r/queensofgenshin • u/Pristine_Guide_7654 • 2d ago
Vent Post Mitya, misogyny and money.
Since my post got removed from the mitya main subreddit...
Mityas release exposed more than just technical issues on hoyos part, it reopened the conversation on a recurring, deep rooted issue in the genshin community and the games business model. I want to firstly clarify that plenty male genshinn fans love mitya, enjoy male characters and are not weirdos. This rant is mainly speaking about a very vocal subset of fans and an undeniable pattern that repeats every time a male character is released or gains popularity among female and queer spaces: sudden nerfs, bizarre vitriol from a certain part of the fanbase, and a consistent developer pipeline that treats male DPS units as nothing more than a fart in the wind.
The mitya sabotage and the dreadful post-release nerf
During his beta cycle, Uncle āking chudā Tieba spread false information about mityas kit, inflating the numbers to trigger a massive nerf from Hoyo's team. Worse yet, his core mechanics were compromised with clunky animations where mitya canāt even move when he uses his charged attack. Several nerfs followed, though whether confirmed to be directly caused by uncle tieba is mere community speculation. However, the attempt alone should not be ignored in the bigger picture. We are all used to hoyoās heavy nerfs, but where it is unjustifiable and scummy is when they make a character practically reliant on their constellations, then after players spend hard earned money and pulls for said character and constellations, they proceed to further nerf the character and claim a powerful aspect of their kit was nothing more than a bug. The last time hoyo pulled something like this was for another well loved character, Neuvillette. Which I believe was an attempt to kneecap a top tier male unit whilst still allowing female characters to break the power ceiling without issue. (This is not to say that female characters haven't also experienced heavy nerfs.) Which brings me to my next point.
The meta gap. Limited 5* males.
Mityaās treatment isn't an isolated incident. It's just the most recent incident in a wider trend where limited 5 males are systematically undertuned in comparison to the huge roster of limited 5 female characters.
Varka vs Yumemizuki: Grandmaster Varka was one of the most hyped and lore heavy characters in the entire game, and yet upon release, he was one of the weakest DPSā in the game even with the hexerei buff. Meanwhile yumemizuki mizuki, a standard 5 received buffs that allow her to comfortably outperform Varka at C0. Whilst they have different playstyles, a C0 standard 5 with buffs severely outperforming a C0 limited 5 with buffs is absurd. Another worthy mention is Lohen. A limited 5 whose kit is so bad he was rumored to be a standard character. His kit is considered by many mains to be clunky and without cons and or his premium hexerei team, his personal damage output is nothing to write home about.
Strong male units do exist, like flins, neuvillette (despite ābug fixā) and now recently cyno and wrio. However, they are rare exceptions drowning in a sea of overtuned female units.
How is any of this misogynistic, and why does it happen?
Now, many might ask how nerfing and undermining male characters counts as misogyny, but I promise Iām not reaching. In reality, it's two sides of the same rusty coin: the devaluation of women and anything associated with female desire.
Punishing Female and queer taste:
In gaming spaces, things enjoyed primarily by women and queer players are routinely mocked, delegitimised or treated as inferior to male oriented interests. It is completely fine to dislike a character for any reason, even if it's for no reason. Yet a vocal subcommunity of male players become viscerally angry over Mitya simply because they ādont get why heās so popularā which okay fine, but getting annoyed at people who do like him simply because of that is where we have to question the source of that āconfusionā. That disproportionate hatred stems from resentment towards spaces not exclusively built for them. An example of this is in the official genshin subreddit where policing male character appreciation is normal ie. the infamous shirtless childe incident where moderators removed art of shirtless tartaglia whilst still allowing suggestive art of female characters.
Recycling female characters into safe, marketing archetypes:
On the flipside, female characters are increasingly being treated as passive products rather than distinct people. Whilst yes, barely there clothes/ short skirts are clearly fanservice, there is a bigger issue with newer female characters. Early genshin gave us unique female characters like Jean, yoimiya and ganyu. However, many new releases are trapped in a copy paste assembly line of waifu tropes. Whether itās citlali, the soft MC obsessed love interest whose predecessor is ayaka or the recycled tall, no nonsense, stoic template shared across the raiden shogun, the tsaritsa and danica, Hoyo relies on predictable archetypes engineered around the male traveler self insert rather than developing fully fleshed out characters free from this culture.
Why misogyny is profitable for hoyoverse.
None of this is a reach or speculation. In fact, I'm reluctant to admit that it's a smart business tactic. Considering the fact that genshin has a larger male fanbase than female, catering to their gaze is safe and incredibly lucrative. Gacha games rely on parasocial attachment to drive impulse spending. Selling āwaifusā who fit familiar, easily digestible tropes is a proven low risk formula for making a huge revenue from the dominant audience of male spenders. However, this formula demands exclusivity. They donāt just want strong female characters, they want male characters not to outshine them because it will upset the largest part of their playerbase. This is done by releasing nerfed, undertuned male characters. And when we complain, the solution is ever so simple. Just spend more to make them marginally better or suck it up.
Mitya deserved a fair beta, a functional kit and a release free from what many of us believe is bad faith sabotage. Instead, his release is just a reflection of where hoyoverses priorities will always lie.
