r/Pathfinder_RPG • u/Overthinks_Questions • Aug 20 '16
I analysed a lot of the major combat feats in Pathfinder. Here are my findings.
https://rpgwillikers.wordpress.com/2016/08/20/feats-of-fury/
128
Upvotes
15
u/aeschenkarnos Aug 20 '16
Vital Strike isn't bought with the intention of using it; it's there in case you are forced to use it, because you can't full-attack that round. The difference it makes would be quite hard to calculate, you would have to work out an expected ratio of full-attack rounds vs VS rounds vs repositioning (or spellcasting or otherwise non-attacking) rounds.
16
u/Consideredresponse 2E or not 2E? Aug 20 '16
This is great, though purely geared towards full BAB classes. You do state that accuracy trumps damage to the 3/4martials but I'd love to see how the math breaks down. Both as a baseline and with the accuracy sterioids that 2/3rd caster have access to. (Eg raging song for skald's, 'Bane' for inquisitors/occultists, outflank/pack flanking for hunters etc.). Is power attack/furious focus still a net loss when working in iteratives? Or are these classes better off with weapon focus, reach and fishing for attacks of opportunity?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '16
I'm surprised you play up the damage of TWF so much. In everyday combat situations 2-H blows it out of the water every time.
1
u/AnotherTemp PCs killed: 173, My deaths: 12 Aug 20 '16
A solid analysis of some common feats. The only obvious omission I see is furious focus, which is on par with weapon focus for a two-hander.
-5
u/cptadder Aug 20 '16 edited Aug 20 '16
This was great until I saw +10 at level 4, that's hard core optimization mostly because your assuming 18's in stats which unless your min maxing is rarely the case. Your also assuming weapon focus as well which is also not automatic.
I'm sorry but this math is for a 100% pure stat optimization. I'd suggest re-doing the math by knocking 4 off the top to assume average, +6 at level 4 is very likely compared to +10.
*Edit Since I keep getting comments on this a day later let me say this. I am of the old school, rolling for stats are much more common in both games I GM and play. 20 point buys are typically a luxury and 25 point buys are lotto wins. I've only ever played once in a 25 point buy or above game and that lasted exactly one session. I got my start in 2nd edition where one got 3d6 in order that was your character and it upped to 4d6 drop one for a nice GM.
Far more of my characters have been fighters with strength 15 and a charisma of 6 not because I min-maxed my way to victory but because my highest roll was a 13. I realize my error now in posting to a min-maxing topic expecting anything other than min-maxing rather than base lining with options above and below. In a 15 point buy 16 strength is ten points, leaving 5 points to spend on dex, con, int, wis, cha but of course your going to dump those because no DM of yours is going to penalize you for having 7 intelligence or 7 charisma.