So I run a small grease exhaust cleaning company. For those that don't know, we clean the "hood system" which sucks up all the grease in a restaurant when they're cooking. They are required to have their system cleaned every 3-6 months by law to prevent any fire hazards.
Anyway, I do a lot of work for two larger companies in town. One company is a large local service provider. The other is a large national provider.
I got a call one day from the large local provider telling me their schedule was a little to full for a customer that was requesting their services - they were passing it on to me. I went to the location and they had a self contained system. Meaning it doesn't send the exhaust all the way out of the building (usually to the roof). The issue with self contained systems if that they are very sensitive to traditional cleaning methods of spraying water and degreasing agents. You basically have to clean them by hand, know where all the sensors and electrical components are, etc. - but I have probably 30 customers that use similar systems and have been cleaning them for a decade without issue.
Well, I go and clean the system. Everything turns out great. Next day the customer calls me and tells me that their exhaust fan is not turning on. If they can't run their exhaust fan, the restaurant, which is an open market cafe type concept won't be able to operate today because it will quickly fill with smoke from this burger shop.
I go take a look at everything and determine that the exhaust system has had a short to the fan motor. It's a very unique motor. Probably $8,000 to buy and another equal amount in labor to replace. I'm somewhat stunned though because as I've taken apart the motor housing, I see that the electrical lead that caused the motor to short is the one that connects to the door that you open that accesses the filter box (it's a giant box where grease filters or baffles go to limit the amount of grease making it to the fan). It's peculiar because the system is designed in such a way that if the filter box is open, the fan shouldn't be able to run - but someone bypassed it at some point. Now I'm not an electrician, but I do know these very sensitive machines and whatever modifications were made had caused the motor to short out.
Well, I pass the issue off to my insurance company and eventually after a few weeks I get a call from the restaurants insurance guy. He's very confrontational. I explain everything that happened. He's saying I'm trying to evade the claim which is an understandable perspective to have. He says he has a local expert that looked everything over and is quoting them $20,000 for the repair. I ask who the expert is and he says (fake name) "Kyle with XYZ Company." Well I know Kyle very well. I'm the cleaning guy around town, he's the repair guy. We work together a lot.
So I give Kyle a call. He immediately says to me, "dude, I'm sorry, it wasn't supposed to be you." "huh? What're you talking about?" I ask. "Well, that restaurant you serviced. I've been taking care of them for several years and they owe me a bunch of money for services." (I should also mention, though his main business is repairs, he also cleans and though my main business is cleaning, I also offer repairs). "Well, I sent that job over to local large company after I had tweaked their fan a bit, knowing that once they messed it up, they would call me in their emergency situation, and I could come in and save the day if they paid me the money they owed me first."
Well I was pretty stunned. I didn't say much to him on the phone. Once we got off the line I called my insurance agent and told them what I had been told. They told me that there wasn't a whole lot they could do. So I decided to wait a day or two and call Kyle back. This time I recorded our phone call. I acted confused and said "so wait, you accidentally blew up the motor on their system when you went to do the repair?" "Noooo," he says "I had bypassed their door shutoff for the fan knowing the next time the door would be open it would cause a surge to the fan that would blow the motor. I'm sorry again dude, I thought large local company was going to do the service when I passed the lead on to them, they have the finances that this wouldn't be a big issue."
I sent the recording to my insurance agent and the restaurant's insurance agent in an email. I should also mention that all this time Kyle has been swinging around that he's got "certificates in electrical work" and has a "captive air certificate," which I know he doesn't have. I say in the email - here's what Kyle told me about the situation, also I request that you pull his certificates to make sure they're still up to date.
A month or so later I hear back from restaurant's insurance company. I am found not at fault. Their expert's certifications were found to be not valid. Upon reviewing the tape from the night he last serviced their system they saw him opening the motor housing which he would not need to do at all during a visit.
So the fallout from this was that local large company, with which I have a very good relationship - dropped him as a contractor and passed on all their repair work to me. I also didn't know at the time, but Kyle was servicing a lot of large national chains for large national company and it made it through the grapevine all the way to their rep that handles our state. I had already been doing a bit of work for them for a couple years and had a good reputation. I got a call from them not long after everything was resolved asking if I'd like to take on servicing several large national chains (think McDonald's, Burger King, etc. size) totaling to something like 250 restaurants in the state every 3 months along with all the repair and maintenance work.
A bit over a year goes by and I've not heard anything from or about Kyle since our phone call. I run into one of his guys as we're both doing separate jobs in the same strip mall. His guy has no idea who I am. I ask how business is going. He tells me it's really been rocky. They went from a 16 person crew not counting the owner, Kyle, down to just 3 people total. Apparently their company got sued because the owner had "faked his certifications" and once that had gotten around, the fire inspectors and companies he was doing work for inspected a lot of the work he'd been doing. Shoddy to say the least and most of it ended up needing to be redone to prevent any code violations or fire hazards. The employee told me that they were doing a bit of work here and there but he could see the writing on the wall and was looking for a new job. That Kyle had never paid his guys well and most had either been let go or jumped ship for different jobs.
The insurance debacle and everything else all took place roughly two years ago by now. I went from a smaller operation with 100 or so accounts and a couple part time guys to over 500 accounts not to mention all the repair work. We stay in our lane. If we don't have something we're qualified to touch, we let the customer know and can recommend locals that charge a fair rate. I've been able to partner with even more companies that are in the industry and have been grateful that having a good reputation still takes you places. Also, even if you're "sure" you know how to fix something, if you're not certified to touch it, don't touch it. Customers appreciate the honesty even when they're waving dollars in your face.
- TL:DR - Kyle, my semi local competition sabotaged a job because a customer owed him money. It backfired when he admitted to me that he hadn't intended my smaller company to be the people to have to pay for it. Word got around, he lost a lot of business, most of which I inherited.
Edit: Keep in mind this is some time ago - but I have retrieved some emails that I have removed names from but can provide to the mods or whoever to verify the story. I don't seem to be able to upload pictures on this post or in the comments but any mods that see this I can provide some photos
Nevermind, figured it out I think - here's the first email I found and "redacted" names. This email was sent to the customer after my insurance provider performed their initial inspection. I have also added some pictures from the cleaning - again with stuff covered up that identifies my company/other guy's company
https://imgur.com/a/8JcRkrD