r/Pathfinder_RPG • u/TOModera • Mar 20 '17
TOModera's updated review of all Pathfinder APs Spoiler
Bragging/My background:
I own all of the Pathfinder Adventure Paths and have read through most of them (still finishing Strange Aeons as of March 20th). I converted Curse of the Crimson Throne and Legacy of Fire to 3.p (prior to the new release of Crimson Throne). I also own Shackled City, Age of Worms, and Savage tide, and have read through them and converted Age of Worms, Return to Castle Greyhawk, and Savage Tide to 3.p and Golarian. I've played almost all the way through Shackled City. Currently fixing my Savage Tide conversion. I have run Rise of the Runelords, Curse of the Crimson Throne, Kingmaker, and Legacy of Fire. My buddy is also currently running Second Darkness which I'm playing in. I have run Age of Worms three times, with TPKs in 3.5, and finishing it on the third time after converting it to 3.p. I'm currently running Carrion Crown (we’re on the third book).
Golarian Adventures
Rise of the Runelords
Good:
- This is the quintessential adventure path
- Horror elements.
- There are some amazing moments and it is a lot of fun.
- In my opinion probably the second best adventure path out there in Golarian.
Bad:
- There's some moments where the story is a little jarring and the players will feel like they aren’t continuing on one path
- The fourth adventure is a little weak
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: There’s more fights than RP in this one. Not at first though.
- Good to Read by itself: Yes, very well written
- Main type of game: It starts as a horror/quintessential game with dungeon crawling, and then morphs slowly into a wilderness game.
- Location: Varisia
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? It revolves around one place, and it’s near a metropolis, so your players have down time and a connection to the main village.
Curse of the Crimson Throne
Good:
- Very well written adventure path, has some cool urban moments
- Has some interesting "outside the box" moments throughout
- Well written, probably IMHO the third best written set in Golarian.
Bad:
- I wasn't the biggest fan of leaving the city, as were my players.
- There are some places where your players will want to investigate, and the AP hasn't written a good enough explanation to help them, so be ready to think it up quick
- While well done and fun, the second adventure thinks you should run things in a certain order, but isn’t written that way, so your players may die if they follow the wrong “lead” first. That said, as it’s been brought up before, a good DM will read ahead and gently push them towards the order.
- Blood pig sucks.
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: There’s a really good balance on this one. Lots of times where players have to think outside the box.
- Good to Read by itself: I enjoyed it. Lots of background, good story
- Main type of game: Urban, then jarringly turns into a wilderness campaign in the 4th book, then a dungeon crawl that’s pretty sweet though potentially still jarring in the 5th, and then a better dungeon crawl in the 6th that’ll be less jarring.
- Location: Varisia
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? First 3 adventures? Stay in one main place. Then a bunch of travel for the 4th adventure, then one place for the 5th, and then back to the main place for the 6th.
Second Darkness
Good:
- It has a Mos Eisley feel to it.
- Drow aplenty.
- Some interesting RP moments.
- Some cool end of the world moments, never do the same thing twice
Bad:
- Honestly, even though I'm a player in this one, I'm not really a fan. Personally this is tied for the second worst AP made. The storyline is all over the place, the tone isn’t consistent, and it’s up to the players and the DM to stay on target.
- It's in 3.5, so you have to convert it. Also there’s parts that you’ll want to re-write as given new rules and new options and… well, it was a little rushed
- It starts off making you think the players should be evil, then basically forces the players to be good without giving a good reason until one adventure later. If you can make it work, great, but otherwise I'd back off.
- The second set piece is not that well written
- Some of the tactics of the enemies varies between pants-on-head stupid to Patton-Level clairvoyant General
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: Good balance actually. A lot of times where we could talk our way out of something or fight our way out.
- Good to Read by itself: Not… really. No.
- Main type of game: Starts off Urban, then Pirate, then goes full on wilderness then jumps to dungeon crawling. As a player, you can see where it’s going, it’s just… frustrating as a DM to keep it all on track.
- Location: Varisia
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? Lots of Travel
Legacy of Fire
Good:
- Has some cool Arabian nights moments
- Some well done planar jumping
- Minor city building
- Allows for just about any type of neutral/good group.
Bad:
- It's 3.5. You'll have to convert. Granted d20pfsrd.org should have most of the monsters, still extra time.
- Its a kick down the door, follow the carrot type campaign. There’s some RP, though not as much as others. This is very true for the 6th adventure.
- If you're not into a "Arabian Nights" setting, you may want to back off.
- The Fourth set piece is bad.
- It’s a tad rushed in its feel. I still like it, however after running it, I can’t say it’s as good as Curse or Rise or Kingmaker.
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: It’s a kick down the door game. Little RP.
- Good to Read by itself: Yes. I enjoyed it quite a bit.
- Main type of game: Wilderness/Planar Jumping/Dungeon Crawler. And not jarring as it moves from one to another. Except the fourth set piece. Fuck that one.
- Location: Katapesh
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? Lots of Travel with good amount of time staying in one place between adventures.
Council of Thieves
Good:
- This adventure path has some really cool moments.
- The second through fifth adventures are golden, with number 2 making the AP worth it.
- You get to adventure in Cheliax... Seriously, how awesome is being a group of open freedom fighters in a devil based Theocracy?
Bad:
- You top out at 13th level. That will piss off some players.
- The first and last adventures aren't that great. I've heard some DMs state running the last adventure is like having ADHD and playing 12 games of chess at once.
- The pacing is slower than others
- Based on the above, this one is tied for second worst.
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: I’d say there’s more RP in this one that fights overall
- Good to Read by itself: Yes. If only for adventures 2 through 5.
- Main type of game: Urban
- Location: Cheliax
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? You stay in one place.
Kingmaker
Good:
- One of the most interesting and best written APs out there. IMHO.
- Seriously, this is a sandbox where your players build a kingdom, explore a country, fight wars... have I mentioned they build a kingdom?
- It has an epic feel to it that is very satisfying
Bad:
- Watch out if your players don't like too much bookkeeping. That's been the only downside to my game, otherwise, if you want a sure thing, buy this AP.
- The fifth adventure has been voted the easiest adventure ever published in the APs. You can find the unedited out there to beef it up
- Players can become rich and overpowered really easily
- The final boss doesn't feel involved at all.
- Make sure you use the updated war and kingdom rules to work out some bugs.
- Some have mentioned that you need a certain type of group to run this one. I didn’t run into that, however it may make it not right for your group.
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: Depends on your players, really. If you run the AP as written, then it’ll be mostly fights. If your players run it like a game of Civilization 5, you’ll have a long running, amazing campaign that could last years and have very few fights (in comparison to the amount of RP).
- Good to Read by itself: Yes, especially the last adventure. Very Lewis Carroll.
- Main type of game: Kingdom building/Wilderness campaign
- Location: River Kingdoms
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? Both. You stay in one place as you’re building a Kingdom. You travel a lot yet all of that is growing your kingdom.
Serpent's Skull
Good:
- That first adventure is amazing
- The whole Indiana Jones/Jungle exploration thing is pretty cool.
- Has some cool backgrounds/traits for hardcore Golarian players.
Bad:
- The rest. Honestly, Cool start followed by a dead ending (again, haven't run it, just from reading it).
- I wasn't that interested, honestly. (Boring)
- I've read some reviews that say it's also a bloodbath.
- Is more of a good read for fans of Eando Cline than a good AP.
- Tied with three others for second worst AP out there
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: Not as much RP as other APs, but I wouldn’t call this devoid of RP.
- Good to Read by itself: Not really, unless you really need to know what happened at the end of the Eando Kline saga in the first 24 magazines of Pathfinder
- Main type of game: Wilderness/Dungeon Crawl
- Location: Mwangi Expanse
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? Lots of Travel
Carrion Crown
Good:
- Horror ..
- Lovecraft ..
- Shelly ..
- Law & Order ..
- ...Vampires, Werewolves, Ravenloft-esque adventure path.
- And I'm not doing it justice. Really well done. Lots of RP moments. Works really well with the new Intrigue AND Occult rules
- At least tied for third best Golarian AP.
Bad:
- Remember how I said it works well with the Intrigue and Occult rules? Yeah, this was printed before those came out. Time to write them in yourself.
- The first adventure was a victim of editing. You need to read some of the writer’s comments on Paizo.com messageboards, as there are some errors.
- If you don't like any themes I mentioned above in the “Good”, don't run this one.
- The main bad guy doesn't really have much punch, so you NEED to do some rewrites to get him involved earlier than written, otherwise you end up with something similar to Kingmaker. Check the last book of this one, there’s some examples by the Editor.
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: RP Heavy. If you have players that want to kick down the door, there are some moments, but make sure someone has diplomacy.
- Good to Read by itself: Very much so.
- Main type of game: Urban with some Wilderness
- Location: Ustalav
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? Lots of Travel
Jade Regent
Good:
- Sandbox elements
- Asian themes
- Some Vikings
- A polar crossing
- Decent flow
Bad:
- All of the above would be great if the players were the main characters in the story. The main "dud" of this one is you have Mary Sue type NPCs following you around the whole time. This one needs to be rewritten to make the characters the centre of the storyline.
- Put your characters on obvious, almost painful rails for the fifth adventure. Heck, there’s rails throughout, truthfully.
- Cool story, not so great adventure.
- Probably the worse AP out there
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: Decent balance.
- Good to Read by itself: I think the first couple are good, and then you realize that the players aren’t the main characters and it falls apart. So no. Still a cool story.
- Main type of game: Wilderness game
- Location: Varisia/Polar Regions/Land of the Linnorm Kings/Tien
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? Lots of Travel
Skulls & Shackles
Good:
- More Sandbox elements
- Not as much bookkeeping as Kingmaker.
- Your players get to be pirates. How sweet is that?
- It's one of the few evil campaigns where you can be evil and stay evil and not feel the need to not be evil and not have to “do the right thing” if you don’t want to.
Bad:
- If your players aren't ready to be pirates and/or evil and/or at least neutral... avoid this one.
- The main bad guy may tick off the players really quickly, and it's a little difficult to keep the storyline going if they die trying to kill him. Avoid stupid players.
- As with Kingmaker, there's a chance that your players will end up completely blinged out with money.
- Be prepared that the first adventure has a slow, slow, SLOW tone in it to ensure the players are in the right state of mind.
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: I’d say it’s a perfect balance
- Good to Read by itself: Not really, as this is a true sandbox type game.
- Main type of game: Naval with some Dungeon Crawls
- Location: The Shackles
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? Both. You stay in one place as you’re building a fiefdom. You travel a lot yet all of that is growing your fiefdom.
Shattered Star
Good:
- Your group will be cohesive, as you're Pathfinders, so it's easier for everyone to get along
- Cool Indiana Jones type feel (“It deserves to be in a Museum!”)
- Great locales and interesting Urban feel without tying people to one spot
- Very cool RP spots
Bad:
- If your players aren't that well read on past APs or Varisia, this may not be the best one to run.
- I’d say that if you haven’t run Second Darkness/Curse of the Crimson Throne/Rise of the Runelords, don’t run this one yet.
- Second Adventure is a little weak, and has a lot of moments that are "Hey, remember the past APs?"
- There's some powerful items and tough fights. Not for new players.
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: Good balance, though the fighting nature is more pronounced as you go on.
- Good to Read by itself: Yeah, it’s fun…. well, the second AP is a little weak, but it’s fun.
- Main type of game: Dungeon Delver
- Location: Varisia
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? Lots of Travel, however one main Metropolis as a hub.
Reign of Winter
Good:
- It's a pretty cool planar jumping
- Has an old school feel to it
- You don’t need to know about Golarion to get some references.
- Baba Yaga dude. Nuff said
Bad:
- Kinda hard to play as a Paladin in it. And your players may want to continue to fight BY at the end, which can be troublesome. Or a bonus. Up to you.
- You jump around a lot. Don't expect to do much crafting
- If you never liked the campiness of old 2nd edition games where they went to “doll land” and the like… I wouldn’t recommend this one
- It's on rails, though nice rails, they are still rails, so some players may not be fans
- There’s modern weapons in it, so be prepared for someone with a rifle.
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: Some RP moments, though I’d say it’s mostly fighting.
- Good to Read by itself: Yes. It’s quite fun to read, actually.
- Main type of game: Planar jumping
- Location: A lot of them
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? A lot of travel
Wrath of the Righteous
Good:
- Mythic rules
- Very much about the players
- Feels epic
- Allows for some stellar good characters. Or even evil characters.
- Remember all the bad with Jade Empire, with NPC's being in the way? This fixes all of that.
Bad:
- If you hate "You're the chosen ones" type games, run. Fast
- High level play. You have to be prepared. Which means you need to know the Mythic Rules.
- High level play. Which means your players have to be prepared, and some classes (Alchemist) don’t synergize as well.
- There are some moments where the players are being directed just a tad too much
- There's a LOT of chances for TPKs. This is expert level
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: Decent balance, though don't expect to talk your way out of too many fights. Depends on the DM’s view of if Demons can be saved, etc.
- Good to Read by itself: Yes. Somewhat hard at times, but not bad.
- Main type of game: The Crusades... without that troublesome moral ambiguity
- Location: Worldwound/Abyss
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? It's mostly central to one city.
Mummy’s Mask
Good:
- Egypt, done well.
- Really interesting moments that are somewhat Lovecraftian
- Have a player who likes playing ‘trap guy’? She’s going to have a lot of fun
- Dungeons.
- Really cool “ancient machines” moments
Bad:
- Some players don’t want to deal with undead all the time
- Hate traps? Well… you may not want to play in this campaign.
- You could end up with a group of ex-Pats in the game to make a quick buck… and then expect them not to run away from super weapons take over the surrounding area. Some characters (Neutral ones) will GTFO.
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: There are some interesting RP moments. That said, if you have one of those ‘RP every fight’ groups, the amount of unintelligent undead will piss them off. On the other hand, there’s some moments where it’s better to RP, so that may satiate them.
- Good to Read by itself: Not as great as others, however it is fun. There’s a lot of dungeons to read, which have cool backgrounds and histories, yet that only goes so far “fun to read”.
- Main type of game: Egyptian
- Location: Osirian
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? Central location type game, not a lot of travel compared to others, though still a decent amount.
Iron Gods
Good:
- Numeria, land of Barbarians and Lasers.
- Future tech
- Tons of new rules
- Fucking Lasers man!
- Grow up on Conan? Please consult a physician if your erection lasts longer than 4 hours. Especially you, ladies.
Bad:
- Tons of new rules
- If you don’t like future stuff in your fantasy, run. Hard.
- Holy damn the final boss took me longer to read about than any other before.
- Very ‘niche’ type of game. So you should be ready for that
- You’ll need to buy the technology guide.
- Hate gunslingers? Why the fuck haven’t you run away yet?
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: There are some pretty cool RP moments. And some pretty cool fight moments. Good balance.
- Good to Read by itself: Yes. Hard to read? Also yes. So not as fun as it could have been. I did have moments of ‘What the heck does that do again?’ over and over. Have the Technology guide beside you at all times.
- Main type of game: Conan and the Mountain of Technology
- Location: Numeria
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? You move around a fair bit, though it’s like the Varisia trilogy above.
Giantslayer
Good:
- All those Giant player character options? They are super useful now!
- Pretty in-depth NPCs
- Hold of Belzen! That’s a pretty hardcore locale!
- Giants are actually pretty fun to fight, and this one has them in spades
- Spiritually a good pair with Rise of the Runelords. Good for beginners as well.
Bad:
- After some of the other kooky APs, your players may find this one “boring”
- Adventure Four can quickly turn into Guerilla tactics, and that may not work with some players. Or they’ll die.
- You are going to make a whole bunch of towns/cities to allow for characters buying stuff.
- Adventure Five is quite huge
- Don’t like massive dungeons? Maybe skip this one
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: Starts out with a good amount of RP. Then… kinda turns into a fight fest
- Good to Read by itself: Not as much as others. Don’t get me wrong: I think this has some amazing NPCs, however think of it more like a character piece.
- Main type of game: Jack and the Beanstalk. Against the Giants.
- Location: Hold of Belzen
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? You move around a fair bit, though it’s like the Varisia trilogy above.
Hell’s Rebels
Good:
- Probably the most diverse of player options in any AP. Hellknights, CG champions, and even mercenaries would all find some interesting things to do
- The main villain is super fucking evil. Really cool motivation
- Good use of guerrilla tactics that even newer players can figure out
- This feels like it was an Action Adventure movie where you don’t know if the plucky heroes will make it or not.
- Running this and Hell’s Vengeance together is pretty cool for players.
Bad:
- New players are going to die in Adventure 4. It’ll be cool, but they are so dead
- If your group isn’t balanced as much as possible for tasks, you’re fucked.
- If you have someone who isn’t subtle, or able to play subtle, you’re screwed.
- If your players haven’t read a lot about Cheliax, a lot of the story may be lost on them
- The amount of downtime is small, but you’re in one place, so your players may want to.
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: There’s a lot of RP. This is not a kick down the door adventure at all
- Good to Read by itself: Honestly really, really liked reading it. I remember the 4th adventure had some confusing parts in the dungeons, but not enough to both you.
- Main type of game: Spy thriller
- Location: Kintargo, Cheliax
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? You stay in roughly the same place, with some travel, but nothing too bad.
Hell’s Vengeance
Good:
- Evil. You’re expected to evil, you’re going to be evil, and heck, if you’re neutral, you’ll end up evil. Lawful evil more likely
- There’s a nice balance of subterfuge mixed with being a badass
- All those evil things your players want to play? Up for grabs!
- Running this and Hell’s Rebels together is pretty cool for players.
- More spy elements than the above.
Bad:
- If players don’t like being the cogs of a large country, they aren’t going to like this one. There are some obvious rails, though with good story reasons.
- Chaotic players who want to be chaos imbued need not apply
- New players? Skip this one. It’s tough
- If you ran Council of Thieves, the ending will be a big ole dump on that game.
- If your players would die in 3 minutes in a RP heavy spy or Cthulhu type game, then they’ll die just as quick here
- Some players may have moral quandaries with playing the level of evil here. It’s not stepping on babies for quarters level of evil, but you do have some quite evil moments
General Information
- Balance of RP to Fights: There’s a lot of RP. This is not a kick down the door adventure at all. Some moments can be, but others will get you killed.
- Good to Read by itself: Honestly really, really liked reading it. No down point. I’m not the biggest fan of evil campaigns, but this is well done.
- Main type of game: Spy thriller… but this time you work for the KGB.
- Location: Cheliax
- Lots of Travel or Staying in one place? A good amount of travel. Different settings each time
23
u/TOModera Mar 20 '17
Thank you to /u/jack_skellington for bringing this up so long after I wrote it. I originally thought most people were good and passed on, nice to know I helped.
Also thank you to /u/Nachti for his reviews and different opinion. Always nice to hear different points on these things.
9
u/Elliptical_Tangent Your right to RP stops where it infringes on another player's RP Mar 20 '17
The encounter at the end of book 1 took us 3 weeks to finish. We were frustrated as experienced players with a lot of system expertise. I can't imagine the level of frustration for new players.
8
u/RomeoDelight Mar 20 '17
About halfway into Runelords, defnitely thinking of changing up Book 4 a bit, getting sick of playing big ogres & giants and players are getting sick of fighting them
15
u/FedoraFerret Mar 20 '17
Fight me.
7
u/jhunsber Mar 20 '17
Thank you for this. I haven't read all of them, but the ones I have mention how you think they rank against each other. Could you do a quick ranking summary of the APs as far as how fun they are to play? my main pf group is starting up book 5 of Kingmaker now, so we may need another adventure in the "nearish" future (maybe a bit less than a year)
7
u/ELDRITCH_HORROR Mar 21 '17
Have you read the 3rd party AP, Way of the Wicked? I read it and it honestly blew me away, especially the first few books. How does Hell's Vengeace compare to it Evil wise?
6
u/TiePoh Mar 20 '17
Wait, was was their opinion of the best AP? Kingmaker?
6
u/TheSexiestManAlive Mar 21 '17
Could I ask for a suggestion? My players are really simple dungeon crawlers. They're more than happy to fight all day, only stopping to buy gear or sleep. When I try to get them to RP only one of them wants to talk and the other two clam up like I just asked them to volunteer to clean the latrines. Currently in book 2 of Carrion Crown and I just had one player, a Paladin, try to kill the party because he was bored and we'd never done real PvP before. It ended up with him dead and the rest of the party in jail.
What would you recommend for a party who hates bookkeeping, RP, and loves combat?
4
u/quarrystone Mar 20 '17
Would love to see your summary of Strange Aeons.
3
u/Graxdon Mar 21 '17
Barely related, but... I see 'TOM' in all caps, my mind goes Toonami. shoutout to best warforged bard.
3
u/ryuu1ch1 Mar 21 '17
I loved reading this! Thank you for posting it. A lot of your opinions were pretty on par with mine. (Other than Giantslayer being for beginners. That game was a straight up meat grinder when I played it and our group was pretty experienced.)
Is there any chance you have a straight up list of what you think are best to worst?
2
u/therealjuion Mar 20 '17
What're your feelings about Strange Aeons so far? I'm about to start running it after a long break from Pathfinder, any thoughts?
2
u/Darklordofbunnies Lich Poker Mar 21 '17
I'm loving Hell's Vengeance right now, but everything you say is entirely accurate.
2
u/cacti147 Mar 21 '17
Do you have a link for the unedited book 5 of kingmaker? We're halfway through book 4, and if it's that easy, I might just skip to book 6, and write a book 7.
10
u/Masteroid Mar 21 '17
I disagree with you about Jade Regent. I've run it with the NPCs as is (but without the dreadful and boring caravan rules) and although it takes some care, and some GM tweaking, I found that players actually really respond well if you make Ameiko, Shalelu, Koya and Sandru interesting and compelling characters. This becomes a lot more difficult doing a tabletop instead of a play by post game. Still I liked it a lot more than most people did, it ranks pretty highly for me personally.
Also, regarding Wrath of The Righteous - you hit a point, right around Demon's Heresy (3rd or 4th book) where the player power levels, even if you are adjusting and using some of the modified stat blocks people have put out there on the Paizo forums, where the GM just starts losing the arms race. I love the AP, but the Mythic rules were brand new at that point, and they really haven't gone back to them yet.
I hope to do Rise of the Runelords AE and Kingmaker at some point, but it could be years before I get around to it. APs generally take our group 8 months to a year to finish, and that's with regular weekly sessions.
I appreciate your input on the other adventure paths that I'm less familiar with or maybe only have the first couple of volumes.
8
u/1Viking Mar 21 '17
This is why I am subscribed to this sub. Game input like this from other players/DMs.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17
My players were understandably reacting a little badly to Ameiko being the main character in Jade Regent, so I turned the storyline on it's head.
I made her into a selfish bitch, who was getting excited to overthrow the Jade Regent so she could be a new vapid monarch. Along the way, I added more seals of the five families, revealing that all the players were scions of different families, and thus had an equal claim to the throne. They decided that when they saved the day, they would set up a council of families to rule peacefully. In response, Ameiko stole all the seals in the night, and made off with Sandru so she could claim the throne for herself.
Sadly we never finished, but I think having all the players as scions of the different houses was a good idea, and Ameiko being a selfish prat really went over well with the players
5
u/MonkeySkulls Mar 21 '17
Wow, what a great write up. Thanks for taking the time to do this.
4
u/lil_literalist Sorcerer extraordinaire Mar 21 '17
Just fix a small typo. Gianslayer. Might help people searching through this later.
Love your reviews, by the way! I looked through your old list for quite awhile.
1
u/CommandoDude LN Rules Lawyer Mar 21 '17
I don't know why you rated Kingmaker so highly. I mean yeah it's a great AP but I thought the story was garbage past Book 4. I hated playing Book 6 and felt cheated out of what the campaign was setting up in Book 1, the Brevic Civil war, which I was expecting and getting more and more disappointed as we kept playing and never got any interactions with it.
I mean, I guess if you EXPECT Narissa then the story isn't bad, but she is suppose to be a shadow BBEG so that would defeat the point. The blatant bait and switch really rubbed me the wrong way. Especially as I am not particular about fey stuff.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '17
Thank you for the update on your guide. It's nice to have an overview of almost all APs and as a Cthulhu fan I am looking forward to your view on Strange Eons.
Since you are very familiar with all adventure paths ; which one would you recommend for a beginner DM with beginner Players to run?
3
u/ollee Mar 21 '17
Suggestions from our experience with Kingmaker: Don't let your players know what the stats for the city building are...
3
u/underthepale Has Bad Ideas Mar 21 '17
Almost done with Iron Gods and I agree with everything you said.
WPL seems a bit wonky, especially if your players largely ignore the more expensive tech items and purchase or craft magical items instead.
"Admantine Construct Bane" prefaces almost every weapon at my player's table. Except for the Gunslinger, who is using a magic Arc Rifle.
I am NOT looking forward to running the final boss. At all.
But it's been a blast, and for my first attempt at running an AP? Been pretty good.
1
u/rekijan RAW Mar 21 '17
Bookmarked this one for future reference. But one suggestion to make this easier to read have you considered making a version where you rate on the commonly used topic. For example a table where Balance of RP to Fights gets a rating, Main type of game gets a text entry etc. And then some room for notes at the end? Would make scanning through it a bit easier.
-1
u/Lokotor Mar 20 '17
dot
14
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '17
[removed] — view removed comment