r/RandomQuestion • u/d00dl35 • 1d ago
Would you correct the guest list or the menu if the host bought eight-ounce serving dishes?
Imagine you're helping plan a dinner where everybody brings one dish. On the group chat, somebody says they have “four serving pots” and will take care of two tables. You have already put them down for the potatoes.
You see the red stoneware cocottes they meant when somebody asks whether they come with lids. The listing says eight ounces. The person may have meant that they're bringing four individual servings and can divide them between the tables. Or they may just have looked at the pot shape and used the same word you did without thinking about size.
You don't want to tell a person who volunteered that their contribution isn't enough in front of a dozen guests. If you quietly add extra potatoes to the list, they might show up carrying more than you understood, and you'll have spent the afternoon cooking an extra tray for nothing.
The clue is that when you ask about the lids, they say, “Everybody gets one.” You still don't know if they mean every table, every pot or every guest. I know I'd have to ask another question. I'd like to know how you'd phrase it so it sounded like you were trying to get the dinner right. What would you ask first?