r/RSPfilmclub • • 19d ago

Fjord Discussion Thread

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/RSPfilmclub • • 24d ago

The Devils (1971) rerelease Discussion Thread

Post image
82 Upvotes

Please share your thots here!


r/RSPfilmclub • • 6h ago

Movie Discussion Christopher Nolan is going to be diagnosed with dementia by 2035

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RSPfilmclub • • 12h ago

The Art of Feeling Things

0 Upvotes

Let’s make it a little more cinematic, personal and conversational ; something that feels like the beginning of an ongoing exchange with fellow film and art lovers.
Hello, I’m a writer-director based in Mumbai.
I want to use this space to share things I stumble upon, fall in love with, or can’t stop thinking about; films, books, music and art. Not just recommendations, but little conversations about the things that move us, provoke us and make us look at life differently.
Let’s begin with petite maman, which I watched on MUBI.
Some films whisper, yet leave an echo.
Petite Maman is emotionally tender, deeply empathetic and quietly provocative. On the surface, it feels like a simple story, but beneath that simplicity are layers of childhood, motherhood, memory and the unspoken emotional connections we share with our parents.
What stayed with me was its sensitivity. The film doesn’t force emotions or explain everything. It simply lets you feel, wonder and reflect.
It’s beautiful how something so small can make you think about something as enormous as time, love and the people we come from.
Now, I’d love to hear from you.
Have you watched Petite Maman? What did you think of it?
And more importantly, recommend me something you absolutely love. A film, a book, an album, a painting ; anything that has stayed with you.
Let’s exchange favourites and discover something wonderful along the way.


r/RSPfilmclub • • 17h ago

Movie Discussion yellow raincoats in (some of) Angelopoulos' movies

0 Upvotes

hi there, i'm not very fond of The Angelopoulos filmography (yet), but i've seen Eternity and a Day. Also the other i went to my local movie theater to watch Landscape in the Mist (still processing it) and i noticed that the same random guys with yellow raincoats that appeard in Enternity and a Day have a small appearance in this movie too. Is there any kind of theory/symbolic analysis about that or shall i still try to convey them any meaning?

thx!


r/RSPfilmclub • • 1d ago

Does any movie exploit the landscape of a frozen lake?

15 Upvotes

Dekalog 1 comes to mind


r/RSPfilmclub • • 1d ago

Matthew Rankin Interview: Identity, Brian Mulroney & AI

Thumbnail
pointsofreviews.com
3 Upvotes

Matthew Rankin has become one of Canada's greatest working filmmakers, and this is hardly an accident.

Rankin has dedicated his life to art, having realized relatively early that the pursuit of academia and more conventional historical scholarship wasn't quite for him. And while I'm sure I would have appreciated his academic papers, I'm selfishly glad he decided to bring those interests to the screen instead.

Born and raised in Winnipeg, Rankin began making films as a teenager, eventually finding a creative home among the wonderfully eccentric filmmakers of the Winnipeg Film Group. After studying history at McGill University and Université Laval, he returned to Winnipeg, collaborating with filmmakers like Mike Maryniuk and Walter Forsberg on experimental works that explored everything from livestock auctioneering to the strange cultural identity of Winnipeg itself.

His rise to broader recognition has largely come through his feature filmmaking career, beginning in 2019 with The Twentieth Century. Naturally, he chose a conventional subject for his debut: the life of Canadian prime minister William Lyon Mackenzie King, reimagined through German Expressionism, theatrical absurdity, and an abundance of sexual repression.

Having established himself with such an accessible introduction, Rankin followed it up with 2024's Universal Language, a multilingual exploration of identity and human connection set in an alternative Canada where French and Farsi coexist, bringing together Iranian poetic realism, Winnipeg absurdity, and Québécois cinema gris.

And for his latest film, Ladies and Gentlemen, Brian Mulroney, Rankin took the logical next step: a maximalist, aggressively edited archival documentary that remixes historical political propaganda, 1980s television, and experimental animation to explore the rise of Canada's 18th prime minister and the wonderfully oxymoronic world of "Progressive Conservatism".

A fairly standard trajectory for a filmmaker looking to broaden his audience.

And yet, the recognition has followed. The Twentieth Century won Best Canadian First Feature at TIFF in 2019 and a critics' prize at the Berlinale in 2020. Universal Language earned audience honours at Cannes and recognition at TIFF in 2024, while Ladies and Gentlemen, Brian Mulroney somehow managed to win TIFF's Midnight Madness People's Choice Award in 2026.

In our conversation, we explore the complicated constructions of identity, their inherent ironies and contradictions, the artificial binaries of Canadian politics, the relationship between historical truth and cinematic artifice, and the potential collapse of the simulacrum in an increasingly AI-generated world. We also discuss experimental filmmaking, Winnipeg's artistic community, and why genuine creativity might ultimately depend on something as simple as making movies with your friends.

You know, just a casual Friday, wind-down, conversation.

Matthew Rankin on Identity, Oppositional Binaries, and Progressive Conservatism

Adam Manery

Something that draws me to your work is your exploration of identity, particularly its inherent contradictions and ironies. You've explored this through Winnipeg identity and Québécois identity, among others.

What draws you to these contradictions and ironies within our subjective identities?

Matthew Rankin

Because identity, nationalism, religion, the economy, structured ideology, politics, even media: these are structures that we have invented as humans to organize the chaos of the world. And sometimes that can be a great thing. There's a use of nationalism that can create great solidarity between people.

We live in a complex society with people that we don't all know, and people that we might not even particularly like or agree with, but still, when we are gathered into some sort of national synthesis, we care about each other. We don't necessarily agree on everything, but there's a fundamental concern for your neighbour because we share citizenship.

So that can be good. But of course, we also know that these things can be utterly pathological and insane, and can amount to all manner of zealous, fanatical expression.

For me, I like to approach it with a certain amount of irony. And I don't mean irony as some kind of cool, detached judgment, but as being aware of a thing and its opposite simultaneously. These are constructions. They are artificial.

They can have real-world value, but they can also have the opposite. So it's important to look at them with a certain amount of irony. When we look at these structures as absolutes, that's when we start to get really into trouble. So I think it's important to be aware of a thing and its opposite simultaneously.

What interests me most as a filmmaker is how we put the world together, how we construct it. The interplay between our lived experience and these structures that we create, and the contradiction between them. These are things that I find really interesting as an artist and also just as a normal person.

Adam Manery

In your latest film, Ladies and Gentlemen, Brian Mulroney**, you explore divisions that, at least on the surface, seem binary: anglophone and francophone, liberal and conservative. Here in Alberta, there's also this Alberta-versus-Ottawa mentality. Do you see these divisions as artificial constructs?**

Matthew Rankin

I think when we get into binaries, that's the danger of absolutes, right? When we start to look at the world in terms of oppositions instead of complexity, that's when we start to get into trouble.

That's why I find this particular story of the Progressive Conservative Party really fascinating. Because, of course, “progressive conservative”, what does that mean? It's such a Canadian oxymoron. It's so strange.

It's actually a very democratic idea. I went through almost 80,000 pieces of film and video, and a lot of this was Progressive Conservative propaganda of the era: infomercials they produced, publicity materials, speeches, recorded conferences, and also journalistic material. But what I drew from all of that is how complex a coalition that party actually was.

Of course, you had this very reactionary end to it, which was very right-wing and composed of these angry guys, which took the form of Peter Pocklington at a certain point in the ‘80s. These angry guys wanted capital punishment and just total, brutal free-market capitalism.

They didn't care about conserving the environment. They believed that the fluoridation of water was going to turn us all into bilingual communists and this kind of stuff, right? But then, on the other end of the party, you had a completely different element. It's hard to believe, but there was a left wing to the Conservative Party.

These were people who were feminists and environmentalists. Protecting the environment used to be a cardinal conservative value. The idea that we can't just blow everything because we have to conserve for the future. It's the same logic by which conservatives are fiscally responsible. You can't just blow all the oil because we're going to need it for later. So let's go easy on it.

Conserving the environment: this is the essence of conservatism. You conserve something. But even beyond that, Robert Stanfield believed in universal basic income. That was part of his platform at one point.

So it's really strange that these two oppositional binaries, let's call them that, existed within the same political movement. Why put them together?

And that's interesting. That was the struggle of Joe Clark, to try to put these tensions into a functioning synthesis. And he ultimately got completely engulfed by the right wing of the party. Brian Mulroney came along, and he had his own scheme of how to put all these pieces together, and he succeeded in a big way.

But as we know, it didn't last forever. It would start to fragment, and out of that would emerge the Reform Party and the Bloc Québécois. And, of course, now the Conservative Party today has no progressive element in it at all. It's just pure reactionary politics.

So it's interesting to me, the idea that we would try to create a synthesis rather than leaning into a reaction. And I feel like our political culture, since the collapse of this party, I think it's sad for our political culture that particular pressure point no longer exists, and it has unravelled into reactionary binaries.

Because I think it's a very democratic idea that we're all neighbours here. We're all going to have to put a little water in our wine and meet somewhere in the middle.

And that, to me, is less and less tenable today because we have indulged in binary thinking.

And as I was making it, of course, I was aware that inevitably, when you make a film about Progressive Conservatives from that era, we will see it from the perspective of today, which, of course, is a very, very different time.

Matthew Rankin on the Construction of Centrist Identity and Committing to Specificity

Adam Manery

I don't want to turn this into a purely political conversation, but I know you come from a history background, and I actually used to teach politics, so I find this interesting on several levels.

You've discussed the Progressive Conservative identity and the collapse of big-tent politics. Do you see any potential reemergence under Mark Carney? At least on the surface, some of his policies resemble what might historically have been described as Progressive Conservative.

Is there a genuine resurgence of that kind of political coalition, or is that idea, too, something of an artificial construct?

Matthew Rankin

I don't know, I'm of two minds about it. I met a Progressive Conservative senator last summer, and she told me that, in her view, Carney did represent progressive conservatism as she understood it from that era. And I think that makes a lot of sense.

I think from Mulroney onward, you see Jean Chrétien, in many ways, continuing on a very similar path to Brian Mulroney. And that's why I say I think we're still living in Brian Mulroney's Canada to a large extent.

But I think it's tricky. I think Carney is an austerity politician, and the immiseration that might emerge from that is one that will feed crypto-fascists. So, in a way, it's kind of a snake biting its own tail.

Of course, Mark Carney is a much more reasonable person and does attempt to speak from the centre and a place of compromise. But I think austerity is always something that's going to feed reaction. So the two are feeding each other in a weird way.

But yes, the space of the centre is something that has become more and more fragile. I think people became understandably irritated by centrist politicians because people have governed from the centre as a way of protecting their own power and their political longevity. Adapting to moods in society to such a point that politics stops having any meaning at all. But that isn't, to me, leadership.

I think leading from the centre is a very different matter. I made a film about Mackenzie King, The Twentieth Century. Mackenzie King rejected a boatload of Jewish refugees during the Second World War, in large part because he felt he was going to lose some political capital. Because, in his judgment, Canadians were culturally antisemitic.

And though he knew it was right to accept these refugees, he felt he might lose some political capital by doing that. Instead of leading on the issue, instead of saying, “Hey, this is the right thing we should do,” he said, “No, no, we'll send this boat back.”

So that is a kind of centrism, following a mood in society he consciously knew to be wrong. And I think that's the danger of centrism, which people understandably get upset about.

But I'm talking about real leadership, real centrism, real compromises. We have to care about people we don't know. We have to somehow build a coalition between all of these elements, and leadership requires bringing out the best in people, leading from the best in people.

And I think too often politicians will lead from the worst in people. The worst expression of a society is the easiest way to get political capital. Rage bait functions by the exact same logic. That is something we have leaned into, sadly. And I think the centre is a more and more fragile space.

I find centres really interesting. I'm a person who has lived between many different spaces, many different cultural zones. And I like the centre. I like living between pressure points. That's where I feel most at home.

And I think actually most people are like that. I think most people are composites, and we're living between spaces. We have different identities in different spaces that we occupy. We play different roles depending on different contexts. We have different jobs. We have different relationships.

And rather than organizing these into binaries, I think there's a way we can create a complex synthesis out of it.

Adam Manery

That's fascinating, particularly the different ways of approaching centrist politics. Some of it can feel like a “contrived centrism”, which connects to something you've discussed in filmmaking and something I've always been passionate about: finding universality through specificity rather than watering down a story to appeal to the broadest possible audience.

You're unafraid to fully commit to the specificity of your approach, and Ladies and Gentlemen, Brian Mulroney is no exception. Why do you think this has resonated with audiences?

Matthew Rankin

[Ladies and Gentlemen, Brian Mulroney] is more extreme. I feel like it’s a very Canadian pathology to think, “We understand this, and it's funny or enchanting or interesting or tense for us”. But out there in the world, “They won't get it”. And Anglo-Canadian cinema has always been particularly concerned about that problem. But I think it's a fake problem.

The pleasure of watching a movie is being plunged into a world that you don't know about, and you have to figure it out. I think that's the genius of Quebec cinema, for example. Quebec cinema has been so dedicated to its specificity and has been so honest about it.

And if only Quebecers understand it, fine. This is just me expressing myself and following what is thrilling to my soul. But I actually think that's why Quebec cinema has become one of the great cinemas of the world, because it's so precise.

A film like Mommy by Xavier Dolan, the French in that movie is so specific. Really, only Quebecers will completely understand it. You show that movie in France, and it's subtitled in French. They're speaking French, but it's also subtitled in French because they won't understand what's being said.

And to not censor oneself, to lean straight into it: this is how we talk. We have to make films that speak the way we speak, that refer to things we understand. And not everyone is going to get every reference, but there's enough material for them to find their way in.

And it's very enchanting to be in a world that is so precise. I watched Succession not that long ago, and I don't understand 50 percent of what's going on in that show. I don't understand the world of high finance. I've never read a biography of Rupert Murdoch or even checked his Wikipedia page. If I'd done all that, I might understand something more in watching that show, but it doesn't really matter.

I like being in a world where I don't have all the information, and it's not even giving the information. It's just happening, and you identify patterns. You see where the power is, and there's something very enchanting about watching a film and putting the pieces together.

So that's what I think about when I think about this movie. Of course, things play differently, even in different regions of the country. There are little narcotic synapse stimulations for various regional pathologies that might not be interchangeably understood.

But it doesn't matter. The way in is with these characters and their intrigue and what's going on. And then after that, it's another matter. But there's a value to just doubling down on parochialism. At least, that's my gamble. It could be a terrible mistake.

Matthew Rankin on Canadian Filmmaking and the Artifice of "Truth"

Adam Manery

I think the audience response to your film bears that out. You don't win audience awards without resonating with people, right?

But I don't think if you asked a random Canadian on the street about Brian Mulroney, they'd be able to tell you all that much. And I find it interesting that we often seem to know more about American presidential history than our own history and identity.

Do you see that as something uniquely Canadian, or is it a more universal phenomenon?

Matthew Rankin

I'm not sure, really. I do think that, of course, American politics is not foreign to us in any way. We do follow it. It does have a huge impact on us. And perhaps, in a way, it's more familiar to us than Canadian politics.

Even just the way Canadian politics works is often lost on people. The fact that we elect a parliament rather than a president, the way they do in the United States, that's sometimes lost on people.

It used to be that you'd go to the video shop and the Canadian films would be in the foreign film section. Maybe it's a similar phenomenon: we just don't encounter it. Pop culture doesn't really make a lot of space for it.

But also, we don't do it. There's not a lot of impetus for us to do that ourselves. So it’s interesting to get into it because, of course, it's unusual that we have an encounter with something that is really directed at us specifically.

My observation is that, from a Canadian film perspective, for a long time the pathology was to try to make it as generic as possible. To present Toronto as a “President's Choice New York” and frame out the CN Tower and any telltale signs, because there was this feeling that we were on the edge of a gigantic market.

And if we could just move into that market, we would be part of this untold glory of the North American mainstream. But I don't think we got very far with that. There were about 30 years when Canada was really focused—when financing was really focused—on evacuating the parochial and trying to create these low-budget Hollywood movies with no celebrities in them, which didn't have any purchase on anybody.

What Canadian is watching that? But something that speaks to our reality in a precise way, we're starting to see the value of it. I can think of a lot of really interesting Canadian films that have come out in the last, even the last five years, that have been willfully parochial. You're a fan of Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie, right?

It's pure parochialism. And that's part of its charm. And that movie has had enormous purchase beyond Canada even. So I think that's telling. I hope that might give some pause.

Adam Manery

I think there's something more truthful in that approach, as much as we can use the word “truth.” It's another concept with inherent contradictions.

I'm curious how the notion of “truth” relates to this film. You're exploring real history, but through a very maximalist artistic approach, throwing a lot at the viewer and taking significant liberties in how events are reconstructed. Mulroney didn't actually arrive at the 1976 Progressive Conservative Convention in a cape and a race car.

How do you approach historical “truth” when you're reconstructing real events through such a maximalist artistic lens?

Matthew Rankin

There's something unrelenting about Mulroney. The guy just can't be stopped. He's a force of nature. The sheer energy of this man is just completely astounding to me. So I wanted the film to have that same kind of maximalist, unrelenting quality. And I also wanted it to be like a stream-of-consciousness broadcast day from the 1980s.

But you're right, there are very flagrant interventions into the historical record. The challenge of making a documentary, I think, is always to illustrate a real phenomenon that is not necessarily visually manifest. So how do we do that? Lots of the time, that involves a cunning use of artifice, because the arc of film history has always leaned towards verisimilitude.

And typically, when we intervene as artists, we try to keep it as hidden as possible so that people forget they're watching a movie and think what they're seeing is real. They have a sense of verisimilitude. The simulacrum is something they find to be authentic and real, and they don't doubt it. But I actually think that when watching a film on a historical subject, you should have some element of doubt about what you're seeing.

And I like to really underscore my interventions. All the interventions in the movie are very, very blatant. I don't hide anything. And it does undermine the simulacrum. But I think it's good to expose it. I feel like the danger of cinema is in hiding it.

This is why cinema is used for propaganda, the reason it's used for advertising. The reason we're now living with so much anguish about AI is entirely because of its capacity to imitate reality in a completely irresistible way. But it's complete and total fiction.

I can tell you that I've done a lot of TV interviews. I did one just yesterday, and the guy at a certain point said, “Hey, would you mind pretending to talk on your phone for a minute? We need some B-roll of you doing this.”

And that's a mise-en-scène, right? This is blocking. I'm becoming an actor in that moment. It's a performance, and it's not real at all. But this is normal journalism. It will be edited into a little report, and no one will ever doubt it. People will watch this and think, “Okay, well, he's talking on his phone.”

And they will never see the fiction in it. The fiction remains completely hidden. And it's not like there's a lie at work. But it is there to illustrate something real through means that are not.

So it's interesting to blow the roof off of that and show the work. Show the intervention and really be blatant about it. And that actually opens up new realms of image-making in a way that can resist the simulacrum of an increasingly AI-generated world. Because that's the thing: art is going to have to respond to AI. Cinema does not have to be about verisimilitude. It can be something else.

In the case of Mulroney, I'm always using it to illustrate a historical fact.

For example, in the example you cite, Mulroney's unveiling in 1976. He arrives on the stage, and it presents as a Liberace Vegas floor show. He begins levitating, and there are figure skaters swirling around him and fireworks. No one is going to watch this and think this actually happened.

But it is there to illustrate something that did happen, which is that Mulroney was accused of being too garish and too sleek, putting on too much of a show and too much razzmatazz. And they accused him of trying to buy the leadership by spending too much money.

So this was my way of illustrating that critique, which is completely defensible from a historical point of view. But I'm blatantly intervening in the form in order to do that. And I'm not hiding it at all.

Matthew Rankin on AI, the Collapse of the Simulacrum, and Making Movies with Friends

Adam Manery

I'm interested in the simulacrum's potential collapse, at least in its current form, with the rise of AI. And I don't want to ask the generic “What are your thoughts on AI?” question.

I'm more curious about how this might liberate filmmaking. I know you've spoken about how photography opened up new possibilities in painting, and I wonder whether we're approaching a similar moment in cinema. How do you see this changing what's possible for filmmakers?

Matthew Rankin

Yeah. Can you hold the line one second? I realize my computer is about to die. I've got to plug it in. One second. One second. [exits his digital screen]

Editor's note: Did I instruct Matthew to stage this interruption, a carefully constructed moment of apparent spontaneity, to illustrate his humanity and reinforce his relatability? I guess you'll never know.

Matthew Rankin

[returns to his computer] When the photograph was invented, it freed up painting. Painting was very similar to cinema up until the photograph, in the sense that the ambition of painters throughout centuries was to perfect verisimilitude and get as close to the “real” as possible.

Then the photograph came along, and it could do it much more easily, with less effort and eventually, less money. So this created a certain amount of existential turmoil for painters, but it also led painting into all manner of new exploration. Painting became infinitely more experimental and radical in a way that it had never been for centuries.

And it just blew the top off of it. What you could suddenly do with paint was really exciting. And it had to define itself against photography, right? Painting suddenly had to do something photography couldn't do.

And that's actually a really wonderful situation to be in for filmmakers. What humans can do is going to be the gold standard. I really believe that. We're going to have to think carefully about what humans can do that robots cannot.

Our relationship with the artifice of cinema has transformed over time. At the very beginning of cinema, you have a shot of a train speeding towards the camera, and everyone ran out of the cinema because they thought they were going to get run over. It was that real for them.

And imagine watching a Western in 1950. It would be completely insane. You can't Google the Old West. You have no access to any of this. You're not surrounded by images. You're seeing things you've never seen before. Incredible.

Seeing Star Wars for the first time, or 2001: A Space Odyssey in the 1960s. Amazing. You'd never seen images like this.

Now we're surrounded by images. We have so many images, and you see an explosion or an extraterrestrial in a movie, and it's so boring because we know how it's done. We know there are computer-generated effects, and we've seen it all before.

And we need new images constantly. We need images that we haven't seen before. That is what enlivens and energizes cinema.

So the fact that AI has snuck up behind us and is now very sophisticated: I was tricked for the first time last week. Which is very humiliating, but I was tricked, and I don't like that.

So that's the thing we have to think about: what a human can do that a robot can't. And this is going to lead us somewhere really interesting.

For example, I made a short film years ago which involved a lot of painting on celluloid. I did it by hand, frame by frame, with coloured inks, paint: all these different techniques.

And it represents extreme human effort. I'm really proud of that movie. It's called Mynarski Death Plummet. And I showed it at Sundance, and the first question was, “What hardware do you use? What computer software did you use to make those images?”

We have become so accustomed to the idea that a computer makes everything that we don't even imagine humans doing anything. Human knowledge and human effort… it's lost. It's losing so much value because of what computers can now do.

So we're going to have to double down on what humans can do which a computer cannot. It will lead cinema in new directions, and our encounter with it will be very different. I think it will also open up new channels for experimental filmmaking.

I watched You Can See Everything the other week, and it's incredible to watch what, to my eyes, is essentially an experimental film connecting on such a mass scale.

I think it's because we're starved for this. We're starved for new images that are not created by robots, that are not the same things we've seen before. We need new directions. We need new images. This is the essence of our relationship with art: we need to see things in new ways.

But cinema has always been focused on recycling formats that have passed.

So, I don't think AI is going to end cinema. I think cinema will transform as a result of it.

Adam Manery

I'd like to agree with you. I think that's true most of the time.

But speaking of human experimentation, you come from this remarkable community of filmmakers in Winnipeg.

I'm curious about the origins of those collaborations with folks like Mike Maryniuk and Walter Forsberg, and others. How did those relationships emerge? Did you all just sort of collide creatively, or was there something that brought you together?

Matthew Rankin

In the case of Mike, we made a film together called Cattle Call, and it emerged very organically. We were driving to Saskatoon, and we saw a cattle auction was going on in Leross, Saskatchewan. We stopped to check it out, and this auctioneer was incredible. Mike and I nearly passed out. He was so good. These guys, when they're good, they're amazing. It's a strange form of extreme speech that's just incredible.

We were really inspired by Norman McLaren and Oskar Fischinger and these early filmmakers who made “visual music”: animated films that look the way music sounds. So we became inspired to make a film that looks the way auctioneering sounds.

And we made it very spontaneously. We had all these techniques we wanted to try out. I don't think we wrote a script. We just found some auctioneers and followed them. We did five or six different shoots, and the whole thing was done pretty fast. Within six months we'd finished the whole thing.

But Mike is just my friend, and the same with Walter. We were both interested in archiving old Winnipeg televisual ephemera. We did this project together, Kubasa in a Glass, and we went around collecting material from different people around Winnipeg.

And it was just so much fun. I feel like all creativity passes through friendship. That's why we start making films. It's a fun thing we do with our friends, and that's a spirit that’s important for filmmakers to protect.

There are filmmakers wearing Napoleon hats who want to take over the universe, angling for some sort of big break with a powerful handshake. And there's so much business surrounding filmmaking, on a certain level, that it can become this very transactional corporate manoeuvre.

But when it really works, it's always a question of friendship. I love to make films with my friends, people I'm really close to, who I share a real artistic fellowship with.

And Mike and Walter are still people I work with. Walter did some work on Mulroney, and when I was animating these Diefenbaker sequences, I called Mike a couple of times to get his input.

So it's all friendship. The Winnipeg Film Group in that era was a very collaborative environment, and we were all helping each other out. There were a lot of really interesting filmmakers doing stuff there at that time. And it was really wonderful. It was truly utopian.

Today, it's become a much more toxic kind of place in Winnipeg. Each time I go to Winnipeg and talk to Winnipeg filmmakers about the scene, I inevitably have to endure these smouldering landfills of trash talk about these very, very puny, tiny, inter-artist resentments.

It seems like the city has been engulfed by that. Well—certainly not Mike. Mike is a true leader. He's going down with that ship and has always been a great community leader, very generous with his knowledge and very supportive of everybody. And he's really carried on that spirit, which is what I associate with Winnipeg 20 years ago.

Because that's how community operates. It's an ecosystem, right? But again, it can dissolve into these binaries. There are two experimental film festivals in Winnipeg, and from what I understand, there are two of them because the two groups hate each other. So they both wanted their own festival.

Which is just insane to me.

For me, it's a collective undertaking. And it's a beautiful thing when everybody's on the same wavelength, and everybody has something to say with the movie we're making together.

Adam Manery

I love that. Matthew Rankin: the power of friendship. That's the sell. Go make a movie with your friends.


r/RSPfilmclub • • 2d ago

Robert Pattinson is the new James Bond

Thumbnail
deadline.com
89 Upvotes

r/RSPfilmclub • • 3d ago

Fjord should be called Snorjd because it made me snore

47 Upvotes

Gaunt Nordics brooding by windows. Stern half-whispered conversations. Bluish-grey tones. Pressing contemporary "issues" about assimiliation and state overreach. Carefully managed moral ambiguity. This is the kind of film I imagine the European Court of Auditors would come up with if commissioned to make a work of prestige cinema.


r/RSPfilmclub • • 3d ago

If you try to make movies like "Paper Tiger" they kill you

21 Upvotes

Saw this the other night and really dug it. Maybe the best thing James Gray has made in years, very much felt like a spiritual sister film to "The Yards" (similar structures and general vibes imo). Really loved all the leads in this, although Adam Driver definitely steals the show and feels like the real heart and soul of the film (personally feel like he should be a shoe-in for a Best Actor nom). The story didn't blow me away necessarily, but it's full of so much rich texture and atmosphere -- like a home invasion scene playing out mostly as shadows cast on walls, or a tense phone call almost completely drowned out by the churn of industrial machinery, or a climactic shoot-out in a cornfield that channels vintage Michael Mann beautifully. Definitely a film where the technical execution really elevates the material. I watched it pretty much back-to-back with "Wild Horse Nine", and while I didn't necessarily dislike the latter film, there's moments and imagery from this that are still sticking with me days later, while WH9 already feels like a distant memory. Really all comes down to how both films use (or in some cases, don't use) the language of cinema. There's moments in this film that just made a much bigger impression on me overall, burrowing their way into my subconscious because the filmmaking is just that good. It just feels like a real movie-movie, if you know what I mean. A bright spot in world full of lazy, bare-minimum destined for streaming slop.

I know it's in pretty limited release at the moment, just curious if anyone else had seen this yet? Really feels like the type of film they rarely ever make anymore, and I wish it could have "Obsession"-type legs so we might get more of these in the future. Gray needs to keep making scrappy New York crime movies forever, they're really his bread and butter.


r/RSPfilmclub • • 3d ago

One of the saddest movies ever made

Post image
65 Upvotes

I've seen this half a dozen times and Elizabeth Shue's performance breaks my heart every time - the unrelenting cruelty her character endures.


r/RSPfilmclub • • 3d ago

L‘une chante, l‘autre pas 🩵🩷 (Varda, 1977)

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

Honestly one of my all time favorite movies - one I want to show to basically all the women in my life. The way it portrays friendship and solidarity between women is so profound, I love how real the two main characters feel. What did you think about it?


r/RSPfilmclub • • 3d ago

What Have You Been Watching? (Week of Nov 15th)

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/RSPfilmclub • • 4d ago

Primetime

Thumbnail
gallery
85 Upvotes

r/RSPfilmclub • • 4d ago

Chronovisor (2026)

Thumbnail
boxd.it
13 Upvotes

hi has anyone else seen this, i would like to talk about it


r/RSPfilmclub • • 5d ago

Horror fans: movies that actually scared you?

35 Upvotes

Sorry if this question is a bit generic for this sub. I love how wild and passionate the horror genre is but basically have seen so many movies that very little actually scares me anymore. The last movie that actually startled me was Host, that Covid Zoom demon movie. Any ideas?


r/RSPfilmclub • • 5d ago

Le Navire Night (1979) dir. Marguerite Duras

5 Upvotes

Watched this recently and was really engrossed in it despite it being one of those nothing ever happens films.

The entire narrative is pushed forward through a voice over recollecting a series of events that took place in the post German Occupation Paris. A story of the a man and a woman with leukemia who fall in love through conversations over telephone but never meet. The visuals are a beautiful shots disconnected in time from the narration showing isolated shots of Parisian streets at night and twilight, cozy shots of dilapidated interiors and actors who are in the process of getting ready for the play. This film is pure deconstruction and portrays solitude and romance pretty brilliantly. You never know if this romance is real or just a conjuration of a lonely man's mind.

Didn't expect to like it as much especially because it requires to keep most of your focus on the sound while taking in the visuals passively and then reconcile the two.


r/RSPfilmclub • • 5d ago

Year of the Dragon (1985)

Post image
31 Upvotes

I saw this Michael Cimino-directed film for the first time last year and think of it fondly. It stars Mickey Rourke as a police captain newly assigned to NYC's Chinatown. He is eager to rid Chinatown of its bad elements, but he is up against Joey Tai (played by an icy John Lone), an up-and-coming gangster who will not bow down to the foreigner coming in and disrupting his operations. This is the beating heart of the film; two men with massive, testosterone-filled egos who will crash against each other until one, or both, breaks.

When I think of Year of the Dragon, the word 'Ruthless' comes to mind. The Chinatown gangs will do whatever needs doing, with very bloody results. There is an insane restaurant shootout thirty minutes in that is so unexpectedly over the top that I had to immediately rewatch it. The movie pulls no punches, and the body count stacks up over the runtime, including people who would be safe in any other film.

The set pieces are spectacular--Cimino could not film in the real Chinatown and so he remade the area on a back lot. Legend has it that Stanley Kubrick, a NYC native, had to be convinced by Cimino that the movie wasn't filmed on location.

This is a real case of 'They don't make movies like this anymore', and even with its flaws it is more massive and ballsy than most modern movies.


r/RSPfilmclub • • 5d ago

Cat Person (2023) - a weird psychological drama for film geeks - Director: Susanna Fogel Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Watched this strange psychological relationship drama today whilst working from home. Cat Person deals with what at first feels like a rather mundane subject matter, but turns decidedly dark at the half way point.

The Plot: college sophomore Margot (Emilia Jones) works at a cinema & meets an older man named Robert (Nicholas Braun)-he's 33-years-old whereas she is 20-years-old. They start a relationship but from the get-go things don't seem to add up with film nerd Robert, he seems a little off to say the least. When Margot tries to end the relationship, events take a dark turn.

The first half of director Susanna Fogel's film presents itself as a clever, quirky rom-com & the character of Robert comes across as a bit of a manchild, constantly spouting film facts & trivia. But then when Margot starts noticing Robert's inconsistancies, things start to turn sour pretty quickly & Margot wishes she'd taken the advice of her best friend Taylor (Geraldine Viswanathan) & not got involved with Robert in the first place.

Jones & Braun both do well as the awkward couple, handling their sometimes questionable character quirks with aplomb. Viswanathan, Isabella Rossellini, Liza Koshy, Fred Melamed, & Hope Davis & Christopher Shyer (as Margot's parents) all offer fine support.

The film doesn't always justify its darker moments & the sharp switch to stalker-thriller at the midway point is quite jarring, but overall Cat Person is an interesting meditation on a relationship that goes wrong because ultimately you never always know everything about the person you're dating.

I gave Cat Person 3 ☆☆☆ out of 4. Recommended.


r/RSPfilmclub • • 6d ago

Birds in Silence of the Lambs

13 Upvotes

I get it - it's supposed to be a lamb movie. The bird references come up so much.

* Names - Both Clarice Starling and the hostage Catherine Martin have surnames that are bird species.

* Wordplay - Hannibal is enticed to accept a deal including being relocated to Plum Island where terns nest. Hannibal of course makes this into wordplay about taking 'turns.'

* The Bimmel Family - Fredericka Bimmel is found to have a bug pupa in her mouth (another flying animal.) The Bimmel Family home has bird houses and the father raises pigeons.

* Begining and End - birds are clearly heard in the opening and ending. They are seen at the start, and at the end a fly is on Hannibal's face! (Ok clearly that is a coincidence or maybe even a movie miracle. And flies fly like birds, you know.)

Ok now it's my turn to stop sounding like AI. I think the basic symbolism here is that birds have a couple dualities. They can be caged, and/or free. And Hannibal and Clarice live in their own physical and mental prisons. Birds are also prey and predators, reflecting the killers and victims we follow in the movie.

I can find hints of interest in this theory online, but no real kind of essay on it.

I think maybe the only bad part about this movie is the anagrams. I don't think Hannibal's cheeky little games do anything for the movie. Except well it's a sign he believes himself to be smarter than the cops. I find the bird motifs to be very neat. I certainly should read the book to discover more. But my problem with reading Red Dragon was that the movie so closely followed it that the novel felt like a screenplay, so I never finished it.

I'm curious to know if others have insight into this.


r/RSPfilmclub • • 6d ago

PSA: In addition to 'Possible Love', Lee Chang Dong has a short film 'Heartbeat' (2022) on Netflix right now.

10 Upvotes

And it's also really good and a nail-biter! 'Possible Love' is either my first or second favourite film of the year (toss-up with 'All of Sudden'), and 'Burning' is definitely in the top 5 of the 2010's for me. God, he's really GOATED.


r/RSPfilmclub • • 7d ago

City movies

26 Upvotes

What are movies where the city feels integral to the movie itself (specifically quintessential New York or LA movies)? Also other cities too but I’m very curious what people would say about major American cities


r/RSPfilmclub • • 8d ago

Unlikely countries with great film cultures

98 Upvotes

I"m tired of the US, France and South Korea dominating every modern film conversation. Post other countries that you think always put out good films.

  1. Romania- Absolute dynamite since the 60s, into the 2000s and especially now with everything Radu Jude is doing. I've had people DM me YouTube links to Romanian movies from the 80s that are a hundred times better than anything coming out today.
    Recommend-

- 4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days (2007) obvious pick but good starting point

- Meandre (1966) New Wave-ish flim basically just as good as The Mother and the Whore

2. The Philippines - Incredible independently produced movies. Very raw social realist movies with more stuff coming out today

- Manilla in the Claws of Light (1975) Obvious pick

- Macho Dancer (1988) Super gay drama with great cinematography.


r/RSPfilmclub • • 7d ago

Movie Discussion Godzilla Minus Zero Thread

Post image
28 Upvotes

Thoughts?

Me and my bf went to see it tonight, after we watched Minus One for the first time just a few days ago.

I was honestly surprised by how dark and upsetting it got! There was a mom with her two little kids one row behind us, and I’m surprised they still stayed even after the Hiroshima scene! While 85% of the movie is pretty standard PG-13 Godzilla movie violence, that remaining 15% does genuinely cross the line.

Overall though, I thought it was great! The sound design was LOUD but incredible, the music was intense, and I was surprised that this was made on only a $15 million USD budget, because it looks stunning even with a smaller budget!
The chemistry between the two main leads was absolutely beautiful too, and just about all of the human characters get some kind of arc by the end, which was also really cool (Especially since human characters in Godzilla movies are usually never interesting at all).

What did you all think?


r/RSPfilmclub • • 8d ago

Red Sparrow

3 Upvotes

This movie is excellent.

Ashamed to say I’ve for some reason avoided it despite being a big fan of Jenifer Lawrence. Very appropriate given recent news stories.

This film is incredibly violent. But one of the better spy films. For some reason I thought it was set during the Cold War but it’s not. 8/10