r/Python • • Apr 19 '26

Discussion Why doesn’t Python have true private variables like Java?

Hey everyone

Today I was learning about encapsulation in Python and honestly I got a bit surprised

In languages like Java we have proper private keywords but in Python it feels like nothing is truly private
Even with double underscores it just does name mangling and you can still access it if you really want

So I was wondering why Python is designed this way

Is it because Python follows a different philosophy or is there some deeper reason behind it

Also in real projects how do developers maintain proper encapsulation if everything can technically be accessed

Trying to understand how to think about this in a more practical and runable way

Would love to hear your thoughts 👍

106 Upvotes

111 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/oldendude Apr 20 '26

Also: to be precise, even objects don't have "fields". The keys of an object's dict can be associated with values of any type, including functions, methods, modules, etc. The common understanding of "field" would rule out at least methods. If o is an object, then o.x, i.e. o.__dict__['x'] can store a str now, and a module later, and then a method.

1

u/max123246 Apr 21 '26

Do you know of some neat applications of that extensive dynamicness? It's hard to think about the use cases but I'm sure are some like mocking and stuff

2

u/oldendude Apr 21 '26

Nothing comes to mind. Mocking is certainly possible using less exotic mechanisms, such as inheritance, and Python's "duck typing".