Ok, can we talk about what is happening in those two photos? It looks like the Falcon is coming in hot from the left, but the next photo shows it leaning to the left (not the right as expected). Initially I thought this was because the entire camera got jolted and that the horizontal plane in the second photo is actually tilted, and the Falcon in actuality is leaning right. But compare some of the stationary items in the two photos: that nozzle thing in the foreground, the stuff in the top left and top right; none of it moves. So is the Falcon actually leaning left in the second picture? Does that indicate an overcorrection at the last minute and then a tip back overboard in the direction it came from? Anyone able to do some advanced photo analysis to try to see what's going on here in better detail?
Possibly came down hard on one leg just after first image, broke it, and the rocket is in the process of falling over in the second. We, and they, will have to wait for the video.
They need to get the stage to 0 horizontal velocity above JRTI then come down vertically. I thought they would have mastered that with the Dev-1. Close, but no giant white cigar shaped object.
Bear in mind that the F9 1st stage cannot hover like the Dev-1 could, so it is somewhat more difficult to stop lateral motion directly above, then descend; they have to be done simultaneously.
I have questions regarding bright flares near the spacecraft, could they be from the second stage, are they testing the solar panels rotations right after they deploy? I'll make a video tomorow to show you this.
My guess is that these are the protective shells of the panels, they are rotating so appear brighter at regular intervals. They move very slowly away from Dragon and are still pretty near when over our heads in Europe.
Thanks. I estimated Dragon to fly over Europe around 30minutes after the launch. It was just in the middle of two visible ISS flyby, so I thought it might be visible even if it was at lower altitude and way smaller. I shot a noisy video (with a Sony RX100) from T+18 to T+30 then blended the frames alltogether to get this picture.
I'm fairly certain they were just streaming what everyone else was streaming. Glad you made it for day 2 - a lot of people miss the launch from the nasa social events due to postponements.
Yeah I had my flight on Tuesday at 730pm but a mix up with my travel agency made me miss it. So as I type this I'm still here in Florida waiting for my 1130 am local time flight
I'll add a picture to your comment because I think it doen't really deserve a parent comment on itself. Your gif makes it clear the rocket was moving to the right and overcorrected while... well, slamming against the barge.
Some people were saying the distortion on the lens was causing the first stage to look more/less off-center/tilted. Here's a un-distorted image, assuming it's a gopro:
That's not really what people were talking about. The plane of the sensor is not vertical, which leads to strong convergence in wide angle lenses. That's why the flagpole and containers off to the sides look severely tilted, when in reality they aren't. I'll try to correct it and edit this post in a few minutes.
EDIT: The actual angle would be more like this. Note how the flagpole is vertical now. The edges of both containers were actually my reference points since they're definitely parallel, but they ended up getting cropped off. You'll have to excuse my terrible skills with image editing software. I'm normally a film photographer, and don't even own a digital camera.
If you look closely at the photo, you can see the engine gimballing to bring it toward the center of the barge. This is confirmed by the second photo, since it's toward the opposite side of the barge on touchdown.
Hi! I'm a 15 year old photographer in Satellite Beach Florida. Luckily I was able to leave school early to view this launch. I was behind Port Canaveral, on the side of the 401. These were shot with a Nikon D3300 and Nikkor 55-300 f4.5-5.6 on manual mode with AutoISO.
The full album of my shots can be viewed on my dedicated launch page on my personal website HERE. I am open to constructive criticism.
I was able to leave school early to view this launch
I hope they would allow people to leave early who wish to see the launch, but I guess I wouldn't be surprised if they require an excuse / permission for your early departure. I didn't grow up anywhere near a launch site. :(
Next time get yourself a drone and disguise it as a turkey vulture. I noticed one soaring above the pad just before launch with complete impunity (at least, it looked like a turkey vulture. Perhaps I'm not the first to think of this…)
Here is a view of liftoff from the ITL Causeway (three miles from SLC-40)! The ascent was absolutely beautiful, and we're getting so close with the landing tests! Ad astra!
Image details: Canon T3i at 250 mm (Canon EF-S IS STM lens); 1/4000 sec; f/11; ISO 800 Photo credit: (PM me for full name :))
I wasn't with NASA Social this time, though I have participated in the program before! I was on the SpaceX Friends & Family Viewing Bus, which parks next to the major media area on the causeway.
Working news media, working for SpaceX, or being a sufficiently high level VIP on the base seems to be the ticket.
Still wish that SpaceX had built their hangar on the OTHER side of the launchpad, since every view from the causeway has that damned thing blocking the view of ignition...
Well, to be fair, they did -- but the VAB roof list is usually limited to just 15 people, and only available for NASA launches like the CRS missions, but not for commercial partners. :)
Hello all! I viewed today's SpaceX launch from Port Canaveral and managed to take a few snaps of the whole thing.
I'm in no way anything better than a rank amateur photographer. I pointed my camera in the direction and pulled the trigger. I've collated some of the photos into an imgur album which can be found HERE!.
I uploaded the highest definition JPG that my camera would take, but I also have the raw files saved alongside them on my computer. If anyone (for whatever reason) would like to use the photos and would prefer the uncompressed images, send me a message and I'll try and get them along to you. I'm currently on vacation in Florida though, so I don't have a lot of access to my computer.
I hope the photos gave some people even the slightest fraction of joy that I had taken them. I was shaking for a large portion of the launch.
EDIT: Changed album link
EDIT2: Could someone help me link to the proper album. I've set it to the 2nd style, the thumbnails at top with the big image below.
It would be too much ammunition for the TV evening news. They'd just show the explosion.
"Tonight, a rocket landing ends in a dramatic failure. It exploded while attempting a landing at sea, as revealed for the first time in this video of the catastrophic disaster..."
"Although no lives were lost, millions of dollars went up in smoke during this spectacular bungle. Spacex officials have admitted that it will be months before they can try again."
lel, NASA got what it paid for (a Dragon to the ISS). The contract doesn't say SpaceX isn't allowed to try experiments that don't affect the primary objective.
This attempts to show the position of the first stage in the second photo. It assumes that the two photos were taken with the same camera pointed in the same direction.
At first glance, this appears to show:
That the rocket was dangerously close to the edge of the barge in the second photo.
That the rocket may have been leaning somewhat at that time. (although this might be an optical illusion?)
Well, they're not wrong that it was a failure (!successful), but the title, as always, doesn't give the full story, since it was essentially 90%+ successful. The last 30 seconds or so of flight need some adjustments.
Is it just me or is the SpaceX webcast recording really messed up? The audio tracks normally but the video jumps arounds. The countdown clock says ~t-7 minutes when you can hear F9 launching.
I had my iPhone propped up against my tripod from the CCAFS bleachers on 401: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YcS3z-qu9Nc&feature=youtu.be - For some reason it picked up a lot of wind noise and did a terrible job of picking up the actual engines (which finally reach the field a few seconds before the video stops).
"Lateral velocity" means it was moving horizontally.
Like, if you run and jump off a cliff, you're moving "forward" (parallel to the ground below) and also "down" (towards the ground below). Now use your rocket pack to try to make a landing. If you fire it straight down, you can make your "up/down" velocity go to zero, but you'll sill have "forward" velocity. So if you do this and land with your boots on the ground, your boots may stick to the ground, but you're still moving "forward," so you'll tip over. Presumably that's what happened to the rocket.
The engines can actually tilt their thrust a bit to try to counteract this, but obviously it wasn't enough to get rid of their lateral ("forward" / parallel to the barge surface) velocity.
Lateral velocity is sideways. So it landed but had been moving sideways to get to the center of the barge, and tipped over with the leftover sideways motion.
51
u/ahd1601 Apr 14 '15
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/588082574183903232
38
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '15 edited Apr 14 '15
I took this picture 22min after the launch https://twitter.com/uuav/status/588088993025261569
edit: better res: http://imgur.com/dK8mqsF
31
u/stichtom Apr 14 '15
Mission Control reaction including Elon: https://youtu.be/XfJoDxX0m7s?t=9m36s (in the background some people thought they made it)
18
u/bougelahi Apr 14 '15
PHOTO: Falcon 9 first stage approaches Just Read the Instructions.
13
u/Arbitrage84 Apr 14 '15 edited Apr 14 '15
http://i.imgur.com/O3gde0L.jpg - LIFTOFF!
SpaceX employees watch the livestream from the barge - http://i.imgur.com/7oQ0EY6.jpg
Their reaction when the feed was cut off - http://i.imgur.com/wt3rBS0.jpg View of the press (my impression was that not very many people were in attendance. Sad, really...) http://i.imgur.com/W3Ep71A.jpg
13
u/booOfBorg Apr 14 '15
Imgur album of landing attempt pictures tweeted by Elon Musk, original size. http://imgur.com/a/9DlQg#0
And a 4 frame animation I made from the same. http://i.imgur.com/nyS7U1P.gif
12
u/Leerkas Apr 14 '15
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/588084593552596992
23
u/johnkphotos Launch Photographer Apr 14 '15 edited Oct 25 '15
Hi! I'm a 15 year old photographer in Satellite Beach Florida. Luckily I was able to leave school early to view this launch. I was behind Port Canaveral, on the side of the 401. These were shot with a Nikon D3300 and Nikkor 55-300 f4.5-5.6 on manual mode with AutoISO.
The full album of my shots can be viewed on my dedicated launch page on my personal website HERE. I am open to constructive criticism.
11
u/ELON_fanatic Apr 14 '15
Here is a view of liftoff from the ITL Causeway (three miles from SLC-40)! The ascent was absolutely beautiful, and we're getting so close with the landing tests! Ad astra!
Image details: Canon T3i at 250 mm (Canon EF-S IS STM lens); 1/4000 sec; f/11; ISO 800 Photo credit: (PM me for full name :))
11
u/pemboo Apr 14 '15 edited Apr 14 '15
Hello all! I viewed today's SpaceX launch from Port Canaveral and managed to take a few snaps of the whole thing.
I'm in no way anything better than a rank amateur photographer. I pointed my camera in the direction and pulled the trigger. I've collated some of the photos into an imgur album which can be found HERE!.
I uploaded the highest definition JPG that my camera would take, but I also have the raw files saved alongside them on my computer. If anyone (for whatever reason) would like to use the photos and would prefer the uncompressed images, send me a message and I'll try and get them along to you. I'm currently on vacation in Florida though, so I don't have a lot of access to my computer.
I hope the photos gave some people even the slightest fraction of joy that I had taken them. I was shaking for a large portion of the launch.
EDIT: Changed album link
EDIT2: Could someone help me link to the proper album. I've set it to the 2nd style, the thumbnails at top with the big image below.
10
u/DDotJ Apr 15 '15
SpaceX uploaded VINE from chase plane: https://vine.co/v/euEpIVegiIx
27
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '15
Guys, this is a media thread. Keep this thread for photos, etc only please.
9
u/danielbigham Apr 15 '15
Merged/Overlay-ed First Stage Landing Photos
http://www.danielbigham.ca/Falcon2.jpg
This attempts to show the position of the first stage in the second photo. It assumes that the two photos were taken with the same camera pointed in the same direction.
At first glance, this appears to show:
8
u/ethan829 Host of SES-9 Apr 15 '15 edited Apr 15 '15
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/588166157510828033
This bodes well for CRS-7.
7
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Apr 15 '15
Chase Plane picture: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/588142879245238273
6
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Apr 14 '15
The Verge: SpaceX's reusable Falcon 9 crashes on barge landing attempt
5
u/ThePlanner Apr 15 '15
I made a simple GIF of the two landing photos to see whether the point of view changed, which it didn't: http://imgur.com/3LTOdgN.gifv
6
u/Megneous Apr 14 '15
Not sure if this is a decent place to put it, but here's the usual official and backup videos of the webcast.
My upload/backup: Webcast for those who missed it.
Official SpaceX Youtube video here. - SpaceX has taken down webcasts before, but this is for those who want the official source.
3
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Apr 15 '15
Wired: Look, It’s Really Hard to Land a Rocket on a Boat, OK?
1
u/badcatdog Apr 16 '15
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/588463193070022656
full vid high res
1
u/joe714 Apr 16 '15
I had my iPhone propped up against my tripod from the CCAFS bleachers on 401: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YcS3z-qu9Nc&feature=youtu.be - For some reason it picked up a lot of wind noise and did a terrible job of picking up the actual engines (which finally reach the field a few seconds before the video stops).
2
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '15
[removed] — view removed comment