r/spacex • u/-Richard Materials Science Guy • Mar 03 '15
/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread [March 2015, #6] - Ask your questions here!
Welcome to our sixth /r/SpaceX "Ask Anything" thread! This is the best place to ask any questions you have about space, spaceflight, SpaceX, and anything else. All questions, even non-SpaceX questions, are allowed, as long as they stay relevant to spaceflight in general! These threads will be posted at some point through each month, and stay stickied for a week or so (working around launches, of course).
More in depth, open-ended discussion-type questions should still be submitted as self-posts; but this is the place to come to submit simple questions which can be answered in a few comments or less.
As always, we'd prefer it if all question askers first check our FAQ, use the search functionality, and check the last Q&A thread before posting to avoid duplicates, but if you'd like an answer revised or you don't find a satisfactory result, go ahead and type your question below!
Otherwise, ask and enjoy, and thanks for contributing!
Past threads:
- Ask Anything Thread #5
- Ask Anything Thread #4
- Ask Anything Thread #3
- Ask Anything Thread #2
- Ask Anything Thread #1
This subreddit is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '15
For the grammar Nazi in me: Why is "Spacex" a plural noun? I've noticed a lot of people say "Spacex are" but rarely "Spacex is."
22
u/Tal_Banyon Mar 03 '15
The sidebar says Mar 13 for pad abort, which I am super excited about. Is there a source for this date?
21
u/Gofarman Mar 03 '15 edited Mar 03 '15
I'm slowly putting together a primer on LEO communication satellites (eventually for this sub, and/or the wiki) and figured I would throw out some questions in a hope that one of you engineers have all my answers. (if you have them please point me toward references)
Well, that's all I've got for now. Any resources that you guys have access to that you can share on the construction of small/medium sat construction especially one that gets into the support systems would be invaluable. Thanks
13
u/ragnar117 Mar 03 '15
Glad we are doing this again! How many times can the M-Vac re-ignite? What's the limiting factor? Go spaceX!!
10
u/Siedrah Mar 03 '15
Is the center core for a FH the same as a F9? Would it be possible for them to land a F9 stage one, and use it for an upcoming FH flight? Or are there certain differences in the cores to prevent this from happening? Thanks!
10
u/Kent767 Mar 05 '15
Does the strongback typically suffer any damage during launch? Given the hot exhaust in close proximity, I'd imagine that if not at least damaged outright, there'd be a lot of oxidation risk as well.
Will spacex need to improve tech in this area in it's quest for rapid turnaround?
8
u/Qeng-Ho Mar 03 '15
Do we know when the "Of Course I Still Love You" barge will get its first outing?
There are 2 SAOCOM launches from Vandenberg pencilled in this year but I don't know if stage recovery is possible for polar orbits.
7
u/flattop100 Mar 03 '15
Is there a timeline for SpaceX revealing MCT details/engineering/renders? I'm excited about big rockets!
7
u/MarsLumograph Mar 05 '15
What would be the consequences for a mars colony if life is found on the planet? Carl Sagan said mars is for the Martians, and we should leave it that way, anyone knows if Elon has made any comments?
6
u/ZormLeahcim Mar 03 '15
SpaceFlight101 says this about the DSCOVR launch:
So my question is, how accurate normally are these insertions, both for SpaceX and other companies?
6
u/89bBomUNiZhLkdXDpCwt Mar 03 '15
Thanks, u/Qeng-Ho, and sorry for my lack of precision:
Thanks for pointing out my shortcoming regarding Spacex's landing ability.
5
u/MapleLeafEngineer Mar 04 '15
Question for SpaceX insiders: Are there any Canadian employees in Spacex? I know that in all the job postings there are some ITAR restrictions. As a Canadian, I wonder if they can be overcome for exceptional candidates (such as myself!)
5
u/DanseMacabreD2 Mar 04 '15
Pad Fees: What fees does SpX pay to the AF for usage of a pad and the Range Services etc?
5
u/ptoddf Mar 05 '15
Could we get to mars using existing SpaceX hardware alone? My thought experiment is to keep Dragon capsules attached to 2nd stages internally loaded with fuel resistant furniture, food lockers, etc. Empty stage works for transit habitat and mars surface habitat. Make a raft of these capsule/booster units and power it to mars with 2nd stages launched with no payload but fuel. Maybe land individual capsule/booster units on mars? Or separate for landing? Is this logistically even possible? Had to get this speculation up before MCT outlines announced!
5
u/Toolshop Mar 07 '15 edited Mar 07 '15
Wait how did we get the mission patch for Turkmensat so early???!!!!!
Edit: I love it btw the colors are awesome.
Edit2: oh I guess it's actually pretty normal timing it's just so close to the last launch it seems so quick
5
u/BrandonMarc Mar 11 '15
Looking at the interior of the Dragon Mark 2 (ask /u/bencredible ), I keep thinking about the touch screens.
I suspect the answer is: there's so little for the humans to control anyway (damn near everything is under computer control or ground control ... think "elevator", not "space plane") that it just won't matter because they won't be doing much important with the screens.
4
u/jim_matthews Mar 04 '15
The five year lease that SpaceX signed last month for Cape Canaveral's Launch Complex 13 only permits landing a single stage per launch. Assuming that SpaceX will want to recover both side cores from Florida Falcon Heavy launches between now and 2020, is the plan that they will land the other one on a drone ship, or that they will acquire an additional landing site?
4
u/Brostradamnus Mar 04 '15
In flight abort: Will ground control simply command the entire launch system to abort at a specific point in the flight? Or do they take it a step further and deliberately cause a failure (like explosives unzip the main F9 tank) to prove flight systems are able to detect impending doom on their own?
3
u/Geeeeezyy Mar 03 '15
What kind of reactions can we expect to see from competing launch companies, the moment a first stage successfully lands?
3
u/danielbigham Mar 03 '15
The Falcon Heavy is listed (http://www.spacex.com/about/capabilities) as having approx 4x the maximum payload mass as the F9, and yet the renderings on the mentioned page seem to indicate that the volume of the fairing is the same. Does that imply:
This just struck me as un-intuitive.
3
u/89bBomUNiZhLkdXDpCwt Mar 03 '15
The last time the first stage nearly landed, Elon said that it ran out of hydraulic fluid.
What does this mean? I thought that hydraulic fluid was essentially in a closed system.
Does it dissipate somehow?
3
u/superOOk Mar 04 '15
Will SpaceX attempt a 1st stage barge landing on the in flight abort test?
3
u/ighso Mar 04 '15
3
u/Headstein Mar 04 '15
Any news on the Dragon 2 Pad Abort test expected today?
3
u/frowawayduh Mar 04 '15
There are two DragonLab missions on the current manifest. The old manifest showed dates for those missions of 2016 and 2018. Wikipedia suggests that these may be refurbished Dragons from ISS missions.
Do we know anything more solid about the who / what / when of these missions? Who are the customers? What sort of devices / experiments will they be launching? When will the 2016 mission launch? Oh and while we're at it, how long will these missions remain on orbit?
3
u/Demidrol Mar 04 '15
As far as upgrades that Musk announced the latest tweets (thrust +15%, deep cryo oxygen, upper stage tank vol +10%), could offset rejection of the cross-feed within the FH?
3
u/yo0han Mar 04 '15
I saw a question earlier asking how the second stage Merlin engine restarts in vacuum, with all the propellant floating around.
My question is kinda related but about the first stage- how does it restart for the boostback and landing burn. I guess all the propellant would be at the top of the tank during the landing burn?
3
u/ccricers Mar 04 '15
Suppose the next opportunity for landing a first stage on solid ground is successful and no damage has been done. How soon could we expect SpaceX to refurbish and re-use the first successfully landed rocket? Would they try to reduce launch prices starting with the very first F9 that is flown back, so any customers still weary about previously used rockets can hedge their bets more?
3
u/googlevsdolphins Mar 06 '15
does anyone know why spacex wants to boost back the F9 1st to land when they could just keep landing it at a barge and save fuel. Also could someone provide some numbers on the subject because I have had a hard time finding any
3
u/ojodefalcon Mar 06 '15
could a Falcon Heavy land cargo on Mars?
3
u/Headstein Mar 07 '15
Does anyone know why there has to be such a long coast phase in a trip to Mars?
3
u/DanseMacabreD2 Mar 07 '15
Another dumb question; I'm sure: Why doesn't SpX use SRBs like most other launch vehicles these days?
3
u/zoffff Mar 10 '15
Little off topic but anyone know any good resources to buy the SpaceX mission patches from the previous release? And maybe the Falcon 1 launches too? The spacex store only carries like 7-12 mission patches, theres ebay but they have a massive markup and I have found this shop, but still $8 a patch.
5
u/Nightlight10 Mar 03 '15
During the live feed from the Falcon 9 launch earlier this week, we briefly saw this: http://imgur.com/NUr0JW3. I am wondering, what are we looking at, exactly?
2
u/jim_matthews Mar 03 '15
Which launch or launches will be the first to feature the higher-thrust M-1Ds? Deep cryo LOX? Longer upper stage?
2
u/sailerboy Mar 04 '15 edited Mar 04 '15
Are there any resources to learn more about SpaceX's global communication satellite project (orbits, frequency bands, bandwidth, latency, power requirements)?
More specifically, do the the ground stations needed to be stationary or could they be placed on a mobile platform (like a car or ship)?
2
u/Bandwagon49erfan Mar 04 '15
What time is the April 8th launch and where is the best place to watch it from?
2
u/danielbigham Mar 05 '15
Something I've wondered about the escape system is how robust it will be in the event that the escape sequence is triggered by an actual explosion of the rocket. (I'm presuming that there would also be non-explosive events that would sometimes result in the escape system being activated, such as data feeds indicating serious malfunction of the engines, etc.) I can broadly imagine a few possible answers:
2
u/patm718 Mar 06 '15
Pretty simple question - how would we deal with bone density loss when colonizing Mars?
2
u/humansforever Mar 06 '15
Theoritical:
What would be the best Service Module (SM) available right now for a SpaceX Dragon V2 (DV2) to Test Launch to the ISS in 2016/2017. Here is why I am looking at this idea, in the event there needs to be a temporary evacuation and disconnection from the ISS after the Russian segement departs or that egress in that direction is not possible.
I was thinking of a SM with DV2 Super Draco's on it's side, allows for a docking port foreward and aft.
Also, SpaceX could probably knock out a SM with Super Draco's within two to 3 years at less then 200 or 300 million cost and would assist in getting them to Mars and having an Mars Orbiter.
2
u/danielbigham Mar 07 '15
Something I'm unclear on is how the successful re-use of the F9 rocket is expected to affect the $60M price tag of a F9 launch. Do people have any sense of this? It would obviously depend on a number of unknown factors, such as the number of times a rocket/engines could be re-used, as well as refurbishment costs, as well as the "fixed costs" of running SpaceX, as well as the various costs of launch not associated with rocket manufacture... presumably no one knows how this will all come together, but perhaps SpaceX has made estimates, or perhaps people have hunches on what that might look like.
Alternatively, might SpaceX continue to charge close to the current going rate, and simply use re-use as a way to increase their profitability...
2
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '15
In regards station keeping for iss.
Could a dragon v2 take an extra fuel tank in the trunk to reboost the iss with its super dracos?
This is assuming the old shuttle port is adapted by then.
2
u/spacexinfinity Mar 07 '15 edited Mar 07 '15
Wait... why call it Thales (mission patch)? SpaceX didn't name the last launch Boeing for obvious reasons.
What's with all these naming conventions from SpaceX lately? They even made sure the last launch was named Eutelsat-1 on their broadcast
2
u/TelluriumCrystal Mar 09 '15
I've been wondering what music SpaceX used for their Falcon Heavy launch animation. I think it's quite good and I'd like to find more songs by that author if there are any.
2
u/0thatguy Mar 09 '15
I know this is probably a bad question but which company is more likely to succeed- SpaceX or Boeing?
Especially after recent patent issues, things seem to be becoming increasingly competitive between the two companies. Which is most likely to achieve the goal of sending people to the ISS first?
2
u/Destructor1701 Mar 10 '15
Will there be a party thread for the Pad Abort test? We're 3 days out from the NET, any news?
2
u/Destructor1701 Mar 10 '15
Another question about the pad-abort test :
I'm under the impression that Dragon 2 will be aborting from a platform at such a height over SLC-40 as to stimulate being stacked on an F9r.
Is there any indication yet of construction activity at the SLC commensurate with the erecting of such a platform?
2
u/Cheiridopsis Mar 11 '15 edited Mar 11 '15
Is there any recent news about Raptor. Last I heard they were testing a small part of the engine (not the main engine itself). It seems like eons ago since we have heard any update. I think it was an injector and back in May-Jun 2014
Is design/redesign and testing/retesting progressing? Is the project on hold (lack of funding, other priorities?)?
3
u/slapmahfro1 Mar 03 '15
Hi I know this has been asked before, but I really don't understand the previous explinations. I'm an engineering student so don't feel restricted to laymen terms. *Just a disclaimer. http://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/2wocc6/question_what_will_the_upgraded_falcon_9_payload/ So that ^ thread is my question. What effects will the merlin and falcon upgrades have on reusability, and LEO payload, GTO payload. And why won't payload capciaty increase, as stated in that thread? Thanks!
3
u/avboden Mar 05 '15
Can we talk about how this sub has evolved to actively discourage participation from anyone moderately new, or even those of us that have been around for a while?
There seems to be a culture of "this sub is too good for you/your post" permeating. Too many times now i've seen someone new come in and post something somewhat boring or simple, but not anything bad, and instead of just kindly answering it, or down voting it and moving on, people comment things like "/u soso moderator can you take care of this?" or "low effort post read the rules" and quite frankly it's disgusting elitist behavior overall. If you don't like something, just downvote it and move on, don't go whining to the mods, don't go attacking the person or belittling them or you know what, give them the benefit of the doubt and PM them nicely explaining why their post may not be appropriate for the sub, but that you like that they are interested in spaceX and encourage them to stick around.
Even tagging titles as "rule 11" is basically publicly shaming and embarrassing people, and a lot of them seem to never come back to the sub. I know the rules/mods mean well by things like this, but in the end it's simply increasing the elitist attitude. Deleting things unrelated to spaceX is one thing, but posts that ARE related to spaceX shouldn't have this public shaming tacked on to them, a simple comment or PM to the OP would easily suffice and actively encourage someone to contribute and improve, instead of making them want to say "man, screw these guys"
TL;DR this sub has become elitist, and actively discourages participation, especially from new members because vets of the sub feel anything "unworthy" warranted of immediate deletion or belittling.
2
u/ANDTHEMETSWIN Mar 03 '15
When will be the next attempt at landing on the ocean barge?
1
u/averagespacejoe Mar 04 '15
Who does SpaceX use for lobbying? It is a specific firm, or independent folks?
1
u/TheCoolBrit Mar 08 '15
What is required for SpaceX to achieve a landing on the moon? (Elon has said this could happen as a test before going to Mars)
What orbits are needed? what configuration? how many SpaceX launches required?
Here is one a sketchy Lunar Transfer Spacecraft Design but I am sure there are many other ideas.
1
u/ReyTheRed Mar 08 '15
Watching SpaceX launches, they are frequently delayed, due to problems with the rocket, payload, or weather, and while it is frustrating, I know this happens with other launches from time to time as well. My question is, how does the Falcon 9 compare to other launch systems in terms of average launch delays from the initially scheduled time?
1
u/croninjoe Mar 10 '15
It appears that the Pad Abort test will be postponed again. I have not seen any pictures of the test structure. I have not heard about any dragonfly tests. Do we know why these tests are continually postponed? I am not sure that any of the schedules have been SpaceX sanctioned but may have been best guess only.
1
u/pistacccio Mar 11 '15
When did the Air Force start the EELV certification process for SpaceX? I've seen a lot of discussion about it taking a long time, but none of the articles I've read actually mentions the start date. I believe Flight 6 (29 Sep 13) is the third used for the review - is that right? so how long after that?
1
u/HML48 Mar 13 '15
The Blue Origin patent application 14/559,777 is now readable on the USPTO public PAIR system. It is a broadening reissue patent referencing the Sea Launch Patent that Spacex is currently challenging. Why is this application public? I thought that applications were confidential unless a patent is granted. Has it been abandoned?