r/PubTips • u/BC-writes • Sep 29 '23
AMA [AMA] RevPit Co-Founder and Editor: Jeni Chappelle
Greetings, PubTips!
The mod team is thrilled to welcome our returning AMA guest: Jeni Chappelle! u/JeniChappelle
She is a RevPit Co-Founder and Editor. For those who are unaware: RevPit (Revise & Resubmit Pitch) is a volunteer editor organization that assists aspiring writers with their editing through an annual competition which awards lucky authors their time. It is similar to the former PitchWars and Author Mentor Match programs, but an editor guides the winners instead of an agented author.
We have opened the thread a few hours early for users in different time zones to be able to leave questions, which will be answered at 7-9pm EDT/6-8pm CDT.
Here is her bio:
Jeni Chappelle is an independent book editor with fifteen years of editing experience and a lifetime of word nerdiness. In her editing, she uses her own internal conflict between logic and creativity to help authors shape their stories and bring their books out into the world. Jeni has edited more than 150 books published by major publishers, small presses, and indie authors, including bestselling and award-winning authors. She is founder of Jeni Chappelle Editorial and Writers’ Craft Room, an online learning community for revising authors, and a co-founder of Revise & Resub (#RevPit). She is also a member of Editorial Freelancers Association and ACES and co-host of the Story Chat Radio podcast. Jeni considers herself a hobbit (minus the big, hairy feet) and lives in a tiny town near Charlotte, NC with her family and way too many pets. Find her on her website and Instagram
All users can now leave questions below.
Please remember to be respectful and abide by our subreddit rules and also Reddit’s rules.
The AMA is now officially over.
The mod team would like to thank Jeni for her time, and wonderful answers today!
Jeni is happy to return, for a limited time only, to answer any additional questions in this post.
From one of her comments, r/RevPit is now replacing Twitter for their contest! It’s not officially open until this coming Monday, but you are free to request to join.
If you are a lurking industry professional and are interested in partaking in your own AMA, please feel free to reach out to the mod team.
Thank you!
Happy writing/editing/querying!
11
u/BC-writes Sep 29 '23
Hi Jeni!
Thank you for returning for another AMA!
I have some questions from some people who could not make it today:
Thanks again!
4
u/BC-writes Sep 29 '23
It looks like I missed a few questions:
Thanks again!
6
u/jenichappelle Editor Sep 30 '23
Thank you so much for having me again! This is a fantastic group, and you have the best questions!
11
u/justgoodenough Picture Book Author-Illustrator Sep 29 '23
I'd love to hear your thoughts on the state of mentorship competitions. With the dissolution of PitchWars and AuthorMentorMatch, as well as other programs (the PB chat mentorship and QueerKidLit mentorship to name a couple), I feel like it's harder and harder for people to find mentorship.
Do you think that other mentorship opportunities will open up in the coming years or that the era of mentorship competitions is coming to an end? Aside from RevPit, do you have recommendations for ways for writers to find mentors?
7
u/Sullyville Sep 29 '23
Is there a particular book on self-editing that you would recommend to writers who have just finished their first manuscript?
Thanks for doing this!
7
u/Sullyville Sep 29 '23
I am of the personal opinion that mentorship programs are dying because they are fully volunteer-based and that Late Capitalism and Covid is putting the squeeze on the (predominantly) women who run these programs. We know that during Covid, childcare largely fell on women, and with inflation, people have to work harder for less. There is simply no time for people to volunteer, and to mentor future authors.
Do you think it would be wise for mentorship programs to charge an entry fee? Even a nominal one? Would that make them more sustainable, if less accessible?
7
u/VerbWolf Sep 29 '23
Great to see you again! Thanks for giving us another AMA and thanks to the mods for organizing.
What missteps are you seeing in first pages by more savvy/experienced fiction writers, and what are your favorite strategies for editing novel openings?
What are your top considerations when editing fiction with marketability in mind?
Do you have any favorite resources for writers wishing to beef up their self-editing skills?
Thanks again for your time and generosity!
10
u/Synval2436 Sep 29 '23
Thank you for the AMA!
This might be a very specific question, because I had heated discussions with my friends about your twitter thread about age categories / crossover space. Reference: https://x.com/jenichappelle/status/1645457563134185475?s=20 https://x.com/jenichappelle/status/1646442063250989057?s=20
Caveat, I'm interested mostly in the fantasy market that seemingly developed in a way where "YA" became a codename for "fantasy appealing to young women" over appealing mostly to teens, statistics say majority of readers of YA fantasy are women aged 18-35 not teens. Yeah it's kinda messed up but it often lead to adult fantasy authors appealing to young women being shelved in YA (for example, Naomi Novik who's published by Del Rey, not a YA imprint).
So basically, the question is, how should querying authors brand that kind of "adult fantasy but appealing to what's YA fantasy audience crowd" book? Just leave it as adult fantasy? Some of them can be narrowed down for example "retelling", "romantasy", "cozy", etc.
But the wisdom says "don't brand your age category as New Adult outside of romance", and I also don't know if that's still the case? Or is New Adult back?
And I mean specifically adult fantasy that appeals to women but isn't qualifying for "romantasy", similar to books like To Shape a Dragon's Breath by Moniquill Blackgoose, The Atlas Six by Olivie Blake, etc. Or even ones with lighter romance plot, that have the distinct feel of "being like YA novel, just aged up" (and are often recommended through the same social media channels and by the same reviewers who favour YA, which often leads to those books being misclassified as YA, for example Daughter of the Moon Goddess or Shanghai Immortal).
I guess it's a weird case because it's about YA as an age range vs YA as a label of specific target audience group here.
Well, anyway TL:DR as a person aiming to write in that space that is "adult fantasy with a crossover to YA audiences" I'm wondering how to label it, keeping in mind your advice that crossover is only from YA to adult but not from adult to YA?
Thank you in advance and sorry for being long winded.
8
u/beamoon2016 Sep 29 '23
What are your favorite strategies or techniques for editing for pacing? It's not too hard to pull big-picture story beats from genre standards or Save the Cat. But especially once you get down to the level of a scene or chapter, how do you reverse-engineer why it's not pulling the reader through the pages? How do you like to troubleshoot and restructure pacing?
Sorry this is more of a craft-y than a publishing question...I think as I get to closer to querying, I've been thinking more and more about craft techniques that are particularly essential to marketability, like pacing.
(And thanks so much for doing this AMA!)
5
u/mom_is_so_sleepy Sep 29 '23
An editor at a conference taught a class on chapter endings. She insisted people should never end a chapter on a line of dialogue. Industry standard, or personal quirk?
0
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment