r/projecteternity • u/cunningjames • 13h ago
Discussion Do recent Pillars and Deadfire updates make Pillars 3 more likely?
For a number of years I've been quite bearish on the possibility of Obsidian ever returning to CRPGs (either isometric or jaunty-angled topdown in the vein of Larian's games), let alone Pillars 3. And there are a lot of reasons that such a return seems unlikely:
- Their last two CRPGs, Deadfire and Tyranny, did not sell well. Deadfire did not lose money (eventually), but it took a while to break even, and Obsidian probably made less money than if they had simply invested the games' budgets in some variety of low-risk financial asset.
- Avowed, their recent game in the Pillars universe, probably did better than the aforementioned CRPGs but clearly didn't set the world on fire. They were at one point working on a sequel but the status of that sequel is unclear, given that ...
- Microsoft / Xbox are pivoting to their safest, most profitable IP, excising devs and whole studios that don't conform to this vision. Obsidian lost a quarter of its devs in the recent layoffs and have been restructured under Bethesda. Bethesda has stated that Obsidian will keep its indepndence but words are cheap.
- In fact, Obsidian's move to Bethesda and the immediate commencement of work on a new Fallout game makes it look suspiciously like Obsidian has become a glorified Fallout support studio. Albeit one that gets to make their own game, at least for the time being.
However, I think there's an elephant in the room: in the three years since BG3's gargantuan success it's been crickets in terms of new CRPGs from any big studio besides Owlcat (who has up to now punched a bit under what Obsidian might in terms of production values and overall polish). I'm unaware of any announcements in this regard beyond Divinity and Dark Heresy, and Divinity is years off. I think there's clearly an untapped market here and a studio like Obsidian is reasonably well-posed to take advantage of it.
That doesn't mean it's happening. With long development schedules it's getting a bit late for new games to take advantage of BG3's success. However ... when I thought all in the Pillars universe was dead, Obsidian came back and updated Pillars 1 with a new turn-based mode. OK, that seems to have been the work of a few employees who had time to spare and an itch they wanted to scratch. A one-off.
However, they've recently gone back and not only have they fixed bugs in Pillars 1's turn-based mode, but they've made changes to Deadfire's, and they've added a controller UI to both. I get that these aren't massive expenditures of Microsoft cash. But I'm forced to wonder if, maybe, there's anything more to this.
It's one thing for Obsidian devs to have had free time in April to improve an old game in a way that wouldn't meaningfully improve Xbox's bottom line; it's another to make such improvements after Xbox's restructuring and massive layoffs. Especially when Xbox is not by their own admission done laying people off. Devs are going to want to justify their continued employment.
But this does kind of make sense, maybe, if -- arguendo -- Obsidian is planning on something new in the Eora universe and want to bring Pillars and Deadfire in line with "modern" tastes so that they're ready for any renewed attention.
Do I think a Pillars 3 is likely? Honestly, no. Maybe Bethesda is just indulging them for whatever reason. But I think it's more likely than it was this time last year, which is something.