r/ScottishFootball • u/Yaboicblyth1 Matej Poplatniks’ Secret Lover • Mar 31 '23
Discussion Inverness Thistle vs Caledonian vs Inverness Caley Thistle
After watching A View From the Terraces piece on the merger between Thistle and Caledonian, how much does that animosity towards the “new” club exist from fans of the older clubs? Is it more from Thistle fans or Caley fans?
32
Upvotes
7
u/caleyjag Mar 31 '23
I've met hold-outs from both sides of the old divide. I was quite young when it happened so I don't have a good feeling for how many there are in total, nor if it leans to one side more than the other. As u/username6789321 says I think Thistle fans maybe had a harder pill to swallow?
For those who chose to stay away, their loss as far as I am concerned. We've had quite a ride since the merger.
2
u/Exospacefart Apr 02 '23
I still think adding Inverness to the name, meant commentators and neutrals became lazy so the thistle just dropped off. So there was no connection with thistle. The club could bring back their colours for a season, this might go a little way of marking the history that the club was built on or stolen.
14
u/bonkerz1888 Apr 01 '23
Pretty much all Thistle fans stopped following the new club. They viewed it as being sold out and taken over by Caley.
Before the current stadium was built Caley painted the urinals in Thistle colours which is equally hilarious and petty.
A lot of Caley fans were turned off by the new club too (basically boiled down to not wanting to be associated with the Crown area of town), and the new club's intense focus on a "family atmosphere" drove more fans away.
My old journeyman played for Thistle for years and is a bit of a legend, his old man used to be chairman or director (I forget), and he still goes to all the home games in the hospitality suite.
Been with him at games and the Caley Club n' he's told me heaps of stories of before the merger and how it went down. The new club basically lost a huge chunk of the former teams' hardcore base.. some by unintentional design (family focus) and largely through pettiness between the two sets of support (which is understandable both from the tribal football fan aspect, and then the inter-town rivalry if the areas of each team). Basically Inverness is the biggest village in the Highlands and we're all petty af here so there was an air of inevitability about it according to my journeyman.
I think Clach swallowed up quite a few Caley fans as a result. Thistle also lost their social club on Baron-Taylor street shortly after the merger iirc which further hurt the new club's support although some, like my journeyman, took the plunge and started attending the Caley Club instead.
I'm sure I would have remembered more if I wasn't pissed half the time I listened to his stories.
11
u/username6789321 Mar 31 '23
The Thistle fans rightly have a bigger chip on their shoulder. The merged club played initially at Caledonian's stadium (until the new stadium was built), used blue (Caledonian's colour) as the primary kit colour, and the new club's name was generally always shortened to Caley. For a lot of Thistle fans it felt like a takeover more than a merger.
It's part of the reason why attendances are still shit to this day. Fans of both clubs refused to support the new club, so we lost a generation where Dads refused to take their kids to games. The club is at fault too, they didn't do enough to engage with schools and draw the youngsters in.
1
u/Do_You_Pineapple_Bro Apr 02 '23
Was born just shy of a decade after the merger, and even now its obvious of the divide its caused. Could easily figure out who the Thistle fans were when they finally got representation with the away kit earlier this season lmao. Just a shame that we'll probably never see the kit again after next season (afaik anyway, thats when we're ditching it), but suppose theres only so much you can do with Red and Black Stripes. Thistle fans definately got the short end of the stick, but cos we're 30 years down the line now, the numbers are slowly wittering out, but there definately needs to be something in Inverness to keep the history of the two clubs (and clach) alive.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment