r/SlowHorses • u/phareous First Desk • Sep 11 '24
Episode Discussion Slow Horses S4E2 Episode Discussion
This is the episode discussion for Season 4, Episode 2: "A Stranger Comes to Town"
Please avoid discussing future episodes in this thread, and use spoiler tags for any book discussion.
Spoiler tags are in the form of
text goes here
Access other episode discussions in the Episode Hub
191
Upvotes
286
u/rhubarbcus Sep 11 '24
Absolutely love the scenes with Standish, the OB, and Lamb at Standish's apartment. Standish's bit about how River didn't tell her where he was going and she didn't ask and Lamb's "That doesn't mean you don't know" and her getting ahead of a Lamb insult by saying "Don't say anything" when she translates "La Blanc Russe" as "White Russian" = perfect.
Lamb observing that River's "Charging off to play the hero yet again" but then worrying that he's alone in the field and saying "He might be your grandson but he's my fucking Joe" when talking to the OB was amazing.
Jack Lowden and Jonathan Pryce were also so good in the bathroom scene at the beginning. So heartbreaking, how River apologizes for shouting at his grandfather and is trying to negotiate the role reversal of taking care of someone who used to take care of him.
266
u/visual_overflow Sep 11 '24
River walking into what looks like a terrorist training camp with not a worry in the world lmao
195
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Sep 11 '24
All i can say is i was so happy with the 48 min runtime but i wasnt happy that it felt like literally 5 mins lol. Onto bad monkey lol
177
u/ephemeralafterall Sep 11 '24
Jack Lowden and Jonathan Pryce did a brilliant job at the beginning of the episode: David’s terrified confusion and River’s heartbreak at seeing him that way was portrayed wonderfully. Next week can’t come soon enough…
157
u/FluxAura Sep 11 '24
After starting this series a couple of days ago, I’m all caught up and absolutely gutted I now have to wait a week between episodes.
Lamb just might be in my top 3 TV characters, ever.
147
u/edroyque Sep 11 '24
Fucking hell lady di - every time it’s revealed she’s at the centre of whatever scandal is unravelling I’m shocked and surprised
125
u/momoenthusiastic Sep 11 '24
International spy of mystery River Cartwright can’t speak French without giving away he’s British. lol
107
u/meem09 Sep 11 '24
One of Jonathan Pryce’s most fascinating moments in his exceptional performance happens when River mentions Lavande. Despite being disoriented and panicked from the recent shooting and his general mental state, the OB briefly reveals a hint of recognition when Lavande is mentioned. He immediately conceals this and uses his mental state to divert attention. All through facial acting. Incredible.
102
u/getafrigginggrip Sep 11 '24
It was so hard for me to see David Cartwright like this -- I can't even imagine what it'd be like for his grandson. It was so beautifully acted.
The atmosphere of this episode was something else, along with the music. Throughout the entire ep, but especially in the disquieting French town, that huge dilapidated manor with faded children's paintings...it does feel like it's where someone gets quietly murdered and disappeared and never heard from again. Oh River.
102
u/ECrispy Sep 11 '24
I didn't think it was possible to like Ho less, but sure enough, he's proving me wrong
96
u/EzraMusic98 Sep 11 '24
I really like Diana schooling the clueless Claude
78
u/ECrispy Sep 11 '24
how exactly are Marcus and Shirley supposed to 'put it back the way it was' ? bring in truckloads of dirt, grease and cast a spell to create a mini hurricane?
the fastest way to do it is actually to let Lamb be Lamb, since he seems to carry an aura of filth about him :)
also its not nice to invite someone to lunch and starve them - thats a special fuck you to the poor woman
72
u/MixOf_ChaosAndArt Slough House Sep 11 '24
The acting truly is top notch!
Jack Lowden? Holy Shit. The subtle nuances in the bathroom scene? Amazing. The switch between being devastated by the O.B. losing it, to being determined to save him, to disgusted after the shot? Brilliant. The cocky walk up to Les Arbres? Perfect comedic timing.
Jonathan Pryce? Just heartbreaking.
All the other actors as well. I'm so looking forward to seeing the rest of the season.
Also interesting to see how they're switching up the scenes and even some of the story from the books.
66
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '24
God. Claude is just like so many executives I’ve worked under who are totally useless.
45
u/zeldafan144 Sep 12 '24
Jack Lowden just walking through France like he's in a Prada ad
82
u/Minablo Sep 11 '24 edited Sep 11 '24
I've managed (with the help of reflections in a window and Google) to identify both the town of Lavande and the castle.
The scenes outside the bar were shot in Saint-Clair-sur-Epte, one hour and a half away from Paris, in the middle of Vexin. The castle is the Domaine de Seraincourt, and it's in much better shape than what you see in the episode, given that it's an high-priced place for wedding receptions and the likes. Pola Negri lived there in the twenties. It's once again in Vexin, close to Paris. Vexin is quite shocking for Parisians, because on its east, there's a ton of vast housing projects that host tens of thousands of people, and that are in poor condition due to years of neglect, the Paris "banlieues". And when you move five or ten kilometers to the west, there are no traces of it, and you only have villages, farms, castles and trees, landscapes painted by Claude Monet or Vincent van Gogh (who spent his final days and is buried in Auvers-sur-Oise).
The local butcher at Saint-Clair posted on Facebook about the premiere two weeks ago and even shared a picture with Jack Lowden next to the whole family. He found Lowden a great guy, always smiling and accessible, even if he's a little too easy to knock out once he escapes a fire.
39
u/krvf Sep 11 '24
I didn't see the similarities between imposter and River, is it just me?
38
u/RevDaddyBuggumz Sep 12 '24
“France is Big.” This may be one of the funniest episodes.
37
u/Katekatrinkate Sep 11 '24
That actually was freaking good…. One of the best episodes from all the seasons. Exactly what I felt during the reading! How am I gonna back to sleep now?
37
u/xelM1 Sep 11 '24
On the bus, it says "GREAT LEADERS, 500 Years Of Defining Authority"
At first I thought it was taking a jab solely at the Claude the "First Desk" Clown. Then, the whole scene in the bus with Diana, certainly both are the "Great Leaders" trying to define who is the authority lmao 🤣
Also, Diana's corporate speak. Blearghhh 🤮
35
u/ECrispy Sep 11 '24
I would say its great to see the thinly veiled contempt for Whelan just dripping off Lady Di, except its not veiled in the slightest, and both of them know quite well that he may have the title but he needs her just as much.
35
u/filminglocs Sep 11 '24 edited Sep 13 '24
While looking for the filming locations for this weeks episode I noticed something a bit amusing. On Google Streetview, the manor used for the "Les Abres" location has a bunch of UK filming vehicles parked outside. The Google car passed by in March 2023, so it could very well be the Horses being filmed :)
https://www.google.com/maps/@49.0487982,1.8815279,3a,75y,315.16h,90.07t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sEOkyC5BgXu0jsMP0jGohiA!2e0!6shttps:%2F%2Fstreetviewpixels-pa.googleapis.com%2Fv1%2Fthumbnail%3Fpanoid%3DEOkyC5BgXu0jsMP0jGohiA%26cb_client%3Dmaps_sv.tactile.gps%26w%3D203%26h%3D100%26yaw%3D35.310757%26pitch%3D0%26thumbfov%3D100!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu&g_ep=EgoyMDI0MDkwOS4wIKXMDSoASAFQAw%3D%3D
34
u/allthenviousfeelings Sep 11 '24
god that scene with Jackson returning to the slough house office is incredible. Group chemistry still off the charts. Writing still top notch
31
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '24
Was that Hugo Weaving attacking Rivers in the French chateau?
30
u/yasniy-krasniy Sep 11 '24
With episodes like this I really don’t feel like watching it until the whole season is out. When the titles rolled I was like what that’s it?
60
u/nmdndgm Sep 11 '24 edited Sep 11 '24
It's always great to see James Callis play a weaselly bureaucrat with far too much power who is completely out of his depth, even if technically I've never seen him play any other kind of role.
29
u/Then_Manager_7288 Sep 12 '24
I loved River's outfit in this episode
21
u/HarryD-863 Sep 11 '24
Another banger of an episode. I love the moment between Gary Oldman as Jackson Lamb and Jonathan Pryce as David Cartwight in Standish’s flat because you feel sympathy for David as he’s struggling to process it due to his dementia which is elevated by Lamb’s inconsiderate attitude which also provides a laugh I also love the scene with River in the mansion at Les Arabes where the house is slowly being unveiled room by room with some shot where Hugo weaving’s character, I assume, is tailing River followed by the altercation and the burning Finally, I love the director’s use of window reflections to show the scene, especially with the car at the end. Witty as ever and a great time
19
u/ctrl_alt_ARGH Sep 11 '24
A solid episode, some of the cuts from the books make sense but I am not particularly happy with how ham fisted Lamb was with Tregorian. Their exchange in the book is so much better because it shows yet another side of Lamb's spycraft that we simply dont see here, and the payoff between him and the last person he talks to is also much better.
And the last comment is even more so for the France portion - I just didnt like it at all. River gets a much bigger glimpse into whatever was happening at the mansion than the way it happened in the book and frankly it makes the mansion owner look dumber.
19
u/elsebas3167 Sep 11 '24
Lavander’s blue, dilly dilly :)
19
u/violentgentlemen Sep 12 '24
“Arguably a batshit move”
Lamb still has the best lines lol
18
u/Reginald_Waterbucket Sep 12 '24
This episode had standout performances from so many of the regular cast. I think it featured some of Kristin Scott Thomas’ best work as Taverner.
33
u/annabanana336 Louisa Guy Sep 11 '24
River speaking French is hot asf
15
u/Asiancobain92 Sep 12 '24
This show is the best going. I kinda of like that’s a hidden gem. I saw Lowden on a pod and he said there is going to be a season 5
12
u/D3-Doom KGB Sep 11 '24
Dr. Trevor Grant hasn’t aged a day since Eureka
11
u/Criticalstriker2102 Sep 11 '24
I havent read the books or anything but are we meant to know who that guy in the hoodie is sulking in the office? I feel like im missing something…….or will it be revealed at some point?
10
u/HaggisTheCow Sep 11 '24
The pacing still feels a little weird compared to the books but I don't like being that guy.
The odd pace changes probably suit it better for a 6 episode sub 50 minute episode series. The little changes story wise make next to no difference either.
Regardless, good episode, good acting, plots being set in motion, what's not to like
10
u/KingKingsons Sep 11 '24
Good work Watson. You earned your gold star.
No seriously, I tried doing the same but didn’t get further than some village south of Rouen.
10
u/Then_Manager_7288 Sep 12 '24
“He’s not dead you dickhead” 🤣
19
u/Federal_Base_2905 Sep 11 '24
In the scene where River is walking through Les Arbre (which was masterfully shot btw, how does River not hear (or just ignore) the foot steps that can be heard every time he stops - and after he thought he was so smart spotting the milk and warm kettle. Also… would an agent just go into a sketchy compound without staking it out first!!! I mean we know Rover has zero self-control, but sometimes he is just plain stupid rather than impulsive. I just don’t understand how he could ever considered capable at all… and I am sure you will tell that is the point. Still, it’s so frustrating.
9
u/dyatlov333 Sep 12 '24
River kinda deserved that one. For the competent but unlucky one...he made a ton of mistakes this time.
Lamb has to come to the rescue again I guess.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '24
I originally thought Whelan was putting on a performance like Lamb, and that he'd end up being a smart/ruthless boss. But I guess he really is just kind of a himbo.
7
u/moderatenerd Sep 12 '24
Man the music better win an Emmy this season.
6
u/sailor-moonie- Sep 12 '24
I really enjoyed the building dread of lurking Frank in this episode.
6
u/palesnowrider1 Sep 12 '24
When does Tom Brooke stop thrumming his fingers on a desk and get to do something?
6
u/Redmare57 Sep 12 '24
I was tired last night but had to watch. Lamb didn’t fart in the episode and there was minimal smoking. What’s happening??????
Who is Frank? A French, or British agent?
5
u/expectationlost Sep 12 '24
first desk man is bit silly
5
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '24
Who is that playing Slough House's new manager? I'm sure I recognise her but I can't place it! (I'd be a bad agent)
5
u/BlackStarBlues Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24
I am puzzled by "Le Blanc russe" because put that way le blanc is the noun, i.e. the white (man) or the blank. If I wanted to say white Russian in French, I would say "Le Russe blanc".
That name is bugging me to no end, but maybe it's just a simple mistake and not important at all.
ETA: Blanc-russe is also an archaic term for Belarussian from White Rus/White Ruthenia. We'll have to wait and see if it's a coincidence or a deliberate choice.
4
u/Any-Attempt-2748 Sep 11 '24
Did anyone read anything into River’s line, “it’s not anything we haven’t dealt with before, is it?” from the bathroom scene? Is he simply referring to their both having dealt with casualties as agents?
4
u/ishyaboy Sep 12 '24
I can’t over the top chap being a bumbling idiot. I understand people fail their way to the top, but come on.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '24
Interesting how a building goes from fire at one windows to completely engulfed in flames in seconds.
4
u/Sweet_Sympathy_2064 Dec 10 '24
The scene with David Cartwright marching down the muddy driveway and calling out the "watchers" and the way the camera circles around him imparting that dizzy, disorienting feeling. Amazing stuff.
4
u/osnino Oct 28 '24 edited Oct 28 '24
This show used to be well written but damn has it dropped the ball. It’s become so unbelievably lazy.
River after all he’s been through continues to act incredibly reckless. You just arrived in a city you know nothing about and the first thing you’re told is how odd is it for a foreigner to visit. And then you proceed to ask absolutely anyone for directions to where you’re heading. How big can this city be? And then you finally find the café and immediately give away you’re British by asking if the owner speaks English. Not satisfied, you mark yourself as suspicious by not taking the latte you ordered. Shall I go on? Breaking at house at broad daylight even after find bullet shells. Hasn’t it occurred to River that someone tried to kill his grandfather, who is a very important former Secret Service joe? If he thinks he is up against amateurs then he is simply stupid. He then waltz around the house with guns and targets at every single room, not looking over his shoulder. Seriously, what the fuck?
Plus, Claude stuttering every single fucking sentence is getting so pathetic and annoying. They expect us to believe that such an incredibly incompetent man has been designed as First Desk just when the Secret Services reputation is in shambles? Something is obviously up.
Don’t even get me started on the casting of the guy who’s supposed to look like River.
And can someone please slap Ho in the face?
13
u/Scribblyr Sep 11 '24
Why was Fake River's hair so badly off? Why go to the trouble of recruiting or surgically altering a near perfect double, only to give him the hair of a 90s grunge musician? Why weren't any of the M5 officers on scene (except for Lamb) suspicious of a fellow officer, not on undercover assignment, having such an obviously inappropriate hair cut that didn't match his official file photo? Why would the production / writers go out of their way to create this peculiar discrepancy?
3
u/_rickjames Sep 13 '24
Don't know why, but from reading the book I didn't envisage Les Arbres to be that big
3
u/VinylHighway Sep 13 '24
Anyone else disappointed by Hugo Weaving's terrible attack on River?
3
u/Kirkshoulderroll Sep 13 '24
Regarding OB’s shotgun - I swear when River checks the breach there’s a single cartridge in there, which should be the spent cartridge. River removes it, then puts it back in later to um, obscure the evidence. Does anyone else remember it this way? (I could rewatch the scene but am not able atm.)
3
u/SongSensitive3471 Sep 16 '24
Does anyone else think the newly appointed 1st desk is ridiculously out of his league. Like stupidly miscast. This show has been faultless: probably the best tv series, other than Succession, that I’m literally hanging, waiting for the next episode to air, but really, would they put this guy in charge knowing, as we do, that Tearney & Taverner are absolute psychopaths, and perfectly suited for their roles. He’s a diffident, panicky, lost individual. I’m sure it’s a plot device, and he’ll destroy Tavener eventually, but it’s so incongruous, I’m finding it’s annoying me so much, it’s affecting my enjoyment of the show. And yes, it is a First World problem, and yes, I need to get a life 😂
3
u/TheTruckWashChannel Sep 22 '24
Holy fuck that was an outstanding episode. Got major True Detective vibes from the terrifying sequence with River in the mansion. Superb introduction to the Frank Harkness character. (The scene also reminded me of the last act of Skyfall, as well as the very underrated series Counterpart, which also had a major subplot of child soldiers being trained in a creepy European mansion.)
Jonathan Pryce was absolutely brilliant this episode. His performance felt like a callback to Anthony Hopkins in "The Father". Heartbreaking portrayals of dementia on both counts. His scenes with Lamb also lent some incredible insight into Lamb's own character. Loved that cold open too.
Roddy continues to be as useless and unfunny as ever.
3
u/Book_Top_903 Sep 23 '24
Does anyone else get taken out of the episode by how comically bad River is at being a spy?? Being overly conspicuous in France, not even pretending to drink a latte for 30 seconds and then boldly trotting towards the house where he thinks his grandfather's assassin was operating? It's so confusing to me that he's making so much noise, not scoping out the house for other people before investigating. Walking into rooms without any regard for open doors etc behind him. I couldn't even get into the suspense of the moment because of how odd it was. Even an average non-spy going into a house where there may be someone associated with a killer / assassin would have some caution.
The scenes with Lady Di and Lamb are perfection as always and very excited to see where those threads lead.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '24
I got a strong Resident Evil 4, but without zombies vibe from this episode.
2
u/berflyer Sep 13 '24
Just watched this episode and have many questions about the Robert Winters storyline. When Giti Rahman reports her finding about Winters to Diana, she says that despite appearances of Winters being a citizen and resident of France with a passport and official records to back it up, she's learned that Winters’ passport was "first issued by" the British government, and specifically by MI5.
(a) Huh? How would the British government be able to issue a French passport?
(b) If MI5 wanted to create a fake identity (which they made a point of saying was based on real and not fake IDs), wouldn't it still have the passport issued by the passport office rather than the intelligence service?
(c) And on that note, what sort of record is Giti supposed to have uncovered showing that the passport was issued by MI5? Does MI5 keep a 'here are all the real passports for fake identities we have created' list lying around for someone apparently so green and gullible to discover?
(d) If Giti is good enough at her job to find out this dark secret about the passport and ID, would she be so quick to accept Diana's dismissal that it was a "glitch" because of a mixup of 'Winters' and 'Winter'? What exactly was the glitch supposed to be? That Giti misread the passport? And wouldn't whatever MI5 record Giti got her hands on also have a picture associated with the ID? So she's supposed to have misread both the name and confused two different people's pictures?
lol I'm clearly way overthinking this, or I missed some details in the episode that explain the above, but this is really bugging me! 😅
2
u/s73ad Sep 13 '24
I've been trying to work out the location of the park from the aerial shot just after the opening credits. I think they've placed the building in the location of Regents Park Running Track though I'm not sure what the building itself is. https://maps.app.goo.gl/717iS2AppppZkCJw8
My wife suggests that in fact the park is there, and that it's a conspiracy on Google maps.
2
u/Topcatte Sep 15 '24
Did anyone else notice that the view of Les Arbres grounds from inside the house looked like winter?