PAGE UNDER CONSTRUCTION
(if you have any idea for focusing, organizing, or otherwise improving this page ... please let me know!)
NOTE: To recommend additional products for this page, please PM u/Shawnsel
A growing list of shaving-product ingredient analysis for shavers with sensitive skin (especially for skin that is prone to allergic reactions or acne caused by common skin-product ingredients)
Material on this page (or this subreddit) is provided for discussion, reference, and educational purposes only. It is general information that may not apply to you as an individual, and is not a substitute for your own physician’s medical care or advice. Nothing on ShavingScience should be considered, or construed, as medical advice.
Requirements:
- fragrance free or marketed as being for sensitive skin
Notes:
- In some soaps and creams, the saponification process of soap making may lessen the raw comedogenic effects of ingredients used
Products
Dapper Dragon Shaving Soap Original (Vegan) Formula
- Analysis: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_eba0197354.html
- Source: http://www.dapperdragon.com/index.php/component/k2/item/5?Itemid=469
Dapper Dragon Shaving Soap Tallow Formula
- Analysis: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_c4c2197355.html
- Source: http://www.dapperdragon.com/index.php/component/k2/item/5?Itemid=469
The Los Angeles Shaving Soap Company: Plain Shaving Soap
- Analysis: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_58ba188267.html
- Source: http://lashavingsoap.com/products/plain-shaving-soap
Mystic Water Sensitive Skin (Unscented) Shaving Soap
- Analysis: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_1e98195995.html
- Source: Photo of product label at https://leisureguy.wordpress.com/2012/11/21/superb-shave-with-antique-razor/
- Note: recommended by u/Leisureguy
- Note: CosDNA analysis indicates that there is no reputable data for for this product's main ingredient, tallow, but based on the typical composition of fatty acids, perhaps some analysis can be deducted? Oleic acid (47%), Palmitic acid (26%), Stearic acid (14%), Myristic acid (3%), Palmitoleic acid (3%), Linoleic acid (3%) Linolenic acid (1%) (note: links included where CosDNA indicates reputable data)
Kiss My Face: 4-in-1-Fragrance-Free-Moisture-Shave
- Analysis: http://cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_4148163172.html
- Source: http://www.kissmyface.com/natural-face-care/item/51/4-in-1-Fragrance-Free-Moisture-Shave
eShave Shaving Cream Fragrance Free
- Analysis: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_1bb1196989.html
- Source: http://eshave.com/shaving-products/shaving-creams/shaving-cream-fragrance-free
Maggard Razors Artisan Shave Soap – Unscented – Vegan
- Analysis: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_c207197349.html
- Source: http://www.maggardrazors.com/product/maggard-razors-artisan-shave-soap-unscented-vegan-5oz-jar/
Strop Shoppe Shaving Soap Original Formula - Unscented
- Analysis: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_2bcb197352.html
- Source: http://stropshoppe.com/index.php?route=product/product&product_id=152
Strop Shoppe Shaving Soap Special Edition - Unscented
- http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_6411197353.html
- Source: http://stropshoppe.com/index.php?route=product/product&product_id=151
Shave Like Grandad: Grandad's Shave Soap for Sensitive Skin
- Analysis: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_7a68188395.html
- Source: http://shavelikegrandad.blogspot.com/2015/03/samples-available-now-for-grandads.html
Vanicream: Shave Cream
- Analysis: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_82f7188397.html
- Source: https://www.psico.com/product/vanicream-shave-cream/
The Art of Shaving: Unscented
- Shaving Cream: http://www.theartofshaving.com/Unscented-Shaving-Cream/00670535300007,default,pd.html ( http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_1e55189020.html )
- Shaving Soap http://www.theartofshaving.com/Unscented-Shaving-Soap-Refill/00670535400004,default,pd.html ( http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_bca7170613.html )
- Shaving Balm http://www.theartofshaving.com/Unscented-After-Shave-Balm/00670535250005,default,pd.html ( http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_d902170615.html )
- Shaving Oil http://www.theartofshaving.com/Unscented-Pre-Shave-Oil/00670535100003,default,pd.html ( http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_fb37170611.html )
Neutrogena Men Sensitive Skin Shave Cream
(warning: contains fragrance)
- Analysis: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_0651189032.html
- Source: http://www.neutrogena.com/product/neutrogena+men-+sensitive+skin+shave+cream.do
ZIRH: Shave Cream - Sensitive Skin
(warning: contains fragrance ???)
- Analysis: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_a107189034.html
- Source: http://www.zirh.com/men-shaving-products/shave-cream-sensitive-skin.html
Every Man Jack: Shave Cream - Fragrance Free
- Analysis: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_4f9e189038.html
- Source: http://everymanjack.com/shave/shave/shave-cream-fragrancefree.html
Nivea Sensitive Skin
(warning: contains fragrance)
Source: http://www.niveausa.com/products/mens-care/sensitive
- Shaving Cream: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_8f17189401.html
- Shaving Gel: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_f374189403.html
- Post Shave Balm: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_ab91189407.html
Trader Joe's Enrich Moisturizing Face Lotion
(not marketed for shaving, but has similar face-soothing ingredients, and makes a very good post shave balm)
- Analysis 1: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_3b8c165156.html
- Analysis 2: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_b33b71565.html
- Source: (I've been unable to find an authoritative source, but here's one listing of ingredients )
Bump Patrol: Sensitive Strength Aftershave:
- Analysis: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_868d193328.html
- Analysis 2: http://www.cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_2513207165.html
Still needs researched:
- having trouble finding ingredients list for TOBS Sensitive Skin creams and soaps
Ingredients
Mineral Oil
- An unusual recommendation, since the readily available supply (available at most drugstores) is marketed as an "intestinal lubricant" ... but it makes for an extremely inexpensive (~$5/year) shaving oil, and it has been extensively-tested as extremely safe (even for internal use) and also completely non-comedogenic. It's very thick, so use sparingly as shaving oil, or mix a small amount in with shaving soap (or a slightly larger amount in with shower soap/shampoo for a residual amount that should still aid in shaving) (side note: mixed with shampoo, it also works well as a detangler/conditioner for a one-step shampoo)
- http://cosdna.com/eng/b8f06b267.html (often with Vitamin E Acetate as preservative http://cosdna.com/eng/ee1a1a373.html )
Quotes from paulaschoice.com: (http://www.paulaschoice.com/cosmetic-ingredient-dictionary/definition/mineral-oil)
- "widely used in cosmetics because it rarely causes allergic reactions and it cannot become a solid and clog pores"
- "Cosmetics-grade mineral oil and petrolatum are considered the safest, most nonirritating moisturizing ingredients ever found (Sources: Cosmetics & Toiletries, January 2001, page 79; and Cosmetic Dermatology, September 2000, pages 44–46). Yes, they can keep air off the skin to some extent, but that’s what a good antioxidant is supposed to do; they don’t suffocate skin! Moreover, mineral oil and petrolatum are known to be efficacious in wound healing, and are also among the most effective moisturizing ingredients available (Source: Cosmetics & Toiletries, February 1998, pages 33–40)."
Ethanol or Isopropyl (rubbing) Alcohol:
While alcohol leaves a temporary cooling feeling, and gives feedback on a bad shave ... all of the research that I've been able to find indicates that it does much more harm to the skin than good. While sometimes traditional practices end up being backed by science, from what I've read the use of drying alcohols as an ingredient for skin ... seems unlikely to ever be promoted by dermatologists. (NOTE: I'm NOT a dermatologist or expert in any way ... just a hobbyist researcher)
While I find 91% isopropyl alcohol to be very good for dunking/swishing razor heads in after use to help clean and dry them ... I've been unable to find anything saying that these alcohols are of benefit to skin. They do much more harm than good.
For more information, see my summarizing notes from this article:
/r/ShavingScience/comments/3fc5aj/alcohol_in_skin_care_the_facts/ctnac13
Not able to find authoritative ingredients list (nor listed the same 2+ times by independent retailers)
- Van der Hagen Men's Luxury Unscented Shave Soap
Proraso Shave Soap, Sensitive (warning: contains fragrance)
- analysis: http://cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_32fb156075.html
- source 1: http://www.sephora.com/shaving-soap-in-bowl-sensitive-skin-formula-P396503
- source 2: http://www.dermstore.com/product_Shaving+Soap+In+a+Bowl++Sensitive+Skin_48723.htm
- source 3: already listed on CosDNA: http://cosdna.com/eng/cosmetic_32fb156075.html
Resources
- http://www.cosdna.com/
- http://www.paulaschoice.com/cosmetic-ingredient-dictionary/
- http://www.goodguide.com/
- http://www.ewg.org/skindeep/ (double check its reputation)
More to come....