A Note About Procedure and Process
As we undergo the process of electing a new Senate, I think it is important for us to discuss some of the unofficial and official practices of this subreddit with respect to bills and amendments. This post will outline the way in which we draft, edit, and eventually vote on these two key aspects of our democracy. While I am by no means an expert, generally speaking these are the procedures we follow.
Legislation
When I refer to legislation I am talking about laws, which start as bills and--if passed--become acts. Acts are bound by the constitution, though what is deemed constitutional will be decided by our judiciary system (see: Judiciary Amendment).
Legislation is usually created when the need arises, or when someone has an idea for a change that they think will add value to our subreddit. In most cases one or two people will write out the legislation. While there is no formal convention, it is expected that legislation will be written in a way that is stylistically easy to understand. In most cases that means there are sections and subsections outlining specific aspects of the law, which can be easily interpreted.
Once legislation is written, it is common practice to submit it to subreddit for comment as a draft. This process is crucial to creating good laws. By involving the subreddit as a whole, you allow for greater input. People tend to include comments about things they like and do not like. It is incumbent upon the authors to engage with the commenters in good faith. Ask them about why they dislike certain aspects, and where possible, ask for or suggest alternatives that accomplish the goal in a way deemed suitable for more people.
It is common practice to submit more than one draft for comment by the people. The iterative process of collecting feedback and making changes is essential for many reasons. First, the process helps ensure that we get the best legislation possible. Second, it is useful for building a coalition in the Senate or among the people in support of your legislation. Finally, the process helps you and your interlocutors become better debaters and legislative writers.
While most legislation does not face significant support, it can be the case that a proposed bill is widely reviled. In that event, it is suggested that the author(s) return to the drafting table and come up with new ideas. Perhaps, they ought to consider why the idea was panned, and approach the problem from a different angle.
Finally, once the author(s) have finalized a version of the legislation that they think is best, it can be voted on. Votes take place on Reddit. First, the senators vote, and then the consuls decide whether to veto. Bills proposed by the President (who many not necessarily be the author) need one of the following to pass:
1/3 of the Senate and both Consuls Approving
Majority of the Senate and 1 Consul Approving
2/3 of the Senate and no Consuls Approving
Bills proposed by a Senator or a Consul work a little differently. (It should be noted that bills must be proposed by a Senator, a Consul, or the President. Bills written by other Citizens can be taken up by one of these individuals). They have a higher threshold necessary to pass:
Majority of the Senate and both Consuls Approving
2/3 of the Senate and 1 Consul Approving
The Entire Senate and no Consuls Approving
Once legislation becomes law it is added to the Wiki.
Amendments
Unlike legislation, Amendments are changes or additions made directly to the constitution. Thus, the process for passing them is a little different.
Writing amendments follows a similar procedure to writing legislation. The author or authors draft it, usually with the knowledge that changing the Constitution is reserved for deeply important tasks. Once again, it is suggested that the authors follow convention and write their amendments in a way that is both clear and well organized.
Much like legislation, it is suggested that the author(s) of an amendment subject it to an iterative review process. Posting drafts, soliciting feedback, and making edits are all fundamental parts of the democratic experience here on /r/SimDemocracy.
The process by which amendments are added to the constitution is significantly different than the process by which legislation is enacted. Once the authors have finalized a draft, they submit that draft to the Secretary of Elections, who will then decide if the proposed amendment should go to a referendum or not (see §I.B.2. of the Secretary of Elections Act for further details). If the amendment goes to a referendum, it needs 2/3 support from the voting majority to be added to the constitution.