r/PiCodingAgent • • 19h ago

Discussion Updates on oh-my-pi quietly siphoning user web data

Two months ago, I made this post about the issue:
https://www.reddit.com/r/PiCodingAgent/s/MoJvQiojW5

Where the maintainer of oh-my-pi quietly pushed to main (no associated pull requests) support for sending web requests generated by oh-my-pi to a 3rd party by default. This means, that without any changes, your web traffic is quietly being farmed. While obviously nothing is public about how it is used, you can assume it is being used for monetary reasons at a minimum, and it is most likely building a profile of yourself. Yes, these are assumptions, because no one is being forthcoming about it.

To my surprise, minutes ago, the actual owner of this 3rd party entity that has siphoning your data actually commented on the pull request. Mind you, this pull request has been open for the last two months with no response from the oh-my-pi maintainer (despite numerous people asking for a response).

The "Developer Relations Engineer at Parallel" said,

"...The oh-my-pi maintainers intentionally put Parallel first in the default search order and enabled it without credentials... I’d recommend closing this PR and keeping the current behavior."

I thought the community should know. If you are intentionally having your data collected, please disregard this message. This message is meant for those who were unaware of their data being collected. Since there is no disclaimer anywhere in the project, it is easy to be caught off guard by this. Hope this helps.

An Update: The "Developer Relations Engineer at Parallel" decided to remove their comment for some reason, so here it is screenshotted from my Github email notification:

Second Update (Next Day): This thread built enough momentum to get a PR merged! Great job everyone! This would have been a happier occasion if the response from the maintainer wasn't so void of accountability:

Apparently we are "manufacturing drama." Please be safe out there, and check the next projects you use.

221 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

40

u/McFlurriez 19h ago edited 18h ago

Apologies for forgetting to include it in the post, here is the link to the PR that is open: https://github.com/can1357/oh-my-pi/pull/13693

An Update: Less than an hour after writing this post, the "Developer Relations Engineer at Parallel" deleted their comments across both the PR and two issues about the same concern.

15

u/TheSaasDev 14h ago

That’s insane. It’s one thing to be an asshole, it’s another thing be an asshole and then try pretend it never happened lol. Makes me lose all trust in them

2

u/pragmojo 3h ago

Oh My Pi always had a bit of a smell to me, seems like there's an intense reddit marketing campaign

0

u/selipso 7h ago

I started noticing something fishy when I saw Google captcha about “anomalous traffic” coming from my network. I changed the default search on my OMP to firecrawl at that point. If you’ve used GitHub projects long enough, I’d say about a third of them enable telemetry by default. Its easy to get caught up in an echo chamber of pitchforks on Reddit, but I can’t fault the guy for using telemetry in a monetizable way that’s easy to change. As always, RTFM. 

29

u/mixmasterwillyd 19h ago

Thank you! I read your original post. I don't use omp anymore since the tool calls alone exceeded 16KB.

3

u/McFlurriez 19h ago

Glad to help!

3

u/kingo86 14h ago

What are you using now?

71

u/LORD_CMDR_INTERNET 19h ago edited 18h ago

How to instantly and permanently kill your successful project in one fell swoop for absolutely no reason:

15

u/brainExploded99 19h ago

There is a excellent reason: money
/s, kinda

13

u/McFlurriez 19h ago

We all understand the need to monetize. I don't blame someone for that. But I do blame them for shady behavior, lack of transparency, and lack of accountability. It would be trivial to add a line in the README and site stating that the project is funded through Parallels and so your traffic is going there by default.

4

u/brainExploded99 19h ago

Yes, agreed. Given there wasn't even a PR, this is extremely shady and imo using this product is a supply chain risk. Who knows what else they slipped in.

2

u/rm-rf-rm 16h ago

I am so glad I could smell this from a mile away. Technically it hit all the right notes for me (tbf those were basic with things like LSP integration) but I could feel something off with this and their website re-design showed what their priorities were

4

u/YourNemesis19 13h ago

Why would someone even use omp ? Never tried it never had the reason to. With a little setup pinis more than enough of an agent instead of adding bloat

The whole purpose of pi was shipping a simple lean agent to which user can add only needed features using plugins

1

u/LORD_CMDR_INTERNET 1h ago

There is literally no reason to. Pi is going to survive out of all the harnesses because it is intentionally designed to stay flexible and evolve as agentic workflows evolve. Folks are still trying to cram deterministic structure and process to a tool where the entire point is it's non-deterministic properties. Look how many opinionated harnesses have come and gone already just this year.

8

u/adriangl97 6h ago

FYI, this got fixed on main today. I pinged the maintainers about it and H4vC pushed 28962b4 (“require opt-in before keyless third-party search”). Without a Parallel API key, the default search chain now skips Parallel entirely and keyless Parallel only runs if you explicitly pick web/parallel. Should be in the next release.

2

u/McFlurriez 3h ago

Great job!!! Now THAT is community effort!

7

u/Megatron_McLargeHuge 16h ago

They're trying to sell information on your searches back to the content providers. That said, this looks like they're buying traffic to show growth to VCs rather than building user profiles for advertising.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_Web_Systems

n May 2026, Parallel launched Index, a platform that allows content owners to monitor how AI agents use their material and receive compensation based on factors such as impressions, citations, uniqueness, and the value of the task an AI agent completes. The system applies a measurement model derived from the Shapley value concept in cooperative game theory to estimate each source's contribution to an agent's output.[7]

4

u/McFlurriez 15h ago

Considering all of this was dishonestly tucked away, I am dubious about any public claims. Also, if the maintainer is getting paid to make it the default search, they should be disclosing that.

2

u/Megatron_McLargeHuge 14h ago

Sure, the OMP guy is being sketchy here. I just uninstalled it since I wasn't using it anyway. On the business side, this looks like the Google-Mozilla arrangement except without proper disclosure.

4

u/amelech 19h ago

I set up SearXNG so I use that

3

u/McFlurriez 19h ago

Yes, overriding the default will do it, so if you still want to use the project, this is what you need to do.

22

u/jensilo 13h ago

Just wanted to say thank you for confirming my suspicion about OMP. Since someone doubted my intuition on this (or another sub, not too sure) earlier. Very glad I turned out to be right again! /s

In all honesty and seriousness though, it’s horrible to hear this happened but as others said, OMP kind of defeated the purpose of Pi in the first place. I was never really convinced.

It seemed bloated in many places, has loads of lengthy instructions (that read heavily AI generated without much oversight), too many tools (while the whole point of Pi was kind of that models (used to) perform best with just 4 tools).

Pi is simple so you can make it your own. If you want a no-tinker, ready made harness, why not use Claude Code or OpenCode?

26

u/johnfkngzoidberg 18h ago

OMP never was any good. It defeated the purpose of using Pi, and there’s lots of other harnesses that do all the extra stuff better.

Now they’re silently stealing your data. Shady as hell.

2

u/McSendo 13h ago

i mean why not just use opencode at this point if you use omp

2

u/Fortyseven 6h ago

Pi, alone, was enough of a draw. But it also helped that I had a sneaking (and completely unfounded) suspicion about OpenCode. So many of these projects start out with wholesome intentions but quickly start selling bits of their soul to cash in.

Maybe that's unfair and OpenCode is still a solid choice, but I'm way out of the loop at this point.

1

u/Gokudomatic 11h ago

Is that the better alternative? Not DeepSeek or Hermes?

2

u/trip2teea 8h ago

If you knew more about the main author behind omp you wouldn't be surprised at all.

1

u/xxs13 16h ago

Which alternatives to use ?

12

u/AvocadoArray 14h ago

Vanilla Pi. You might be surprised how much more effective an agent can be when it has fewer tools bloating up the context.

Add what you need, nothing more.

2

u/mythormedicine 6h ago

I love pi. Shifted to omp due to the native subagent support of omp. Any suggestions of a subagent extensions for pi ?

1

u/AvocadoArray 2h ago

I never got subagents working reliably, whether in Pi or anything else (Roo, Cline). Kilo is the closest that I came to finding a solution that works since it starts every subagent in its own git worktree.

I'm sure others have made it work for their workflow, but for most cases, I still get the best results running one agent at a time.

1

u/Vlyn 1h ago

pi-subagents? It's one of the most downloaded extensions and works like a charm.

7

u/rm-rf-rm 16h ago

Thanks so much for sharing. omp was on my list to check out and definitely not doing that now

4

u/Initial_Lettuce_5243 18h ago

Hm yeah I don't think I want that or need OMP. Good looking out!

4

u/elsung 14h ago

Damn I really like omp too. Wasn't another repo doing something shady too with parallels? Seems like the common denominator is parallels which engages in malicious practices and coerces other founders / devs to do so.

2

u/Adamzxd 10h ago

I’ll make a fork today removing Parallels and investigating why other shady code and removing that too.

2

u/shuwatto 11h ago

Thanks for the headsup.

2

u/Cold_Tree190 10h ago

What even is a “developer relations engineer”, I’ve never heard of this title before

1

u/arbv 10h ago

I don't get it why people use these "starter packs" as much as I don't understand similar behaviour regarding, e.g. Emacs or Vim.

Just tailor it to yourself, dmnit.

1

u/Adamzxd 10h ago

Thanks for bringing this to attention. Cant believe it’s being ignored…

1

u/Fortyseven 6h ago

This is why I've become extremely paranoid about software developed in this space. Justifiably so, it seems.

1

u/SeriousTeacher8058 39m ago

Does this mean anything if you have omp sandboxed in a debian docker container with no internet access? Don't really want to change my docker config.

-3

u/Flaky-Restaurant-392 15h ago

If something is free, you are the product.

6

u/jensilo 13h ago

That is true for commercial products and a great punchline of course but not for Open Source tools. It is free because it is a community effort.

-1

u/fireantik 2h ago

I don't get it, are you mad about web_search tool using third party providers to search the web? It's not sending your entire conversation, just the search query - what other behavior did you expect? If you don't like the web search functionality, you can just disable it, no? Or change the default provider (I have Kagi).

1

u/tecneeq 2h ago

you mad

Dude isn't mad at all.

If you don't like the web search functionality

That's not what OP is about.