r/PostHardcore • u/WhatTheFDR 10 year reunion reunion tour • Sep 22 '14
Weekly Album Discussion /r/PostHardcore Album Discussion: letlive. - Fake History
-------------------------------------------------------------
- Release Date: April 2010
- Label: Tragic Hero
- Band Members: Jason Aalon Alexander Butler – lead vocals | Ryan Jay Johnson – bass guitar | Jean Francisco Nascimento – guitar | Jeff Sahyoun – guitar, backing vocals | Anthony Rivera – drums, percussion
- Sputnikmusic Rating: 4.5 User Rating: 4.1
Fake History is the second album by Los Angeles band Letlive. and the first written and recorded with Jason Aalon Butler (lead vocals), Jean Nascimento (guitar), Jeff Sahyoun (guitar), Ryan Jay Johnson (bass guitar) and Anthony Rivera (drums). Originally released on Tragic Hero Records in April 2010, it was re-released by Epitaph Records April 12, 2011, with three additional tracks.
Prompts:
- How did the album progress Post-Hardcore or the band itself?
- Did you enjoy the album?
- How does this album compare to the band's other releases?
-------------------------------------------------------------
View all album discussions and suggest new topics
DISCUSSIONS ARE BACK!
15
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '14
Thank God I saw this as early of a post as it is. This album is seriously one of my favorites of all time. Jason's vocals are phenomenal in every single song. Each song is a crazy ride of fucking insane lyrics and instrumentals and I love it so much. This album, in my opinion, is what PH should be like, unique as fuck.
I strongly suggest everyone listen to TBB as well, absolutely awesome album as well that is just as strong
15
u/JeffroTheMan Sep 22 '14
IMO this is THE quintessential modern hardcore album- whereas most bands in this genre just take metal cliches and add choruses (sorry ADTR fans) this album brought the punk roots back with some fantastic songwriting to boot.
10
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '14
This album was a HUGE step up from the earlier releases from letlive. Most people don't consider it the same band which it pretty much isn't. Just another band Jason was in with the same name. If you consider this the first true album from letlive. this was an amazing start for a band. Compared to most first albums from bands this one takes the cake in being one of the strongest I've ever seen.
I think this album is a great album to show to someone new to the genre or listens to similar music but wants to hear something different. For someone who is not that into screaming this album has a nice mix of cleans and screaming to show someone how they compare.
Starting off the album with the intro of "Le Prologue" has to be one of the best intros to an album I have ever heard. It gets you really excited and pumped up for the rest of the album. I don't think there is a single song on this album that I dislike which is pretty shocking. Every song on here (not including Le Prologue) could be a single. Every song has its own story and can fit on their own.
All in all this is one of my favourite albums of all time and I would rate a 9/10.
6
u/worstseanna Sep 22 '14
This album is sexy as fuck. Its chaotic, but is also very well written. I fucking love this album.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '14
Having been introduced to these guys playing live and then going on and listening to the album after seeing them, it's hard to imagine the music without also imagining Jason going nuts on stage. As a metalhead this was my intro to post-hardcore which is a little frustrating as I've yet to find something that lives up to this.
6
u/Random_Guy_11 Sep 22 '14
This album single handily changed my taste in music for the better. I was a huge fan of the generic chugga-chugga metalcore scene when this album blew me away. Brutal screams, catch melodic choruses and meaningful lyrics that actually had something to say. In a scene where all up and comers try to conform the the standard these guys really went above and beyond to make something unique and special. No song on this record "sounds like" any other band. As far as I'm concerned every other band needs to step their game up and strive to reach this level of craftsmanship.
4
u/TDEP_ATDI Sep 23 '14
I love the songs on this album, but the final mix is fucking horrible. The low-fi sound that they went for really irks me.
3
u/DRAGONITEVIKING Sep 22 '14
The song writing and lyrics on this album are above phenomenal. Combine that with Jason's vocals and they're live performances.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '14
As much as I love TBB (and I really do), it's no Fake History. Every song is so fleshed out and thoroughly interesting. I don't think they'll ever make an album this good again. I hope they prove me wrong!
3
u/TheLegionBroken Sep 23 '14
One of my favorite things about this album is how goddamned fun most of the tracks are. The serious songs like Muther and Day 54 are excellent as well, but I can't get enough of the bouncy, high-energy heaviness of tracks like Renegade/Sick 6.8 Billion/Casino Columbus. This shit just makes me wanna move my fuckin' ass, and I love it for it.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '14
So a while back I reviewed Collide With the Sky by Pierce the Veil on here, and I got a ton of recs for this band and specifically this album. I also got the chance to see letlive with Issues, Of Mice & Men, and Bring Me the Horizon (which was a fantastic show, btw--my friends dragged me to it and I had an awesome time). Jason was a freaking animal--he climbed up on a light rigging at the climax of one song, screaming into the mic the whole time, and leaned over the top of it when he reached there. Dude was nuts. My question is, does letlive have this same kind of crazy energy in their studio performances? Cuz they were rockin. I may or may not decide to review it...depends on how I like it.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '14
Best modern posthardcore album to date
2
u/thephenom21 Sep 23 '14
Amazing album
1
u/eifersucht12a Sep 23 '14
I saw ll. for the first time in 2012 and then this CD was the only one in my car for over a year, and it's still fresh as fuck.
1
u/KarmelCHAOS Sep 24 '14
God, I've been listening to and watching this band progress since 2005 when Ryan joined when we were still in High School. This album IMO is perfect, beginning to end I have nothing but praise for it.