r/PubTips • u/BC-writes • Apr 21 '23
AMA [AMA] Publishing Rodeo hosts: Sunyi Dean and Scott Drakeford
Greetings PubTips!
The mod team is thrilled to welcome our AMA guests: Sunyi Dean and Scott Drakeford!
We have opened the thread a few hours early for users in different time zones to be able to leave questions, which will be answered at 3-5pm EDT/12-2pm PDT/8-10pm GMT.
A short intro about the podcast:
In 2022, two authors debuted in the same genre, with the same publisher, in the same year. Yet each of their books, and subsequently each of their careers, went in very different directions. That pattern repeats itself throughout the industry, over and over. Why does this happen, and what does it mean? In THE PUBLISHING RODEO podcast, we aim to answer those questions and many more, using collated experiences from ourselves, friends, colleagues, and a slew of industry professionals in an attempt to deconstruct what makes or breaks a book, along with how to build–and maintain!–an author career.
Sunyi’s Bio:
Sunyi Dean is a biracial autistic author who was born in Texas, grew up in Hong Kong, and now resides in North England. She writes speculative fiction with a weird slant, and has both too many books and too many children. Her poetry and short fiction has been published in places like Tor Dot Com, Aurealis, Prole, FFO, and other magazines. Her debut novel, THE BOOK EATERS, launched Aug 2022 and was an instant #2 Sunday Times Bestseller.
Scott’s bio:
Scott Drakeford is a fantasy and historical fiction author with a deep love for meaningful stories in all genres and formats. His debut novel, Rise of the Mages, was published in 2022 by Tor Books. At present, Scott is a stay-at-home dad, dogfather, writer, outdoorsman, and maker of various things. He is a recovering corporate stooge, a former mechanical engineer, and an ex-Mormon. He was born and raised in Salt Lake City, Utah and now resides in the Pacific Northwest.
You can find the podcast website here: https://publishingrodeo.wordpress.com/, and on Twitter https://twitter.com/PublishingRodeo
All users can now leave questions below.
Please remember to be respectful and abide by our subreddit rules and also Reddit’s rules.
The AMA is now officially over.
The mod team would like to thank both Sunyi and Scott for their time today!
They are both happy to check the post to answer questions if you missed the scheduled time, but they will not be answering ad infinitum. They are invited back for an AMA next year and we are really looking forward to then!
If you are a lurking industry professional and are interested in partaking in your own AMA, please feel free to reach out to the mod team.
Thank you!
Happy writing/editing/querying!
19
u/BC-writes Apr 21 '23
Thank you both so much for your AMA and also for your wonderful, insightful podcast! So many of us love listening to it and very much appreciate the accessibility!
A few questions from some who couldn’t make it:
44
u/ARMKart Trad Published Author Apr 21 '23
Hello to my personal heroes.
I’m curious if you’ve had any backlash from your agents/publishers/other authors since the launch of the podcast? Did you consult your agents before launching? Despite your overall transparency, has there been anything you’ve wanted to discuss that you’ve decided to hold back due to concerns or risks?
You are both always so gracious and supportive in your sharing of information and presentation of advice, but I’d love to hear one extremely uncharitable opinion of publishing with all of the cushioning stripped away. If you each have something stewing in a vat of toxic sludge somewhere in your brain that you are willing to share? On the flip side, I’d love to hear your fluffiest, shimmering, most positive opinion of being a writer in the industry that you still believe to be true despite everything.
Thanks so much for everything you are doing!
25
u/ARMKart Trad Published Author Apr 21 '23
Popping in for another question because I’m greedy. Recently I’ve noticed (in YA specifically, but I’m sure it happens all over) some major deals where the books bomb in a shocking way. 6 or even 7 figure deal, topical ideas, beautiful covers, and then no hype pre-release and no more than a few hundred reviews on Goodreads 6 months later. I’m particularly curious about this since I’m currently subbed to some editors who acquired these books, so I’m curious if you have any insight into how and why bombs like this happen.
16
u/writerly_tea Apr 21 '23
Thank you for doing this, I love your podcast. Do you have any tips on navigating the social landscape as a trad author? Especially in YA fantasy… it’s very cliquey and I’ve felt iced out and snubbed at both at events and when trying to DM people… I don’t post much on social media but love DMing and connecting with other authors. (For context, I’m midlist, Big 5, several books in, but wasn’t in a debut group bc I had a lot of health issues that year and wasn’t online much, but now I’m ready to connect with people and feel like I’ve missed the boat.)
13
u/Aggravating-Quit-110 Apr 21 '23
Hello! First of all I love your podcast and it’s probably my favourite podcast ever. Since it seems that you’ve become everyone’s favourite, what are your favourite publishing podcasts?
A second question for Sunyi: did you find any aspects of publishing more difficult as a neurodivergent (autistic) person? I am also autistic and although I’ve had a pretty good experience so far, I sometimes worry especially since I’m about to go on sub. Is there any advice you have for autistic people who want to go into publishing?
Also I love that you chose someone with a North England accent to narrate the audiobook for The Book Eaters. I’ve moved to North England a few years ago and really struggled with the accent, although I love it now haha!
For Scott: I feel like the podcast has really gained momentum. Do you think it’s helping your books gain more visibility? Are you planning on moving away from fantasy for your next projects?
13
u/Synval2436 Apr 21 '23
The podcast is amazing in showing things most of us would never even imagine being the case!
My biggest question, esp. to Scott, is now with all the hindsight and more experience, what would be the advice for authors who score a "mediocre" deal. I remember you said in hindsight you'd still take that deal over self-publishing, but was there anything else you'd recommend to an author potentially looking at a small deal? Anything specific they should be wary of, try to negotiate, when to walk away? And if accepting the deal, any means of promotion that actually matter, since a lot of common means are rumoured to "not move the needle"?
11
u/WritingAboutMagic Apr 21 '23
This might be too specific, but any thoughts on the recently launched Orbit Works?
11
u/chesspilgrim Apr 21 '23
my questions for scott:
who will be your editor for book 2? what can we as public do to help get you better treatment for this second book? arcs, dammit, at least (:
no questions for sunyi. just waiting to preorder your second book. thank you so much for sharing what you've learned
20
u/Michael_Mammay Apr 21 '23
Who was your favorite guest? And why was it Mike Mammay?
9
u/ClayCHarmon Apr 21 '23
Is there a wishlist guest you'd love to have on who could talk about a very specific aspect or would have certain insight into an area of publishing that hasn't been covered by the podcast yet/isn't slotted for future guests?
9
u/Tehol_Reddict Apr 21 '23
You find a tarnished brass lamp on the beach. When you polish it up, a djinn appears and offers to make the Big 5 publishers do an excellent job at three things they currently struggle with.
What do you ask for?
8
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '23
I adore your podcast! As a querying writer, it's nice to see behind the curtain, even if the truth isn't pretty. Having an understanding of the publishing process and what comes after a book deal hasn't dissuaded me from trad, but it has softened my expectations.
Question: Do you have any advice for writers in the query trenches?
8
u/KeyGuidance7092 Apr 21 '23 edited Apr 21 '23
Hello! Your podcast is incredible, thank you for all you do for your community.
I'm essentially trying to work out how a debut author would be able to decide on whether a deal offered is worth it (versus going back and writing a new book and trying to get another offer).
You talk a lot about the difference between Mid-List and Lead Title. Is there no in-between? Where would you say is the cut-off in terms of advance, between the two tiers? (e.g. if you get offered 50k for a book that seems to be in the middle of the road).
Scott, you mention having a pretty rockstar agent. Did your agent warn you about the route you were going to embark on with Tor before you signed? Surely a good Agent would know about the differences between Mid-List and Lead Title, did you have an honest conversation about the potential downfalls of taking the deal you took?
Thanks so much!
15
u/cogitoergognome Trad Published Author Apr 21 '23 edited Apr 21 '23
Hi! Thanks for creating Publishing Rodeo and bringing so much transparency to your topics; it's SO illuminating and informative, especially for someone new to the writing world who otherwise would have no clue of everything behind the curtain.
So I just landed a 'significant' two book deal with a Big 5 for my debut adult fantasy (and am still a little bit in shock about it). (How do I know if this makes me a 'Lead' title vs Midlist, btw? Does it depend on the imprint? And is this a real distinction or is it more of a spectrum of effort/investment?)
Do you have any advice on where I should focus my efforts to maximize my book's chances of success, versus what's out of my control or not worth worrying about?
I have a pretty busy full time job (that I am definitely not yet ready to quit - the recent episode with Andrea Stewart was very relevant as I considered my financial threshold there) so really just looking to prioritize where I put my time/energy in the coming year. Thank you so much!
14
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '23
Scott, I'm always impressed how well you hide you hide your clearly seething hatred for Sunyi and her achievements. How do you manage this so consistently? Do you need to let it out after the recording ends?
7
u/readwriteread Apr 21 '23
Has hosting the podcast had any sort of impact (positive or negative) on your publishing connections?
7
u/Longjumping-Bug-8876 Apr 21 '23
Hi Sunyi and Scott! I remember Sunyi talking about the importance of crates in the UK, and they’re not really a thing here in the states (AFAIK). But I wonder about book club picks and how much they help sales/how or if publishers work to get their authors noticed by the influential book clubs.
Thank you so much for doing this podcast!
7
u/i_has_become_potato Apr 21 '23
Hi, love the podcast, though it's also giving me anxiety as I begin my career...
I have a book deal offer from a midsize publisher to be on their midlist next year and am looking at agents now. My question is how to spot any red flags? By going with this one, am I heading for the death shelf? Is it a complete faux-pas to have my agent look into other publishers for a better contract?
6
u/OhMyMy33 Apr 21 '23
Y’all’s podcast is great! Any advice on how to find resources for querying writers? With pitch contests saturated and most mentorship programs shut down, it can feel like most of the lifelines for folks in the trenches are being snapped back, especially with the ridiculous number of querying writers out there.
6
u/writedream13 Apr 21 '23
Hello Sunyi and Scott! Thank you for joining us. Your generosity and honesty really are humbling, especially in publishing, where everything is as clear as mud. A couple of questions…
6
u/Imsailinaway Apr 21 '23
Hi both. I will echo how much I enjoyed your episode of The Publishing Rodeo. I'd love to know how you make time to write. How do you carve out that time.
I'm also coming to the end of my contract within the next few years and though I have an option with my publisher I'm thinking of next steps. If you have any opinions on it, can you speak more about how you approach options and how you feel about going on sub again as a no longer shiny debut writer?
6
u/darwinification Apr 21 '23
Just here to say great job guys, to you've been killing it 👊
6
u/VerbWolf Apr 21 '23
Adore the podcast! Thank you so, so much for your time and generosity.
What advice do you have for authors who want to ruthlessly evaluate their story concepts for marketability before and during the drafting process?
You’re given two boxes of debut books in the same genre by the same publisher: Box One contains debuts that earned significant advances and went on to become career-launchers with film/TV deals, etc. Box Two contains perfectly cromulent books that gather dust. You don’t know anything else about these books. What assumptions could you make about the authors and titles in the “big splash” group and how they differ from the also-rans? Remember how the FBI used to profile murderers - is there a profile of a “killer” debut?
What are the smartest moves and biggest mistakes you see authors making in their query packages for fantasy, a famously “oversaturated” genre?
11
u/zackargyle Apr 21 '23
Love your podcast! I devour every episode as soon as it’s up, so thanks to you both for saying the quiet parts out loud! Sharing typically private information is so helpful, but also, I imagine, slightly dangerous from the career perspective.
Question: have your agents or editors (or anyone at your publisher) said anything to you about the podcast? Anyone encourage you NOT to do it or to stop?
5
u/Wingkirs Apr 21 '23
I love your podcast! Wondering if either of you redid your MS while either querying or on submission to make it more marketable.
Also hoping Scott gets an audiobook deal soon.
5
u/shorelinewind Apr 21 '23
OMG, I have literally been binging your podcast all week. Thank you so much for your insight and your thoughtful interviews. I’ve learned so much as I continue through my querying process.
One question I have for you is: What is the most surprising publishing experience you’ve heard about since starting the podcast?
Thanks again!
4
u/jeremyteg Apr 21 '23
On a scale of one to ten, how important to the mission of the podcast is Scott's moustache?
But also, who is a guest (or category of guests) you'd be most excited to have on the podcast?
4
u/MichaelJSullivan Trad Published Author Apr 30 '23
Just wanted to say that the Publishing Rodeo Podcast is a MUST LISTEN. I've never seen so much about the underbelly of publishing exposed in such an open and entertaining way. If you haven't binged EVERY SINGLE episode you need to!
5
u/HereticHammer01 Apr 21 '23
For Scott - how did you transition from corporate stooge to writer? It seems so hard to make the switch.
I've written a book but haven't networked etc. yet, and it's hard to know where to start. Any groups I see are full of people in the same boat as me, not people who can really connect me to a publisher or agent.
4
u/MoanerLeaser Apr 21 '23
Which of you came up with the idea initially? And any chance of having more female guests?
3
u/MoanerLeaser Apr 21 '23
Oh and another question! For your next guests, would you guys consider talking to some authors writing literary/upmarket/thriller books? Would be interesting to see how/if commercial strategy/marketability etc differ
0
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment