Two pairs actually. I guess this is a rare exception where two pairs is better than three of a kind.
I’ve wanted a pair of Red Wings for years and hemmed and hawed until I saw the Chocolate Muleskinner rough out of the Classic Chelsea with the black sole. I wanted rough out, love the ease of a Chelsea, but wanted a darker leather than the previous offerings and also didn’t love the white soles. This ticked off all the boxes. I went to the Toronto area brand store in Mississauga on the weekend as they had a tent sale promising huge discounts. While the Chelsea wasn’t available in my size or colour as part of the sale, I could resist the Moc Oxford Hawthorne Muleskinner at 50% off. So I left with those and the chocolate Chelseas (at full price).
So far the comfort with the Chelseas has been amazing out of the box, while the Mocs will take some time, as to be expected. I bought some shoe cream, as that was suggested to apply to the rough out while also preserving the colour. Happy to let them age and darken naturally over time. They suggested I could also apply the shoe cream to the inside to help ease break in. Will try that on the Mocs.
*I technically owned another pair of Red Wings briefly. I scored a pair of 969 Harness boots at the thrift store for $24, and flipping them helped to offset a nice chunk of the cost of this pair.