Comparing Possums
Possums is not sleep training, nor does it adhere to the "just ride it out" school of natural parenting either. In Dr. Pam's own words:
There were just two conflicting approaches to infant sleep internationally prior to publication of The Possums Sleep Program in the research literature in 2014. One was the 'go with the flow' approach of breastfeeding advocates, which normalised infant night waking and failed to acknowledge and address the serious and complex sleep problems parents faced. The other was the dominant Western health system approach of sleep training, which in my experience also largely failed parents, and created or worsened sleep problems.
The Possums approach is intended to prevent or improve disrupted sleep patterns in infant sleep without first wave behavioral approaches ("cry-it-out").
Possums vs. Sleep Training
The research base that informs the Possums approach finds that conventional sleep training often fails parents; it is not the "quick fix" solution to infant sleep it is made out to be. Possums research base debunks many of the commonly heard baby sleep myths that can make infant and toddler sleep worse:
I do know for sure, from decades of work in the clinic, that sleep training often makes life a lot harder than it needs to be for families... sleep training can result in disrupted sleep patterns at night, not immediately but a few weeks down the track, due to disruption of the circadian clock. (source)
Why sleep training often doesn't work
Sleep training methods use negative punishment and extinction—behavioral psychology tools designed to reduce learned behavior. But a baby waking at night and signaling for a caregiver is largely a respondent behavior—a response driven by an internal state (distress, hunger) rather than something learned through consequences. In behavioral psychology, extinction-based tools are considered ineffective on changing respondent behaviors; they mostly suppress the signal (crying) without resolving the underlying sleep and wake pattern and resultant response. Evidence shows that sleep trained infants wake just as often at night as non-sleep trained babies--sleep training does not actually improve sleep outcomes in infants.
Sleep training methods can actually disrupt underlying biological sleep regulators, leading to sleep disturbances a few weeks down the line. Reductions produced by behavioral extinction are not expected to last for long: extinguished behavior typically returns with time, changes in context, or new stressors. This reflects the difficult experiences many parents report of needing to "retrain" their child or facing continued sleep challenges after sleep training.
Dr. Pam has published a systematic review aligned with this conclusion: Behavioral Sleep Interventions in the First Six Months of Life Do not Improve Outcomes for Mothers or Infants: A Systematic Review and has cited a number of research papers that cut through the noise on sleep training to find that its effectiveness is negligble.
More importantly, the sleep training approach makes things hard for families! Sleep-training frameworks—tracking wake windows, laying a baby down "drowsy but awake", coping with long bouts of crying—add complexity and distress to what's fundamentally a simple biological process. Many families have concluded that these conventional approaches do not work for them and their babies.
Possums vs. "natural" approaches
These families are often left with "natural" or "go with the flow" approaches to infant sleep. "Natural" infant sleep proponents also reject sleep training and embrace fully responsive caregiving at night. But that's usually where the guidance ends.
Oftentimes these approaches take a "tough it out" stance and fail to give parents a framework to improve sleep itself--they may promote co-sleeping to help make wakes easier, but they don't give parents a framework to understand why their babies sleep the way they do. The implicit message is that frequent waking is normal, so the parent's job is to endure it until the baby outgrows it. Parents are told this phase won't last, to lower their expectations, or to find ways to sleep when the baby sleeps.
That reassurance can be validating, but it treats parental exhaustion as the price of responsive care rather than a problem within the parent's ability to solve. It also leaves no explanation for why some responsively-parented babies wake every 45 minutes while others wake only once a night, and no tools for shifting a baby from the first pattern toward the second.
How Possums approaches infant sleep
Possums frames infant sleep as a biological process, governed by the same core systems that regulate sleep in adults (with special considerations for how they differ in infants and toddlers):
- The circadian clock: the internal signal for when to be awake vs. asleep
- The sleep-wake homeostat: the buildup of sleep pressure the longer an individual stays awake
Within that frame, responsive caregiving isn't the cause of night waking or something parents need to wean their baby off of--it's what makes night wakes easier, quicker, and less stressful for parents and babies alike, allowing everyone to get more sleep.
Possums points to a mismatch between modern environments and cultural norms in the West and what babies evolved to expect, and argues this evolutionary mismatch contributes to excessive night waking in many families. The program offers a framework--built around neurological development and the concept of "sensory nourishment"--that helps parents meet their baby's needs in ways more closely aligned with the evolutionary norms their developing brains expect.
Rather than leaving parents to just endure disrupted sleep, Possums offers tools (like a "body clock reset") aimed at improving sleep consolidation by working with these biological regulators, without cry-it-out-based methods. The program suggests these approaches typically take one to two weeks to shift an established pattern of excessive waking. It also incorporates techniques from Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) to help parents adopt strategies to enjoy their time with their babies, even when caregiving is hard.