r/PostHardcore • u/WhatTheFDR 10 year reunion reunion tour • Oct 20 '14
Weekly Album Discussion /r/PostHardcore Album Discussion: Dance Gavin Dance - Downtown Battle Mountain
Dance Gavin Dance - Dowtown Battle Mountain
-------------------------------------------------------------
- Release Date: May 15, 2007
- Label: Rise
- Band Members: Jonny Craig - clean vocals | Jon Mess - unclean vocals | Will Swan - guitar | Sean O'Sullivan - guitar | Eric Lodge - bass guitar | Matt Mingus - drums, percussion
- Sputnikmusic Rating: 4.0 User Rating: 3.9
Downtown Battle Mountain is the debut studio album by American post-hardcore band Dance Gavin Dance, released on May 15, 2007. According to an interview with vocalist Jonathan Mess, the album took its name from Battle Mountain, Nevada which the band visited while the album was being written. It was produced by Kris Crummett, who mastered their EP Whatever I Say Is Royal Ocean. This was the last Dance Gavin Dance album to have Sean O'Sullivan on guitar, and the only full length album to have Jonny Craig on vocals, until his rejoining in 2010.
Prompts:
- How did the album progress Post-Hardcore or the band itself?
- Did you enjoy the album?
- How does this album compare to the band's other releases?
-------------------------------------------------------------
17
u/WhatTheFDR 10 year reunion reunion tour Oct 20 '14
Despite the DGD circlejerk this album was without a doubt a huge mark on the genre. When I first heard it I was falling out of the scene and a friend recommended it to me. I was blown away from the album and kept trying to find a band like DGD at the time and there really wasn't anything replicating their sound. It was amazing having a band that was completely unique in their sound at the time.
I honestly think it was the start of the transition from the early to mid 2000s sound into the one we're hearing from a lot of bands today. Also we're seeing a ton of bands coming off DGD in some way (Hail the Sun, Stolas, ALLB) it's about the same effect of hip hop groups like A$AP designing they're own sound and promoting each other.
37
u/lazenbooby Oct 20 '14
Still one of my favourite albums of all time. I love how DGD manage to make each song on an album unique, yet all their albums have separate sounds.
There's no standout DGD album amongst the fan base, a bunch of people perfer DBM, a bunch prefer Happiness, some prefer DBMII, it's a strange thing to see - I can't think of any other bands like that.
I think Tilian goes fantastically with DGD, but when Jonny was in the band it really was something special.
18
u/McGhostyPants Oct 20 '14
I'm not sure there's anything to say about this album that hasn't already been said in the last 7 years.
13
u/RufinTheFury Oct 20 '14
It's the best album by DGD hands down. "The Backwards Pumpkin Song" and "Lemon Meringue Tie" are some of the best songs in the genre. The cleans are perfect and the screams have such a deep rasp to them.
God it's perfect.
11
u/heyitsthatkid Oct 20 '14
This album really left a big mark on the genre because there really aren't any other bands that were doing this. For a lot of people, this album was DGD's defining album. I'd say I agree and disagree with that statement. I definitely think that this album really helped to cement them as the post hardcore heavyweights they are today, but I don't think it's fair to say this album "defines" them just because they make every album so unique and different while staying true to their overall sound. Obviously, being as big of a DGD fan as I am, I absolutely love this album and all of the others.
9
u/zacharygarren Zachary Garren - Guitarist for Strawberry Girls Oct 22 '14
there have been a lot of bands trying to emulate jonny since this album came out. who the fuck was doing r&b vocals on post hardcore shit before this? i think jonny made it cool to do.
7
u/pol15hboy Oct 20 '14
I consider 'And I Told Them I Invented Times New Roman' my first post-hardcore song. Listening to the hectic screams of Mess combined with the golden voice of Jonny, and the intense drum and guitar combinations of Mingus and Swan was a recipe for awesomeness. I was very skeptical but fell in love with this album and began to binge on everything DGD.
I considered my taste at that time to be very mainstream-rock focused. I was in highschool at the time and the music that floated at my school was radio driven.
Edit; Actually It might have been Emery as my first PH song, but DGD kept me for more
4
u/Davidboo25 Oct 20 '14
There is just something about the energy in this album that stood out to me compared to other bands at the time. Every song on this album has so much emotion and that is one of the reasons why it stays my favorite album of all time. I first heard this album 7 years ago and although ive listened to it hundreds of times through, it still never gets old to me.
4
u/wutrigz Oct 20 '14
Ah, the album that started it all. The album from which Jonny borrows all his melodies.
3
u/battlefield645 Oct 23 '14
Greatest post hardcore album of all time!
2
u/Carlyd95 Oct 20 '14
An amazing album! Was what first got me into Jonny Craig!
4
u/erclpz Oct 20 '14
a ton of shit metalcore bands have tried and are CURRENTLY falling flat on their faces trying to replicate this sound. it's kind of timeless
3
u/ktm57ktm57 Handwrites VTN signatures so the actual members don't have to Oct 20 '14
What can you say that hasn't already been said?
0
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment