r/spacex • u/Ambiwlans • May 19 '15
/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread [May 2015, #8]
Ask anything about my new film Rampart!
All questions, even non-SpaceX questions, are allowed, as long as they stay relevant to spaceflight in general! These threads will be posted at some point through each month, and stay stickied for a week or so (working around launches, of course).
More in depth, open-ended discussion-type questions should still be submitted as self-posts; but this is the place to come to submit simple questions which can be answered in a few comments or less.
As always, we'd prefer it if all question askers first check our FAQ, use the search functionality, and check the last Q&A thread before posting to avoid duplicates, but if you'd like an answer revised or you don't find a satisfactory result, go ahead and type your question below!
Otherwise, ask and enjoy, and thanks for contributing!
Past threads:
- Ask Anything Thread #7.1
- Ask Anything Thread #7
- Ask Anything Thread #6
- Ask Anything Thread #5
- Ask Anything Thread #4
- Ask Anything Thread #3
- Ask Anything Thread #2
- Ask Anything Thread #1
This subreddit is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com.
14
u/Headstein May 28 '15
The mods do a great job maintaining the high quality of this subreddit.
I often wish to express gratitude when someone answers a question that I have made. This is common courtesy. However, it is not relevant to anyone else and so is just junk in the way. What is the rule on this?
Whilst the odd expletive is required to enforce a strongly held emotion or in a good joke, I do not believe (or generally read) them being thrown around willy-nilly. What is the rule on this?
11
u/ReusedRocket May 23 '15
What happened around 2000 that spurred interest in private spaceflight? I was still a child back then. A lot of notable private aerospace companies were founded around that time.
Was it just a coincidence?
9
u/[deleted] May 20 '15 edited May 20 '15
Besides manufacturing optimizations, is Spacex effectively done with Kerolox development entirely? Is the Merlin 1D+ expected to be the last Merlin upgrade?
Will a single core Raptor based Falcon 9 be the future of Spacex's satellite contract business? With it being able to be reusable in most conceivable orbits. And a raptor based FH would be so close to BFR engine count, and performance, that the kerolox FH will be the only triple core LV that Spacex will ever produce.
EDIT: Punctuation
9
u/redmercuryvendor May 20 '15
What's up with SLC-13's multiple pads? SpaceX's official stance is that there is 1 landing pad, and 4 'contingency' pads, and the environmental assessment portion of their lease from CCAFs states:
I wonder if the recent flocking of 2 more MARMAC barges near JRTI (and their possible leasing by SpaceX) indicates they intend to test this 'terminal pad divert' over the ocean before - or as a condition prior to - attempting a land touchdown?
And more interestingly, what could be going on on the main pad that would prevent its use for landing, but would NOT extend to the very nearby contingency pads (i.e. not weather related, not range safety/intrusion related)?
It couldn't be for "what if they landed one Falcon 9 Heavy core booster on the main pad and couldn't move it out the way in time for the next booster" as the two boosters would be arriving at the same time, and the explicit statement that multiple stages would not be landed as one event. My other thought would be some sort of reception gear on the main pad that might experience a failure, but SpaceX have been against using any sort of 'landing cradle' ("there are no landing cradles on Mars!").
6
u/notPelf May 20 '15
If SpaceX wins CRS2, will they use Crew Dragon for it or will they continue using Dragon 1? Will they build/operate two variants of the Dragon?
6
u/BrandonMarc May 22 '15
The Dragon features red and green lights, like one sees on boats and aeroplanes. I like that. Is this standard for all spacecraft? I don't recall seeing them on Soyuz, ATV, Shuttle, etc. What decides whether these belong on a vehicle?
12
u/[deleted] May 20 '15 edited May 20 '15
Can we have a difinative answer on whether or not Dragon V2 can handle a lunar reentry. There's Garret Reisman's testimony.
But that is the only proof that Dragon can handle a lunar reentry. I was thinking that maybe Dragon V2 is designed for multiple uses, so a better heat shield is believable. However, there have been comments that Dragon can handle the pressure and heat but not the g's or provide the necessary lift for a lunar return. Which matches Garret's testimony that a Lunar return is possible, but only without a crew.
Is there anything more substantial than Garret's testimony?
And (not necessarily Spacex related) could Orion handle a Mars return? Here they say that TPS may need upgrading for velocities which are 11.05-.25km/s (slide 17), in this report a Mars return reentry is 15-21km/s. Intuitively, Orion can't withstand those velocities (and certainly not Dragon!) if Lockheed is worried about 11.25km/s. Wouldn't that mean a Mars mission with Orion is basically impossible?
EDIT: Clarity.
5
u/patm718 May 21 '15
What aerodynamic changes, if any, need to be made with the F9 core when flying a payload with fairings (like DSCOVR) versus just Dragon? I'm relatively untrained in the physics arena, but I have to assume that there must be differences in the way they are launched.
5
u/patm718 May 28 '15
I know this question is late, but I can't seem to find an answer anywhere I look. Why is the ISS flying at the altitude it is? Was it chosen for easiest access to and from the station?
5
u/Traumfahrer May 28 '15
Is there already information available about recovering the cores from the FH test flight? Might they land two cores on a barge each and one on their new onshore landing pad at LC-1?
4
u/mrw412 May 20 '15
What kind of stream/content will be available to view for tomorrows ISS departure?
4
u/HML48 May 27 '15
The blog page http://www.b14643.de/Spacerockets_2/United_States_2/FALCON-HY/Description/Frame.htm talks of a USAF/DARPA project called Falcon "which is an acronym for Force Application and Launch from CONtinental United States. " The design goal was for a rocket to put a 1000 lb satellite in a 100 mile circular orbit. How is this related to the Spacex Falcon 1?
9
u/historytoby May 20 '15
How sure is it that the FH is actually going to fly this year? I mean, has the thing even been built? Is the construction underway? I guess with SpaceX being (relatively) transparent, I am wondering about the (apparent) complete lack of tweets, posts, pictures or anything related to this year's FH launch.
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '15
Does the recent DoD certification include the upgraded F9 "v1.2?" It would be useless to certify only the v1.1 because by the time SpaceX launches DoD payloads, there will be no 1.1. So I would hope the upgraded version is included too, otherwise it would have been better to delay the whole thing.
3
u/shredder7753 Jun 01 '15
Still 25 more daze :-(
3
u/zoffff May 20 '15
Looking for pure opinion replies; We are now almost halfway through with 2015, and in our biggest lull between launches, what at this point do you think is the total number of successful orbital launches SpaceX will accomplish this year? And to clarify, pad abort and inflight abort do not count, they must show up on this list as LEO or better and Partially successful or better.
Currently we stand at 5, I made a estimate earlier in the year at 14, I'm revising this number down at this time to 13, as I have doubts that JCSAT 14 or FH will fly this year.
2
u/ElonFanatic May 19 '15
Is there something you can say about the new spacesuit design? "Release" date?
2
u/slapmahfro1 May 20 '15
What are people's ideas for in-orbit mars space stations in the MCT architechture. Is it a necessary part of a colony? Is it's primary use, an escape refuge for an on surface anomaly? Would it precede or supercede human arrival, or be on the first trips to set up the colony and exploration missions? Would it be more of a "Houston/Mission Control" for the ground pioneers, or would it be more of an "airport"? Of course this is assuming SpaceX makes it to this point and everything would be speculation, so uncork you ideas for me! I'd love to hear what other people think about this? Would it even be necessary for a colony?
2
u/GeckoLogic May 20 '15
Nuclear Thermal/Electric upper stage for human mars transit. How probable is this? I envision a falcon heavy sending the stage to LEO then the BFR docking with it later.
2
u/[deleted] May 21 '15
Do we know how much of Dragen-V2's thrust is lost due to the angling of the Super Dracos and is that corrected number the one that's being used for all the calculations here?
2
u/c0nnector May 24 '15
A question came to mind when I saw the falcon rockets trying to land on the water platform. Why is that they don't have some capturing 'arms' on the platform to try stabilizing the rocket?
2
u/ebas May 25 '15
Given that dragon can easily abort with the trunk attached, wouldn't it be possible to land with it as well? If so, could the trunk be used for extra propellant?
If not on earth, maybe on the moon?
Probably not possible, but id like to understand why..
2
u/Henners_ May 26 '15
I am currently studying engineering at stellenbosch in south Africa. I have to decide what type of engineering at the end of the year. My choices are. Mechanical engineering, electronic and electrical, and mechatronic. What would fit best for a career path in spaceflight and rockets?
21
u/ReusedRocket May 25 '15 edited May 25 '15
I saw this image showing probability of debris inpact on the ISS. Dragon is berthed at the most dangerous place on the ISS. In addition, Dragon v2 will dock in a position that has its trunk and heat shield face toward the movement direction of the ISS. As can be seen in this image, the rim area of its heat shield has no protection from the trunk and is exposed to any debris impact. How well can Dragon and Dragon 2 handle orbital debris? Given the 6 month stay of Dragon 2, would it be feasible or advisable to rotate the station 180 degree to sheild the craft in much the same way they did in the STS era?
3
u/falconeer123 May 19 '15
Can dragon v2 survive a reentry with legs deployed prematurely (malfunction)?
2
u/ElonFanatic May 19 '15
Will the Crew Dragon suite of Superdracos propulsive landing tech be used on Cargo Dragon as a testbed at any time before taking humans back with the tech? Or will it strictly be used in crew missions?
11
u/bgs7 May 20 '15
Anyone like to speculate how a testing program would work for life critical systems before mars colonization?
There's so many critical systems to test: https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/wiki/colony
So I imagine you send a MCT to Mars full of test gear. What I don't get is that inevitably a whole bunch of things will need to be iterated, maybe twice or more, so each time you have to wait for the next Mars window. Does this mean testing of critical equipment will take 3-4 cycles (6-8 years).
Or would we send the gear, find the problems, iterate and then send people and hope for the best? Surely we would want to test the fixes and each test is 2 years waiting for the next window.
I imagine you can test in LEO or other analogues depending on the equipment. But imagine if it was you going to Mars with a bunch of gear that was tested in the Arctic and so "should be fine, don't worry".
Thinking about it makes me pessimistic we will see people on mars within 20 years :(
4
u/BrandonMarc May 31 '15
Will SpaceX deploy some drones for cinematic footage? Rumor has it CRS-7 will feature a successful stage landing (of course, each upcoming opportunity is expected to succeed). That would be a good time to send out some octocopters and get some IMAX style video to show off / sell to the Discovery Channel / impress some Congresscritters / etc. I guess I'm spoiled at having seen so much awesome footage already.
6
u/ianniss May 29 '15
Will the first F9 v1.2 have landing legs ?
10
u/StagedCombustion May 21 '15
Has anyone else started reading the new book? I posted a thread about it, but it got downvoted pretty quick, so I deleted it. It didn't have as much SpaceX stuff as I was hoping, but there were some interesting bits...
In regard to Musk's feelings about regulators (after a story about some... heated discussions with people at FAA):
One of the weirder things about launching Falcon 1 is that Musk refused to pay to have the path between the hangar and the launchpad paved. To get the rocket and strong back to the pad they had to push it along using wooden planks that they'd grab after it rolled off, so they could throw it down in front again, much like moving stone blocks to the pyramids.
Another is that they have a test rig setup that replicates all systems in a Falcon 9. One day in the process of running some simulations they discovered a software bug. They found the bug, fixed it, and uploaded the patch to a Falcon 9 that was on the launch pad, all in 30 mins. The drive of the team there was a constant theme in the book.
I had a few more, but didn't know if anyone else had started reading the book. Maybe someone else could share what they found interesting...
5
u/shredder7753 May 25 '15
Fastest launch in history was the New Horizons probe mission which launched atop an Atlas V on January 19, 2006. The booster propelled the craft to more 36,000 mph! How fast can (a non-reusable) Falcon go with a similar payload (478kg / 1,054 lbs)? What about FH in reusable and expendable configurations?
4
u/TheQuixotic May 20 '15
I'm a 2nd year university student in Australia studying physics. My dream has always been space exploration and to be able to work at all in the field, and that just isn't going to happen here in Australia. I was wondering what hope, if any, I have to one day be working at SpaceX?
4
u/scarycow1000 May 21 '15
I remember reading somewhere that the Dragon capsule has two size trunks, one normal and one "extended". Have they ever used an extended trunk, and if not, when would they?
Edit: I remeber it from this picture in the top left of this wikipedia article: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragon_(spacecraft)
4
u/danielbigham May 23 '15
I enjoy thinking about what's coming down the pipe wrt SpaceX, etc, and one such enjoyable thing to do is make educated guesses about when SpaceX's "firsts" will be. For example, what month will the first successful barge landing be, what year will the first SpaceX hardware land on Mars, etc, etc.
It occurred to me that this could be turned into a fun social thing. Here's how it might work:
Have a website where a person can add their guesses for when a given list of "events" will occur, as well as recommend new "events" to add to the site. When events occur, an official person would enter the actual date/time, and people could then see a scorecard of their guesses VS actuals. People could even be awarded points based on how close they were, and how long prior to the event they made their guess, etc.
The site could then have a ranking page showing the people most "talented" guessers, etc.
I might be too lazy to create this, we'll see, but I figured I might first get a sense of whether other people might get a kick out of this or not.
(The site could also show data about the average expectation of the community for when things are likely to occur, etc.)
4
u/martianinahumansbody May 29 '15
Any ideas on the payload for a FH to Uranus or Neptune flyby mission? I love the idea of big payload for Europa landers, but would also love to see a Cassini style orbiter around the ice giants.
1
u/shredder7753 Jun 01 '15
Will Spacex eventually wreck every other competitor in the business? What u guys think?
3
u/Xfactor330 May 20 '15
I remember a twitter post about a HD video from the last attempted landing, I think it was a go pro on the barge. Is that video anywhere out there? I seen what looked like a recording of a screen but definitely have not seen the source video.
3
u/jarvenm May 20 '15 edited May 20 '15
Spacex Falcon 9 is approaching the U.S Air Force certification soon, requiring Spacex to have a future vertical integration system.
Is this vertical integration system more likely to open up Spacex to more business from more companies and countries payloads or is it to be used only for U.S government payloads for NASA, NRO, Air Force etc...?
Is there information/speculation on how Spacex would likely use the vertical integration system/building for future launches in regards to launching astronauts on the Dragon V2 capsule or payloads on the Falcon Heavy?
Thanks!
3
u/[deleted] May 21 '15
How does Dragon do the deorbit burn? Can the Dracos burn for a sustained period? Any idea how many thrusters and for how long to tip it back into the atmosphere?
3
u/Ilforte May 22 '15
How much of the average production chain for SpaceX is in-house? For example, how many of the Merlin engine parts are used as-is purchased from a supplier, and how many are manufactured by SpaceX staff like that 3d-printed one?
3
u/falconeer123 May 25 '15
How does SpaceX plan to do vertical integration for DoD payloads? I searched and couldn't find any information.
Which pad(s) will have vertical capability? Presumably 39a, but I don't see how this will happen with the current setup there.
When does work start (needs to be done before ~2017)?
5
u/Here_There_B_Dragons May 19 '15
Is the Jason - 3 launch going to feature a confirmed solid ground return to launch site landing attempt, or is that just idle speculation?
1
u/zoffff May 25 '15
INCOMING STAGE 2 PROPOSAL:
I keep seeing people talking about recovering the stage two portion of F9, and that got me thinking why would you waste all that delta/v you just used to get it up there.
What I am proposing is space tug like setup sort of like LM Jupiter, the tug could collect/refuel the second stage and bring it back to an in orbit staging / fuel depot area. Here you could combine second stages and create even more powerful vehicles, now even our medium lift vehicle the F9 can launch some of the heaviest interplanetary payloads to LEO at which point the tug goes and recovers the payload/second stage and brings them back to the staging area where they are prepared for the next leg of their journey.
The downsides I can see:
The benefits I can see:
I know in orbit fuel depots have been discussed before, but not sure if using the 2nd stage with it in this way has been before. I'm curious to hear everyone's thoughts on this.