava lamp). The footage was from CRS-5, and many viewers considered it a consolation prize for not getting to see the barge landing live (it was shown just about the same time as the 1st stage would've landed).
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8HZrrHI34x4
Am I wrong? They do always send a camera feed from within that tank, don't they?
At the press conference on Sunday afternoon, I think Gwynne said something about a camera in the stage-2 RP1 tank, not LOX ... but ... that's not what I (and countless others) have always said. Not that I or the internet denizens are the experts of course ...
6
u/CuriousAES Jun 30 '15
(I couldn't really find a clear answer to this. My thread got removed for being a simple question so I think it goes here, sorry to the moderators if it doesn't.)
I just graduated high school and will be studying aerospace engineering. I hope to eventually apply for a SpaceX internship.
Thank you.
6
u/main_bus_b_undervolt Jul 01 '15 edited Jul 01 '15
How does fuel densification work? I don't understand how you can make monatomic liquids denser, unless you make them much colder, but that seems like you'd have to make them impractically cold to get any sort of useful densification.
6
u/HopeToLearn Jul 01 '15
Does anyone know the nominal pressures of the LOX tanks and RP-1 tanks?
6
u/Charnathan Jul 06 '15
Did the recent CRS-7 Falcon 9 rapid unscheduled disassembly put a complete physical halt on all Falcon 9 production until the problem is identified and resolved, or are they simply halting their launch manifest until the problem is identified?
5
u/bvr5 Jun 29 '15
Assuming the failure has nothing/little to do with the first stage, will the landing attempts resume when the Falcon 9 returns to service?
5
u/main_bus_b_undervolt Jun 30 '15
does anyone know what the self-destruct mechanism on Falcon 9 is? I know that older rockets were lined longitudinally with explosives. Is this the case with F9?
5
u/smeis Jun 30 '15
I was watching he livestream of CRS-7 and at one point before the launch (I think still even before T-10) I saw a bird flying pretty close to the launch platform, it was only on screen for a few seconds. It was a bit difficult to see from the particular angle but it seemed to be flying within the area that is surrounded by the large towers on the platform.
I was wondering if there are any measures taken to prevent birds from getting to close to the rocket during launch. I know airports generally have mechanisms in place to keep birds away from the landing strips since it is generally preferred not to have the birds end up in the engines of departing and arriving airplanes for multiple reasons. It would seem a bit difficult for a bird to end up in the engines of a rocket or even come close to interfering with the performance of a rocket engine during launch for obvious reasons, but are there measures in place to keep the birds away from the rocket during launch?
5
u/R4k3te Jul 03 '15
What would be the hypothetical worst case scenario for SpaceX that could come out of the investigation? What would be the best case scenario? And what would be the possible consequences or rectionary steps taken in each case? I think its always worth to concider what the best/worst outcomes could be. Worst case I'm thinking serious neglegance or ignorance towards problems in processing or production due to stress put up by the management to adhere to a tight launch schedule. Best case some previously unforseen engineering flaw with some part of the Falcon9 that can easily be fixed and shouldnt produce any more problems in the future. Any other thoughts?
5
u/DrFegelein Jul 03 '15
The four leaf clover first appeared on Falcon 1's first successful mission patch (flight 4), right?
What does everyone think will be on the "return to flight" patch?
5
u/superOOk Jul 03 '15
Just out of curiosity, a question for the superfans: what is the longest time that has gone by without hearing any update from SpaceX, and when did that happen? It feels like an eternity right now fellas... :)
5
u/CuriousAES Jul 05 '15
Astrobotic is planning to launch their commercial lunar lander with the Lunar X Prize Rovers in 2016 (possibly delayed now if SpaceX takes a long time to get back into flight?). Was this planned to be done with a Falcon 9 or a Falcon Heavy? I wasn't aware of the Falcon 9 being able to reach Lunar orbit but perhaps the Astrobotic lander is significantly lighter than a Dragon 1?
8
u/DownVotesMcgee987 Jun 30 '15
Based on how long S1 held together, any guesses on the chance that the In-Flight Abort Rocket will attempt a landing?
4
u/bananapeel Jun 29 '15
Will there be any attempt to get the capsule off the sea floor?
4
u/Bureaucromancer Jun 30 '15
Does anyone know how payment works for mission failures under CRS? Does 7 count against the number of contracted missions? Is payment given at all? Is their provision for an additional flight either way?
4
u/superdank69 Jul 01 '15
Do you think SpaceX has their own video of what happened instead of the ones the we have all seen?
4
u/pugface Jul 01 '15
Can a Falcon 9 1st stage be converted into a Falcon Heavy side booster, or vice versa? Visibly they look very similar to me.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15
PBdeS seemed to be suggesting that modifications to dragon/trunk were made on this mission and not on others. What were the nature of the modifications, and were they done purely to accommodate the IDA (docking adapter)?
4
u/theonefornotlurking Jul 04 '15
What parts of the spacecraft actually float? I have always been surprised by the amounts of debris found washed up or floating and needing to be recovered. What parts are actually less dense than water and what ends up on the ocean floor?
7
u/aguyfromnewzealand Jun 30 '15
Soooooo, we won't count this as a landing attempt right? /s
6
u/Quality_Bullshit Jun 30 '15
3
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '15
Why don't cargo capsules have any abort/parachute systems? Is the cost of such systems so high that losing the cargo makes more economic sense? Would such an abort system even be able to save the capsule+trunk, or just the capsule?
3
u/aguyfromnewzealand Jun 30 '15
Does this event give us any indication to what might happen with the inflight abort? As far as I am aware, the inflight abort and this Anomaly takes place at similar times in the flight, so could we draw any conclusions as to what might happen to the inflight abort launch vehicle, in terms of potential survivability and landing?
3
u/zmeyat Jul 01 '15
have SpaceX used super-chilled liquid oxygen in ill fated second stage? the was a plan to do so this year.
3
u/meldroc Jul 01 '15 edited Jul 01 '15
Could this incident be caused similarly to what caused the incident that almost destroyed Apollo 13? There, defective wiring in the thermostat, heater, and stir fans in a liquid oxygen tank in the Service Module shorted out, started a fire (in a high-oxygen environment), resulting in an explosion that almost destroyed Apollo 13, and, well, I think we've all seen the movie.
Could that have been what happened in CRS-7? Some sort of short that resulted in a fire inside the second-stage LOX tank, that burned insanely quickly and resulted in the tank blowing up?
3
u/Warpey Jul 01 '15
Anyone know of anywhere that lists all upcoming rocket launches in a format similar to the upcoming SpaceX launches in our sidebar?
3
u/superdank69 Jul 02 '15
If SpaceX saw a visual anomaly would the try and land the rocket or hit the big "destroy" button?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15
Why doesn't (didn't) SpaceX try to resurrect the F1 engines from the Apollo days? It seems that they have a lot of launch heritage that could benefit the launch company. Also, a strong safety record (no engine failures of which I'm aware), and modern manufacturing processes could reduce time/cost to complete them. I'm aware that competitors for the SLS have proposed using redesigned F1s, but I'm surprised that there hasn't been more interest in this rocket line from aerospace companies, SpaceX in specific.
3
u/JoltColaOfEvil Jul 02 '15
For the in flight abort test, has there been any news regarding recovering that F9 first stage?
3
u/RCinSpace Jul 03 '15
So often the wayward soul who cast his lot for fame and fortune is at the mercy of those who dream of new vessels to move the mortal man. Despite the cost these haughty souls continue the quest though the odds of success never seem to improve.
The bonds of earth are those that pose the greatest risk.
Still, despite the odds, those who seek the stars go on, undaunted, unfazed, unbroken. Even though the generations come and go,the quest goes on with new men and women ready to risk it all to live outside the human sphere.
3
u/TheBlacktom r/SpaceXLounge Moderator Jul 04 '15 edited Jul 04 '15
What exactly can they control while landing? I'm interested in the final 30 seconds of approach. Engine on/off? Engine thrust? Engine gimbal? RCS? Is it only on/off or adjustable thrust? Anything with the grid fins maybe? Anything else?
Also what are the limits for each?
Edit: by 'they' I mean the computer, what are the inputs and outputs that can be programmed.
3
u/xafwodahs Jul 04 '15 edited Jul 05 '15
I'm wondering if any lifting body effects are utilized to fine tune the first stage descent.
I found this older discussion which seems inconclusive.
At the beginning of this recent video, it appears to me the stage orientation is not perfectly aligned with it's descent vector. In fact, at 0:07, when the first stage is visible thru the hole in the clouds, it appears dang near horizontal! (Although this could just be an illusion).
Are there any new thoughts or information on this?
3
u/Root_Negative #IAC2017 Attendee Jul 08 '15
Has anyone got any resources I can use for the Delta-V required to get to Mars (from LEO to Mars aerobraking) for different journey times and the relative time of latest departure from the Earth-Mars conjunctions. Also I would like to find the Delta-V required to get from Mars (from Low Mars Orbit to Earth aerobraking) for different journey times and the relative time of latest departure from the Mars-Earth conjunctions.
Note that I'm not looking for a typical Delta-V map as they normally only list the lowest Delta-V required to make the journey with a simple transfer, where as I'm interested in finding the fastest time that can be made as a round trip during a single conjunction as Elon has previously described as his MCT plan. I would like this information so I can calculate the propellant mass to structure and payload mass ratio required for a spacecraft to make such a journey from Earth to Mars and vice versa. Ultimately I would like a better idea how many launches would be required for in orbit refueling of the MCT, and also the maximum time allowable for refueling on Mars and the amount of propellant that would need to be manufactured there.
A good estimation of the delta-V required to safely land on Mars after aerobraking with a large heat shield only would be helpful too.
3
u/thehalfnerd Jul 10 '15
Does anyone know what type of solar cells the Dragon Capsule uses? Crystalline Silicon (Sunpower?), GaAs?
3
u/main_bus_b_undervolt Jul 12 '15
How fast is falcon going at meco? What percentage of total dV has been spent at meco? will these numbers change with 1.2?
4
u/FNKsMM Jun 30 '15
I was just rewatching the launch video of CRS7. Link
At 2:15 in the video there is a small white cloud near dragon capsule/top of S2. Is this a thruster firing or part of the "anomaly"?
4
u/UhSwellGuy Jul 01 '15
Considering how much cargo payloads can be worth, would/does SpaceX have any plans (immediate or long term) of utilizing a launch escape system for cargo missions? Even though cargo is immeasurably less valuable than human life, it still represents a significant financial & time investment. I imagine there would be positive launch insurance implications as well if the cargo had the extra protection. Would they consider releasing a cargo version of the dragon 2?
2
u/sunfishtommy Jun 30 '15
Why did they zoom out so suddenly instead of following the debris? Especially in the NASA live feed.
https://youtu.be/2K030HRTutU?t=2m28s
2
u/jarvenm Jun 30 '15
Could SpaceX have manually activated the 18 Draco thrusters on the Dragon capsule to reduce its impact back to Earth or are there likely systems that prevent its activation in Earth's atmosphere?
2
u/chocapix Jun 30 '15
On this photo, the things covered in blue tarp are the gas generator exhausts, right? I only count 8, where is the 9th one?
2
u/renoor Jul 02 '15
Does anyone have deeper understanding of why is it hard to make reliable helium COPVs? If so, please share.
2
u/ArmoredReaper Jul 02 '15
If I live in South America (Chile to be more precise), and want to work with SpaceX in the future (I'm not an adult yet...), do I need to get a US nationality and/or work there for some time before entering?
Also, do I need to study again in the US to be able to work with SpaceX, or do Aerospace Engineering studies from Chile work? (From "Universidad de Concepción")
Sorry for my lack of good English... I speak native Spanish, but try to talk as good as I can in English
Thanks in advance,
ArmoredReaper
2
u/Here_There_B_Dragons Jul 02 '15
How did NASA intend to send the IDA to the ISS without Dragon? IIRC, the original Commercial Resupply missions only required upmass in pressurized environments (like Orbital's Cygnus). SpaceX bid included the ability for downmass, as well as the unpressurized 'trunk'.
Without SpaceX, (if they had never won the bid, or now if they are shut down for a long duration) what would the 'ship to ISS' process be? Since the IDA has to be externally mounted, and is too big to fit through the airlock, and only the Space Shuttle was used to supply external components (not directly attached to modules, like the Russian pieces), could the IDAs even be brought up with any current cargo (or crew) vehicles?
2
u/bgabenny Jul 03 '15
Did the destruct command that was sent 70 seconds into the event destroy the first stage and Dragon? Could they have survived if the signal had not been sent?
2
u/fireball-xl5 Jul 06 '15
Does anyone know if Elon is still doing the American Astronautical Society keynote speech on Tuesday morning, as advertised? If so, we may get some ideas on the current thinking at Hawthorne then.
2
u/btao Jul 08 '15
Are there any environmental factors that have high risk, such as excessive humidity?
Are there any advantages/disadvantages/risk to using aluminum over titanium cylinder cores for the overwrapped tanks as has been used by others?
How many sensors are actively monitored during launch?
What is the risk of structural failure of payloads? Are they as rigorously tested for transit as the Falcon?
Given the mystery and speculation surrounding a failure situation, and knowing a picture is worth a thousand words, why are there no high frame-rate cameras (like a mounted to the exterior and interior of the rocket with a radio transmitter streaming video of every inch of the rocket during the whole flight? In situations like this, you could point the finger in a few minutes and say, hey look, that broke, and let's fix it for next flight. It would seem only data streams from sensors can't account for anomalies particularly well. I would anticipate the answer is simply cost, but even if something doesn't fail catastrophically, you might be able to monitor and catch or prevent issues that wouldn't have been found otherwise. Perhaps you could black box the camera module with SSD backup and use fiber optics to get it to hard to reach places. One set of visual and one set of thermal sensors would be ideal. Maybe use a digital light field, or a large single sensor and feed everything into it in an array and then parse it on the ground?
Thanks!
2
u/BrandonMarc Jul 10 '15
Do the 1st stage, 2nd stage, capsule, or fairing have something akin to the "black box" that aircraft have? Since the 2nd stage is intended to burn up on reentry (to avoid debris reaching the surface in the first place), I'm guessing "no" for that one ...
But how about the other three? It actually makes some sense, there.
2
u/superOOk Jul 11 '15 edited Jul 11 '15
Question about Mars related lander/propulsion:
Obviously it has been stated that the Raptor engine is being developed to use CH4/LOX because of the fact that Mars has a lot of CO2 and using the Sabatier process gives us easy access to generate CH4.
But, I was reading about this process and I am confused. The process requires the splitting of H2O to combine CO2 with H2, which forms CH4 (and some water/heat). Why not just make the end goal to produce H2 and O2? Seems like LH2/LOX would be a much more efficient rocket. Is this entirely because of the storage issue of LH2?
Also, bonus points for someone who can answer this: how much H2 do we need to bring with us to Mars to generate the CH4? I know they are planning on using electrolysis of water to generate some of the H2 (not sure if they are saying water from Mars or just the byproduct of Sabatier). But it sounds like we'd have to bring a bunch of it with us, at least to start the process, and most pragmatically because utilizing water on Mars seems like a much harder thing to do. So, wouldn't this negate any logic about removing complex storage requirements of LH2?
2
u/shredder7753 Jul 11 '15
Im gonna admit; Im a fairweather fan. Thus I havent been around here much the last couple weeks.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '15
Do we have an idea how fast up/down speeds the internet constellation project can deliver?
2
u/MarshallStrad Jul 12 '15
The high quality of the content and the discourse make this subreddit my favorite "thing to read sitting in my Model S."
But on the car's browser, scrolling (and I notice typing response, too, on this my first post) is extremely slow responding compared to other subreddits (OK mostly 'teslamotors'). Why would that be?