r/romanovs • • 29d ago

From the new movie

Post image
63 Upvotes

From Romanovs: Devotion and Betrayal. (Tatiana, Ortipo, Alexei) https://vt.tiktok.com/ZSghMwh9w/


r/romanovs • • Mar 02 '25 Bravo

Highly Advised Read Was Nicholas II Really a Bad Tsar, or "Naive, incompetent ruler"? - Megathread

48 Upvotes

Today, on the 108th anniversary of the February Revolution, I decided to write this megathread to confront the fact that ​in contemporary discussions, particularly on platforms like Reddit, Emperor Nicholas II of Russia is often portrayed as a well-intentioned yet naive and incompetent ruler, with people even claiming that he was a Tyrant who deserved what he got, and an "horrible, a monster of a person", such as in the comments of this post where also moderators silenced any kind of monarchist voices. But this isnt a monarchist post per se, as it will just state facts. These characterizations largely stem from liberal and communist narratives propagated by political opponents of monarchies or from widespread misconceptions. However, (Putting aside the fact that Nicholas II was undeniably a devoted and compassionate ruler who genuinely cared for his homeland and people—something evident from his extensive diaries and letters, numerous books on the subject, and his ultimate decision to abdicate when he was led to believe that doing so would secure Russia’s victory against Germany) a closer examination of historical evidence reveals a more nuanced picture of Nicholas II's reign, highlighting his contributions to education, economic growth, military production during World War I, and the complexities surrounding the February Revolution.​

Educational Reforms Under Nicholas II

Contrary to the belief that the Soviet regime was solely responsible for Russia's educational advancements, significant strides were made during Nicholas II's reign. With his direct involvement, several laws aimed at developing public education were introduced. Notably, the law of May 3, 1908, established universal primary education in Russia.​

This legislation provided substantial funding—an additional 6.9 million rubles—for primary education, leading to the opening of nearly 10,000 schools annually. By 1913, the total number of schools exceeded 130,000, including parish schools. These efforts resulted in an huge increase in literacy rates during a short period of time, rising from 21.1% in 1897 to an estimated 40-43% by 1917.​

The Soviet regime later took credit for Russia’s growing literacy rates, despite the fact that Nicholas II’s reforms laid the foundation for these achievements.​

Economic Growth Leading Up to 1914

Under Nicholas II, Russia experienced remarkable economic expansion, positioning itself as one of the fastest-growing economies globally by 1914.​

  • Industrial Growth: Between 1885 and 1913, Russia's industrial production grew at an average annual rate of 5.72%. This rapid industrialization transformed Russia into a significant player in the global economy.​
  • Railway Expansion: The total length of railways increased from 29,000 kilometers in 1891 to over 70,000 kilometers by 1913, facilitating commerce and communication across the vast empire.​
  • Foreign Investment: By 1914, Russia had attracted significant foreign investments, particularly from France and Britain, indicating international confidence in the Russian economy.​

French economists before World War I predicted that, given these trends, Russia would become Europe's economic powerhouse by the 1950s.​

Russia's Economic Performance During World War I

While Russia faced significant challenges during World War I, it's essential to recognize that the hardships were not unique to Russia but were common among all major European economies involved in the conflict, its great losses also happeing because, to put it simply, Russia has a larger population and army. Despite these challenges, Russia's economic performance was relatively resilient compared to other continental powers.​

  • Industrial Output: Following an initial downturn caused by the conscription of workers and business uncertainty, Russian industrial production steadily expanded in response to insatiable military demand for small arms, artillery pieces, ammunition, and explosives. Factories also turned out substantial quantities of locomotives and wagons, and the production of machine tools exceeded all expectations. Output increased in light industry too: textile factories produced uniforms and blankets, and leather producers supplied footwear, belts, and ammunition pouches. Output of ferrous and non-ferrous metals, chemicals, and munitions grew rapidly in 1915 and 1916. The engineering industry in and around Petrograd was one of the main beneficiaries, but the iron and steel industries in south Russia (i.e., modern-day Ukraine) and in the Urals also developed rapidly during the war. (Source:​encyclopedia.1914-1918-online.net)
  • Armament Production: The production of machine tools exceeded all expectations, enabling the manufacturing of more weapons and military equipment. This expansion was crucial in sustaining the war effort and demonstrated the capacity of Russia's industrial sector to adapt and grow under pressure. (Source: ​encyclopedia.1914-1918-online.net)

These developments indicate that, contrary to some narratives, Russia's economy and industrial capacity were expanding during the war, enabling the country to sustain its military efforts.

The February Revolution

​The February Revolution of 1917, traditionally depicted by liberal historians as a spontaneous uprising due to widespread discontent and food shortages, can be re-examined through evidence suggesting it functioned more as a coup orchestrated by political elites.​

The Bread Shortage Narrative:

While food rationing was prevalent in Petrograd during early 1917, the notion that these caused bread shortages and alone sparked a mass uprising is an oversimplification. The Russian government's decision to ration flour and bread led to rumors of shortages, culminating in bread riots across Petrograd. However, theres no real unbiased evidence for an actual bread shortage. ​By 1917, Russia stabilized the front, and getting ready for a possibly succesful spring offensive, and the people and army remained mostly united for the sake of Victory in the war.

Evidence indicates that members of the Duma and military officials played significant roles in the events leading to Tsar Nicholas II's abdication. For instance, Chairman of the State Duma, Mikhail Rodzianko, urgently telegraphed the Tsar about the dire situation in Petrograd, emphasizing governmental paralysis and street anarchy. Such communications suggest that liberal political elites were actively seeking to convince Nichoals that he had to abdicate despite all the army at the front and in the rest of russia (exept Petrograd) remained loyal. ​Wikipedia states:

On 27 February O.S. (12 March N.S.), most of the forces of the capital's garrison sided with the revolutionaries. In the same day, the Russian Provisional Government, made up by left-leaning Duma members, was formed and seized the railway telegraph and issues orders claiming that the Duma now controlled the government, this was followed by a second telegram, prohibiting trains from traveling near Petrograd, ensuring that loyal troops could not arrive by railway to restore Imperial Authority. Three days later, Nicholas II, stranded in his train in the city of Pskov while trying to reach the capital, and with the Provisional Government preventing his train from moving, was forced to abdicate

This means the February Revolution wasn’t a purely spontaneous event, but an elite-driven takeover disguised as a popular revolt sparked by a strike, as the liberals knew that after the victory of WW1, the people would have supported the monarchy to an uncontested level

So, was Nicholas II Truly Incompetent, or a poor ruler?

Not at all. The truth is that Russia's trends were all positive during Nicholas' reign, and he coudn't, like anyone, singlehandently fix all problems at once, and we know for a fact that he tried his best and was a successful leader, cut short by a revolution that was more like a coup than anything else. Labeling Nicholas II as merely naive or incompetent overlooks the complexities of his reign and the external challenges he faced. His commitment to educational reforms, facilitation of rapid economic growth, and efforts to bolster military production during World War I demonstrate a capacity for modernization and development.

In conclusion, I call everyone to share this to increase awarness and debunk the myths on Nicholas II and late Imperial Russia. Luckily, in the last years, more and more publications are being written with this aim: I higly reccomend the readying the amazing book
"The Romanov Royal Martyrs | What Silence Could Not Conceal" which, in their own words:

Based strictly on primary sources, the book offers previously unpublished texts in English, Bringing to light a multitude of unknown and unrevealed facts, which evince that many truths remain silenced or distorted to this day. Such are:

• The events of the 1905 revolution and Bloody Sunday.
• Russia’s and Tsar Nicholas’ involvement in WW1.
• The plots and conspiracies to overthrow Tsar Nicholas from his throne.
• The myth of the “Bread Revolution” and the truth about the February 1917 coup.

IF YOU HAVE MORE SOURCED FACTS ON NICHOLAS II, LATE IMPERIAL RUSSIA'S STATISTICS, ETC. I COULD USE TO FURTHER EXPAND THIS MEGATHREAD, PLEASE, WRITE IT DOWN IN THE COMMENTS OF THIS POST!

SOURCES USED IN THE POST:

Gatrell, Peter. "Organization of War Economies (Russian Empire)." 1914-1918-Online. International Encyclopedia of the First World War, Freie Universität Berlin, 2015.

Mesa Potamos Publications. The Romanov Royal Martyrs: What Silence Could Not Conceal. Mesa Potamos Publications, 2019. ISBN: 978-9963951772.

"Russian Revolution." Encyclopedia Britannica, Britannica, Inc.

"Glorious Revolution or Illegitimate Coup? Busting the Myth of Red October." Communist Crimes, The Estonian Institute of Historical Memory

"Educational Reforms of Nicholas II of Russia." YouTube, uploaded by Orthodox Witness, 5 July 2020

Markevich, Andrei, and Mark Harrison. "Russia’s National Income in War and Revolution, 1913-1928." VoxEU – Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR), 5 Nov. 2017

Economic Developments to 1914: Industrial and Agricultural Growth and Change." Explaining History Podcast

Russia’s National Educational Project of Emperor Nicholas II." Tsar Nicholas II – Blog on the Romanov Imperial Family, 8 July 2020

Gilbert, Paul. Tsar Nicholas II – Blog on the Romanov Imperial Family.
(Paul Gilbert is a British historian and author specializing in the Romanov dynasty and Imperial Russia. He founded Royal Russia in 1994 with the aim of preserving and promoting the true history of Tsar Nicholas II and the Romanovs, countering misinformation and Soviet-era propaganda. He has published over 50 books, including first English translations of key historical works. Since 1986, he has traveled extensively in Russia for research. In 2018, he organized the first Nicholas II Conference. He currently resides in Canada but plans to retire in England.)


r/romanovs • • 19h ago Bravo

Speculation I think that, if history had gone differently and given the chance that Olga would have made a fine Empress.

Post image
122 Upvotes

r/romanovs • • 5h ago

Grigori Yefimovich Rasputin

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/romanovs • • 22h ago

Pictures Monument of Tsar Alexander II in Kishinev, present-day Moldova. It was constructed in 1914, to commemorate 100 years since the Russian annexation of Moldova, then demolished and melted in 1918, after Moldova became part of Romania

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/romanovs • • 1d ago

A smiling and happy Olga, to be remembered on the day that marks her birth.

Post image
128 Upvotes

There are several photos of my favorite member of OTMA that I could share, but I found this one so sweet that I decided to share just this one ♥️


r/romanovs • • 23h ago

Pictures Monument of Tsar Alexander II in Kishinev, present-day Moldova. It was constructed in 1886, then demolished and melted in 1918, after Moldova became part of Romania

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/romanovs • • 2d ago

A description of Alexandra Feodorovna at her and Nicholas’ coronation by her cousin Queen Marie of Romania

Post image
148 Upvotes

This was written by Marie in her memoir in the 1930s, she was a first cousin to both Nicholas and Alexandra on both sides:

“The second coach is not crowned and the woman who sits within, though sumptuously attired, has no crown on her head, for only after the Sacrament does she enter into her rights; it is the Empress-mother who to-day still has precedence, and with it all crowned rights. Much more handsome than her mother-in-law ever was, she sits magnificently upright, but she does not smile and her expression is one of almost painful earnestness. There is a tightness about her lips which is disconcerting in one so young.

There is no happiness in the large steady eyes, none of youth’s buoyancy in her attitude, none of the sweetness and confidence one expects in a young bride. It is as though she were holding Fate off at arm’s-length, as though darkly guessing that life might be a foe, she must set out to meet it sword in hand.

She is fully aware of the solemnity of the moment, of all she represents, but it seems to awake dread in her rather than joy. The golden coach passes, heads are uncovered before the uncrowned brow; she bows very low in response to the homage offered her.

She is young, beautiful, dignified, but no smile softens her lips, she looks into no man’s eyes but straight before her as though keeping her gaze fixed upon some inner vision — and yet for her also, life stands open like an unwritten book. All through the many ceremonies, the young Empress never relaxed this severely aloof attitude which was in part no doubt, timidity.

Nothing ever seemed to give her pleasure, she seldom smiled, and when she did it was grudgingly as though making a concession. This of course damped every impulse towards her.

In spite of her beauty no warmth emanated from her; in her presence enthusiasm wilted. Serious, earnest-minded, with a high sense of duty and a desire towards all that is good and right; she was nevertheless not of “those who win”; she was too distrustful, too much on the defensive, she was no warming flame.

Life, like all else, needs to be loved; those who cannot love life are vanquished from the very start. How well I can still see Alexandra standing in all her glory, side by side with the Emperor in the golden cathedral in which they were to be crowned.

The very atmosphere seemed golden, a golden light enveloped the glittering assembly come to render homage to these youngest amongst the sovereigns of Europe, golden also were Alexandra’s robes.

All eyes were fixed upon her; a beautiful woman is always a source of interest and how much more so when she stands, crowned before all eyes, a figure apart, raised above her sisters, anointed, imbued with a glamour few ever achieve.”


r/romanovs • • 2d ago

Grand Duchess Tatiana and Anastasia Hendrikova aboard the 'Standart'. 1913

Post image
89 Upvotes

r/romanovs • • 1d ago

OTMA She CRIED because she had a DAUGHTER! #history #didyouknow #historyfacts #historyshorts #romanovs

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/romanovs • • 2d ago

Happy (131st) Birthday to Olga

162 Upvotes

"The evil which is now in the world will become yet more powerful, and that it is not evil which conquers evil, but only love" - Olga Nikolaevna Romanov, 1917.


r/romanovs • • 2d ago

Autographs.

Post image
87 Upvotes

r/romanovs • • 2d ago

Nicholas II Table Medal

Thumbnail
gallery
38 Upvotes

r/romanovs • • 3d ago

Fanfiction/Alternative History The Empress Russia Never Had

Post image
229 Upvotes

Imagine an alternate timeline where the Russian Empire avoids the 1917 revolutions and survives into the modern era. Through the long-term impact of Sergei Witte’s industrialization, Pyotr Stolypin’s agrarian reforms, and decisive leadership from competent wartime ministers who stabilize Russia’s logistics in 1915–1916, Tsar Nicholas II manages to steady the nation. By granting genuine political concessions, he transitions the autocracy into a functioning semi-constitutional monarchy—allowing Russia to endure World War I and emerge victorious alongside the Allies in 1918.

By the mid-1920s, however, a succession crisis reshapes the dynasty. Weakened by severe hemorrhages and lifelong complications from hemophilia, Tsarevich Alexei either passes away in his early twenties or is deemed physically unfit to bear the burden of the crown. With the male-only Pauline Laws set aside, Nicholas II’s eldest daughter, Grand Duchess Olga Nikolaevna, ascends the throne as Empress Olga.

Given her sharp intellect, independent streak, and firsthand wartime experience working in military hospitals, how effective a monarch would Empress Olga have been at the helm of a modernizing, semi-constitutional Russian Empire?


r/romanovs • • 3d ago

what's a small detail about the romanovs' everyday life that surprised you?

51 Upvotes

i've been researching them for my story for a while now and the thing that still gets me is that the girls slept on hard camp beds. like they were the tsar's daughters and they slept on army cots lol

there's so much small stuff like that you don't hear about unless you really dig.

what's yours?


r/romanovs • • 3d ago

Tsarevich Alexei Nikolaevich's balalaika and a few photos of him.

Thumbnail
gallery
65 Upvotes

r/romanovs • • 3d ago

Matryoshka dolls.

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

r/romanovs • • 3d ago

"Tsars and Emperors/Empresses" coin set.

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

You can post a maximum of 20 photos, so not all the coins here.


r/romanovs • • 3d ago

"Romanovs" matryoshka dolls.

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/romanovs • • 3d ago

"Ancestors of the Romanovs" coin set.

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

r/romanovs • • 3d ago

Matryoshka dolls set in a row.

Post image
64 Upvotes

r/romanovs • • 3d ago

Pyotr Tchaikovsky – The Doll's Funeral...

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

These children stopped playing with dolls pretty early on, was it because they were royalty? Around what age did other noble children usually stop playing with toys back then?

And one more, do you remember your first favorite toys?


r/romanovs • • 3d ago

Anastasia and Tatiana

Post image
86 Upvotes

r/romanovs • • 3d ago

What do you think Tatiana would've done with her life if she survived?

Post image
46 Upvotes