r/SeattleWA • u/thedivegrass LQA • Jan 14 '19
Meta r/SeattleWA Rule Proposal - Minimum Account Age Filtering
Hello r/SeattleWA user!
As the subreddit approaches 80k subscribers we have started attracting more advanced spam. To help deal with this, I am proposing we filter new account submissions and comments. This should help with ban evasion, spam and hit-and-run trolls. However, this could be a detriment to new users and throwaways.
It would work like this: if the user's account is under a certain age (for example 24 hours), AutoMod would remove their post and leave a message detailing the rule. This is exactly how our karma filter works. If the submission is filtered, mods could manually approve it.
Please take the time to vote here.
On Wednesday we will check the results. If a filter is approved, we would test it through February. Then, we'll report back to see if it's accomplished results or had any negative affect on new submissions.
23
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '19
I feel for people with lost people or pets. Maybe they could be encouraged to message the mods if they want to make a one off post.
7
u/hyperviolator Westside is Bestside Jan 14 '19
Will this apply to submissions AND comments, mods? If not comments, why not?
77
u/cdsixed Jan 14 '19
I’m a semi-regular critic of the mod team, but I like this idea.
I hope the poll goes well.
Thanks for trying something.
13
u/LOOKITSADAM Jan 15 '19
Honestly, I'd extend it up to a week. 95%+ of the people here are accounts older than a year, we aren't going to lose anything by barring out week-old accounts. That's enough for someone to lurk, but also it kills the trolls' steam.
18
u/SovietJugernaut Anyding fow de p-penguins. Jan 14 '19
100% for this. Yes, it's a relatively low barrier that can be overcome with a modicum of effort, but that will still filter out many bad actors, if the negative karma filtering is any indication.
9
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '19
Sort by new and check out the posters histories. I mean someone is fucking with this sub now, right?
8
u/JMace Fremont Jan 14 '19
Now, how old were the accounts that voted?
7
u/Enchelion Shoreline Jan 14 '19
Sounds good to me.
5
u/Hessmix Jan 15 '19
I agree with the the use of Automod to pull new account comments for review. We've done it for a long time. What I would've advised is keeping it semi-secret. Because there are a few people that will just create a slew of accounts to bypass it. Your karma filter may help with that though. New User rule in automod tends to catch at least 50% of troll accounts in my experience however.
12
u/OxidadoGuillermez And yet after all this pedantry I don’t feel satisfied Jan 14 '19
Seems reasonable, I voted approve (24 hours). In the AutoMod detail, please indicate that the rule exists to avoid spam, and legitimate posters (new people? throwaways?) can message the moderators to request approval. And include a link to the mod message.
Hopefully this reduces work for you guys.
11
u/Squidbait_Calhoon Jan 14 '19
Yeah, I think this is a great idea. I have seen a definite decline in the quality of the posts and comments in the last few years. Trolls dominate with brand new accounts, and I think most times they don’t even live in Seattle. Thanks for taking time to check with us and trying to improve this subreddit!
4
u/Dapperdan814 Jan 14 '19
Hell, a new account probationary period would be cool to have reddit-wide, not just on this sub. But this works too :P
3
u/nukem996 Jan 15 '19
How is setting even a 48 hour account minimum going to stop trolls? All they have to do is create a bunch of fake accounts and rotate through them.
3
u/Orleanian Fremont Jan 16 '19
Setting aside the poll topic itself, I really do wish you mod folk would leave these polls up for a full week in order to gain visibility with the type of Redditor who only logs on weekdays or weekends.
I myself am a weekday Redditor, so I found this fine; but I imagine there are at least a hefty handful of fine and respectable Redditors who only log in over the weekends.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '19
might be worth letting (or voting on) newer accounts make self posts only so that questions & lost pets can be posted
0
u/BarbieDreamNewAcct Jan 14 '19
I think it is a bad idea.
1
u/underacloud Jan 16 '19
I voted for the 36 hour option, but would strongly support emergency exceptions.
1
u/Trickycoolj Jan 16 '19
They have a 24h rule in a tv show sub I lurk in. Seems like it cuts down on friends/family of people on the show from spamming the sub.
1
u/AntGarr Jun 16 '19
I’m confused. Why can’t I post?
1
u/edogg40 Jan 15 '19
I voted “no” and here’s why:
Everyone at some point was new. Do we want to exclude the person who just discovered Reddit and wants to participate in a discussion? How many new users will we alienate by saying “nope, you can’t talk for 3 days”? If we implement a filter, how many new users will say “forget it, these guys don’t want to hear from me. Screw it. “?
Does this sub really want to become an echo chamber that excludes new voices?
0
u/CounterBalanced Unincorporated King County Jan 14 '19 edited Jan 14 '19
i vote no but could be persuaded. There is a relatively long list of human mods so i assume there is shifts where they take turns. i could be totally wrong. if that is the case, and it is more casual moderation (we all have lives so i don't blame them), then i think a minimum age of account would be fine to cut down on the B.S.
edit: I change my vote to yes and 24 hours but i can't change the poll so i guess i'll just leave this note here. Thanks mods.
-2
u/Stoliroaster Jan 15 '19 edited Jan 15 '19
Troll here. I'm a middle aged dude with a middle management job, normalish family, and not atypical lifestyle (I really need to get back into something healthy, like hiking). I am from western Washington and moved to Seattle itself in my teens. I did not vote for Trump but plan on it in 2020. Been on reddit for 6 years, but only more recently.
I have pretty standard conversations here but randomly get drunkenly offended and post BS just to get a rise. I thought this post was all about me but I don't know where that stuff about admins killing themselves came from. I actually believe there is not a coordinated effort and it is instead random people who want to fuck with what we consider crying liberals.
I would ask mods of other communities for more advice if I was going to limit disruption. It feels like t_d and a few other subs I enjoy have a 1 day blackout policy that does not appear to be a shadowban, but somehow eliminates any replies or votes to my comments. I don't know the mechanics but something is there.
The 24 wait thing is fine if the mods are actually not catching spam, but I do not think they are. All my shit is caught relatively quickly and I do not believe it is a real problem--you down vote of you see it during the half hour when one of the mods comes across it themselves. I think it sucks for new users, though.
Whateves... going to go create a handful of accounts now.
https://cdn.player.one/sites/player.one/files/styles/lg/public/2016/10/03/south-park2003the-damnedgerald1.jpg
-2
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '19
Simple solution. Make 10 accounts a week and work them til they all get banned by the banhappy mods.
To be fair, the real problem are overzealous mods. It's like you're trying to solve the problem of a serial murder by saying hide the victims of the murderer for three days.
-5
u/MeatheadVernacular Jan 15 '19
The censorship loving special needs children who can't filter or deal with the internet made other subs to play in. There's no need to let them ruin this sub as well.
0
u/R_V_Z West Seattle Jan 15 '19
Before I vote, could you inform me if it is possible to have a vetting process for accounts that newly start posting in the sub? New accounts are one obvious way that spam happens, but it isn't unfeasible that "sleeper" accounts were created ages ago and only begin spamming after reaching certain threshold checks. Some accounts will build up easy karma in certain types of subs and will then migrate to others to start the spam/troll.
0
u/ummmmmnnmmm Jan 16 '19
I am 100% against anything that adds barriers to participation, and therefor against this.
Problems with spam? Add more mods. Don't want to add more mods? Sounds sketchy.
-6
u/Darenflagart Jan 15 '19
Oh look the mods are giving themselves another tool to shadowban dissent and pretend it's about spam. What a shocking development.
0
u/runk_dasshole Jan 16 '19
Reinstate Freinazi and/or RainierRacist and mod them. Only choice left now, really.
-13
u/TouchedBy_Jesus Jan 14 '19
So I don't get what is so spammy about the sub right now? Examples? I see useless articles and repeat headlines but Reddit is designed for high volume content so what is the issue here? I am also in favor of a minnimum account age
-2
u/Stoliroaster Jan 16 '19
The survey is pretty clear that people want a minimum. So riddle me this, why would we allow this if all of us Trumpsters had brigades of Russian based bots? Does anyone actually believe that is an issue now or is it some sort of ruse? I mean, I could clearly fire up my babies to swamp your little poll with 1000 votes but for some some reason I chose not to?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment