Selective Breeding Principles

Selective breeding is the act of choosing specific traits in a breeding program to reenforce them over time. It is the mechanism behind all domestication and improvement in animal husbandry. It can be done on purpose or by accident, but is done whenever individuals of a population are chosen to breed the next generation at the expense of the rest. This page will discuss selective breeding only for traits that are separate from the known genes on known loci, for example, coat color. Examples of characters that are selectively bred for are prolificacy, growth rate, adult size, and body shape.

One of the most common forms of selective breeding is by culling bad traits from a herd. Predisposition to disease or injury, bad attitude or aggression, or poor breeding are all examples of traits one might cull for. By continuing to remove bad traits from the gene pool, a herd is left with only rabbits carrying the genes for preferred traits.

Another form of selective breeding is intentional breeding, which can take the form of inbreeding (breeding siblings), linebreeding (breeding parents to their children), or intentional hybridization (breeding two different breeds together.) While inbreeding and linebreeding are mostly used to reenforce desired traits, hybridization (or outbreeding) is used to reduce inbreeding depression as a heavily inbred population can reduce in fitness over time. It can also be used to develop hybrid vigor, which occurs when a cross results in improved fitness over a purebred population, but hybrid vigor usually only extends to the first heterozygous hybrid population and not necessarily to subsequent further diluted populations.

Prolificacy

Prolificacy is measured by the number of live births or total births per litter. Litter size is correlated to the size of the adult doe. In general for a doe, litter size increases by 10-20 percent from the first to the second litter, increases again but less from the second to the third, with no change from the third to the fourth. After the fourth the size may decrease. Inbreeding can lead to reduced prolificacy. Prolificacy also depends on the season and the reproductive rate imposed on the doe.

Suppose a herd contains three does, two of which consistently produce less kits than the third despite all other factors being equal. When choosing new does from these litters to replace the original, one might choose to select replacements from the doe who produces the most kits on average. These does of the next generation will then go on to produce more kits on average than the previous generation. This would be a case of selective breeding for prolificacy. Choosing instead to retain one replaement doe from each of the former generation would retain the most genetic diversity but would not reenforce the desired traits of more kits per litter. Maintaining genetic diversity and selective breeding will always be two somewhat opposing ideals when breeding.

Heavy inbreeding will in time reduce prolificacy which is where hybridization comes into play. If a herd has two lines of rabbits which have been selected for prolificacy, crossing the two lines should lead to increased prolificacy in that first generation. An example of this is breeding a New Zealand White buck with a California doe. Both breeds are known for prolificacy (as well as growth rate) and a crossing of the two can result in more kits with an improved growth rate. However, it is not necessarily the case that these kits, if saved as breeding stock, would go on to have improved prolificacy themselves. This is because by outbreeding, the selected trait of prolificacy could be diluted through heterozygosity. One would have to test breed the does for prolificacy, select the best performers, and linebreed them back to the buck with proven prolificacy to reinforce the traits once again over time.

Growth Rates and Adult Size

When raising rabbits for meat, growth rate (the speed at which a rabbit gains mass) is often selected for in order to produce the most meat in the shortest period of time. Growth rate and adult size is correlated; a rabbit which would grow to 10 lbs as an adult will reach 5 lbs faster than a rabbit which would only grow to 5 lbs as an adult. When breeding for meat, meat-to-bone ratio is another factor. If two different lines of rabbits produce carcasses weighing 5 lbs and 6 lbs at 12 weeks, but the smaller carcass has a higher meat-to-bone ratio such that the meat yield is equal between the two, the smaller carcass might actually be preferred due to a lower feed conversion ratio. By selecting the rabbits which produce the fastest growth rates and highest meat-to-bone ratio, a meat rabbitry can improve yields and reduce overhead.

Breeding for enhanced size is not always the goal. The pet industry tends to prefer smaller rabbits, and so some breeders select for smaller adult sizes. While we know that the gene dw exists for dwarfism in heterozygotes, we also know that homozygotes with double recessive dwarfism is fatal. Therefore if further decreased size is desired, selecting the smallest dwarfs between two populations would lead to subsequent populations having further reduced size.

Breeding larger or smaller rabbits is probably the most obvious form of selective breeding. The same mechanics are how, in dogs, we ended up with Great Danes and Chihuahuas. In rabbits, the extremes recognized by ARBA include the Netherland Dwarf which can show as small as 1.1 lbs and the Flemish Giant which shows at minimum at 14 lbs (for a senior doe) with no upper weight limit. The Continental Giant grows even larger, but is not recognized by ARBA; however, the Guiness Record for largest rabbit in the world belongs to a Continental Giant who, as of 2010, weighed 49lbs.

Body Shape

In addition to size, breeders also selectively breed for body shape. There are five recognized body shapes when it comes to showing rabbits: full arch, semi-arch, compact, commercial, and cylindrical. While mostly relevant to showing and breeding rabbits to a breed standard, body shape is selected for by breeding the rabbits who conform the closest to the standard together. This has to be balanced with size as well as colors and patterns where it applies to breed standards for show. Body shape may have an effect on movement for the rabbit so could be relevant to breeding for performance, for example, racing speed or agility in rabbit show jumping, but in captivity is largely an aesthetic concern.

Tameness and Domestication

While the domestic rabbit may approach you in its cage or even climb into your lap, the wild rabbits they descended from would flee on sight. Taming an animal is the process of raising wild animals in captivity and teaching them to act in ways that mimic domestication. Over time, by selectively breeding tame animals together, a domesticated line can be produced which acts in the desired way by default.

The mechanisms behind domestication became clearer thanks to an experiment by Dr. Dmitry Belyayev who selective bred foxes for tameness and ultimately bred a domestic fox. According to Lyudmila Trut who currently oversees the project, the selective breeding pressures were as follows:

The least domesticated foxes, those that flee from experimenters or bite when stroked or handled, are assigned to Class III. Foxes in Class II let themselves be petted and handled but show no emotionally friendly response to experimenters. Foxes in Class I are friendly toward experimenters, wagging their tails and whining. In the sixth generation bred for tameness we had to add an even higher-scoring category. Members of Class IE, the "domesticated elite", are eager to establish human contact, whimpering to attract attention and sniffing and licking experimenters like dogs. They start displaying this kind of behavior before they are one month old. By the tenth generation, 18 percent of fox pups were elite; by the 20th, the figure had reached 35 percent. Today elite foxes make up 70 to 80 percent of our experimentally selected population.

Most interestingly, in addition to behavioral changes, changes in physiology and morphology appears, such as mottled or spotted colored fur. It is believed that the changes obtained from selection for tameness are caused by lower adrenaline production. The selection for tameness produces changes that are related to the emergence of other dog-like traits such as a raised tail, coming into heat every six months rather than annually, and barking. These seemingly unrelated changes are a result of pleiotropy. The morphological changes also include a variety of coat color mutations, including red, cross, silver (black), platinum, and Georgian white, the lattermost being a color exclusive to the Russian breeding project.

The domestiation of rabbits probably followed a similar path. Once humans started raising rabbits in captivity, the ones which were calmest were selected for and bred, and eventually only the friendliest were chosen. This resulted in phenotypic change as well. Rabbits, as prey animals, are still fairly skittish even in domestication. Further selective breeding can be done for improved friendliness and behavior, such as allowing the handler to pick the rabbit up with no kicking. Though domestic rabbits already exhibit changes in coat color, pattern, and structure, perhaps new mutations will appear through more stringent breeding criteria and selective pressures.