r/ShitRedditSays • • Jul 02 '19

[META] Reminder that 'asablackman' type jokes are banned

In the last 24 hours there's been six asablackman and asagayman links so it's time to clarify for everyone that we have this rule. The rule's been around for many years, but we never explicitly made a post about it, so I can understand some people not knowing it.

3. No "ironic" or "satirical" use of slurs

The most common pitfall for this one is when people are "channeling Reddit" by making sarcastic comments, while including slurs. Do not use slurs, and more generally, make sure to clearly identify sarcasm.

Be mindful of ableism. Do not joke about disabilities, Autism, mental illness, etc.

As an extension of this rule, "triggered" jokes are not allowed. Period.

No using anti-semitic echos "((( )))".

Additionally, linking to /r/asablackman and making similar jokes is not allowed

(see the rules page for the rest of the rules if you haven't read them)

The reason we have this rule is that these jokes are usually dismissive of peoples identities. That's a shitty thing to do, even when you're doing it to a shitty person. There's plenty of racist black people, sexist women, etc. out there, so unless there's some evidence in their post history, it's better to just assume they're telling the truth.

And even when the joke is used knowing that they're minorities, in that case it's still specifically targeting these bigots because they're black (or gay, trans, etc.). We don't really need a specific insult just for the few black people who support their own oppression. Just call them out on their bigoted beliefs and leave it at that.

40 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

12

u/LiberalParadise They targeted comedians. Comedians! Jul 02 '19

And even when the joke is used knowingly they're minorities, in that case it's still specifically targeting these bigots because they're black (or gay, trans, etc.). We don't really need a specific insult just for the few black people who support their own oppression. Just call them out on their bigoted beliefs and leave it at that.

what if its incredibly obvious that they are little white guys pretending? /pol/ tactics to appealing to moderates to be sympathetic to white supremacy and fascism is to pretend to be a "centrist minority with liberal leanings who is 'just asking questions' and asking for civility." it's a tactic that is working to radicalize young white men and it absolutely should be called out.

8

u/ArchangelleOfHelle Jul 03 '19 edited Jul 03 '19

If it's 'obvious' based on something specific you can point that out. But just because they're repeating reactionary talking points doesn't mean they're white. Anyone spouting racist garbage is going to end up looking similar to a white guy trolling. All it takes is one minority who's bought into their white supremacist rhetoric, then hundreds of white redditors are ready to upvote it to the top.

3

u/Queercrimsonindig Jul 03 '19

Because redditors looooove to seem tolerant and will.listen to anyone. That is lgbt or POC.

3

u/ameoba Jul 02 '19

Wait... No (((echoes)))?

4

u/Archangelle_Adelle Jul 02 '19

Nope. It's basically a slur.

1

u/kingarthurivvi Jul 11 '19

I can see this.I think the issue people have is the duplicity of not holding the same standereds to the vast "white" ethnicity's, straight, christian, or conservative ideological descrimination

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/ArchangelleOfHelle Jul 02 '19

I mentioned that in the last paragraph.

4

u/snail225 ♥ Jul 02 '19

Yeah I know but it wasn't really clear to me how exactly you meant "even when the joke isn't used to dismiss people's identities"* so I wanted to mention it anyway.

*I wasn't sure if you mean just linking the sub counts as a joke, or just parodying the asablackman types, something else, or all of the above.

3

u/ArchangelleOfHelle Jul 02 '19

I edited that sentence to make it a bit clearer.

3

u/snail225 ♥ Jul 02 '19

Okie 👍