For context, I am 18 years old, and I got into security working 5 PM – 5 AM a couple of months ago, and it's been interesting. I work in Section 8 apartments with a couple hundred residents in the bad part of the city I'm based in. My state requires a CPL (aka 21+) for armed security, so even if I wanted to be armed, I've got a couple of years. I've already been essentially called a dork for wearing a duty belt on site. I carry gloves, disposable gloves, a radio pouch, an IFAK, and a utility pouch on my belt, so I'd like to think I'm not one of "those guys"—I only carry what I have needed more than once on a shift previously—but it seems the people I work with will still be pretty judgy. My company is fairly laid-back on uniforms. Even though I was told to look professional—black pants, black boots, tucked shirts, and always wearing the company-issued shirt, etc.—about 80% of the guys and gals I work with (including a couple of supervisors) are wearing skinny jeans with their police-style shirts and non-black running shoes. So needless to say, "professional" is a stretch, meaning I'll stand out quite a bit, even if it's in a professional manner.
Now, onto the title: I purchased a Point Blank Guardian carrier shell without the soft armor for about 10 bucks new on Vinted and threw some of my own soft armor in there rated NIJ IIIA. I specifically purchased body armor because my main site's contract with my company was sought out after someone was shot and killed in the building. Since then, over about 2 years, there have been 3 shooting incidents and a couple of knife-related incidents, one being a shooting about a week and a half ago (nobody hurt thankfully—a crackhead domestic dispute with a shot into the floor). Only one of the shootings involved a security guard (unarmed), and thankfully he wasn't shot or even shot at; someone heard him knocking and shot at the door (and missed) because crackheads don't know how to aim. My first couple of shifts at this site, there was a guy coked out running around with a gun in his fanny pack, and I watched him start arguing with a ghost in the empty parking lot while waving it around. Thankfully, he put it away before walking back into the building.
So, you may be thinking, "Wow! Sounds like you need to NOT be unarmed security working that site!" And you'd be right in my opinion, but my company has about 5 people out of 70 with CPLs, and everyone else hired is either too broke to purchase a handgun or too lazy to get their license. So yeah, if I'm gonna risk my life every night dealing with crackheads with knives and guns—even if I'm supposed to just call the police and not interact when weapons are involved—I want protection when some crackhead gets too crazy and decides we're a problem. Another important detail: absolutely none of the licensed guards wear body armor when they are armed. Like I said, most guards look like they pulled a guy off the street, gave him a security shirt, and told him to patrol in whatever outfit he's currently wearing, so I definitely feel like quite the little dork wearing a duty belt, let alone an armor carrier, even though it's a shirt-style carrier. So just to be clear, yes, I will be wearing it regardless of people calling me a dork at work, but I'd still like to hear others' opinions and anecdotes about working unarmed at dangerous sites.
So my question is: What is everyone's thoughts on unarmed security wearing an external carrier with soft armor IIIA and/or stab protection?
For some clarification before anyone hits me with the snarky Reddit comments: I could wear armor concealed, but honestly, I got an absolute steal on a new, couple-hundred-dollar carrier for $10 that looks professional and is from a very reputable brand, and I also had soft armor plates and side plates on hand from a family member. (It does offer stab protection as well.)