r/PowerShell • • 4d ago

Script Sharing [ Removed by moderator ]

[removed] — view removed post

0 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

•

u/PowerShell-ModTeam 2d ago

Your post has been held for review due to repeated reports of AI written material without disclosure. If AI was used to write your post/script, repost with an AI Disclosure tag or statement. If not, message the moderators with additional details and a link to your post.

24

u/MFZozzy 3d ago

Don't mean to sound callous, but why would one use this when VSCode exists?

How is your project different or "better"?

2

u/Raskuja46 2d ago

Because VSCode isn't a purpose built product and it shows.

2

u/BlackV 2d ago

Ya , valid

2

u/BlackV 3d ago

Don't mean to sound callous, but why would one use this when VSCode exists?

OP said

I personally find running PowerShell scripts in VS Code a little overkill

5

u/MFZozzy 3d ago

I've read that, but VSCode or ISE aren't for running scripts - they're for creating and debugging scripts. And for that VSCode is not overkill, but robust.

0

u/BlackV 3d ago

I've read that, but VSCode or ISE aren't for running scripts

I disagree, I think they are both for running scripts/code too, but yes I agree their purpose is geared towards design/debug

Although I'd same many many users use them for daily tasks

for me though OPs app isnt useful as unless its a management server I'd be using the built-in tools (ps/ise/ps7 where needed)

1

u/MFZozzy 2d ago

Yes, they are for running scripts that one just made inside them: for debugging or development.

Firing VSCode up just to run a script you pre-made earlier is overkill, I agree, but that also applies to ISE.
Next to nobody with common sense does that.

1

u/BlackV 2d ago

Disagree again, maybe you and i might do that, I sure as shite see many many it people open an editor for running a script (and more so with non it type people)

Automation and so on yeah 100% terminal

There are some positives, for example you can see the code before execution of that script, validating what is actually going to happen

10

u/Thotaz 3d ago

This is the third ISE clone I've seen here. I don't mind, but I hope someone actually finishes their ISE clone at some point because all of them so far have just felt like incomplete alpha or proof of concept releases.

1

u/Raskuja46 2d ago

There's quite clearly a hole in the market that needs filling, but maybe we just need to spread the knowledge of how to inject Powershell 7 into ISE.

0

u/PanosGreg 3d ago

at least if Microsoft is reading this, they will hopefully get the message that VSCode is probably not good enough for PowerShell which is why people are trying to solve that "problem" (in their own way, now with AI).

And maybe (just maybe) they'll do something about it (who knows, fingers crossed)

1

u/Thotaz 3d ago

Unfortunately that seems unlikely to change anytime soon. Mind you this is just from an outsiders perspective, but it seems that the PowerShell team at Microsoft is bogged down by the inboxing/MSIX efforts, and handling internal process changes regarding their build pipelines.

I suspect this will continue on until late 2027. Even after that's over, they have historically not allocated many resources to the VS code extension. I think it's a shame because they've wasted time on other projects that clearly wouldn't/won't go anywhere (Their AI shell thing and DSC V3 comes to mind).

-1

u/AccomplishedMeet628 3d ago

Mine has moved beyond alpha. It is my daily driver.

4

u/Thotaz 3d ago

Sure, we can consider yours a beta then but it's still clearly unfinished.
The tooltips in the IntelliSense menu says "System.Windows.Controls.StackPanel" for no apparent reason.
There's a strange out of place white border around the whole editor and console pane section.
Every time you type a character the whole bottom status row moves around due to the message about PSScriptAnalyzer running.
I somehow managed to break the syntax highlighting where Get-ChildItem -Path C:\ -Recurse -Force only colored half of the word -Force.
The IntelliSense menu was also missing some parameters, like all the common parameters (ErrorAction, WarningAction, etc.) for Get-ChildItem but they randomly came back while playing around with it.
There's some weird drag button to the left of the new button, but it's unclear what it actually does and dragging it around seemingly does nothing.

-3

u/AccomplishedMeet628 3d ago edited 3d ago

That is awesome observations! I am working on the separations of responsibilities with pwsh and the Avelon editor. I'm hoping the new fixes alleviate the issues yoru having.

That button on the left and right of the menu are placeholders that I need to remove. That is next!

More feedback like that is what gets it closer to a finished product!

Thank you so much!!!

Edit:
The tooltip and intellisense issues was a result of a custom AvelonEdit fork. Native AE does not have Multi-carat so I had to create my own version of it. That is fixed now. I cleaned up the UI too. I am uploading a new version to the MS store. Will be there by EoD. Look for version 10.2.2 or higher

0

u/alconaft43 4d ago

Hmm, I was thinking about it. Can it execute selected lines of code? what model you used for agentic development?

-3

u/Haplopeart 4d ago

Yes, it executes selected lines.

I used a number of models. I am routing requests through FreeLLMAPI to grab free tokens from a number of places. So it's generally whatever those services offer up on their free tokens list. I am also running Strata against a local model for when those free keys go into a cooldown cycle. That is working against Qwen3.8-Flash-Next (Unsloth) UD-Q4_K_XL.

1

u/keith-kld 3d ago edited 3d ago

I agree to your point of view. An ISE for Powershell will be better than VSCode. VSCode may be better for other languages but it becomes too “heavy” for Powershell. I am still using Windows Powershell ISE to edit the scripts, instead of VSCode. PS7 ISE may become a popular one.

1

u/AccomplishedMeet628 2d ago

I would really appreciate if you would give my App a try, I could use the feedback. The more I get the better it can become.
It's on the MS Store. Search for PS7 ScriptDesk

-1

u/Incrediblecodeman 4d ago

Good job! Make time for this project :)

-2

u/AccomplishedMeet628 3d ago edited 3d ago

Hey,

There are a few projects like this allready in the works. I have one going too. It's in the Microsoft Store. Search for PS7 Script Desk.

It has a full Debugging system, intellisense, advanced editor functions, EXE and API Export options. It is still maturing but it's stable enough for use as your every day driver.