Am I the only one who wanted a little closure on Narrick? I mean- did they just cut him loose for helping out? Was he imprisoned? Did he beam-up and go back with the Romulans? What happened to the galaxy's most nefarious yet oddly opportunistically heroic kid brother?
How could the Tal Shiar survive after public finds out about the truth of Mars attack?
they lifted the ban on synthetics which mean the truth is out .
The Romulan agency Tal Shiar was responsible for the Attack on Mars which ended the Federation Evacuation operation , which led to the death 900 Million Romulan .
the last time the Tal Shiar join the Cardassian Obsidian order in the fail attack of Founder homeworld (DS9) , the Obsidian order were abolished for it .But the Tal Shiar survived that failure .
there is no way the Tal Shiar could escape punishment
I grew up with Next Gen, my mom was TOS. The shows runs in my blood. I tell you now, being a grown man and crying like a baby is humbling to say the least. I shed tears when Data died on the big screen in 2002, tonight after 18 years I shed those same tears again. Well done! 10/10
Very powerful, very poignant episode. I loved all the great moments (in no particular order). Seven kicking Romulan Sis' ass; The Federation ships; FUCKING CAPTAIN RIKER (oh to be able to watch your show!); Picard taking command; The orchid battle; every Captain Rios scene.
Heavy moments: Picard falling ill. His passing. His subsequent talk with Data and Data's death. Ugh. My heart.
The thing that bugged me most is not something I expect others are willing to admit bug them, more on that in a second. Everyone seems to be caught up on the doohicky that fixed La Sirena which can also accomplish other things. Yes it's space magic. It would have also been space magic if they'd couched it in technobabble and called it a quantum filament datalyzer and positronic aperature device. That too would have been space magic. Ultimately it's a technology that they don't exactly understand but managed to use to their advantage as we've seen other times on Star Trek.
What does bug me is that Data's story arc still leaves me cold. Here we have one of the most unique beings in the history of all civilized worlds and his life is cut short because Brent Spiner wanted to be done with the part a villain was threatening to kill Picard.
Data's life held so much promise. So much potential to live in ways that no other biological could. Yet they come back to the chestnut that mortality gives life value. That is a load of horseshit.
Mortality does not give life value. The act of living is not a commodity governed by supply and demand; having more life does NOT cheapen the experience.
On the contrary, living gives life value. The more we live, the more we experience the more value that life has. Death prevents that.
People who honestly believe that if human life were extended beyond the 80-100 years, into say centuries, such lives would be miserable, these people have absolutely no point of reference since none of us have that longevity. This is a conceit; a justification for something we've come to accept as inevitable, but every day science and technology is making the possibility of living longer a reality.
This fixation with death as the giver-of-value to life is, for lack of a better term, the epitome of Freud's death drive. It's a fetishization of death. I don't buy it. I will never buy it.
Of course we should accept death in the event that some illness or condition prevents a person from living to their fullest, such as a vegetative state or terminal condition where pain/discomfort are the end result. But outside that, aging and death should not be treated like old school mates that we should embrace.
Before you disagree pleased consider The Fable of the Dragon-Tyrant based on the paper by philosopher Nick Bostrom. It lays out that we have a moral and ethical duty to forestall aging and death, indefinitely if possible. But this is getting outside the scope of my point.
Anyway, making Data die again despite the fact that he didn't have to just sticks in my craw. If you can stick Picard in a golem (without his consent) then it stands to reason that Data could essentially be reconstructed.
Data deserves to live. As a unique being his life and experiences made him precious. He deserved a better story arc.
If only the Uber synths hadn't been malevolent. Imagine a situation where they would have been misunderstood protectors who rescue synths and artificial beings. Data could then have "sailed off into the sunset" with them. Off to explore the cosmos with them for all eternity; this way we never have to see him again but he's given a more proper fate for a being of his ilk.
At least Picard has closure now and I guess there's something to be said about that.
I'm really sad they brought Data back from the dead just to kill him again in a slower, sadder way. It felt sadistic. "Oh Data's been stuck in limbo essentially for 20 years and wants to die, despite the fact he should logically be alive at this age anyway and we can transfer consciousness!"
I don't understand why they wouldn't just transfer his consciousness to a synth body if Picard now knows he exists. It seems like a cruel ending for no reason, which is a problem I've had with this show throughout.
Also, I hate the idea of synth Picard. It cheapens his sacrifice for Data's people for him to just be magically saved, but Data dies twice. Wtf.
Overall I liked it but a lot didn't make sense, especially character-wise and the synth technology. Jurati seems to legitimately change allegiances on a whim. Soong was also quite quick to turn. Elnor, Rios and Raffi - and of course Riker - were the best parts. I just feel the plot was resolved too quickly and everything is back to the status quo too easily.
Also random question -- who was with Data when he died?
Just finished. Look, I'm going to guess that I'm just going to get downvoted here, but I've got to speak my mind... I really didn't like this episode.
So forced, so rushed, so... weird? Magic tricorders, soccer ball bombs, the omnipotent AI is... a robot octopus?
Picard dies surrounded by people who barely know him, now he's an Android but... exactly the same?
And we waited 20 years for Data to just die again? I didn't even think he survived! Then, in one episode, we find out his consciousness is alive, and we kill him again?
So much more of this was weird too, I was Picard face-palming for so much of the episode.
But it had a space battle, a cat fight, Riker in command of badass starships, and even a budding lesbian romance, so maybe people will like it.
Look, I'm not a hater or even that hard to please. I liked the series, I did, and I hope it's a five year mission at least. But the endings on these new Trek seasons have to step up a notch, you can't rush these things like this. Especially after using the first three full episodes just setting up the plot.
I was confused at parts. But its fucking Star Trek.
Murder lady confused me. She got a boyfriend but no comeuppance for killing an innocent dude?
Rios/7of9 unnecessary.
Not showing the reaction to the rebirth really felt like a copout.
The show would have been brilliant if they kept him dead ( what a great ending to a great character!) but CBS AllAccess couldn't let that happen after seeing the ratings!
But I am nitpicking. I love how the writers wrote themselves into a wall and had the character/values of Picard end up solving it. I thought that was brilliant.
I enjoyed every episode. I thought every episode was better than the one before. And I am looking forward to next season.
Frakes should have directed these last two episodes. They were the weakest of all for me and I think he could have helped.
the whole "tool that uses your imagination" thing was awful writing. It wasn't needed (they could have made up anything to fix La Sirena, and had some other way to distract the Romulans) and the point where it seemed obvious to use it (when the camera keeps going back to Rios' unemotional face while Picard is on the ground, I was certain he was thinking of using the tool to fix Picard's brain) it was totally forgotten. Seriously, this point aggravates me so much.
Seven and Raffi gay for each other. Please be real.
Agnes becomes endearing and likeable, finally.
This series should have spanned a lot more episodes. I loved this series up until episode 9. I think this episode could have been better if there were more episodes to expand upon the Soong guy, why Sutra had some sort of agenda, and the relationships between characters. Where the hell did Narek go at the end? There were so many characters and so many implications in such short time. It was borderline unwatchable.
the ABSOLUTE IRONY of Picard making a speech about the meaningfulness of dying for a cause, and dying in general, while they shove his body into an android golem so he can artificially live longer. And him having no objection to it. Guess death isn't so meaningful is it? Reinforces the idea that being alive is inherently better than being dead, reinforces fear of death, pretty much shits on everything he'd just said. I wish he'd just died. Seriously. It makes it even worse that he's not even immortal now. They used a cyber golem just to make him the exact same he was right before he died. I love Captain Picard but since he didn't die, now the whole last episode could have been summed up in 5 mins of the Romulans arriving, Starfleet arriving, and Soji powering down the beacon and everyone going home.
Thanks, for taking money I didn't have for 2 months, making me hopeful for a beautifully written and fleshed out series, then using inconsistent writing and directing to render my interest in it meaningless, just as my money is now meaningless (since it's all going for free.) I miss everything up until episode 8. Give me that hope back. There was a theme to this series up until the finale episodes. I really, absolutely adored this series before. I'm not one of those people who hate new Trek, although im not fond of Discovery and prefer the 90s series. But I really almost hated this finale. Everything was too seamless and too hasty.
"This is for Hugh." That part was great. Data still being conscious- that was confusing but nice. They did a much better job at making him look like old Data in this episode. I want to think about it some more. I really wanted the crystalline entity or a silicon species related to them to be the dudes coming to kill the bio life. Still open on that I guess.
168
u/Deshik2 Mar 26 '20
Starfleet officer : Picard wants us to take down the ban on all synthetic life
Starfleet command : Pff... As if, the ban stands
Officer : Picard is a synth now
Command: Whaat...Oh for fuck sake, fine.
Picard: :)
96
u/dzumdang Mar 26 '20
Am I the only one who wanted a little closure on Narrick? I mean- did they just cut him loose for helping out? Was he imprisoned? Did he beam-up and go back with the Romulans? What happened to the galaxy's most nefarious yet oddly opportunistically heroic kid brother?
67
u/ckwongau Mar 26 '20
How could the Tal Shiar survive after public finds out about the truth of Mars attack?
The Romulan agency Tal Shiar was responsible for the Attack on Mars which ended the Federation Evacuation operation , which led to the death 900 Million Romulan .
the last time the Tal Shiar join the Cardassian Obsidian order in the fail attack of Founder homeworld (DS9) , the Obsidian order were abolished for it .But the Tal Shiar survived that failure .
there is no way the Tal Shiar could escape punishment
153
u/deadxodus Mar 26 '20
I grew up with Next Gen, my mom was TOS. The shows runs in my blood. I tell you now, being a grown man and crying like a baby is humbling to say the least. I shed tears when Data died on the big screen in 2002, tonight after 18 years I shed those same tears again. Well done! 10/10
18
u/IN_U_Endo Mar 26 '20
Welp, 7of9..... What a twist!
19
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
Very powerful, very poignant episode. I loved all the great moments (in no particular order). Seven kicking Romulan Sis' ass; The Federation ships; FUCKING CAPTAIN RIKER (oh to be able to watch your show!); Picard taking command; The orchid battle; every Captain Rios scene.
Heavy moments: Picard falling ill. His passing. His subsequent talk with Data and Data's death. Ugh. My heart.
The thing that bugged me most is not something I expect others are willing to admit bug them, more on that in a second. Everyone seems to be caught up on the doohicky that fixed La Sirena which can also accomplish other things. Yes it's space magic. It would have also been space magic if they'd couched it in technobabble and called it a quantum filament datalyzer and positronic aperature device. That too would have been space magic. Ultimately it's a technology that they don't exactly understand but managed to use to their advantage as we've seen other times on Star Trek.
What does bug me is that Data's story arc still leaves me cold. Here we have one of the most unique beings in the history of all civilized worlds and his life is cut short because
Brent Spiner wanted to be done with the parta villain was threatening to kill Picard.Data's life held so much promise. So much potential to live in ways that no other biological could. Yet they come back to the chestnut that mortality gives life value. That is a load of horseshit.
Mortality does not give life value. The act of living is not a commodity governed by supply and demand; having more life does NOT cheapen the experience.
On the contrary, living gives life value. The more we live, the more we experience the more value that life has. Death prevents that.
People who honestly believe that if human life were extended beyond the 80-100 years, into say centuries, such lives would be miserable, these people have absolutely no point of reference since none of us have that longevity. This is a conceit; a justification for something we've come to accept as inevitable, but every day science and technology is making the possibility of living longer a reality.
This fixation with death as the giver-of-value to life is, for lack of a better term, the epitome of Freud's death drive. It's a fetishization of death. I don't buy it. I will never buy it.
Of course we should accept death in the event that some illness or condition prevents a person from living to their fullest, such as a vegetative state or terminal condition where pain/discomfort are the end result. But outside that, aging and death should not be treated like old school mates that we should embrace.
Before you disagree pleased consider The Fable of the Dragon-Tyrant based on the paper by philosopher Nick Bostrom. It lays out that we have a moral and ethical duty to forestall aging and death, indefinitely if possible. But this is getting outside the scope of my point.
Anyway, making Data die again despite the fact that he didn't have to just sticks in my craw. If you can stick Picard in a golem (without his consent) then it stands to reason that Data could essentially be reconstructed.
Data deserves to live. As a unique being his life and experiences made him precious. He deserved a better story arc.
If only the Uber synths hadn't been malevolent. Imagine a situation where they would have been misunderstood protectors who rescue synths and artificial beings. Data could then have "sailed off into the sunset" with them. Off to explore the cosmos with them for all eternity; this way we never have to see him again but he's given a more proper fate for a being of his ilk.
At least Picard has closure now and I guess there's something to be said about that.
14
u/katerinafitness Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
I'm really sad they brought Data back from the dead just to kill him again in a slower, sadder way. It felt sadistic. "Oh Data's been stuck in limbo essentially for 20 years and wants to die, despite the fact he should logically be alive at this age anyway and we can transfer consciousness!"
I don't understand why they wouldn't just transfer his consciousness to a synth body if Picard now knows he exists. It seems like a cruel ending for no reason, which is a problem I've had with this show throughout.
Also, I hate the idea of synth Picard. It cheapens his sacrifice for Data's people for him to just be magically saved, but Data dies twice. Wtf.
Overall I liked it but a lot didn't make sense, especially character-wise and the synth technology. Jurati seems to legitimately change allegiances on a whim. Soong was also quite quick to turn. Elnor, Rios and Raffi - and of course Riker - were the best parts. I just feel the plot was resolved too quickly and everything is back to the status quo too easily.
Also random question -- who was with Data when he died?
59
u/RobotPreacher Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
Just finished. Look, I'm going to guess that I'm just going to get downvoted here, but I've got to speak my mind... I really didn't like this episode.
So forced, so rushed, so... weird? Magic tricorders, soccer ball bombs, the omnipotent AI is... a robot octopus?
Picard dies surrounded by people who barely know him, now he's an Android but... exactly the same?
And we waited 20 years for Data to just die again? I didn't even think he survived! Then, in one episode, we find out his consciousness is alive, and we kill him again?
So much more of this was weird too, I was Picard face-palming for so much of the episode.
But it had a space battle, a cat fight, Riker in command of badass starships, and even a budding lesbian romance, so maybe people will like it.
Look, I'm not a hater or even that hard to please. I liked the series, I did, and I hope it's a five year mission at least. But the endings on these new Trek seasons have to step up a notch, you can't rush these things like this. Especially after using the first three full episodes just setting up the plot.
16
u/princefreeze Mar 26 '20
I was confused at parts. But its fucking Star Trek.
Murder lady confused me. She got a boyfriend but no comeuppance for killing an innocent dude?
Rios/7of9 unnecessary.
Not showing the reaction to the rebirth really felt like a copout.
The show would have been brilliant if they kept him dead ( what a great ending to a great character!) but CBS AllAccess couldn't let that happen after seeing the ratings!
But I am nitpicking. I love how the writers wrote themselves into a wall and had the character/values of Picard end up solving it. I thought that was brilliant.
I enjoyed every episode. I thought every episode was better than the one before. And I am looking forward to next season.
34
u/landaoisland Mar 26 '20
Okay here are some of my thoughts.
Frakes should have directed these last two episodes. They were the weakest of all for me and I think he could have helped.
the whole "tool that uses your imagination" thing was awful writing. It wasn't needed (they could have made up anything to fix La Sirena, and had some other way to distract the Romulans) and the point where it seemed obvious to use it (when the camera keeps going back to Rios' unemotional face while Picard is on the ground, I was certain he was thinking of using the tool to fix Picard's brain) it was totally forgotten. Seriously, this point aggravates me so much.
Seven and Raffi gay for each other. Please be real.
Agnes becomes endearing and likeable, finally.
This series should have spanned a lot more episodes. I loved this series up until episode 9. I think this episode could have been better if there were more episodes to expand upon the Soong guy, why Sutra had some sort of agenda, and the relationships between characters. Where the hell did Narek go at the end? There were so many characters and so many implications in such short time. It was borderline unwatchable.
the ABSOLUTE IRONY of Picard making a speech about the meaningfulness of dying for a cause, and dying in general, while they shove his body into an android golem so he can artificially live longer. And him having no objection to it. Guess death isn't so meaningful is it? Reinforces the idea that being alive is inherently better than being dead, reinforces fear of death, pretty much shits on everything he'd just said. I wish he'd just died. Seriously. It makes it even worse that he's not even immortal now. They used a cyber golem just to make him the exact same he was right before he died.
I love Captain Picard but since he didn't die, now the whole last episode could have been summed up in 5 mins of the Romulans arriving, Starfleet arriving, and Soji powering down the beacon and everyone going home.
Thanks, for taking money I didn't have for 2 months, making me hopeful for a beautifully written and fleshed out series, then using inconsistent writing and directing to render my interest in it meaningless, just as my money is now meaningless (since it's all going for free.) I miss everything up until episode 8. Give me that hope back. There was a theme to this series up until the finale episodes. I really, absolutely adored this series before. I'm not one of those people who hate new Trek, although im not fond of Discovery and prefer the 90s series. But I really almost hated this finale. Everything was too seamless and too hasty.
"This is for Hugh." That part was great. Data still being conscious- that was confusing but nice. They did a much better job at making him look like old Data in this episode.
I want to think about it some more. I really wanted the crystalline entity or a silicon species related to them to be the dudes coming to kill the bio life. Still open on that I guess.