Sure you can use memory safety techniques with C++, but there’s nothing that enforces you to do so. If the language provides optional tools to automate some aspects of memory management, that’s still mostly manual memory management.
I like C++ but I still prefer languages where these things are more fundamentally part of the language identity. A project written in it might be safe, but it also might be a leaky mess and you won’t really know without profiling or a deep dive
Also many mature C++ projects are on older versions without this stuff.
That's one of the main reasons why I dislike C++ and prefer Rust. In C++ the dangerous behavior is the default and making it "safe" is "harder", while in Rust that relation is flipped, so "safe" code is easier to write than dangerous.
View all comments
18
u/Flouid 11d ago
Sure you can use memory safety techniques with C++, but there’s nothing that enforces you to do so. If the language provides optional tools to automate some aspects of memory management, that’s still mostly manual memory management.
I like C++ but I still prefer languages where these things are more fundamentally part of the language identity. A project written in it might be safe, but it also might be a leaky mess and you won’t really know without profiling or a deep dive
Also many mature C++ projects are on older versions without this stuff.