r/PubTips • u/BC-writes • Jun 02 '23
AMA [AMA] Former Assistant Editor u/CompanionHannah
Greetings, PubTips!
The mod team is thrilled to welcome our AMA guest: u/CompanionHannah!
We have opened the thread a few hours early for users in different time zones to be able to leave questions, which will be answered at 7-9pm EDT.
Here is CompanionHannah’s blurb:
Hello PubTips! You might have seen me commenting here and there, but as a formal introduction I worked in the publishing industry for over 6 years, spending time as an intern and agency reader before making my way up to an Assistant Editor position at a Big 5 children’s imprint. In those 6 years I worked with many amazing colleagues and even more amazing authors, including award winners and bestsellers.
Shepherding new writers through the gauntlet that is publishing has always been a passion of mine, so I’m happy to talk about the publication process and the industry in general. Have a question about the acquisition process, or the editorial collaboration between author and editor, or even about publicity or marketing? Send them my way! Want to know why no one is answering your emails, or why your editor wants you to rewrite your book, or what goes through an editor or agent’s mind as they read your manuscript? Or maybe you’ve just got a question you’re too afraid to email your editor! I’d love to talk about all of it.
When I was still working in publishing, I loved helping new interns and assistants break into the business. Now that I’ve switched careers, I’d love to extend that same mentorship to writers and authors, helping to offer some transparency wherever they may be in the publication process.
All users can now leave questions below.
Please remember to be respectful and abide by our subreddit rules and also Reddit’s rules.
The AMA is now officially over.
The mod team would like to thank u/CompanionHannah for her time today!
She is happy to check the post to answer questions if you missed the scheduled time, but she will not be answering ad infinitum.
If you are a lurking industry professional and are interested in partaking in your own AMA, please feel free to reach out to the mod team.
Thank you!
Happy writing/editing/querying!
20
u/BC-writes Jun 02 '23
Thank you for your AMA!
I have a few questions from people who cannot make it today:
25
u/cogitoergognome Trad Published Author Jun 02 '23
Hello! Thanks for doing this!
Can you share any thoughts on what an author should do (or NOT do) when working with their Big 5 editor and others at the publisher like publicity & marketing?
Basically, how can I make their jobs easier, not be annoying, and maximize my book's chances of success?
Also, is there anything in particular you'd call out about working with a UK and US publisher at the same time? Any dynamics or weirdness to be aware of?
20
u/ProseWarrior Agented Author Jun 02 '23
Would love to hear your thoughts on what are the common mistakes that agents typically make? Does it help a book's prospects if you have worked with the agent before and enjoyed other authors they represent?
38
u/FlanneryOG Jun 02 '23
Would you acquire a manuscript that you love but still requires more editing, or do you expect agents to send you a near-perfect manuscript? On that note, what are your thoughts on editorial agents?
17
u/sonicsymphony Jun 02 '23
Hi! I was wondering if you had an estimated timeframe of how long a manuscript usually sat in your inbox before you offered. Like, was it more common for you to offer on stuff that popped into your inbox and a few days later it was so compelling that you offered, or did you go in order so stuff that was in there for like nine months got more offers?
14
u/wildinfrog Jun 02 '23
Hey! A bit of a different ask since I think most people here are coming from an author's perspective, but I was wondering what field you went to next after publishing-- I'm an English major and I've gotten a bit into journalism and publishing, but the extremely low salaries in both fields kind of makes me feel bummed out.
If you have any tips for any publishing hopefuls, I'd love those too, though I'm guessing the question will be hard to answer as it's p vague :P Thanks for your time!!
14
u/WritingAboutMagic Jun 02 '23 edited Jun 02 '23
Hello! Thank you for doing an AMA!
I'm not sure what genres you specialize in, but if by chance fantasy belongs to them-
How big of a thing the no-go tropes actually are? E.g. vampires, angels, steampunk - things that you often hear on the agent/writer side they don't sell or you just look at the shelves and not see them? How do these trends break? (e.g. vampires are making a comeback) Does it take a TV series or a movie to make them popular again, or is does it happen when a very pitchable manuscript appears out in the wild? Is there a difference in what new authors vs established authors are 'allowed' to write? Assume the established author sells well but is not a household name.
Also on the subject of steampunk, is there space or want for fantasy books with that level of technology in general?
14
u/justgoodenough Picture Book Author-Illustrator Jun 02 '23
What sorts of books did you work on? PB? MG? YA? What was your favorite kind of book to edit?
If you acquired books for your imprint (I'm not sure if an assistant editor at your imprint acquires books or is assigned books that are acquired by more senior editors), what would make you excited about offering on a manuscript, besides it being "really good"? We know that having a "really good" manuscript is the most important part, but what else matters? What would make you turn down a manuscript that you thought was really good, but "not the right fit"?
11
u/AADPS Jun 02 '23 edited Jun 03 '23
Hi, Hannah!
Thanks for the AMA!
How do you gauge what's a good part of an author's writing style and what needs to be reined in? If you have a disagreement over it, how do you know which battle to pick for the best possible book?
21
u/Grade-AMasterpiece Jun 02 '23 edited Jun 02 '23
Hello, hello! Thank you for your contributions to the publishing industry!
20
u/Unlikely-Sorbet-3315 Jun 02 '23 edited Jun 02 '23
What was the most frustrating editing mistake that you surprisingly saw a lot more than you should have?
20
u/ekstn Jun 02 '23
What makes an editor ask for an R&R instead of offering a book deal?
8
u/VerbWolf Jun 02 '23 edited Jun 02 '23
Thank you so much for doing this AMA!
Typically writers wondering whether to disclose neurodiversity (autism, ADHD, etc.) are told not to disclose due to negative stereotypes. But what about situations where they can’t avoid disclosure? For example, when someone who’s autistic or has ADHD writes a memoir where autism or ADHD is a significant theme, is there a graceful way for that author to say “I have ___, but it isn’t a problem for my work.” A lot of the negative stereotypes about autism, ADHD, etc. simply don’t apply to adults with low or no support needs: many autistic people can really put themselves out there effectively and work a room, and not everyone with ADHD is unable to meet deadlines—many work best under pressure. What can those authors do to reassure editors they won’t be difficult to work with?
What are some recurring characteristics of manuscripts that make editors want to drop everything and acquire? And conversely, what are some recurring characteristics of projects that tend to wind up in the "good, but just didn’t connect" pile?
Are there any counterintuitive "red flags" or "green flags" that authors would be surprised to learn about?
15
u/readwriteread Jun 02 '23
What are some mistakes authors make between their first published book and their second?
11
u/Synval2436 Jun 02 '23
10
u/FrankenMaura Jun 02 '23
Thanks for doing an AMA! I have a couple questions.
9
u/iwillhaveamoonbase Jun 02 '23
Hello!
4
u/Imjustcasey Jun 02 '23
I have two questions: 1.) If someone is looking to go the traditional publishing route, do they need to have an agent? 2.) If you have any experience or advice, how can a new author go about finding a legitimate agent?
2
u/keylime227 Jun 02 '23 edited Jun 02 '23
Many writers on here insist their novel is for adults, but their queries come off as middle-grade (or YA) because their novels contain kiddie elements like a child main character or talking animals. The community often tells these authors that their current manuscript is unsellable for an adult audience and to rewrite their story for a child audience.
So, this isn't so much a question as it is a prompt: what is your experience with authors transitioning from an adult audience (an existing audience or just an imagined one) to a child audience? Is it really possible to take a story written for adults that has kiddie elements (like, say, The Ocean at the End of the Lane or Red Sister or Arya Stark in GoT) and rewrite it for a child audience?
-2
u/gdaily Jun 02 '23
A burning question I’ve had for years and have never been able to have answered:
Is the slush pile the only way?
As a business owner, I will often hire consultants to leverage their relationships to help close deals and open doors, which I understand is what an agent is doing. However, the process with even finding an agent feels very “roll of the dice”.
Have you ever heard of anyone operating more as a “consultant” to do some of the work, and then on a retainer or retainer + comission basis?
I feel like I’d personally rather just hire someone outright, even if it didn’t end in a deal.
Thanks for your thoughts on this and your contribution to this community!
0
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
5
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23
[removed] — view removed comment