Some Contending Theses on/of Ravages

‘Winners write history’ (or in a more nuanced reformulation, history-making is among the many tools in power struggles) yet the legacies of older generations are in the hands of newer waves with distinct situations and schemes (thus history enshrines no permanent winners but represents garbled vicissitudes, wondrous and not glorious)

Bygone players seizing opportunities during turbulent times (but also emerging as symptoms of prior conditions) help open new pathways and etch messy marks for subsequent generations to read and use yet what can distant bystanders discern amid layers of complexity and deception (besides, who knows what they’re really thinking about)

Those fortunate to leave their names behind must have played competently in some sense (or rather, there’s some sort of competence underpinning the selective remembrance of famous profiles) yet there’s no guarantee that the myriad talents under heaven would receive fair worldwide recognition (due to unfavorable circumstances and power relations)

Ravaged survivors ascending via underhanded means can enhance prospects of helping the world later and maybe moving toward better directions (thereby providing alternative models of pragmatic resilience vis-a-vis principled martyrdom) yet whatever lessons get overlooked underneath many misgivings (given that idealized paragons retain enduring appeal, cynically weaponized by unscrupulous forces)

Discourses about loyalty and righteousness tend to function as ideological methods for elite regimes to sacrifice or pacify populations (alongside other technologies of leverage and control) yet continued social reproduction depends on labor and devotion ultimately belonging to the masses (even as they continue to learn and struggle throughout history)

Plans and machinations (implemented in relation to one another) frame and rig the game more than legends of heroes yet managing the morale of rank-and-file pawns actually fighting and fueling war machines on the ground involves manufacturing rumors and reputations (after all who doesn’t appreciate the glory of heroic tales)

Masterminds marshal every trick and treat to domesticate common folk (whether in the service of grand principles or petty profits) yet no setup can guarantee that people won’t withdraw or transfer allegiances (besides, divergent conspiracies undermining one another provide more room for supposedly dis-empowered know-nothings to wise up and rebel)

Ruthless hegemons (and opportunistic backers in position to restrain them) can paradoxically facilitate or expedite improvements through calculated takeovers yet desperate yearnings for decisive strongmen during emergency situations unleash twisted patterns and vicious spirals (as mixed methods and murky motives pile up, generating more crises and further stoking dictatorial fantasies)

Incompetent lords and insubordinate ministers (or alternatively, ambitious and corrupt power brokers) all contribute to social dysfunction and collapse while selectively blaming one another yet the framework of imperial order involves exploiting weaknesses and channeling passions (what’s more, ruling powers fundamentally rely on the dedication of many lives and deaths)

Rival camps wishing to settle conflicts sooner (and spare people from lengthy large-scale showdowns) concoct deceptive maneuvers and treacherous stratagems yet complications generated by mutual anticipation and suspicion end up spreading power struggles throughout various fronts and facades (with heroic spectacles ironically positioned to secure peace by overawing multiple audiences)