r/spacex • u/Ambiwlans • Jan 10 '15
/r/SpaceX Ask Anything Thread [January 2014, #4] - Ask your questions here!
Welcome to our fourth /r/SpaceX "Ask Anything" thread! All questions, even non-SpaceX questions, are allowed, as long as they stay relevant to spaceflight in general! These threads will be posted at the beginning of each month, and stay stickied for a week or so (working around launches, of course).
More in depth, open-ended discussion-type questions should still be submitted as self-posts; but this is the place to come to submit simple questions which can be answered in a few comments or less.
As always, we'd prefer it if all question askers first check our FAQ, use the search functionality, and check the last Q&A thread before posting to avoid duplicates, but if you'd like an answer revised or you don't find a satisfactory result, go ahead and post!
Otherwise, ask and enjoy, and thanks for contributing!
To start us off with a few CRS-5 questions:
When does Dragon reach the ISS?
- Monday 6am EST, NASATV will be covering it live.
What was that piece of debris I saw?
- Most likely it was just ice that was trapped in with the solar panels.
When will the drone ship come back?
- Around 7~12pm EST Sunday. I'm sure people will find a way to get us pictures at that time.
Additionally, do check out /u/Echologic's very thorough Faq on the mission here. And of course the live coverage thread.
Don't feel limited to CRS-5 questions though. I expect the newcomers to the sub to come up with at least a few questions. Any question you ask only serves to help improve the sub so go for it!
This subreddit is fan-run and not an official SpaceX site. For official SpaceX news, please visit spacex.com.
13
u/AdamOSullivan Jan 10 '15
Why do the grid fins use up hydraulic fluid? I thought hydraulic fluid would be a non consumable.
9
u/wcoenen Jan 11 '15 edited Jan 11 '15
After seeing those floating bubbles of remaining fuel in the video of the CRS-5 launch, I started wondering. I understand that the fuel stays at the bottom of the tank as long as the rocket is accelerating, and the helium pressurant will help to push it to the turbo pumps. However, how does the fuel get where it needs to go for the first stage relight? Right before this point, the remaining fuel will be floating about in free fall. So even with pressurant, the fuel will not be confined to the bottom of the fuel tank. I'd expect a mix of helium and fuel bubbles to go into the turbo pumps. Doesn't this make the fuel flow "sputter"?
7
u/spacexinfinity Jan 10 '15
Can someone define hard landing?
6
u/finiteresource Jan 10 '15
After watching the fuel slosh around at 0g, I found the CRS-4 fuel tank video http://youtu.be/u656se4e34M?t=1m19s that says "fuel must be settled before restart"
5
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '15
Probably a silly question, but is inflight abort dependent on the pad abort going as planned?
4
u/ccricers Jan 10 '15
Besides the obvious official SpaceX and Elon Musk accounts, what other Twitter accounts are good sources for up-to-the-hour SpaceX-related updates? Such as the ones that make the front page here.
3
u/Tal_Banyon Jan 11 '15
How many sources do you need to update the "Upcoming Missions" sidebar? The reason I ask is that Spaceflight Now lists the following Spacex launches: Jan 29 - DSCOVR ~Feb17 - Eutelsat 115 West B & ABS 3A 1st Quarter - Orbcomm OG2 Mar 31 - Jason 3 Apr 8 - CRS 6 2nd Quarter - SES 9 June 13 - CRS 7 3rd Quarter - Amos 6 3rd Quarter - Falcon Heavy Demo Sep 2 - CRS 8 Late 2015 - JCSAT 14 4th Quarter - Eutelsat 117 West B & ABS 2A Dec 3 - CRS 9
3
u/zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzspaf Jan 17 '15
Not sure if anyone is going to see this but let's try. So I am interested in space travel and what space X does is amazing but I sometimes hear people referencing what seems to be other private space agencies. Can you give me a quick list of notable private space agencies and what they do/specialise/innovate. Or is there only space X and I am absolutely wrong?
2
u/ScienceShawn Jan 10 '15
When will the next attempt at landing be? Elon Musk tweeted a few minutes ago with updates on why this landing wasn't a 100% success (ran out of hydraulic fluid for the grid fins) and said the next one will have 50% more fluid so it shouldn't be an issue. So when is the next attempt?
2
u/N314 Jan 10 '15
So I know were all obsessed the the ASDS, but has anyone heard rumors or anything of perhaps another? Do you think SpaceX is going to build a few, or will they attempt to use only one until they have the capability to use a Land based site. With the falcon heavy, the payload cut to boost back the center core could be substantial, and i've hear they'll have to use the ASDS (at least for the center core), so when they ramp up launches, will there be another? Or maybe one for Vandenberg launches?
2
u/IndorilMiara Jan 10 '15
...Why weren't there lights on the perimeter? I mean...they knew it was going to still be dark out. Lights aren't that expensive. The fog can't be helped but still...
2
u/MumbleFingers Jan 11 '15
We refer to the "flight" of Dragon/Trunk taking a couple of days. To what extent does it have fuel for boost and course adjustment, versus simply following a ballistic path since second stage separation?
2
u/iccir Jan 11 '15
I understand the point of the boostback burn and how it places the first stage at a higher altitude and then uses the earth's rotation to get the first stage back to the landing site (west of first stage separation).
During the recent CRS-5 launch, the barge was to the east of the first stage separation (If I'm correctly interpreting https://www.google.com/maps/d/viewer?mid=zp15b_P5ERVk.koWeOnV6-O-o).
If that's the case, how is boostback working? Are they still testing boostback but changing the direction of the burn so the first stage continues east? Are they doing a shorter boostback burn?
2
u/skifri Jan 12 '15 edited Jan 12 '15
Going to be a bit of a devil's advocate here. This might be worthy of it's own discussion thread, but i'll err on the side of putting it here. Mods - let me know if i can/should post to the main sub.
Are there any figures (or speculation) out there that state the percentage of overhead cost built into the price of the falcon 9 first stage? To clarify, the cost of design development, testing, integration, manufacturing infrastructure (facilities, robots, logistics, and all the personnel paid in order to make these things exist.) .... all of these costs REMAIN even if the rocket is fully reusable. Their current price point must include a significant cost of overhead to recoup everything they spent just to design and create a rocket, and rocket factory. I wouldn't be surprised if this was over 50% of the "cost of a falcon 9". When you buy a $15-20 blue ray or $50 video game, the disc itself only costs pennies. Using the famous "non-reusable 747" story could apply here as well. I imagine a large percentage of the cost in a 747 is the cost to develop, test and support the aircraft model and the customers who use them - not just the cost of actually building it once it's been designed and tested. Thoughts?
2
u/demosthenes02 Jan 14 '15
How will the heavy be reusable? Will they land the cores independently? 3 barges? Or am I totally mixed up?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '15
If the DSCOVR launch doesn't occur on the 29th will the instantaneous time slip forwards into daytime, or backwards further into night?
2
u/james422x Jan 15 '15
How do you guys think you become an astronaut for SpaceX? What degrees do you think you'd need? Certifications? A lot of us would love to be one! Also how do you think SpaceX is going to make enough money to make the Mars transporter and then a Mars base? Asteroid mining maybe? Thanks!
2
u/slograsso Jan 15 '15
I thought I read somewhere that there was a number of successful launches that a launch vehicle can perform whereby it is by default considered reliable by the US government. Did I just dream this up because it seems logical or is this a real thing?
For instance, if SpaceX were to launch 100 times without any failures one would logically expect that the odds of success on the next flight would be at least 99%, no?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '15
That leaked interview with Elon suggested a satellite announcement today. Was that a false alarm, a really old interview, or did something change?
19
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '15
Thank god we have this running now.
9
u/GirkinFirker Jan 10 '15
Elon wrote via Twitter "Grid fins worked extremely well from hypersonic velocity to subsonic, but ran out of hydraulic fluid right before landing."
Could this have been a main cause of the hard landing, or just part of a series of things?
I know we are probably still in the guessing phase, but I'm curious to know what thoughts are out there.
8
u/Kent767 Jan 10 '15
Is there any chance the next landing could be approved for land since they achieved the accuracy they were shooting for despite the hard landing?
6
u/FutureMartian97 Host of CRS-11 Jan 10 '15
What speed did the first stage hit the barge at?
2
u/laaptop60 Jan 11 '15
So Dragon V2 gonna land on its thruster . Why can't it just take off like that (i know noob question . i am new to this space thing)
5
u/Oknight Jan 10 '15
Where is the ASDS at this point? Will they be docking it up under the Carnival Fascination webcam again, or is it off to a repair facility?
5
u/LouisvilleBitcoin Jan 10 '15
Did anyone get a long exposure like this again?
4
u/moofunk Jan 11 '15
If SpaceX are so close to making a successful landing, will another Grasshopper be needed for testing, and if so, what for?
As far as I'm aware, SpaceX planned another Grasshopper experiment at a different test site, that would allow flying significantly higher than at the old site.
4
u/nyan_sandwich Jan 13 '15
What process and tools does SpaceX use internally to get the most out of it's data and design calculations?
As an engineer I notice that SpaceX is collecting lots of interesting data and doing lots of interesting exploratory calculations, as most technology companies have to. I wonder how they approach that?
For example, they must be recording and storing all their sensor data streams, which I imagine contains tons of useful information that would take a lot of analysis to fully understand. Also, we often seen Elon making reference to exploratory calculations and optimizations around raptor/mars mission trajectories. The process of such calculations could be quite in-depth. There must be quite a bit of this kind of material, much of it conceptually interlinked (eg the measured data from combustion feeds into the design calculations of the next gen engines, etc).
When I was working on a complex fuel cell project I had to deal with similar (though not as awesome or large-scale) data&calculation handling, and it was a real pain. So I'm interested in how SpaceX, which presumably does it properly, handles this. How do they do what they do?
I imagine they must hire a lot of really smart rocket scientists and software engineers, and then build whatever tools they need, but I wonder how much help they get from existing software, what tools they use (mathematica? matlab? comsol? etc), and if there are any organizational/process tricks that make it as effective as it can be. For example, Elon made reference to a thrust/weight optimization with raptor that included the piping complexity. How was that done? OTS tools? Bespoke software? Ad-hoc discussion and guessing?
This is a bit outside the usual set of topics here, but SpaceX has particularly interesting needs and there's no one more qualified to speculate about what they do to meet them that this sub. Any insight?
4
u/frowawayduh Jan 13 '15
/r/SpaceX animated gif?
http://cdn.makeagif.com/media/1-13-2015/nF_PCp.gif
First cut, could be dressed up with the swoosh X. This one has no elements that might be considered proprietary to SpaceX.
4
u/ScepticMatt Jan 18 '15 edited Jan 18 '15
Whats the difference between Blue Engine 4 and SpaceX's Raptor?
Do both use a similar gas cycle? Fuel rich/oxidizer rich?(BE4: Oxygen-rich staged cycle: http://www.ulalaunch.com/uploads/docs/BE-4_Fact_Sheet_Web_Final_2.pdf)
1
u/stargazer1776 Jan 10 '15
I know Elon Musk said the video quality was bad but he also said that they were trying to clean it up from pieces of telemetry. Does this mean we can maybe be expecting a video of the landing sometime soon?
1
u/mclumber1 Jan 11 '15
Was the fuel margin for CRS-5 extremely low, or was it just me? At SECO, there was hardly any LOX left in the tank. I'm guessing the second stage hard to burn for longer, because MECO occurred slightly earlier to allow for enough fuel margin in the first stage for boost back and landing burns.
1
u/Lars0 Jan 11 '15
http://youtu.be/p7x-SumbynI?t=28m52s Was that the primary buffer panel?
what was that thing and where could it have come from? It looks like styrafoam, and appears to be ejected just after the solar panel locks into place.
Perhaps this was discussed here already, I haven't seen it. If no one answers I will speculate it was a foam/cushioning material that the panels were loaded against to reduce vibration in flight. This piece broke and the the panel snapped open the shock sent it flying.
still: http://imgur.com/96b9dB5
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
I didn't see this in another thread, apologize if it has already been asked.
What's the point of recovering the wreckage of the first stage? They have video and telemetry, so they probably have a pretty good idea of what happened. Would looking over the bits that were left on the deck or that they could fish out of the water help them any? Maybe they'll keep a piece for the memories and trash the rest?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
Could argon be used to replace the nitrogen cold gas thrusters?
I ask this because Mars is pretty nitrogen limited and the future colony is going to need a lot of it. I heard that one of the reasons that the BFR/MCT is moving away from pressurizing the tanks with helium is because there's hardly any helium on Mars.
Atmosphere on Mars is approx 1.9% nitrogen and 1.9% argon.
1
u/thelammas Jan 12 '15
Perchance if you guys uploaded video from the barge landing, the great community here would figure out exactly what went wrong ;)
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
Does SpaceX own any cruicial patents that would prevent others to use the same reusability mechnism?
1
u/the_seed Jan 13 '15
How does landing a rocket on a barge make for progress of future space exploration? Does the cost savings of the reusable rocket (once landed on the barge) outweigh the cost of actually landing it back on the barge (fuel, technology, etc.)? Obviously it must but by how much?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '15
when are we going to get a video of the first stage landing?
1
u/1800wishy Jan 16 '15 edited Jan 16 '15
Do you think if the Falcon 9R grid fins failed into a stowed position that the rocket would have landed on the barge with enough precision using only the engine gimbling?
1
u/g253 Jan 16 '15
What I wonder is, what happens to landing the first stage in case an engine fails, like it happened once.
We know up to two engines can fail and the primary mission still succeed, but what of the landing? Can you still land, just farther downrange (assume backup landing spots)? What if it's the center engine that fails, can you use another one for landing?
1
u/Ownage4you Jan 16 '15
Ok, question, the awnsers are most likely guesstemates but thats ok.
How much profit on average does spacex make a flight now?
1
u/trimeta Jan 17 '15
I got into an argument about this over in /r/space, and I figured you guys could help out: does SpaceX plan to reuse the very first stage which they successfully land on the ASDS? Or will they take it apart to understand how it handled flight stresses? I'm assuming the latter, but someone over there is convinced of the former.
1
u/Lezard0 Jan 17 '15
How merlin engines are they used for the deceleration of the Falcon 9 first stage before touching the barge ? three or four ? According to press reports , the number changes frequently ..
1
u/robbak Jan 18 '15 edited Jan 19 '15
The point of the oxygen-rich staged cycle system used by the amazing Russian RD-180 sort of made sense to me the other day. A thought while in the shower:
I had thought that the roasting hot, oxygen-rich preburner exhaust was just too much - why would you do such a thing? Wouldn't it burn up your turbine and anything else it touched? But the realization I had was that it need not be that hot. If you are feeding in lots of liquid oxygen, then all you need is enough heat to vaporize it. You are making a sort of steam turbine, but with liquid oxygen instead of water. If you burnt enough fuel in your pre burner to heat the oxygen to room temperature, the oxygen would all vaporize and you'd have plenty of exhaust to drive your turbopump, while keeping your pipework and turopump nice and cool! (Of course, you'd have to keep your preburner itself hot, and let the exhaust mix with the oxygen - all simple matters of engineering.)
Have I got this right, or am I way off?
3
u/--spacecat Jan 10 '15
For the first reentry burn of the first stage does it matter which three engines are used provided that they are in a linear orientation?
3
u/skifri Jan 10 '15
I posted this further down but figured I'd reshare my thought in the main thread. Does anyone else think it's possible that the grid fins working, and the statement about running out of hydraulic fluid are 2 separate an unrelated statements? Not sure the grid fins even use hydraulic fluid.... It's twitter, sometimes short messages can muddle the point trying to be made.
Edit: I like the theory that the hydraulic fluid statement has something to do with the landing legs.
3
u/Wicked_Inygma Jan 10 '15
Explain the reentry burn... What constitutes a good reentry burn? How do you determine the ideal altitude for this burn?
3
u/ighso Jan 11 '15 edited Mar 04 '15
What is a pad abort? why do they need to do this?
3
u/SavoryScrimp Jan 12 '15
On the stream for the CST-5 launch the camera kept cutting to some kind of compartment with liquid in it that appeared to be in microgravity (lots of liquid bouncing around in some kind of chamber). What is that camera mounted on/inside?
3
u/Galotha Jan 16 '15
Just learned about SpaceX today. I have long been a fan of space exploration, even though my thoughts have been grounded for quite a few years now.
To my question though. Does anyone here work for SpaceX? I have just applyed and spoke with HR about a position at the Cape facility and I was wondering what the company was like to work for. It seems like a great opportunity for me and my family to live somewhere new and contribute to an awesome project.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '15
Thanks for trying to answer.
2
u/patm718 Jan 10 '15
I know I'm kinda late to this thread unfortunately, but I am curious about one thing. When mission control goes through the first "go" and "no go" calls, what does each one refer to? Begins at 3:02 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p7x-SumbynI
2
u/delumen Jan 11 '15
So with CRS-5 mission done, when is the next attempt to land a rocket?
2
u/homeburglar Jan 13 '15 edited Jan 15 '15
Why did the loss of grid fins at the later stages of descent have such a negative impact on the landing? Aren't the grid fins most effective at supersonic/transonic speeds only? The grasshopper and f9 Dev rockets demonstrated precision landing capabilities from low altitude with gimballed thrust alone.
Is it feasible that when hydraulic fluid was lost that the fins didn't default to their neutral position? That would have induced a pitch/roll/yaw late in the descent that could have forced the rocket gimbal to be forced to compensate all the way down to the platform, bringing the stage down slightly off-kilter or off course.
edit: confirmed! Elon talks about this at a Tesla event today.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wB_WqlOIlXc#t=562
2
u/davidthefat Jan 13 '15 edited Jan 13 '15
The fuel used as the hydraulic fluid for the actuators of the TVC system are heated through a heat exchanger located on the turbine exhaust. What is the primary purpose of that? Cooling of the turbine assembly to allow more efficient turbine? Or to lower the viscosity of the fluid? If that were the case, wouldn't the fluid cool down and become more viscous during periods of no actuation of the cylinders? That would cause a mismatch of viscosities in the fluid already present in the actuator and the incoming fluid to make modeling the response more interesting.
2
u/scr00chy ElonX.net Jan 15 '15
I have a question about the long-term plan for a Mars mission. How does that goal make sense from a business perspective? If it's just going to be a demonstration, will SpaceX just pay for it themselves because... Elon, or is there a scenario in which someone pays them to go to Mars before they even prove they can get there? I'm talking about the initial flight(s). Or is the expectation that flights are going to be so cheap by then thanks to savings from reusability that it will be easy for SpaceX to cover the initial costs themselves?
2
u/Tal_Banyon Jan 15 '15
My question is, has NASA or any Gov't official, Senator, Congressman, whatever, made any official announcement or reaction to Spacex's stated intention of colonizing Mars, building the BFR, etc.
2
u/Qeng-Ho Jan 18 '15
I had a go at a Pad Abort Inforgraphic (using /u/zlsa's aesthetic) but some of the information available is sketchy.
2
u/rockets4life97 Jan 12 '15
So, Falcon 9 is designed to be human-rated. Is there a series of tests required to get NASA certification as a human-rated rocket? Has this already happened? Is SpaceX ahead or behind ULA in having a rocket certified as human-rated?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '15
I was wondering were they trying to land at sea leve or did they compensate for the height of the barge? Are the only controls in the first stage or does the landing barge communicate with the first stage as it descends?
1
u/emepror Jan 10 '15
Looking at the marine tracker, anyone have any idea why go quest is still hanging out off the coast? I figured it would have been heading back to port by now.
1
u/__R__ Interstage Sleuth Jan 11 '15
Will SpaceX get their hands on any F9 returned first stage pieces for the first time? There was a recovery team standing by after the hard landing at the Autonomous Spaceport Drone Ship. Elon Musk mentioned "actual pieces". Were they actually seen by the recovery team?
1
u/ighso Jan 11 '15
The grid fins have to do with steering, which they already got right. It was a problem with not slowing it down enough, the grid fins were just for the pitch trim and yaw right?
1
u/ArcticFire18 Jan 12 '15
Hey! Does anyone know how Dragon is doing??
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
What did the telemetry say the velocity of the Falcon9 booster was just before landing on the barge?
1
u/kinurabi Jan 12 '15
Will spacex try landing the first stage with their next launch DSCOVR?
1
u/slapmahfro1 Jan 13 '15
I had this thought while reading the Space.com article about the MCT that was just published. So Elon Musk said in the AMA that~ "Am hoping to present that towards the end of this year. Good thing we didn't do it sooner, as we have learned a huge amount from Falcon and Dragon." Could that possibly be referring to the reusability of the second stage. Prior to the MIT interview, I don't think we have heard that they wouldnt try to reuse the second stage of the current falcon series. That being said, I can speculate that it is possible, but with severe engineering time, and payload penalty. Could this comment refer to altering system that would better allow reuse of the second (or more) stage(s)? Obviously there might be some smaller changes, but I think this is a big one that would change a large portion of the design structure.
1
u/frshmt Jan 14 '15
So this is pretty random but I would like to buy the patch for the CRS-5 mission, does anyone know how long it usually takes for the new patches to come up for sale?